Re:Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance?
by pdonis on Thursday March 08, 2018 @03:45PM
(#16547485)
> per special relativity, from the point of view of the photon the moment of it's emission and detection are the same. It's traveling at the speed of light, so no time passes between those events
This is not correct. The correct statement is that, in SR, the photon's worldline is a null worldline. But the concept of "proper time" is not well defined on a null worldline, so you can't say that "no time passes". In fact, in any inertial frame, the time of the detection event will be later than the time of the emission event, so time certainly does pass between the two events in the only sense in which "time between events" can be consistently defined in SR.
Also, the photon's state does not have to be constant along a null worldline.
>is this what the Paris Zigzag does - treat the state of the photon and it's twin as a single state
No. The "Paris Zigzag" just says that causality can flow "backwards" along null worldlines, from what we call the "detection" event to what we call the "emission" event, instead of just the other way around. All of what I said above still applies.
This is not correct. The correct statement is that, in SR, the photon's worldline is a null worldline. But the concept of "proper time" is not well defined on a null worldline, so you can't say that "no time passes". In fact, in any inertial frame, the time of the detection event will be later than the time of the emission event, so time certainly does pass between the two events in the only sense in which "time between events" can be consistently defined in SR.
Also, the photon's state does not have to be constant along a null worldline.
>is this what the Paris Zigzag does - treat the state of the photon and it's twin as a single state
No. The "Paris Zigzag" just says that causality can flow "backwards" along null worldlines, from what we call the "detection" event to what we call the "emission" event, instead of just the other way around. All of what I said above still applies.