A lot of the people who owe big bills to the IRS didn't make any money at all, and have no way to pay it.
As an example, say your LLC buys a million dollars worth of round iPhone cases because you're 100% sure Apple is releasing a round iPhone before Christmas 2017. Apple comes out and says "sorry, we're pushing the release to Christmas 2018!"
Now, your company has 1m in assets, probably more by a fair market value of round iPhone cases because you expected to sell them for 10m, so now the value of your company has increased by some millions of dollars.
Now, say you bet 100% of your liquid cash on that (regardless of if that's a smart idea or not), how do you pay your tax bill?
You could liquidate your round iPhone cases to someone today, but, you'll lose a ton of money on them.
This isn't a 100% perfect example, in a lot of ways, but it does indicate a highly contrived example of ways in which you can have 0 free cash while having huge reportable income.
And if next year, you only sell $1m worth of cases and you don't think you will be able to sell any more of the cases, then you write the rest off as a loss and would pay no taxes since you didn't make a profit.
And the tax man says that family business is worth $10 million. You know you could never get that much money in a sale, but the IRS doesn't care. Have a fire sale and pay them the millions you owe in taxes.
It turns out you were only able to sell it for about how much you owe in taxes. So, they adjust the appraised value and lower your tax burden right? Nope. Pay up and you may need to kick in a bit of your own money to make up the difference. Your welcome, says the IRS.
Well, not so fast. Depending on the way you earned that money and which state you lived in, you could very well end up paying more in taxes than you get to keep.
If coinbase does your buy/sell off chain than this is really more a matter of what coinbase knows/doesn't know and is/isn't willing to report. The transparency isn't asserted like it is with the blockchain which is public.
I find it stunning anyone can deliver a line like this as if the issue is quite simple, just a matter of greed vs. personal responsibility, of paying what is owed, etc, seemingly without a shred of doubt. How many deaths of Iraqi children is it that the US embargo is thought to have caused again? Isn't the federal government still grinding toward the 50th year of the drug war? "The right thing to do," it is vastly more complicated than that, and the older I get, the more it looks like when I pay the IRS, I'm feeding a machine that causes misery to others to avoid inconvenience to myself.
If you don't like what our government is doing (and I'm with you on the examples you cite), put in the time and $ to make it different.
I mean, I'm not advising anyone to not pay taxes either, but it's a protest tactic with a pedigree.
There is extremely impractical. First the voting system is extremely antiquated, and second your average American is not terribly smart, and will tend to prefer to get "free" stuff from the government paid for by people making more money.
I've seen the drug war, surveillance of US citizens (the two things you listed), the slide of America into oligarchy, and a host of other issues that I care about get worse, hardly believing it could be possible even as it happened. Yet here we are.
As a driver of change, withholding taxes doesn't seem to do much in our time. Didn't shorten our war in Vietnam. Didn't deflect the savings & loan crisis in the 80s & 90s, nor the financial crisis of 2007 - 2008. People who commit tax fraud become easy targets for Draconian civil and criminal penalties, and it's really hard to scale that strategy up to where it might be effective.
The IRS only has a right to demand what's legal. So I favor aggressive tax minimization (pay the absolute minimum the law allows), which is not tax fraud. I contribute my tax savings in hope of improving governance at all levels, and to other causes (shelters for battered women, etc.).
But I have to say, the rapid increases of regulatory capture, surveillance, and wealth concentration, along with the 2016 Presidential election result have eroded my optimism. Gerrymandering + electoral college = effective barrier to honest government. Like you, I don't see effective peaceful means of change remaining, those means having themselves been captured. It's not good, and I don't have answers at present.
You don’t want to go from mild-mannered software engineer to tax criminal, do you? Think about it hard. Government lawyers and regulators are indeed incentivized by metrics - the max number of pleas and convictions. They don’t care about your stories.
The smart move is to pay what you owe, and if you don’t like it, structure your affairs for the future to minimize taxes. But it’s very risky to lie about your past.
Additionally, tech industry workers have not exactly been worshipped by the press as of late. Expect a lot of backlash if you, an already highly paid knowledge worker, cheated to pay what taxes you dutifully owed. The press would not be kind to you, and they would not be in the wrong.