News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by nimbius on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:11PM (#16504699)
Quitting to start your own business is lauded in the annals of Americana because it positively reinforces certain tenets capitalism that are valued by the ruling class.

Organizing a labor union however is vilified in American society as it directly challenges the inherent class structure of capitalism. Workers in the past have been beaten, murdered, and imprisoned not because they sought better pay and more amicable working hours, but because they dared to challenge the success and profit of the classes above them.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pmarreck on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:19PM (#16504757)
Which is why a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative is a more ethically-defensible way to organize humans.

Or pretty much any business model where all the laborers share in any profits by the collective.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by dqpb on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:31PM (#16504848)
Are there any notable tech coops?
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by nathan_f77 on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:43PM (#16504939)
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by jboynyc on Monday March 05, 2018 @03:58AM (#16519697)
See this Ask HN from four years ago for a few good examples from around the world: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7634152
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pathseeker on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:55PM (#16505085)
How is democratic voting control fair to the people that have put significantly more work and history into the company?
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by substack on Friday March 02, 2018 @03:04PM (#16505172)
How is a command hierarchy where a board of investors appoints a CEO fair to the people who actually built the company?
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by emerged on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:34PM (#16504868)
Tyranny of the many has dangers just as does tyranny of the few. There can be significant downsides to unions, so it's a bit reductive to think they're a universal good and that to disagree with them in any case is necessarily about "the inherent class structure of capitalism"
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pdkl95 on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:39PM (#16504907)
Unions (or similar labor organizations) are not only a universal good, capitalism only works when ^both* labor and capital keep each other restrained. The problems start when either side is allowed to "win". Power always needs to be restrained with checks and balances.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by lolsal on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:46PM (#16504982)
> Unions (or similar labor organizations) are not only a universal good

Can you explain why this is universally true? It seems that the behavior of companies reacting negatively to unions is a counterpoint to this.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pdkl95 on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:50PM (#16505028)
> companies reacting negatively to unions

Yes, that's the intended result. Each side has to fight for their own goals. The resulting competition is what limits each side from gaining too much power.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by lolsal on Sunday March 04, 2018 @02:58PM (#16516321)
You did not address why unions are a universal good.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by rexpop on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:53PM (#16505059)
What happens when the "Union side" "wins"?
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by conanbatt on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:40PM (#16504915)
Sure, and this is a good case of things being kept in check.

A union that only subsists because it gets special state powers is not a union, its government.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by dragonwriter on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:51PM (#16505041)
> A union that only subsists because it gets special state powers is not a union, its government.

You do realize that all business organizations other the sole proprietorships and simple partnerships (including, but not necessarily limited to, all of, in the US, corporations of any kind, LPs, LLPs, LLLPs, and LLCs) only subsist because they get special state powers, right?

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by conanbatt on Saturday March 03, 2018 @10:26PM (#16513100)
The state could do away with all of those and corporations would still exist.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pdkl95 on Sunday March 04, 2018 @02:40AM (#16513689)
Corporations are a "special power" granted by the government by definition.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by conanbatt on Sunday March 04, 2018 @03:58AM (#16513859)
Only in the legal sense, not in the economical sense.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pdkl95 on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:45PM (#16504965)
> special state powers

Like the limited liability granted to corporations?

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by pathseeker on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:51PM (#16505032)
I'm not sure you understand what that means. The limited liability applies to the people. The corporation is still fully liable.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by dragonwriter on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:56PM (#16505089)
The corporation is a legal fiction created by government to shield the people from liability for harm those people cause through their agents while seeking profits; it's the original (well, at least an early) manifestation of socializing risk while privatizing gains, done through the power of the State.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by knieveltech on Friday March 02, 2018 @04:24PM (#16505842)
"The corporation is still fully liable." is incoherent. Pfizer (the corporation) is a convicted felon. Whereas this would basically eliminate an individual's access to credit, ability to vote, and a whole host of other rights and privileges, in the context of a multi-national corporation it means literally nothing. They got fined a little money, that's it.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by conanbatt on Friday March 02, 2018 @06:36PM (#16506739)
Unions also have limited liability.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by dragonwriter on Friday March 02, 2018 @06:39PM (#16506753)
Yes, unions are usually corporations. But it's not the side defending unions in this thread arguing that relying on government-granted power deligitimize an organization.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by andrei_says_ on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:49PM (#16505013)
I completely agree. If we look at the compensation growth in the last 50 years, I think we can see that “tyranny of the few” has been the predominant force in the U.S. and things have been far, far out of balance.

Worker pay has been extremely stagnant while c-suite pay has skyrocketed to over 300x the worker pay.

This wouldn’t be so problematic if worker pay was not being pushed below livable wages. The presence of unions could balance things a bit.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by Mithaldu on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:39PM (#16504910)
Leaving anything run unchecked has downsides. If "has any downsides" is good enough to exclude it, then you can't do anything ever.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by humanrebar on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:22PM (#16504775)
There are lots of people who vote against unions that don't care one bit about the "inherent class structure of capitalism".
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by zorpner on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:29PM (#16504834)
Choosing the status quo is still a choice, in this case in favor of the inherent class structure of capitalism.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by chimeracoder on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:40PM (#16504913)
> Organizing a labor union however is vilified in American society as it directly challenges the inherent class structure of capitalism. Workers in the past have been beaten, murdered, and imprisoned not because they sought better pay and more amicable working hours, but because they dared to challenge the success and profit of the classes above them.

This is unabashedly revisionist. Look at what labor unions did throughout the first half of the 20th century. They went to great lengths to ensure that their members could access the privileges of the upper capitalist classes by explicitly oppressing other groups of people - black workers, east Asians, south Asians, Mexicans, and Puerto Ricans. They fought to deport legal immigrants and migrant works. They fought to inter (poor) Japanese-Americans in camps in order to free up jobs for their relatively well-off, white members. After the war, they fought to prevent Japanese-Americans from returning to their homes. The immigration quotas that people oftentimes complain about on Hacker News? Those quotas were originally written to appease labor unions in the first place. The disaster in Puerto Rico? Labor unions opposed allowing foreign relief ships to temporarily service Puerto Rico, which has been standard practice for every single hurricane since Katrina, because they wanted to protect US members' paychecks.

If you want to cherry-pick some good things labor unions have fought for, fine, but don't portray them as the antagonist of capitalist class structure. Labor unions have always thrived on class inequality; their goal is simply to make sure that their members are on the "right" side of it.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by dtornabene on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:51PM (#16505035)
That depends entirely on which unions you're looking at, the wobblies were organizing across racial lines and across industries. The pullman porters were black. And, yeah, unions very much are a class antagonist, they were conceived as precisely that. I'd even go so far as to say that actually your comment is the revisionist one. Note how you start the history at "the first half of the 20th century" leaving out arguably the most violent and repressive period of union struggle. Google The Battle of Blair mountain.
Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by chimeracoder on Friday March 02, 2018 @03:00PM (#16505142)
> That depends entirely on which unions you're looking at, the wobblies were organizing across racial lines and across industries. The pullman porters were black.

I'm looking at the unions that were the strongest, the most powerful, and the most influential. The IWW was never particularly strong after WWI, and that was at the peak of their membership. AFL- and CIO-affiliated unions were the strongest - and, more importantly, remain so to this day.

It's funny you mention the porters' union - they were the first to receive recognition by the AFL. Why is that unusual? Well, they were special not because they were a union that represented black members, but because they were the first union of black members that the AFL didn't deny membership to based on race, after decades of explicitly prohibiting black unions from joining their federation. (Even after that, they refused to recognize most unions that accepted black or Japanese workers as members).

> I'd even go so far as to say that actually your comment is the revisionist one.

No, it's not "revisionist" to point out counterexamples to OP's claim, especially when those counterexamples include the largest group of unions for the last 100 years.

Yes, sometimes it's convenient for labor unions to leverage rhetoric that flirts with socialism or communism, but in reality, their source of power is dependent on both capitalism and class hierarchy, which is why the largest and most influential ones have fought so hard to preserve it.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by dtornabene on Friday March 02, 2018 @04:09PM (#16505714)
You also neatly sidestepped my point about the origin of these unions, by starting in the "early 20th". You also ignored the Blair Mountain reference, and other deeply capital-hostile examples of union struggle. Unions started as an instrument of class struggle and remain precisely that, the fact that that is even slightly controversial is more representative of the ideological climate of today and specifically this website. Also, if unions are not a direct, full frontal attack on capital and hierarchy, why are they facing constant attack from organs of ruling class consciousness, like, say, the WSJ, the Financial Times, or even other less explicit papers like the New York Times? Why are teachers unions treated like the scum of the earth everywhere? Its downright weird that this is even questionable.

EDIT Also worth pointing out, there is an anti-union case being argued before the supreme court today. Its been widely acknowledged as an attempt to "kneecap" public-sector unions. If unions are not hostile to capital, are not an element of class struggle, where do these battles come from? Why are unions perpetually on the defensive, not merely from specific owners of specific companies facing individual actions, but across the board from class conscious (from above) institutions and people who have no individual stake in any given organizing struggle.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by okdana on Friday March 02, 2018 @04:44PM (#16506039)
>Also, if unions are not a direct, full frontal attack on capital and hierarchy, why are they facing constant attack from organs of ruling class consciousness, like, say, the WSJ, the Financial Times, or even other less explicit papers like the New York Times?

The fact that the capitalist class doesn't appreciate tactics that complicate or reduce the effectiveness of their preferred business practices doesn't mean that those tactics represent an attack on capitalism itself. Corporations violently oppose taxes and regulations, too, but neither threatens capitalism or its fundamental class structure.

>Unions started as an instrument of class struggle and remain precisely that, the fact that that is even slightly controversial is more representative of the ideological climate of today and specifically this website.

It's hardly peculiar to the 'climate of today'. Karl Marx, 1865:

At the same time, and quite apart from the general servitude involved in the wages system, the working class ought not to exaggerate to themselves the ultimate working of these everyday struggles. They ought not to forget that they are fighting with effects, but not with the causes of those effects; that they are retarding the downward movement, but not changing its direction; that they are applying palliatives, not curing the malady. They ought, therefore, not to be exclusively absorbed in these unavoidable guerilla fights incessantly springing up from the never ceasing encroachments of capital or changes of the market. They ought to understand that, with all the miseries it imposes upon them, the present system simultaneously engenders the material conditions and the social forms necessary for an economical reconstruction of society. Instead of the conservative motto: “A fair day's wage for a fair day's work!” they ought to inscribe on their banner the revolutionary watchword: “Abolition of the wages system!”

And in regards to unions specifically:

Trades Unions work well as centers of resistance against the encroachments of capital. They fail partially from an injudicious use of their power. They fail generally from limiting themselves to a guerilla war against the effects of the existing system, instead of simultaneously trying to change it, instead of using their organized forces as a lever for the final emancipation of the working class that is to say the ultimate abolition of the wages system.

Re:Tech company Lanetix fired software engineers seeking to ... by refurb on Friday March 02, 2018 @02:53PM (#16505060)
Organizing a labor union however is vilified in American society as it directly challenges the inherent class structure of capitalism.

It's vilified because of the corruption and strong-armed tactics many unions have resorted to in the US. You talk about beatings and murders, but the unions pretty quickly took up those tactics as well.