News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by simonh on Thursday March 08, 2018 @12:39PM (#16546020)
And yet the photon travels at the speed of light. You're probably quite right, but how should we think about time with respect to the state of a photon?
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by whatshisface on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:36PM (#16546492)
In relativity, the the meaning of the term "reference frame" is "coordinate system." The fundamental geometry of the situation gives us a bucket of possible coordinate systems. From this bucket, we can choose a coordinate system where any give object appears stationary, unless the object is moving at the speed of light in which case there's no corresponding coordinate system.

The coordinate systems are the fundamental physics part, and the idea of matching coordinate systems with objects comes out as just something we happen to be able to do for some objects.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gowld on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:22PM (#16546369)
You had it right the first time. A photon has no time. The Universe has 0 size in the reference frame of a photon. In a photon's reference frame, photons are absorbed by the instant they are emitted, discretely, they do not travel in a continuous manner. It doesn't really make sense to think about the reference frame of a photon.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:50PM (#16547518)
> A photon has no time. The Universe has 0 size in the reference frame of a photon.

Both of these statements are incorrect. The correct statement is that the concept of "proper time" does not apply to a photon, and that "the reference frame of a photon" doesn't make sense, so neither does "the size of the Universe in the reference frame of a photon". See below.

> It doesn't really make sense to think about the reference frame of a photon.

This is correct, but it contradicts your previous statement, quoted above.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by placebo on Thursday March 08, 2018 @06:44PM (#16548723)
Not a physicist so please bear with me:

Isn't this just an argument about definitions? It makes no sense to say that the universe has 0 size from a photon's reference frame and it also makes no sense to say the photon has a reference frame, but intuitively the experience of space "shrinking" with correlation to higher velocity for the viewer in some reference frame suggests that the as the reference approaches the speed of light, the length of space approaches zero, and while it makes no sense to speak of something with mass traveling at the speed of light, the intuition is that from that imaginary perspective space has no size.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:26PM (#16548913)
> Isn't this just an argument about definitions?

No, it isn't.

> the experience of space "shrinking" with correlation to higher velocity

This is not a good description. Length contraction is not a real process of "space shrinking"; it's a matter of perspective, similar to the way objects can have different apparent sizes in ordinary geometry depending on which direction you look at them from. An object moving with a high velocity relative to you is "rotated" in spacetime relative to you such that it appears shorter; but the object itself is unaffected.

Notice that I said "high velocity relative to you"; this is another way of seeing why "space shrinking" is not a good description. Velocity is relative: "high velocity" relative to you is not the same as "high velocity" in an absolute sense (there is no such thing). So saying that "space shrinks at high velocity" doesn't make sense.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by placebo on Friday March 09, 2018 @01:51AM (#16550185)
I understand that space "shrinking" is a perspective (which is why I originally placed it in double quotes) and that velocity is relative - my question was meant more as a thought experiment of taking the subjective experience of what things seem like as relative velocity increases and then extrapolate it to what they might seem like as relative velocity approaches the speed of light, i.e what would experience be like were it possible to ride on a photon. Since riding on a photon is not possible, perhaps this question is meaningless - it's just that since there is a pattern to how space is experienced with increasing relative velocities, the tendency is to extrapolate this to try and imagine how space/time would be experienced if it were possible.

That being said, I understand that a "universe of length zero" or "no time" is not relevant nor practical in the context of doing physics.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:31PM (#16556310)
> what would experience be like were it possible to ride on a photon

But that's not what "space shrinking" represents. The object or person that is moving at close to the speed of light relative to you does not see their own space shrink. Their "space" appears to you to "shrink" (I put the words in scare-quotes because of all the issues I already brought up). So even if "space shrinking" is a reasonable interpretation of something, that something is not what you would even want to extrapolate to "the experience of riding on a photon" (which is meaningless anyway, as I said in my other post just now), because it doesn't describe the experience of the observer moving at high speed relative to you, it describes your own experience, and to yourself, you're at rest.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by pdonis on Friday March 09, 2018 @07:27PM (#16556284)
> Since riding on a photon is not possible, perhaps this question is meaningless

Yes.

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gumby on Thursday March 08, 2018 @01:21PM (#16546354)
Read up on Lorenz geometry.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gumby on Thursday March 08, 2018 @07:59PM (#16549094)
Why should this be downvoted? It exactly says how to think about the question the parent asked.
Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by raattgift on Sunday March 11, 2018 @02:28PM (#16564129)
It's not a helpful one-line reply; you could at least have offered up a link or reference to your suggested place to study.

It's also wrong in that you use "Lorenz" (as in Ludwig, the Danish one) instead of "Lorentz" (as in Hendrik, the Dutch one). Don't feel too bad; lots of respectable authors have made a similar typo ("Lorentz gauge" instead of "Lorenz gauge"), but it makes your one-liner even less useful as a piece of advice.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludvig_Lorenz?oldformat=true

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hendrik_Lorentz?oldformat=true

Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance? by gumby on Monday March 12, 2018 @07:43AM (#16567488)
Thanks