Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany
by gambiting on Sunday March 04, 2018 @05:03AM
(#16514032)
Sure, but Germans having an issue with an American site just cost that American company €50,000 for no reason at all. I agree with the poster saying that if Germany had an issue with content they could have just blocked the website themselves.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany
by jhasse on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:04AM
(#16514559)
The books being available for download for free might have cost a German company even more. So I wouldn't say "no reason at all".
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany
by gambiting on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:21AM
(#16514615)
Like I said before - there is a legal path for foreign companies to sue American companies under the American legal system. If the plaintiff could demonstrate loses due to actions by project Gutenberg, I'm 100% certain that an American court would have ruled in favour of the plaintiff. But this €50k isn't even going to the publisher - it's in fees to the German court system, which - in my opinion - could have been completely and totally ignored. So when I said "no reason at all" I meant that PG will now be paying €50k for something that they shouldn't be a part of.