News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by lovich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @11:59AM (#16439035)
Looks like a duck, acts like a duck. Google lives and dies by their advertising revenue, they made have decided that engineering is a core component that creates all that advertising revenue but it's still just a means to and end
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by Husafan on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:41PM (#16439459)
I don't think this fits the analogy. The DNA was/is search tech long before ads came around.

It's like saying Lebron James' DNA is basketball because that's how he makes all his money. In reality, his DNA is his natural athletic abilities. Basketball is something he does well because of it.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by fizzledbits on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:12PM (#16439163)
At any large company like Google (where I worked for 4 years), if you find a way to leverage a vast existing business (i.e. ads) in what you are offering, then that's naturally an advantage for you. Doing so isn't required to survive as a project within Google and many projects don't fit that mold.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by jdietrich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:39PM (#16439434)
Thought experiment: A Google team develops a search algorithm improvement that increases the quality of results by an order of magnitude, but reduces Adwords revenue by 50%. Would management allow that improvement to be deployed to production?

Wherever you make your money, that's your business. Google's customers are advertisers rather than users, a fact that becomes readily apparent if you ever need customer support. The PR department can spin it however they like, but the accounts department see the truth in red and black.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by rock_hard on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:56PM (#16439618)
You are not gonna like this, but Google as any other healthy company would ship the improvement and take the short term revenue hit...they do so all the time!

The incentives are well aligned here because it’s proven that if you improve the product people will use it more in the long term!

Facebook just announced such thing a couple days ago...they are taking a huge hit in time spend (and therefore ad revenue) to increase meaningful interactions between friends and family’s.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by lovich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @01:19PM (#16439867)
What you are suggesting is against so much of the current american business culture that I am going to have to request some evidence here. A consistent complaint about any publicly traded company is that they are incredibly short sighted and focused on quarterly results as that is all shareholders care about.

What you have stated is that none of that is true and that everyone else is incorrect about corporate culture

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by rock_hard on Thursday February 22, 2018 @03:45PM (#16441208)
Take it from the man himself then: https://www.facebook.com/zuck/posts/10104413015393571

I personally think there is a huge difference between the old economy and how the new players play the game...it’s really what gives the later a competitive edge in the first place, being more people focused instead of money. It just happens to be that when you do that as an outcome you end up building the most valuable companies in the world!

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by cpeterso on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:02PM (#16441364)
Facebook is just reacting to reports about fake news and Russian trolls. They don't want their users to be turned off of Facebook, so they're trying to mitigate that threat.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by oblio on Thursday February 22, 2018 @04:26PM (#16441545)
> You are not gonna like this, but Google as any other healthy company would ship the improvement and take the short term revenue hit...they do so all the time!

Only because they are sitting on a mountain of cash. Let’s see if a downturn has them losing a ton of money. The safe bet is on them doing what almost big company does: fight for their core market and avoid risks.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by karprabbimiller on Friday February 23, 2018 @05:14AM (#16445408)
Thought experiment flawed assumptions. Can't reduce Adwords revenue by 50% overnight (unless by a bug). Think advertisers set budgets, they just get spent on different searches.

What could be reduced is the quality, and that could lead to gradually losing of revenue over time. So you have a trade-off between increase of quality here and decrease of quality there. So it really boils down to the ratio of these two quality changes.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by lovich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:17PM (#16439210)
The existence of technically focused projects within google doesn't change the fact that the vast majority of their efforts are made with advertising revenue as the overriding concern.

I mean fuck, the projects you're describing used to just be called R&D at companies. Xerox invented the PC, the mouse, the GUI and others in their R&D but that didn't change them into a computer company, they were still focused on printers

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by fizzledbits on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:56PM (#16439614)
The ad business funds the majority of what they do, but that doesn't mean everything or even most of what Googlers are doing day to day is tied to ads in some meaningful additional way or that every product can be viewed through that lens.

The projects I'm describing aren't all R&D. For example the GCP products aren't dependent upon or strongly connected the their ads businesses.

There are many "technically focused projects" that have users but don't relate to ads, as a byproduct of their bottom-up culture (a very real thing there which is sometimes great and other times a massive PITA, especially when trying to accomplish anything cross-PA), or as a response to innovation at other companies. In my experience Google is, for better and worse, not the manifestation of the vision of one or a small number of people, so when I hear intentions ascribed to Google writ large (such as OP's "let's not pretend that they are driven by..."), I laugh.

Does that make sense? I don't think we completely disagree.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by lovich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @01:40PM (#16440090)
Google might do all those things but ads still win. Another poster put up a thought experiment about whether google would take a 50% hit to advertising revenue for an improvement in search results. The answer to that would show what Google actually is, and I believe that Google would not take the hit

Additionally google is not flat management. As much as it might feel at the moment that it's driven from the ground up, if someone higher up the chain can put the kibosh on something below them on the chain, then it is manager driven

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by fizzledbits on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:51PM (#16440800)
edit: In the contrived scenario you referenced, I agree that the internal analysis wouldn't begin and end at simply "put the users first!" :P But since the vast majority of activity at Google isn't in that critical path, I'm not sure how useful the thought experiment is.

>> if someone higher up the chain can ... then it is manager driven

Again, it's not this simple. Things have gradations in the real world.

I've seen the "business case" be ignored because a VP doesn't think they could get their engineering team excited about it because (a) it's uninteresting or uncomplicated to implement and their perf-focused workers will transfer to other, shinier teams or (b) it's counter to the project's culture or philosophy and they will similarly lose people. Google is "management driven" in some scenarios and "engineering driven" in others. It's part of the gallows humor in Google that some mucky muck or PM is unable get their team to do something we think makes business sense.

edit #2: This is what is really meant by "bottom-up" in the case of Google. The specific incentives from their performance review system, the size of and breadth of projects at the company, and the degree of mobility of its engineers combine to give engineers concrete leverage over their management. I've worked at 4 very large companies and Google is an outlier in this regard. A number of success stories at Google can be traced to that structure, and at other times it's criticized as leading to inefficiency or redundancy, lack of focus or long term commitment, etc.

I'm not even sure what we're arguing about. Of course ads dominate the company, it's what drives the most revenue. If you're trying to have an informed view of the place that would allow you to predict or interpret some specific thing they do with some level of certainty, you can't just look at the mean statistic.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by opo on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:15PM (#16440470)
>...Xerox invented the PC, the mouse, the GUI and others

While Xerox invented the GUI and other technologies, Douglass Englebart at SRI invented the mouse and Henry Edward Roberts designed the first PC, the Altair 8800

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_mouse

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ed_Roberts_(computer_engineer)

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by lovich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:35PM (#16440666)
It appears I was incorrect about the specific list of items

My point still stands that they developed technologies outside of their core business focus but it didn't mean that their core business focus changed

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by Jyaif on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:05PM (#16439100)
I think you've got it backwards.

Pretty sure Larry and Sergei don't give a rat's ass about advertisement, they just want to do cool tech (cf investment in AI and self driving cars, among many many other things).

Advertisement revenue is a mean to do all this stuff.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by ironjunkie on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:36PM (#16439404)
That opinion is typical of the overoptimistic tech guy that drinks the Silicon Valley Koolaid.

The ONLY incentive for Google is amount of revenue, and that means ads.

They are very good to market themselves as a friendly company that cares about engineering more than advertising, but that's Branding and Marketing! And you fell for it.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by drusepth on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:48PM (#16442288)
The comment you're responding to is referring to Larry and Sergey's motivations, while you're referring to Google (as a company)'s motivations.

You both could very well be right. It's (almost always) in a company's best interest to focus on profit. That profit, however, is very often used as a means for the people in charge of that company to march towards their personal motivations, which may not always align 100% with the company (but often overlap enough for a mutual benefit).

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by AndrewUnmuted on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:11PM (#16439156)
The co-founders of an enormous company that makes all its revenue from ads... Don't give a rats ass about them? Come on, now. Be reasonable.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by coliveira on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:55PM (#16439601)
You must be kidding. Maybe this could be true for the founders, maybe they would still be nowadays developing cool technology even if it didn't make any money. This is NOT TRUE for Google. This is a company that exists solely to extract money in form of online advertisement. The moment search stops being the best vehicle for this purpose, they will boot out search to continue on their ways.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by lovich on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:14PM (#16439179)
If that were true then they wouldn't have made decisions that benefited advertising over tech or the product. Do you think they didn't give a rats ass about advertisement when they disabled the "+" operator on search for anything other than google+?
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by the-dude on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:14PM (#16439181)
Google was not a business when they only had search. When they came up with the revenue-model(ads), they became a business.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by HillaryBriss on Thursday February 22, 2018 @01:32PM (#16440014)
Keep in mind that their CFO (a former Wall Street Banker) keeps a careful eye on costs and spending:

"CFO Ruth Porat is pushing Google “creatives” to bring their costs under control."

http://fortune.com/google-cfo-ruth-porat-most-powerful-women...

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by cmurf on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:43PM (#16439473)
Ends justifies the means? The arguments against this are ethics 101, it leads to extremism.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by rubatuga on Thursday February 22, 2018 @02:31PM (#16440627)
Sure, if you're part of the Kantian ethics group. But in terms of utilitarianism, I would strongly argue that Google has done more good than harm.
Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by cmurf on Thursday February 22, 2018 @03:47PM (#16441231)
Yeah coal and cigarette industries said the same thing, with blinders on, when all claims of health related problems were poopoo'd. They said no one could have known or imagined or predicted, even though they were and they did but it was dismissed by the gatekeepers.

I see pretty much total shit knowledge of history, ethics, and philosophy in the tech industry. It intentionally has blinders on, zero imagination for anything other than the good intentions rails it's wants to believe it's on. Oh no one could have known, no one could have predicted, you had no evidence that these bad outcomes were possible. It'll be the same excuses we've seen before, because no one wanted to confront the possibility and how to mitigate complex interactions, they just want the ends because that alone justifies everything.

That of course will be convenient when claiming a lack of responsibility for the outcome, shifting the blame, because only good was intended. Now trust us.

And the reason why I increasingly don't trust tech, is because the language the industry uses is consistently dismissive of basic concepts in ethics, merely accepting assertions of "good intentions" as sufficient evidence of ethical behavior.

Re:The reason Facebook won’t ever change by johnchristopher on Thursday February 22, 2018 @12:25PM (#16439290)
Basic branding : 1. How you perceive yourself 2. How you are perceived 3. How you would like to be perceived