News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by jsmeaton on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:32AM (#16501199)
It sounds like it was one manager. Is that all you need to blacklist an entire company?
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by humanrebar on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:30AM (#16501559)
How a company deals with a bad manager is very important. Assuming you believe the accusations (1), the fact that Google wasn't immediately firing people and settling with the plaintiff is worse than the original complaint.

(1) A big if. I haven't seen any hard evidence yet.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by notahacker on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:54AM (#16501798)
I imagine that not believing the accusations (or believing other accusations - true or not - made by the manager against the plaintiff) play a large role in Google not rushing to settle. They'd be mad not to regardless of their politics if the course of events happened exactly as described.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by fwdpropaganda on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:36AM (#16501224)
To be fair, from the outside it is often hard to tell what is one manager and what is company culture.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by tyingq on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:37AM (#16501620)
The complaint is pretty detailed and compelling. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4391847-18-CIV-00442...
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by PeterisP on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:16AM (#16502038)
It's not hard - if in this escalation the company would have facepalmed and fired the manager, than that would be the case of one weird manager; but if the company fires the recruiter and keeps the manager, then obviously that's the company culture they intentionally want to have.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by organsnyder on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:45AM (#16501276)
For any organization this size, assume that there is a fair amount of variance from one division to another.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by nugi on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:54AM (#16501320)
I hold all organizations responsible for their own actions, reguardless of size. Too big to fail is a poor concept, logically, ethically.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by boomboomsubban on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:07AM (#16501414)
This isn't too big to fail, it's "a bad egg doesn't ruin the bunch." Whether that's the case here is arguable, but no one is saying they aren't responsible for their actions.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by novembermike on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:25AM (#16502122)
The saying is "one bad apple ruins the bunch".
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by gaius on Friday March 02, 2018 @04:28PM (#16505881)
Neither eggs nor apples come in bunches!
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by nugi on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:28AM (#16501543)
Is 'allowing for variance' up to and including racism and sexisism in hiring? Because it seems like you are giving them a pass, because there are many hiring managers.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by edanm on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:53AM (#16501788)
If someone who worked for Walmart became a murderer, would you condemn all of Walmart as murderers? Promoting a culture of murder?

If that's too far removed from the actual job for you, how about if someone at Walmart acted in a sexist way in an interview. Would you condemn all of Walmart? Would you automatically assume there is a culture of sexism? Or would you at least entertain the possibility that Walmart employs thousands of managers, so it's not crazy to imagine that some of them might sometimes act in sexist ways, even without such a corporate culture?

You need more than a few instances to prove a claim of "this must be a cultural thing", IMO.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by HelloNurse on Friday March 02, 2018 @11:04AM (#16502605)
A Walmart shop could be an isolated environment where a bad person can prosper despite a generally contrary company culture, but it isn't an appropriate comparison for this case: important HR managers like this Alogna aren't many, even in a large company, and the higher level management who kept him and fired the recruiter is an even smaller part of Google. They must be assumed to be representative of the whole company.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by organsnyder on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:34AM (#16501587)
I'm not saying that bad behavior should be dismissed. But I am saying that the larger the organization, the more potential there is for there to be a bad actor that doesn't match the overall organization's culture.

If the recruiter's accusation is indeed true, then we should ask questions about whether it is endemic to the entire organization. Though given the company's size—especially its growth through acquisitions (such as YouTube)—it's likely that the behavior is constrained to a single manager or department.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by cm2187 on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:44AM (#16501263)
Well apparently the company stands behind the decision of its manager.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by Unkechaug on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:51AM (#16501306)
I doubt this single incident alone is the reason, but maybe the catalyst. Google and its unhealthy lust for diversity has been an increasingly frequent topic. Hell, someone got fired for posting an anti diversity rant last year. While his arguments were weak or flat out wrong, it's clear that Google is making a point to single out underrepresented minorities to the detriment of others who may actually be better candidates.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by DanHulton on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:58AM (#16501357)
I mean, if it's the same memo in thinking of, it wasn't a "diversity memo" he was fired over, it was a manifesto that has been reviewed and agreed on as sufficient cause for his dismissal several times now.

In it, he argued that women were essentially worse at logical tasks than men, and further that this made them poor engineers.

That's not a diversity memo, that's a sexist screed.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by naasking on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:40AM (#16501640)
> In it, he argued that women were essentially worse at logical tasks than men, and further that this made them poor engineers.

No he didn't. He said they were inherently less interested in STEM, and speculated about a few personality characteristics from psych research that might explain why, but all of that is irrelevant. Damore explicitly said that you can't judge individual competence from a probability distribution, even if the distribution of competence of each gender were different (which they largely are not).

Here's a broad overview of the literature covering what Damore got right and wrong: http://heterodoxacademy.org/the-google-memo-what-does-the-re...

Turns out, he was right that women seem to have different interests. I suggest reading about the things vs. people hypothesis. You can get more women into STEM subfields that deal with people if you highlight those aspects. Hiring quotas and some of the other measures Damore was arguing against would indeed have no effect on gender diversity given these facts.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by ofirg on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:09AM (#16501430)
That is not what the memo said. did you not read it or is this what you think the writer meant even if he did not actually write that but you have some kind of mind reading abilities?
[dead]
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by viridian on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:42AM (#16501674)
There are a couple of reasons people are so quick to claim other people didn't read the memo verbatim. The first being that the first major publication to run with it, and the biggest one here on HN, was the verge's article where citations and graphs were stripped away from it.

The other is that is it often given such uncharitable descriptions that people who have read it simply can't believe the hate levied at it comes from actually having read the thing. I've actually talked this whole topic through for hours back and forth with someone who is very against the memo, but even they they would call it a sexist manifesto. That sort of thing comes across as off the cuff criticism by people who haven't read the thing.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by acdha on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:53AM (#16501781)
There are many people who’ve read it and reached the same conclusion about his claims. Simply accusing people of not having read it – or the other standard talking point of claiming that the citations somehow completely change the meaning – is a dishonest way to avoid engaging with those criticisms. If they’re wrong, it should be easy to demonstrate that or find a statement by Damore that he didn’t intend his words to be read that way.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by viridian on Friday March 02, 2018 @12:24PM (#16503607)
Sure thing. He says as such during his interview with Joe Rogan. If your claim is that he intends to present the idea that women are inferior in this field, that interview contradicts it.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by acdha on Friday March 02, 2018 @01:27PM (#16504296)
Right, so that would be the thing to talk about rather falsely accusing people of not reading his original memo — it was certainly sloppy enough to be possible that the way many people read it was not how he originally intended.

If he's made direct statements rejecting biological determinism it should be easy enough to cite them — and it'd be useful to do so to avoid distraction when his supporters try to rehash the arguments in favor of that position.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by ofirg on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:36AM (#16501608)
You do no get to decide what contributes and what does not beyond your +-1. you do not have the moral high ground when you are repeating lies. It is clear to me that anyone that has read the memo, and is not laying will not describe it the way DanHulton did. Seems to me that what ever conversation you want to have it should not be based on falsehoods.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by dwringer on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:04AM (#16501907)
I read it, and I think DanHulton described it in pretty much the same way I would. The charts struck me as lacking meaningful context, and loose correlations were treated as logical, causal relationships in support for discriminatory hypotheses, reading like a case study in how to fallaciously present opinion as fact through charts and statistics.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by NutriSugar on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:27AM (#16501542)
Are we counting reviews by pushing the same narrative that was being pushed by the people he originally offended? What I've seen is a number of scientists (in the specific fields that are related to it) backing his work, others attacking it, and all agreeing it doesn't rise to the muster of a peer reviewed paper/meta-analysis (though that seems a pretty insane bar to begin with).
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by emsy on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:07AM (#16501412)
Agreed on by whom? Did you even read the memo yourself?
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by ng12 on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:40AM (#16501237)
If he was fired over it, absolutely.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by johngalt on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:07AM (#16501944)
Per the complaint it appears to be four managers in a row across two levels of management. With HR getting involved haphazardly at best.

Keep in mind that this is only one side of the story. There is little evidence to support the complaint. It's too early to draw conclusions.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by kerng on Friday March 02, 2018 @10:44AM (#16502357)
Where there is smoke, there might be fire. Its not unlikeley related to KPIs set by high managment (given the news around Google in the past). And further down the food chain managers want to look good and do these things.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by chippy on Friday March 02, 2018 @09:02AM (#16501379)
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4391847-18-CIV-00442...

It appears it was more than one. Possibly it was two.

Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by bbarn on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:34AM (#16501209)
That happens every day, in every industry. That's why selecting managers is so important.
Re:Ex-Google recruiter: I was fired because I resisted “ille... by whatyoucantsay on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:47AM (#16501286)
This is a good point. There's a lot of negative press and truly appalling allegations swirling about Google, but it's near impossible to get an accurate idea of extent or even the truth of the situation from the outside.

Based on Reddit stories for a while, it seemed that even settin foot in the US was a near guarantee one would then be tasered, have their money taken by police officers, and then detained by agents from an unknown 3-letter agency and shipped to Guantanamo.

It's possible, though we have no way of knowing, that what's in this story is a case of a lone manager with an axe to grind. It's also possible that the attitude is pervasive.

It's likely best to withhold judgement and keep asking questions.