News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by yostrovs on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:08AM (#16473021)
Perhaps my view of German energy industry is not detailed, but what are the advantages of diesel engines in cars if not efficiency?

Cold starts can be hard, they smell, make a funny sound, slow to accelerate. Maybe maintenance is easier when there are no spark plugs.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by olex on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:12AM (#16473042)
> slow to accelerate

Have you driven a modern diesel? At lower speeds, they easily beat similar-displacement petrol cars off the line with superior torque. They are weaker at high speeds, but in normal (especially city) driving, a diesel is usually faster than a petrol.

But yeah, their main factor for popularity is the cost per km. They use less fuel than petrol engines, and the fuel is less expensive (in Germany). This is offset by higher road tax and insurance somewhat, but for commuters and others who drive a lot (>~20000km per year) diesels are a much more cost effective option in Germany than anything else.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by Svip on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:00AM (#16473358)
Diesel isn't that cost efficient actually, even if you drive a lot. Diesel are more expensive to maintain due to regulations, plus diesel cars tend to be more expensive their petrol counterparts. Moreover, there is depreciation, which tend to be worse for diesel cars, because they are valued less on the second hand market (fairly or unfairly).

On average, you should expect to drive at least 150.000+ km before you've broken even on a diesel car with its petrol counterpart.

People only look at fuel consumption and fuel prices, but maintenance and depreciation are actually one's biggest loss on a car purchase. And in general petrol comes out on top.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:18PM (#16475557)
The premium of diesel engines over petrol is one of the key reasons that we don't get many in the USA (the other issue being emissions). Bob Lutz, former GM CEO, was a big proponent of diesel but repeatedly acknowledged that it doesn't make sense in the USA. The market for people willing to pay the $5,000 premium (in 2007 dollars, mind you) was very small. Americans don't appreciate just how cheap cars in their region are.

GM did manage to get a diesel Cruze into the USDM market, and keep it here, but it's low-margin and not a huge seller. A manual diesel Cruze starts at about $25,000 (compared to $17,000 for the base). So it is basically slotted as an "enthusiast" model, just not a high-performance one like Ford and Honda would offer.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @10:04AM (#16473881)
Different tax systems can affect the equation even if you disregard that you pay less at the pump for fuel that your car consumes less than a petrol equivalent – lower CO2 figures may also mean that you pay less yearly fees or less taxes on car registration as well. The break-even figure certainly varies by country (as does depreciation of different cars).
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by zaarn on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:38AM (#16473637)
Diesel has a higher maintenance cost too, especially if you only drive short distances. IIRC the main cost here is the catalysator, which basically clogs up if it can't properly heat up. That doesn't happen on short range.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by c3833174 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:20PM (#16476296)
No, that only applies to cars with the more fancy antiparticulate filter that also requires urea fluid.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by xyzzyz on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:18PM (#16478003)
No, this has nothing to do with urea fluid. This is just a quirk of some DPFs.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by blau3 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:22PM (#16478574)
> Now Germany spews out about same carbon as before giant investments in solar, electricity is four times the price as in US, plus they now have to buy from France cause they don't produce enough.

Well, they require a more complex motor which handles higher pressures and supercharging. The picture would be different if you would compare motors with the same price.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by bluedino on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:24PM (#16475624)
It's an illusion that diesel vehicles are faster than gasoline. Gasoline engines have way more horsepower and are faster that the diesel options (unless Germans are getting neutered or smaller power plants than say, the USA)
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by bdamm on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @04:18PM (#16478006)
That's a strange statement. More horsepower based on what? I think if you look around, you'll see that the largest and highest horsepower combustion engines all burn diesel. Semi-trailers are exclusively diesel.

Your statement on speed is also odd. Record setting cars may burn gas, but your typical car driving around a city or highway needn't ever go faster than 160km/h. Most cars can achieve this, and most modern cars, whether diesel or gas, can achieve this without much difficulty.

This leaves us with acceleration, where diesel vs gas is equally unclear. As small diesel engines often ship with turbos, you'd be perhaps comparing a turbocharged 2.0L diesel vs a normally aspirated 2.0L gas engine. Assuming roughly equivalent mass of the cars, with higher low-end torque, the diesel will win just about any street race.

If what you're comparing is purchase price to acceleration, then indeed the gas cars may win.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:46PM (#16478770)
> the diesel will win just about any street race.

This is really wrong. It's a weird myth that gets perpetuated in America where people don't really drive diesels.

Let's compare a 2.0L diesel Golf TDI to a 2.0L petrol Golf GTI. Same car, same displacement, both turbo engines.

The Golf TDI does 0-60 in 9.0s and a quarter mile of 17.0s@84 mph.

The Golf GTI does 0-60 in 5.7s and a quarter mile of 14.2s@100 mph.

There's a staggering difference in performance there. The TDI is so slow that it's genuinely difficult to find a Motor Trend instrument test on a slower car, because at that point, it's too slow to really bother.

I found the 2018 Rav4: 0-60 in 9.3s and a quarter mile of 17.0@82.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by Matthias247 on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:03AM (#16480794)
If you want to do this comparison please do it right: The Diesel equivalent to the Golf GTI is the Golf GTD. There's more than just displacement that makes up an engine and the fact that is some kind of turbocharger.

Their difference in 0-60 seems to be 6.4s vs 7.4s according to what I find. Guess the difference in higher regions might be even less, because of a different torque profile in turbocharged diesel engines.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Thursday March 01, 2018 @10:43AM (#16492810)
The GTD is Euro-only, so it's harder to get performance comparisons. But it's still much slower than the GTI, I found a 15.6@93 in the quarter.

0-60 is an awful way to measure acceleration; most of what it measures in modern cars is traction, since a Mk7 GTI will shred the front tires with a hard launch. So high five second and low six second times are both accurate, it just depends how good the launch was.

That's why you compare quarter mile times when looking at acceleration. And the GTI is still so much faster than the GTD; a full second and a half and 7mph trap. Meaning, in a drag race, the GTD wouldn't be close enough to read the GTI's license plate.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by bdamm on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @01:14PM (#16485210)
I think the 0-40 profile would be much more favorable to the TDI, and much more useful to the typical driver. But we'll never really know as that's not the standard measurement.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Thursday March 01, 2018 @11:04AM (#16493045)
The diesel golf is still a lot slower to 40 than the GTI. The TDI diesel has a lot of turbo lag, a narrow powerband, and poor gearing. What people who've never owned diesel cars fail to realize is, that peak torque number is hugely misleading. It sounds impressive, but it starts from like 2200RPMs and falls off a cliff past 3500. While a (modern) turbocharged petrol engine has full torque by ~1800rpms and that lasts until like 5000rpms.

I've owned a (Jetta) TDI before, I even tried to make it fast. Even with a tune and full exhaust it was slower than a stock turbo petrol.

It's always Americans that talk about how awesome diesels are. I never see posts from Europeans (who are the ones that actually have to drive them) talking up diesels. They are always complaining about how terrible they are.

Diesels are great for trucks, but not cars.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by kazinator on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:48PM (#16478779)
If it were true, Formula-1 would use nothing but diesel engines.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Thursday March 01, 2018 @10:46AM (#16492850)
This comment makes no sense. I'm saying diesel engines are bad for performance. It's not physically possible to make a diesel 1.6L engine that produces F1 levels of power, they just can't spin fast enough.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by kazinator on Thursday March 01, 2018 @11:48AM (#16493587)
The comment make sense, since I'm saying "[i]f it were true [that diesels easily beat gasoline burners in a street race], Formula-1 would use nothing but diesel engines [which they don't at all]."
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by nawitus on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:18PM (#16475552)
You need power for acceleration, not torque. (But I agree that modern diesel cars accelerate fast enough).
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by 72deluxe on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:25AM (#16473105)
I have not had a problem with cold starts with diesels in the decade I've been driving them. I did have a VW Golf with a PD engine but now have a VW with a Common Rail engine. In both cases I prefer them to petrol cars because:

a. the torque is great - not slow to accelerate at all. Try one! The PD engine had great low-end torque but the common rail has great torque for the entire power band, which is extensive. Really rapid. Perhaps you were driving an ancient SD-engined vehicle without a turbo??

b. Driving is so smooth; petrol is quicker to respond which is less forgiving.

Also, as the engine components are larger and slower moving, they last far longer; my work colleague's 2005 5-series BMW is nearing 250,000 miles and is still supremely fast. (Contrast with a bike engine that goes for 40k or 50k due to high revs?)

My 2008 Golf did get smokey but the guy I sold it to has been using the BP cleaning diesel (or the Shell equivalent) and says it doesn't smoke at all any more.

I like the sound of them; the non-sporty petrol cars round by me sound like the engine is rattling to pieces (eg my colleague's Vauxhall Astra); with high-performance tuned sports cars then yes the petrol sounds great. I rarely see any V-configuration engines these days.

This perspective is from myself in the UK.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by MasterPI on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:20AM (#16473084)
> they smell

And petrol cars don't smell?

> slow to accelerate

I think you've never driven a big modern engine diesel car. I have driven this BMW 535d[0] and believe me this monster is not "slow" in any way (0-100km/h in 5.5 seconds). It accelerates faster than the petrol equivalent because of the more torque it produces.

[0]http://www.automobile-catalog.com/car/2011/1337945/bmw_535d....

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by pebers on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:00PM (#16475364)
> And petrol cars don't smell?

I at least find the smell of diesel actively unpleasant; petrol isn't something I'd choose to smell all the time but it's still nowhere near as bad.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:30PM (#16475682)
Sure, a big engine diesel is quick, but small-engine ones are slow. The lack of top-end power makes them suffer at highway-speed passing. The diesel Cruze, for example, has a 5% (4mph) lower trap speed at the end of the quarter mile over its gas sibling (with the same 0-60).

Also consider that 3.0L I6 diesel has the same 0-60 as a 2.0L turbo four-cylinder Honda Accord, but a huge reduction in highway acceleration (traps 98mph vs. 103mph in the Accord).

[0]https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2017-chevrolet-cruze-ha...

[1]https://www.caranddriver.com/chevrolet/cruze

[2] https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2018-honda-accord-20t-a...

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by Zigurd on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @02:08PM (#16476775)
Diesels have better torque, which is mostly what feels like "power." Few people travel at top speed, so lower horsepower does not have the same feeling to the driver as high torque.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @03:58PM (#16477816)
Diesels have literally the worst powerband for automobiles, especially mated to automatic transmissions. Diesels have power down low in the RPMs, but that's never where you are when you need power. When you need to accelerate, you floor the throttle and the transmission downshifts into the upper RPMs.

They are good for accelerating 0-40, but they are significantly slower at 40+ -- which is where most people accelerate hard, like merging on the highway or passing.

When I merge onto the highway, I use 5500-7000rpms, when I don't want to accelerate quickly, I use 2000rpms. It's why I hate driving diesels: 280ft-lbs at 2000rpms is useless and only 105hp; I want 280ft-lbs at 6500rpms (345hp).

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by MasterPI on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @04:11AM (#16481739)
:) Please specify when you talk about small diesels. Non of that 0-40 acceleration is true for the 535 I mentioned in my previous comment.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Thursday March 01, 2018 @11:19AM (#16493227)
No replacement for displacement does hold true for diesels. I've seen some crazy fast, crazy large diesel pickups at the drag strip. 3.0L is about the displacement diesels can start making power, anything below that the limitations of physics are holding it back.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by morsch on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:12AM (#16473045)
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by teamhappy on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:18AM (#16473074)
> what are the advantages of diesel engines in cars if not efficiency?

I wouldn't assume that there's a direct relationship between diesel engines still being around and diesel engines still having an advantage over others. Not having to replace your fleet of trucks, buses, trains or whatever is a big enough advantage for most companies.

Also, importing energy from other countries isn't a sign of poor energy production. If buying energy from you costs me less than turning my power plant on for a day I'm gonna shut it down and call it a day. Not to mention the fact that energy prices are sometimes negative (i.e., they pay you for taking it).

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mywittyname on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @12:46PM (#16475890)
This x1000.

To add a bit, it should also be noted that many of the reliability issues that passenger diesels have are related to emissions equipment. Industrial diesels engines are not required to have all the fickle equipment, so they are generally much more reliable.

So buses and trains have significantly longer service lives and lower operating costs than passenger diesels do. Turns out, diesel engines are wonderful when you don't care about emissions.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by blensor on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:28AM (#16473124)
Can you please elaborate where you got your data points from.

I am a diesel car owner (have been for about 15 years) and I have yet to experience those issues you mention. Currently it has -12°C outside and my car starts just fine.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by scrumper on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:06AM (#16473408)
Back in the late '90s when I got my first diesel (a Citroen AX, with what was at the time the smallest production diesel power plant available) you'd have to wait many seconds for the glow plugs to warm the car before trying to start it. Diesel also freezes in the extreme cold, though that's not really a major issue in the UK. You could also run it on used cooking oil.

In the 20 years since then diesels have undergone massive and very rapid evolutionary changes through tax incentives (massively favoring low CO2, high MPG cars) and resulting fleet buying pressures. The result is what we have now: fabulously complicated, precision-engineered common rail engines with multiple turbochargers, incredible efficiency, almost petrol-like smoothness, weird stuff like urea tanks, and instant starting. If you put old vegetable oil in them they would break instantly and expensively.

I went from that AX in 1995 to a new Jaguar XJ6 in 2008 (via lots of petrol cars). The only thing they had in common was the black pump. In no other way were those engines comparable; the Jag was a beautiful, torquey, silky, rumbling thing that felt like a big V8, did 1,000 miles on a single tank, and beat 911s off the traffic lights (well, until 30mph). The AX was an agricultural dinosaur that deafened anyone in it and was so nose heavy you'd break a sweat parking it. One of those cars I could and did keep in tune with a hammer and a can of WD-40; the other needed a team of factory mechanics with computers and an expensive annual service. I sold it as soon as the warranty expired, but the AX was running fine until my sister drove it into a parked car shortly before I got the XJ.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by blau3 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @05:35PM (#16478685)
> If you put old vegetable oil in them they would break instantly and expensively.

Haha, an acquaintance of a local Linux user group I used to visit drives an old BMW which he has modified to run on vegetable oil. To be precise, oil which has been used for preparing french fries. You can easily recognize the smell. He was a car mechanic, I guess he knows quite well what he does.

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by scrumper on Thursday March 01, 2018 @12:29PM (#16494081)
Yep. A basic diesel engine is a pretty amazing thing that, like a jet engine, can burn pretty much anything and is simple to maintain. Once you start adding all the modern gubbins in it to make it efficient and powerful, you lose that generality.

The main issue with using alternative fuels in modern diesels is the injectors: unit injectors and common rail systems are high pressure, precision components that are very sensitive to fuel quality. Used frying oil is not clean.

So your mate's BMW either had some modifications to let it use vegetable oil reliably, or it's really old!

Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by Xylakant on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:44AM (#16473232)
Usually diesel fuel in winter contains additives to prevent freezing/clogging the filter. Some diesel cars also have heated filters. I’ve had a diesel car fail due to a frozen/clogged filter in winter, but that was more like -20. It’s rare, but it happens.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by mjh2539 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @08:20AM (#16473083)
In support of your statement, in comparison to gasoline, diesel costs less to produce, it has more energy per unit of volume, it is much safer to store and use, diesel engines produce more torque at lower RPMs, and yes, vehicle maintenance is less costly over the length of ownership for the vehicle.
Re:Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules by ableal on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @09:57AM (#16473821)
> vehicle maintenance is less costly

Nowadays with turbos, injectors, particle filters (required in Europe from 2007) and other fiddly bits, it's not clear that diesel engines have an advantage.

The particle filters are especially kludgy - most rely on having fuel injected down the exhaust pipe to burn the trapped cinders and regenerate the filter. If you don't run the engine long enough at 2000 rpm or so (to get the right temperature), you may clog the filter and need an expensive replacement.

(Worse yet, some designs just use the engine fuel injectors at the "wrong time" to get the piston to expel fuel down the exhaust pipe. This can contaminate the engine oil with diesel fuel and cost a few thousand in repairs, as a colleague learned the hard way ...)