Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by floatrock on Thursday February 08, 2018 @05:24PM
(#16336142)
YC releases a Requests for Startups list that's part VC zeitgeist, part buzzword bingo, but mostly an interesting summary where they think interesting things are: https://www.ycombinator.com/rfs
Was curious how these companies stack up against that list:
1. *Energy: none*
2. AI:
- Cognition IP
3. *Robotics: none*
4. Biotech:
- Nutrigene ? (stretch)
5. Healthcare:
- Medumo
- Nutrigene ? ("these statements have not been approved by the fda")
6. *Pharmaceuticals: none*
7. Education:
- Juni Learning
8. Human Augmentation
- Nutrigene
9. *VR and AR: none*
10. Transportation and Housing
- Statecraft
11. *One Million Jobs: none*
12. Programming Tools:
- Buglife
- Storyline
13. *Hollywood 2.0: none*
14. Diversity:
- tEQuitable ?
15: Enterprise Software
- Slite?
- Storyline?
- Substack
- tEQuitable?
16. *Financial Services: none*
17. *Computer Security: none*
18. *Global Health: none*
19. Underserved Communities
- Statecraft
20. *Food and Farming: none*
21. *Mass Media: none*
22. *Improving Democracy: none*
23: Future of Work
- Slite?
- tEQuitable?
- The Lobby (and probably not in the good way)
25: *Water: none*
26: Other:
- Sheerly Genius ?
I don't really know anything about these companies beyond the 1-paragraph summaries from the article, and yes, you may arrange your Startup Superheroes(TM) trading cards into slightly different piles, but the point of this is that (of the announced companies), it's curious to see where the gaps in the debutants are.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by tlb on Thursday February 08, 2018 @05:36PM
(#16336212)
Keep in mind that that this isn't a unbiased random sample. It's selected for companies that launched publicly within 6 weeks of the start of the batch, which usually means they have a working MVP. Companies with long R&D cycles (like most energy, robotics, biotech and pharma companies) are underrepresented in this sample.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by dcole2929 on Thursday February 08, 2018 @05:47PM
(#16336271)
Wanting companies that work on these problems is great. But finding ones with unique and interesting value propositions is probably incredibly hard. There is a reason that the Hollywood model for instance, has managed to last 100 years. Yeah there's an absolute shit ton of protectionism going on but also no one has come up with anything better yet, and not for lack of trying. The same is true of a lot of these categories. The issues they have are hard, and expensive. I'd be interested to see the list of companies YC rejects.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by koolba on Thursday February 08, 2018 @04:02PM
(#16335578)
> The Lobby lets candidates buy affordable 1-on-1 calls with company insiders to help them land top finance jobs without needing an inside connection.
This one made me smile. It’s only a matter of time until the employees of these companies directly monetize their connections. It happens indirectly already through hiring bonuses and quid pro quos though the latter is on a much longer timescale.
There’s also the possibility of only losers trying to monetize their connections, thus watering down the overall value.
I’m not sure if the idea will generally pan out as employment agreements may bar this type of practice but it’s either genius or terrible. Best of luck!
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by ryandrake on Thursday February 08, 2018 @09:28PM
(#16337444)
It would be cool after some time to see some abundance of data showing the service works. As someone who went to an arguably elite (or near elite) school, took advantage of numerous opportunities to chat with insiders, and still failed hard at breaking into investment banking, I am skeptical but convinceable.
I bet you could charge (and have people actually pay) 10x or even 100x if you offered a money back guarantee. I would have paid $N,000 (and maybe $N0,000) without even thinking about it if I only had to pay if I got the job.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by dchhugani on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:52PM
(#16336987)
hey koolba! glad it made you smile :). Definitely issues to consider as we scale up, right now it seems to be adding a lot of value to people who are a) trying to figure out if this career path is for them but have no way of understanding what life is actually like until they speak to someone or b) getting the inside tips & tricks that can help you get hired but that you won't access without a close friend or elite school connection.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by hguhghuff on Friday February 09, 2018 @01:20AM
(#16338308)
There's a very long trail of companies that tried to pay people to refer their connections for jobs. They all fail. People don't seem interested in monetizing their connections.
The funny thing is that people keep building companies to monetize their connections because they see no one else doing it, unaware it's a graveyard.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by exolymph on Friday February 09, 2018 @03:35AM
(#16338773)
> People don't seem interested in monetizing their connections.
I think people would be happy to monetize their connections if it wouldn't piss off the valuable contacts who are worth monetizing. Unfortunately, that isn't the case.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by dchhugani on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:53PM
(#16336997)
Agreed! Companies basically give you incentives to train, coach, and jam your friends down their throat, which in our view is a huge conflict of interest vs. just letting you get paid small amounts just to speak with people who are fascinated by what you do every day, but don't have access to you.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by csa on Friday February 09, 2018 @03:51AM
(#16338810)
> what you do every day
For the median entry-level hire at a large investment bank, this rounds to... being a high-paid gopher?
I went to an elite school, I talked to my Wall Street contacts (both newer people and older) as I went through school, and I ran the other direction. The new folks were drinking the kool-aid, and the older folks had a nice income but were mostly heavily medicated and/or hated life.
Note that there are some niches in finance that are super cool to work in, but my thought is that you have to be eyeballs deep in the field already before you are likely even to have a clue that these places exist, much less be a strong candidate for a job at one of these places. For reference, it took me quite a few years after graduating to really grok what these places were about and meet some people who worked there (they were decidedly uncool boutique firms... and also stupidly profitable).
Maybe my info is dated. Does anyone have any convincing counter examples to my experience (also shared by quite a few other people I know).
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by christophepas on Friday February 09, 2018 @01:17PM
(#16342515)
Hey @Keats! Probably too marketing & our tagline is ever evolving so thanks for the feedback ;)
We do think there are no good note apps that have really been thought for teams & Slite is really good for that. Evernote never did a great job on that in my opinion.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by spIrr on Friday February 09, 2018 @04:31AM
(#16338989)
My team uses Evernote Premium, which shares collaboration features with Business, I believe, and it feels like any sort of collaboration is really an afterthought, for example:
* the complete note gets locked when someone simply places a cursor anywhere in the note, just like in the days of carbon/master copies and check-in/check-outs.
* work chat is meaningless, I have hardly seen anyone use it beyond the automatically-generated messaged when you share a note
* notes shared with you are ONLY accessible from the work chat, there is no menu item to access a list of notes that have been shared with me.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by christophepas on Friday February 09, 2018 @01:24PM
(#16342578)
I guess spIrr said it all. Evernote's collaborative features are an afterthought to say the least.
The fact of thinking the tool for teams changes entirely the design : in Slite it made us focus on a flawless collaboration with collaborative editing, mentions, comments, notifications system, activity & so on from day 1.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by swedish_mafia on Thursday February 08, 2018 @06:00PM
(#16336356)
Question for the YC folks: these companies seem reasonably far along. One of them has 300 users already. So would a Dropbox be accepted into YC today? (IIRC dropbox had a barely working prototype and no customers)
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by capocannoniere on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:02PM
(#16336696)
Yes, these companies seem far along. But do keep in mind that this is somewhat of a biased sample -- the dozen or so companies that "launch" on HN months before demo day are likely to be the companies that are the most far along.
There are ~100 other companies in the current batch [1] that haven't launched. I imagine many of those companies are not nearly as far along as the ones mentioned in this article, and some are still pivoting / navigating the idea maze.
That said, it does seem like in the most recent batches, YC companies get to demo day with significantly more traction than the early YC companies. I wonder to what extent that's because YC's reputation has gotten better over time (thus self selecting for startups with traction) or because it's gotten easier/cheaper/faster for startups to build a product and gain traction.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by orb_yt on Thursday February 08, 2018 @06:22PM
(#16336474)
I'd love to hear some discussion on the following:
I really like developer focused companies like Buglife. However, what path could Buglife take to reach a $1B dollar company?
The post notes that they are currently in 300 apps. I'd assume the majority of these 300 are on a free plan. Let's assume that they hit a growth spurt and end up in 10,000 apps. Let's also assume that every one of those customers is paying for their Premium plan. That works out to a little over $2 million a month in revenue.
Not only that, but there are already very established companies in this space (Fabric/Crashlytics, Firebase, Sentry, etc.). It's also fairly trivial to switch to another provider.
How do companies like this propose they hit that $1B mark?
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by elihu on Thursday February 08, 2018 @06:34PM
(#16336547)
1) Does YCombinator only invest in companies with a plan to become $1B?
2) What you're doing right now isn't necessarily the thing you end up doing in the long term. Sometimes it makes sense to create a simple product with a smallish market that people use now, and adapt over time to address or create a larger market. This other discussion today is relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16334035
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by elihu on Thursday February 08, 2018 @09:38PM
(#16337486)
> I think it's a pretty well known fact that YC tends to invest in companies that have the opportunity to be billion dollar ventures.
"Tends to" isn't the same as "always". I expect they'd rather invest in unicorns, but maybe they're willing to invest in a few more modest endeavors for various reasons.
> What sort of opportunities do you think a company like Buglife could focus on?
Beats me. I wouldn't have guessed that Amazon was going to become a cloud provider back when they were just an e-commerce site. I think Paul Graham has said that sometimes YCombinator will accept founders who have an uninteresting idea if they seem like the sort of people who are capable of generating new ideas and changing course as the situations demand.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by orb_yt on Thursday February 08, 2018 @09:14PM
(#16337382)
I love Crashlytics, it was a great success and continues to be an awesome service. However, this comment highlights my question. Crashlytics was an early "first mover" in this area, has been a goto for developers for years now, and could likely be considered as a "best case" scenario for this type of software. Yet, it was acquired for far less than a billion dollars.
My original comment was in regards to the well known fact that YC tends to invest in companies that have the opportunity to be billion dollar companies. In fact, it's a known question during interviews[1].
So, my question is what do these founders say when asked this question? What possible paths are there to a billion dollars for this type of company?
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by jacquesm on Thursday February 08, 2018 @03:37PM
(#16335379)
It's actually quite funny to see this from the same group that made it clear that 'pay to play' accelerators are a bad thing.
When it comes to start-ups I've seen enough that I thought would never make it succeed and enough sure bets fail that I'm willing to just wait by the sidelines to let the hand of time sort it all out. That seems to be a better mechanism than to decide up front what is ridiculous and what is not.
It is the cowards way out but I've come to the conclusion that my 'hot or not' meter is seriously broken in this respect.
Re:Companies from the YC Winter 2018 Batch
by lokipo on Thursday February 08, 2018 @03:41PM
(#16335408)
at the end of the day there is an enormous market for these services, so I'm not saying they won't succeed
But from a consumer's pov, if you go to a semi-decent university, or even if you don't, there are much better and cheaper (ie price of a cup of coffee) ways of networking than paying for calls with some analyst
Was curious how these companies stack up against that list:
I don't really know anything about these companies beyond the 1-paragraph summaries from the article, and yes, you may arrange your Startup Superheroes(TM) trading cards into slightly different piles, but the point of this is that (of the announced companies), it's curious to see where the gaps in the debutants are.Exactly why the gaps are interesting.
Also: they need to fit the VC timeline and specific VCs' returns model (there are other business models outside of taking SV VC money)
I wonder if Hollywood 2.0 would still be on there.
This one made me smile. It’s only a matter of time until the employees of these companies directly monetize their connections. It happens indirectly already through hiring bonuses and quid pro quos though the latter is on a much longer timescale.
There’s also the possibility of only losers trying to monetize their connections, thus watering down the overall value.
I’m not sure if the idea will generally pan out as employment agreements may bar this type of practice but it’s either genius or terrible. Best of luck!
I bet you could charge (and have people actually pay) 10x or even 100x if you offered a money back guarantee. I would have paid $N,000 (and maybe $N0,000) without even thinking about it if I only had to pay if I got the job.
The funny thing is that people keep building companies to monetize their connections because they see no one else doing it, unaware it's a graveyard.
I think people would be happy to monetize their connections if it wouldn't piss off the valuable contacts who are worth monetizing. Unfortunately, that isn't the case.
For the median entry-level hire at a large investment bank, this rounds to... being a high-paid gopher?
I went to an elite school, I talked to my Wall Street contacts (both newer people and older) as I went through school, and I ran the other direction. The new folks were drinking the kool-aid, and the older folks had a nice income but were mostly heavily medicated and/or hated life.
Note that there are some niches in finance that are super cool to work in, but my thought is that you have to be eyeballs deep in the field already before you are likely even to have a clue that these places exist, much less be a strong candidate for a job at one of these places. For reference, it took me quite a few years after graduating to really grok what these places were about and meet some people who worked there (they were decidedly uncool boutique firms... and also stupidly profitable).
Maybe my info is dated. Does anyone have any convincing counter examples to my experience (also shared by quite a few other people I know).
I don't mind marketing/bragging but that sounds silly. The first, really?
I mean Slack wasn't exactly novel when it shipped...
Actually, I believe Evernote Business deserves that title: https://evernote.com/business
* the complete note gets locked when someone simply places a cursor anywhere in the note, just like in the days of carbon/master copies and check-in/check-outs.
* work chat is meaningless, I have hardly seen anyone use it beyond the automatically-generated messaged when you share a note
* notes shared with you are ONLY accessible from the work chat, there is no menu item to access a list of notes that have been shared with me.
The fact of thinking the tool for teams changes entirely the design : in Slite it made us focus on a flawless collaboration with collaborative editing, mentions, comments, notifications system, activity & so on from day 1.
There are ~100 other companies in the current batch [1] that haven't launched. I imagine many of those companies are not nearly as far along as the ones mentioned in this article, and some are still pivoting / navigating the idea maze.
That said, it does seem like in the most recent batches, YC companies get to demo day with significantly more traction than the early YC companies. I wonder to what extent that's because YC's reputation has gotten better over time (thus self selecting for startups with traction) or because it's gotten easier/cheaper/faster for startups to build a product and gain traction.
[1] I don't know the exact number of companies in the current batch. Last batch had 124 companies so using that as a proxy http://blog.ycombinator.com/yc-summer-2017-stats/
I really like developer focused companies like Buglife. However, what path could Buglife take to reach a $1B dollar company?
The post notes that they are currently in 300 apps. I'd assume the majority of these 300 are on a free plan. Let's assume that they hit a growth spurt and end up in 10,000 apps. Let's also assume that every one of those customers is paying for their Premium plan. That works out to a little over $2 million a month in revenue.
Not only that, but there are already very established companies in this space (Fabric/Crashlytics, Firebase, Sentry, etc.). It's also fairly trivial to switch to another provider.
How do companies like this propose they hit that $1B mark?
2) What you're doing right now isn't necessarily the thing you end up doing in the long term. Sometimes it makes sense to create a simple product with a smallish market that people use now, and adapt over time to address or create a larger market. This other discussion today is relevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16334035
> What you're doing right now isn't necessarily the thing you end up doing in the long term.
What sort of opportunities do you think a company like Buglife could focus on?
"Tends to" isn't the same as "always". I expect they'd rather invest in unicorns, but maybe they're willing to invest in a few more modest endeavors for various reasons.
> What sort of opportunities do you think a company like Buglife could focus on?
Beats me. I wouldn't have guessed that Amazon was going to become a cloud provider back when they were just an e-commerce site. I think Paul Graham has said that sometimes YCombinator will accept founders who have an uninteresting idea if they seem like the sort of people who are capable of generating new ideas and changing course as the situations demand.
My original comment was in regards to the well known fact that YC tends to invest in companies that have the opportunity to be billion dollar companies. In fact, it's a known question during interviews[1].
So, my question is what do these founders say when asked this question? What possible paths are there to a billion dollars for this type of company?
[1] https://www.indiehackers.com/businesses/coderpad
Buglife, tEQuitable, Slite and Cognition IP all fit that bill.
It takes making shovels to sell to the gold rush seekers to a whole new level.
Reminds me of the recent beta of Twilio Studio. Both should help when you want to quickly develop some tools.
Or are they doing what Atrium is doing and really running two entities, a tech company and a law firm?
When it comes to start-ups I've seen enough that I thought would never make it succeed and enough sure bets fail that I'm willing to just wait by the sidelines to let the hand of time sort it all out. That seems to be a better mechanism than to decide up front what is ridiculous and what is not.
It is the cowards way out but I've come to the conclusion that my 'hot or not' meter is seriously broken in this respect.
But from a consumer's pov, if you go to a semi-decent university, or even if you don't, there are much better and cheaper (ie price of a cup of coffee) ways of networking than paying for calls with some analyst