Concerta doesn't magically give you attention abilities you didn't have before. It's a nervous system stimulant. It makes you neurotic, trapped in your own head. Maybe this makes it easier for some people to focus, but I have enough experience with it to explain why. It forces your attention from the world around you to your own mind. You will be more physically still and "studious", only because you are mentally struggling more. It makes you feel sick. Food seems abhorrent. You will eat a small fraction of what other kids your age eat, you will be below the 99th percentile in height and weight for your age and you will stay that way for the rest of your life. You will be paranoid and anxious, more than ever before the meds. When things are illogical, when you see other people make bad decisions that seem so simple to you, you will be ANGRY. You will be inhumanly smart, but you will be inhuman.
The food, yes, the frustrations with illogical decisions, yes. I'd never recommend the drugs to a child, just run them outside until they wear out, but for adults who have trouble keeping multiple plates spinning; yes, use science to overcome your random genealogical assignment.
There is no proof that social disorders like ADHD/ADD are genetically deterministic. Which is why the diagnosis relies solely on social observations rather than biological tests. That is of course not to say that drugs can't enhance desired brain functions.
>Finally, one of the key goals of genetic studies of ADHD is to understand its aetiology and mechanisms. The challenge undoubtedly will not only be in identifying risk factors but more importantly testing causal mechanisms.
Again, there is no proof, only hypothesis. This is in stark contrast with actual biological pathologies which have proven genetic causes, such as sickle cell anemia.
The whole thing bubbles down to the drawbacks of any hard drug -- addiction, physical dependence, side effects, and rebound effect from physical dependence. Psychological dependence, poor discipline due to not having to exercise it as much.
I guess HN is with the "carry a bag with a bunch of drugs. drugs have desirable effects." Need to fall asleep but you can't because you are _bad_ at it? Pop some benzos. Need to wake up, but you feel sluggish and hungover? Pop some coke or amphetamines. Toe hurts because you stubbed it? Pop some opiates. Lacking creativity? Pop some ketamine, lsd, or smoke some weed. Etc etc.
No one is saying amphetamines aren't effective. They are a hard drug. Drugs as a crutch, are bad, mmkay?
Individual experiences vary. Patients have reported experiences like what both of you describe, though the reality tends to be a lot more middle of the road than that.
I’ve required such medications myself, and my experience was much more on the positive side, though not as extreme.
Assuming the worst of posters is definitely against the site rules, and just rude in general. As someone who takes Equasym - the same as Concerta except the different release cycle - I can't recognise anything in your post as being what I've experienced, nor does it match anyone else I know that also uses the same medication.
Your anger certainly seems misplaced to me, but severe enough that you should probably seek help for it. Hope you manage to move on in life.
I see irony in calling someone else uninspired for being more attentive, and I eagerly await the publication of your well-founded study on the subject of demarcating things that are objectively and universally worth ignoring.
Ah, I didn't realize that by "people" you meant "people who are me and not someone else". That clarifies things, thanks.
> There is no reason to pay attention to everything in this world.
The inability to see reasons for things is like the definition of uninspired, though.
> Being obedient is common in...
I eagerly await publication of the results of your well-founded study of the relationship between obedience and vigilance.
So...you know...stop saying crazy things and I'll stop eagerly awaiting your publications.
I get it. You don't believe the problems are real. Or you don't believe that the drugs are effective at treating them. So I'm lying. And other people are lying. We're all lying to you, part of the vast conspiracy of children who never actually went through something that you didn't go through. Congratulations, you found us out! Or maybe you don't actually know everything.
> You are welcome to keep thinking you are doing yourself a therepeutic solid
I'll do you one better. My mother's strong advocacy for my mental wellbeing saved my life and ultimately made me an understanding and compassionate person who listens when someone tells them about real childhood trauma from being literally unable to read until the medicine magically fixed what was wrong.
> I feel bad that you think amphetamines are some class of "lifestyle" drug
I feel bad that you don't understand that different people have different needs to be able to function, and that sometimes things go wrong in ways that are fixable. I feel bad that you don't understand that people are very often willing to accept harmful side effects because those are less bad than the alternative.
> one of the most simple drugs around
Simple, eh? Let me tell you a story about a little drug called Lithium Carbonate. We can compare.
Ah. I understand now that you think that taking drugs is a similar professional qualification to, say, decades of medical accomplishment and meta-analysis in Neuropsychology. What a joke.
> The specific biochemical mechanism of lithium action in stabilizing mood is unknown.
Fun fact: Nobody knows why _any_ mood or cognition altering drug works the way it does, because nobody knows how the brain produces awareness. Nobody can predict which if any mood or cognition altering drug will treat known problems, because nobody knows yet what fundamentally causes the problems. It's why psychiatric treatments always require experimentation to discover which of multiple medications might work and at what dosage. Or are you saying you know that too? Because if you are, then I eagerly await the publication of your well-founded study.
Every time you assert that your experiences are universal, that's a crazy thing. It's even crazier that your basis for asserting it is that you did some drugs.
The reason psychiatric treatments require experimentation is because most psychiatric drugs are poorly understood in their mechanisms. We use them mainly because of pragmatic effects - not because we actually know their precise mechanisms.
I never said my experiences are universal, just that amphetamines have a markedly simple mechanism in humans and other animals -- that is, increasing dopaminergic activity, along with noradrenal activity. It is common knowledge that by increasing levels of dopamine, harder tasks can be performed without as much exhaustion. But mind you, the body's energy supply isn't unlimited - and though the mind might be more resilient, the body still pays for the extra activity done under guise of ease.
It is clear that you find the tradeoff worth it. Like you said, everyone has different experiences and finds different tradeoffs worth it. For me, the tradeoff isn't worth it - I find that taking amphetamines daily extracts most of the beneficial effects into tolerance, and what follows is pretty much just maintanence. If you find the tradeoff worth it, then clearly you should be using it. Only you can decide whether you are getting an overall positive effect from a narcotic that provides both positive and negative effects.
My main point is that we cannot deny that amphetamines are hard drugs - narcotics. And thus, it seems wrong to give them to kids with such ease.
I'm sorry that you think another person's life experiences are shit.
> I have to wonder if I'm reading from some big pharma social media bot.
It's very strange to hear this coming from an account created 15 days ago with a generic name and scant comment history.
> It makes you neurotic, trapped in your own head...you...you...you...
I would like to be the first totally-a-human person to welcome you to the real world where your personal feelings aren't universal truths.
I often wonder how horrible my life would have been if I had done well in school and not pursued my dreams through entrepreneurship.
I’m greatful every day that I get to live life riding the roller coaster of startup life.
My personality is well suited to the insanity and chaos often brought to this kind of life.
Had I been tempered by medication so the words stopped moving and I didn’t have to re-read I might never have learned how to learn.
It is true that the statistics show that those who are born with the right traits to succeed in life are more likely to do well in school and in the workplace, which is unsurprising. Life is a gradient, but when we take it to the logical extreme, it becomes quite apparent that someone with a crippling mental disability is not going to be able to go far in school, nor are they going to be a top choice to do business with. But that does not mean that there are not cases where people who are born with the right traits slip through the system. The education system is big and complex and sometimes fails. Someone with successful traits does not lose their successful traits from that experience.
That said, I agree that there is more to life than career success. The enrichment that school could have provided him may have made his life better in other ways.
I feel like the raw statistics are a bit misleading here, because yes, on average, formal education improves outcomes. And I think most of us here are hardcore outliers, and have a passion for learning and self-development outside of a formal education context.
A passion for learning only helps if you learn useful things, and a child with ADHD will focus on what they find interesting. And I don't see how improving your ability to focus on uninteresting things would have held you back.
I've found the most magic in finding the intersection of useful and interesting, and suspect that this has led me to more satisfaction than someone who has found something only useful and used their willpower to focus on it.
Second,those aren't the two options. You're gaining the ability to focus on uninteresting things, something people without ADHD have and don't use constantly. All the traits mentioned in your last post don't disappear when you add the ability to focus.
How likely is it the failing in school helps you? Not very.
Given that you have succeeded because of failing in school, what was the probability that failing in school helped you? There's no such thing as that probability because there's no such thing as how likely it is that your actual outcome came about. There's no such thing as what fraction of possible life-outcomes are similar to your actual outcome. At least you can't possibly know these things.
Lets hope it works out in the Whitehouse also.
I see where you're coming from, and happy to find your relatively niche fit, and for sure I hope it's something long term sustainable.
But since you're clearly describing something you don't have experience with - what your life would be when actually finishing university and being more 'stable' - you paint a dark picture. It's actually opposite - you would have many more options in life.
I've met tons of 'unstable' people in life, for whatever reason - they can sometimes find spot in the universe to fit in, but long term they almost always, consistently struggle. Their life is a mess. Relationships are often crap. Long-term happiness and life balance are mythical phrases. And so on.
I hope this isn't and never will describe you (and ideally nobody)
25 years later I’m so glad she did and I’ve benefitted enormously. Ultimately I wound up with a combination of a stimulant medicine and a low dose anti-seizure medicine to take some of the edge off the stimulant (speaking fast, jumpy, etc).
In the end, the experience has made me much more of a believer in psychiatry than psychotherapy. I never benefitted from that the few times psychiatrist I’ve had have requested me take it. If anything, going to confession / mass has helped more in the “non-medicine” stuff you can do.
> Dr. Allen Frances, professor emeritus at Duke University School of Medicine, the former chairman of its psychiatry department, and the chairman of the DSM-IV (1994) task force, feels the problem is not corruption but the slow creep of misinformation. "I know the people. They're not doing it for the drug companies—they really believe what they're doing is right. They really believe ADHD is underdiagnosed, and they want to help people who should be getting medication. I just think they're dead wrong."
I probably would have been on these meds if not for a teacher who became a mentor to me. He helped teach me how to study and other things that were enormously valuable to me, but never would have happened normally.
I get your sentiment. I can say Adderall has helped me so much that I could get teary eyed. But thats only because I am too lazy and lack the willpower to discipline myself naturally. Speed is an easy way out of self improvement. The last thing we should do is put kids on it, and promote a life long cycle of helplessness and shortcuts to mental toughness through drugs.
Have you been diagnosed with ADHD? Do you even believe in ADHD? Your post seems to contain a lot of self-hatred, which is sad to read. As someone diagnosed at the age of 31 I have had a lot of time to reflect on my childhood and early experiences, and despite managing and in many ways thriving, medication earlier on would have made a lot of subtle differences that would have made things much easier over the course of my adult life.
I've never experienced a "cold, robotic mind space" either :)
Amphetamines aren't somehow special for one person and not for another, lest we are talking about actual brain damage.
They will make any person more apt to do mental and physical tasks. So keep on excusing the fact that you are doing a hard drug as a substitute for actually learning to learn. Being on speed your whole life is not a good thing. It's gross that this thread is being subverted to claim non-medical anecdotes about how gentle a hard drug is, and "once you get used to it, its no big deal!"
It's fucking speed! Of course it makes you feel great and more energetic. Thats what stimulants do!
(not advocating for this...yet).
It's easy to dismiss the value of these medicines if you've never felt saved by them. It's hard to understand how painful and frustrating it is for a child to not be able to complete an exam because when he gets a few words into a question he has to start over from the beginning again and again and again and again and again because the words just keep slipping away from him. It's hard to explain that, no, extra time doesn't actually mean a special edge against other children who don't have the same problem. It's hard feeling really bad at subjects that you're actually really good at because you can't keep your thoughts together. It's hard to walk out of an exam room crying because you can feel yourself starting to lose your grip. It's hard as an adult to say "this saved my life" to another adult who doesn't understand it. But it's just weird when adults who are perfectly happy to drug themselves on the regular for no other reason than because it feels good are like "yeah, but..." when there are kids out there who will gladly take negative side effects over the alternative.