News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by simonh on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:39AM (#16543966)
What confuses me about these experiments is that, per special relativity, from the point of view of the photon the moment of it's emission and detection are the same. It's traveling at the speed of light, so no time passes between those events. So talking about it's state at this or that time is not talking about it's intrinsic state, only our external view of it from our frame of reference. But in terms of a description of the photon in it's frame of reference, that's meaningless.

EDIT: Or is this what the Paris Zigzag does - treat the state of the photon and it's twin as a single state, regardless of our time-based view of it, incorporating the moment of detection, emission and detection of the entangled twin within the same description?

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:45PM (#16547485)
> per special relativity, from the point of view of the photon the moment of it's emission and detection are the same. It's traveling at the speed of light, so no time passes between those events

This is not correct. The correct statement is that, in SR, the photon's worldline is a null worldline. But the concept of "proper time" is not well defined on a null worldline, so you can't say that "no time passes". In fact, in any inertial frame, the time of the detection event will be later than the time of the emission event, so time certainly does pass between the two events in the only sense in which "time between events" can be consistently defined in SR.

Also, the photon's state does not have to be constant along a null worldline.

>is this what the Paris Zigzag does - treat the state of the photon and it's twin as a single state

No. The "Paris Zigzag" just says that causality can flow "backwards" along null worldlines, from what we call the "detection" event to what we call the "emission" event, instead of just the other way around. All of what I said above still applies.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by whatshisface on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:48AM (#16545554)
There is no reference frame where the photon is stationary: this is directly axiomatic, because we take the speed of light to be equal and nonzero in all reference frames.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by simonh on Thursday March 08, 2018 @12:39PM (#16546020)
And yet the photon travels at the speed of light. You're probably quite right, but how should we think about time with respect to the state of a photon?
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by whatshisface on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:36PM (#16546492)
In relativity, the the meaning of the term "reference frame" is "coordinate system." The fundamental geometry of the situation gives us a bucket of possible coordinate systems. From this bucket, we can choose a coordinate system where any give object appears stationary, unless the object is moving at the speed of light in which case there's no corresponding coordinate system.

The coordinate systems are the fundamental physics part, and the idea of matching coordinate systems with objects comes out as just something we happen to be able to do for some objects.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gowld on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:22PM (#16546369)
You had it right the first time. A photon has no time. The Universe has 0 size in the reference frame of a photon. In a photon's reference frame, photons are absorbed by the instant they are emitted, discretely, they do not travel in a continuous manner. It doesn't really make sense to think about the reference frame of a photon.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:50PM (#16547518)
> A photon has no time. The Universe has 0 size in the reference frame of a photon.

Both of these statements are incorrect. The correct statement is that the concept of "proper time" does not apply to a photon, and that "the reference frame of a photon" doesn't make sense, so neither does "the size of the Universe in the reference frame of a photon". See below.

> It doesn't really make sense to think about the reference frame of a photon.

This is correct, but it contradicts your previous statement, quoted above.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by placebo on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:44PM (#16548723)
Not a physicist so please bear with me:

Isn't this just an argument about definitions? It makes no sense to say that the universe has 0 size from a photon's reference frame and it also makes no sense to say the photon has a reference frame, but intuitively the experience of space "shrinking" with correlation to higher velocity for the viewer in some reference frame suggests that the as the reference approaches the speed of light, the length of space approaches zero, and while it makes no sense to speak of something with mass traveling at the speed of light, the intuition is that from that imaginary perspective space has no size.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:26PM (#16548913)
> Isn't this just an argument about definitions?

No, it isn't.

> the experience of space "shrinking" with correlation to higher velocity

This is not a good description. Length contraction is not a real process of "space shrinking"; it's a matter of perspective, similar to the way objects can have different apparent sizes in ordinary geometry depending on which direction you look at them from. An object moving with a high velocity relative to you is "rotated" in spacetime relative to you such that it appears shorter; but the object itself is unaffected.

Notice that I said "high velocity relative to you"; this is another way of seeing why "space shrinking" is not a good description. Velocity is relative: "high velocity" relative to you is not the same as "high velocity" in an absolute sense (there is no such thing). So saying that "space shrinks at high velocity" doesn't make sense.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by placebo on Friday March 09, 2018 @01:51AM (#16550185)
I understand that space "shrinking" is a perspective (which is why I originally placed it in double quotes) and that velocity is relative - my question was meant more as a thought experiment of taking the subjective experience of what things seem like as relative velocity increases and then extrapolate it to what they might seem like as relative velocity approaches the speed of light, i.e what would experience be like were it possible to ride on a photon. Since riding on a photon is not possible, perhaps this question is meaningless - it's just that since there is a pattern to how space is experienced with increasing relative velocities, the tendency is to extrapolate this to try and imagine how space/time would be experienced if it were possible.

That being said, I understand that a "universe of length zero" or "no time" is not relevant nor practical in the context of doing physics.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:31PM (#16556310)
> what would experience be like were it possible to ride on a photon

But that's not what "space shrinking" represents. The object or person that is moving at close to the speed of light relative to you does not see their own space shrink. Their "space" appears to you to "shrink" (I put the words in scare-quotes because of all the issues I already brought up). So even if "space shrinking" is a reasonable interpretation of something, that something is not what you would even want to extrapolate to "the experience of riding on a photon" (which is meaningless anyway, as I said in my other post just now), because it doesn't describe the experience of the observer moving at high speed relative to you, it describes your own experience, and to yourself, you're at rest.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:27PM (#16556284)
> Since riding on a photon is not possible, perhaps this question is meaningless

Yes.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gumby on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:21PM (#16546354)
Read up on Lorenz geometry.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gumby on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:59PM (#16549094)
Why should this be downvoted? It exactly says how to think about the question the parent asked.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by raattgift on Sunday March 11, 2018 @02:28PM (#16564129)
It's not a helpful one-line reply; you could at least have offered up a link or reference to your suggested place to study.

It's also wrong in that you use "Lorenz" (as in Ludwig, the Danish one) instead of "Lorentz" (as in Hendrik, the Dutch one). Don't feel too bad; lots of respectable authors have made a similar typo ("Lorentz gauge" instead of "Lorenz gauge"), but it makes your one-liner even less useful as a piece of advice.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludvig_Lorenz?oldformat=true

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hendrik_Lorentz?oldformat=true

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gumby on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:43AM (#16567488)
Thanks
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by rohit2412 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @12:38PM (#16546014)
From what I can read, entanglement extends to other particles like electrons, which have mass and do take time to travel. So, your theory doesn't explain entanglement for electrons.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by alex_young on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:27AM (#16545372)
> from the point of view of the photon the moment of it's emission and detection are the same. It's traveling at the speed of light...

From the perspective of the photon (really kind of silly since the photon can't have any mass, and therefore no observer), there is no time or distance traveled. It takes 0 time to travel 0 distance.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by jcims on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:59AM (#16545665)
I've been wondering this lately. Does the photon actually exist in the space between where it is emitted and where it is absorbed? In other words, if nothing interacts with it along the way, is it really there?
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by btilly on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:28PM (#16546414)
The answer is a curious no.

More precisely, the double slit experiment demonstrates that the possibility that it existed in one place at a particular point in time interacts with the possibility that it existed elsewhere, and the interaction affects where it can be possibly found.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gowld on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:25PM (#16546391)
That's metaphysics. Physically, there's no way to answer the question. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_particle
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by simonh on Thursday March 08, 2018 @12:32PM (#16545965)
That's really the riddle of the Schroedinger equation for any quantum entity.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:47PM (#16547497)
> From the perspective of the photon (really kind of silly since the photon can't have any mass, and therefore no observer), there is no time or distance traveled. It takes 0 time to travel 0 distance.

This is not correct. It is not possible to have an inertial frame in which the photon is at rest. It is possible to construct coordinate charts in which the photon's worldline has constant values for all but one coordinate; but that coordinate is not a "time" coordinate, and there is no well-defined notion of "time" or "distance" along the photon's worldline in such coordinates.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by jerf on Thursday March 08, 2018 @09:28AM (#16544486)
I favor this quantum interpretation a bit for very similar reasons to that. Relativity already tore away our ideas about time being a single steady march forward in an independent fourth dimension, which was a big step. Similarly, I don't consider this "retrocausality"; I consider it a sign that time works differently than we thought yet again, and in fact all qubits and their interactions are probably actually moving forward in time, in what is arguably the most real sense of "time". However, in that view, time is shaped very, very funny relative to what we humans would consider "time", because that means that a photon in the cosmic background radiation emitted that many billions of years ago that hits one of our instruments is still a single atomic event.

I consider this view supported by relativity where, as you mention, technically a photon is an atomic event from its own point of view. There isn't any before or after in its own frame of reference.

What we call time would then be a secondary phenomenon on top of this much more complicated (from our point of view) time organization of the universe. (However, I reject the idea that that makes "our" time an illusion, or some BS like that. Our human conception of time is perfectly real. It just may not be fundamental. But even if we discover that "real time" is something like what I'm hypothesizing here, human time will still be as real as ever.)

What is not clear to me is whether or not this could be set up in a reasonable manner. It's on my long list of things I'd love to have time to try my hand at. It's feasible, you just need to start with maybe a 5 or 6 qubit system that interacts in this "real time" manner in the counterintuitive "retrocausal" manner, but for which there is a point of view in which it all happens forward in this "real time" metric. You don't have to simulate an entire universe to show this is a feasible idea, if you can establish it at that scale, it is merely a matter of extreme complication to assume the universe could work that way.

There's also an interesting implication for the "deistic" point of view. If this is how quantum mechanics "really works" then it becomes relatively easy to imagine that the Great Simulator is simulating the universe, but actually has little to no power to influence it, because from his point of view during the computation the entire universe is a tangled mess of everything essentially happening at once (from our point of view). The only thing the Great Simulator might be able to do is examine the final state of the universe after it has finished computing, at which point the entire history of the universe would be open to him, but to affect the state of the universe would be wildly more computationally expensive than the simulation itself, because any attempt to insert or modify even a single qubit's worth of change would essentially require the entire thing to be recalculated again as the changes propagate in (from our point of view) all the way forward and backwards in time again. Depending on the nature of "true time", though, it might be possible, depending on exactly how it ends up working.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by ctdonath on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:00AM (#16545125)
I've been casually considering: what would the universe look like from a photon's point of view, considering that its entire lifespan is - from its own perspective - instant? Photon views itself as a point, with the totality of everything viewed as a radius from that path.

And great insight on God having a very different perspective of time. That's pretty clear in most theologies, but how it's different is never seriously considered. Only change to your point I'd make is: whatever the actual nature of time, a "tweak" (miracle?) may be made & propagate in a much simpler fashion than our perspective perceives it as (ex.: we see "spooky action at a distance", but God sees it as just changing the state of a singleton).

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by lostmsu on Thursday March 08, 2018 @11:47AM (#16545546)
In the current theory, photons do not have a frame of reference.

"The spooky action at distance" is a media term. In quantum physics it is indeed a "single state".

I fail to see why Odin, or any other god you could have meant would "see" Universe's events any differently from physics. Physics by definition is seeking the full description of the Universe. What we argue here is how to interpret that, but that is mostly needed for people, who are too lazy to grok actual equations as they are.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by jerf on Thursday March 08, 2018 @02:28PM (#16546909)
"Physics by definition is seeking the full description of the Universe."

From the "inside". We can not have an exterior perspective, and the Church-Turing thesis suggests that we will never know what the "outside" looks like because there's any number of possible models and literally zero ability to discriminate them from within the system. The only way to find out would be for someone from the outside to tell us, and even then you can get into some interesting philosophical knots asking how you'd evaluate such a claim, or even be sure it was from the outside.

I HAVE HIJACKED JERF'S MESSAGE TO TELL YOU FROM THE OUTSIDE HOW YOUR UNIVERSE WORKS. YOUR UNIVERSE IS A QUANTUM SIMULATION RUNNING ON WHAT TO ME IS ANALOGOUS TO A SMALL BREAD PUDDING WHICH HAS JUST STARTED BAKING, WHICH I INTEND TO CONSUME SOON FROM MY POINT OF VIEW. YOU NEED NOT WORRY, IT'S MANY TRILLIONS OF YEARS IN YOUR PERSONAL VIEW OF THE FUTURE.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by tylerjwilk00 on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:45PM (#16548727)
I agree with your view on this. We can not compute the computation that we are contained within. As for the "internal" vs "external" perspective of this computation, I have found the analogy of a music record a good metaphor for explaining. The entire album is contained staticly on the disc all at once as viewed from the external. However, from an internal point of view as the record needle it exists as a flow of time over the record.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by ctdonath on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:55AM (#16585143)
You're failing to differentiate a program from the programmer.

You're equating Odin (or whatever) to the operating system, which while superior to other programs is, in essence, just another program.

I'm equating Odin (or whatever) to the programmer, who knows far more about the essence & foundations of the system, and even has a debugger capable of stopping the entire system, editing values, and resuming the system as though absolutely nothing happened (save for occurrence of a miracle).

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gowld on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:26PM (#16546397)
"spooky action at distance" is a relativistic term, coined by Einstein.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by lostmsu on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:20PM (#16548611)
We are well past Einstein at this moment.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by 09bjb on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:35PM (#16546480)
These are beautiful ideas.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by raattgift on Sunday March 11, 2018 @02:21PM (#16564103)
tl;dr (and mathlessly) Colloquially, you'd hold something other than the photon stationary and consider the light's path in that stationary observer's frame, and then it doesn't matter whether proper time is rigorously defined.

For a handful of others in this thread:

While it's strictly true that proper time is hard to define usefully for a classical massless particle, you can still parameterize a null curve any way you want, depending on what it is you're trying to do.

In flat spacetime you're rarely trying to eke out a transformation much more complex than a Lorentz transform (the matrix for which involves \gamma, which is undefined for v=c), and so you're stuck with ds = 0. On the other hand, your objects on lightlike curves are probably light itself (classical or otherwise), so you'd generally look to something like an affine parameterization like k^b\Delta_{b}k^a=0 and k_{a}k^a=0 where k^a(x) are the components of the photon's momentum, or (aiming for E=pc) parameterize on the wave vector k (where v=c implies k^2={\omega}^2, where \omega is the wave angular frequency).

Other sensible choices of affine parameter are available, and typically give you freedom to pick out a momentum vector k^\mu = \dot A^\mu where A is the affine time; usually you'd do this so as to match the momentum-energy at the emitter or absorber (or the redshift along the null curve).