> There needs to be an incentive to to do well and I'd be against cutting into that too deeply.
I've never understood why any tax rate would be a disincentive to do well. Even if the tax rate was 90%, doing well is doing well. If I make more money, I get to keep more money, even if taxes are high.
If we have tax brackets, then yeah sure there could be an unlucky minority of people who just barely land in a higher bracket than someone just under the line, so they pay a higher percentage than someone else.
But if you're well above the threshold, the amount you keep is more the more money you make before taxes. Isn't the primary incentive at all times to make more money, regardless of taxes? Or is the idea of paying a higher percentage than someone else a strong enough motivator to actually keep people from trying? Or am I missing something?
I think if you take it to the limit, you can see the effect more clearly. As the tax rate approaches 100%, say 99%, then even if I make $100,000 before taxes, I'd only keep $1,000. If I push myself hard to earn $200,000, I'd get to keep $2,000. Yes it is still double, and I am doing better, but not much of interest changes in my life and I personally wouldn't say I'm doing well. I can barely afford to take that second vacation, or see much value for my efforts. My efforts are simply less rewarded, giving me less tangible reason to make the extra effort. I think this would kill off the incentive to create wealth in the economy.
Wealth is needed to take care of basic needs, so it would be self defeating if you were trying to take care of everyones needs and make sure they had a little spending money to participate in the economy.
Somewhat as an aside, I didn't consider what benefits I would receive for paying a 99% tax rate, presumably it would be all the basic needs plus some more, but this would start to feel like a planned economy where individuals, with their small discretionary funds, would't have as much input into what is created in the economy, rather it'd be a course political process which could be slow to meet the needs of the citizens, or fraught with other unforeseen difficulties.
I realized I'm also mixing a few different thoughts in my head. I've heard the high taxes being an economic disincentive idea applied to the rich and to corporations and to investors, and I think my question applies more to them than to the middle class. You weren't talking about only the rich, I think I'm projecting a little bit.
Is the idea for businesses and investors that with higher taxes, in the aggregate there are always alternative places for the money, and so behavior changes statistically as tax rates increase? Maybe I'm interpreting "incentive" too literally.
For me, and for people like me, it would be. I work high-paying shit jobs precisely because they pay a lot. The amount of saving I'm able to do in these jobs is life-changing (i.e. FU money after 5-8 years). If most of that money went to taxes, there'd be little point in doing them and I might as well induldge in doing something more satisfying instead.
This statement makes me think you might be confused about tax brackets. This is a common misconception, so I'll explain how tax brackets work.
Tax brackets assign a percentage to tax up to a certain amount of income. Suppose you went over a bracket by $100, then only that $100 is going to taxed the highest amount. The entire income is not taxed the amount in the highest tax bracket. So, while the unlucky people are still taxed at a higher amount, it is for a very small amount of their income. Their after tax income will be still be more than somebody who earned less money and was just under a tax bracket.
Tax those same people 90%, and they’ll work for 30 years.
There is evidence of this phenomenon from the early days of the automobile: Craftsmen building cars by hand could and did retire after a few dozen cars, further inflating wages by constricting demand of labor. In contrast, Ford’s screw-turning factory workers worked for decades.
I don’t buy that lowering effective wages decreases the number of hours most people will be willing to work.
And the Ford example, while interesting, doesn't have to do with taxes does it? It has to do with Ford lowering the barrier of entry for factory workers AND increasing productivity rate at the same time. I think we can all agree that that advancement was good for society as a whole?
Am I understanding you correctly? Or is there something I am missing?
So I take it you’ll be paying extra on your federal taxes next year and earmarking the difference for the federal debt or other things you find worthwhile?
Arguing that we should all collectively pay more does not require one to individually contribute at that higher rate, nor does arguing that we (including the proponent) should collectively pay more ring near as hollow as arguing that those other people should pay more.
Can these people ever see tax as a value proposition? Wasted tax dollar are bad. But if you pay 5% more and get universal healthcare and get a liveable social security safety net that seems OK to me.
Further this attitude that its 'taking money I earnt' need to understand they are driving on roads that were built by generations ahead of them. Using sewers that their grandfathers laid, often on tax dollars. Benefiting from the political freedoms people literally fought and died for. Etc. If they want to claim the money earn is theirs the should go to someplace completely unoccupied and carve out an existence. See how much success they create truly on their own back. Maybe then they can understand we are all standing on the shoulders of those that came before us and that opportunity/system needs to be paid for and ideally continued to be improved upon.
It’s about sticking to your principals — if you disagree with the tax cut, the last thing you should do is benefit from it. Give the government the money you would’ve paid had there not been a tax cut. Doing otherwise gives you no right to complain about it.
You can't stand your ground on every issue that demands that a large part of society support it to work, that's not how it works. A lot of principles are only helpful if a larger part of society shares and act on them, individually they are useless.
If someone thinks sending the gov't an extra $10,000 is money well spent, then they do it regardless if others do it.
It’s about the principal of the matter. If you disagree with the tax cut, don’t benefit from it. Take a stand.
Will the tools be there? You basically have monetary policy limited as interest rates are already low. And fiscal policy is limited as major tax cuts are already given and the debt/deficit mean increasing spend is difficult or come with potential negative consequences.
Am I missing something?
I'm more hopeful the govt uses this window to get itself in a position to manage the next downturn vs ride the good times and then not have the tools for the bad.
Every time a president claims economic growth to be because of them they reveal themselves to either be a liar or a fool.
Every president claims credit if economy is doing well. Same for Obama, Bush and Clinton. All were claiming credit for their periods of solid economy. That's just what you do as politician, take credit for good things and try to blame somebody else for bad things. Part of the political profession.
Is both possible?
For production and non-managerial positions, which is nearly the entire economy, inflation adjusted annual wage growth is under 1%. We'll need to see 4% or 5% nominal wage growth, with inflation holding at 2% or lower, to generate meaningful wage gains at the median.
Disclaimer: I don't know much about the arguments, to me it just looks like a typical linear graph.
What information are you basing this off of? I'm not doubting you, just curious as to where one could find that sort of sentiment of institutional investors?
Workers today relying on those programs in retirement will find them reduced or eliminated.
Let's only consider how that effects the top 1% and a rough estimate. Currently that's around 1.73M filers with an average income of 1.4M a year. Under the new tax rules the average 1% will save $40,000 over 480k (will obviously save more under 480k but not counting that). That totals out to be $692B in tax cuts over 10 years or in other words basically 70% of the tax cut deficit based on standard scoring and 138% based on dynamic scoring (obv not exact). So this could have been a revenue neutral tax cut even after a massive tax cut to everyone, just a slightly less of a tax cut to the top 1%.
In other words 70% of the tax plan deficit over the decade is coming from cuts from the top 1%. I would have preferred a different allocation that would have decreased their tax burdens but not by that much. Obviously this doesn't consider many smaller factors but it's a fairly accurate estimate.
It'd probably a lot lower.
You need to consider other code changes. For instance a filer in CA with W2 taxable income of $1.4M saves only $4,500 due to the loss of state income tax deduction offsetting the vast majority of beneficial rate changes.
I believe it's far more accurate to say that 70% of the tax cut-related deficit is coming from tax cuts to the 1%. The impact on the overall deficit is far less than 70% from those cuts.
To their point though, a person could reasonably support the tax cuts and seek to reduce the deficit on the premise that reduced spending would satisfy the latter over time. Whether or not the current administration is making a genuine attempt to do so is a separate argument and one that their comment did not mention.
Right, that would be an argument, but not one that's on the table. The Republicans and the President justified the tax cuts not by saying they would subsequently reduce spending, but by saying the cuts would invigorate the economy so much, any reduction in revenue directly caused by the cuts would be offset by gains in GDP.
Overall the 3% wage growth is huge for the economy especially because unemployment is so low. Other economic indicators also show a very healthy economy so when the next recession hits we'll have the tools to stop it. Inflation not rising has like stated baffled everyone so glad we are now dealing with what we know rather than wading into the unknown. The normal rules seem to apply again.
This is also why presidents shouldn't make their number one accomplishment the market because often times market crashes don't correlate with recessions or a poor economy. Trump did have a huge effect on the market, but not 10% which he thinks he did. That said the market is still higher than it was 5 weeks ago.
Risk averse savers will finally be rewarded. My biggest fear is the huge deficit, and the huge spending. I think the tax cut is great long term but could have been made significantly better, and could have scored under $100B deficit over 10 years under dynamic scoring (currently at 500B) if they decreased the top rate but still made it significantly higher than what it is today, and made the global min tax per individual countries but payable over time rather than all combined.