News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by grecy on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:35AM (#16274617)
Like I said in the other thread, it's sad this is even legal.

Here in Africa when Authorities allow obscenely rich people/companies to get away without paying their legally-mandated share of taxes it's called "bribery".

Apparently in America it's just "business".

Citizens should be protesting in the streets about this. Their educated, healthcare and infrastructure sucks because of it.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by djrogers on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:49AM (#16274727)
That’s a really simplistic and overly cynical view of what’s happening here. It’s also completely incorrect - bribes are paid to people, there are no mayors or city councils getting payoffs here...

Imagine you run a city where you tax businesses 1% of foo. For every dollar of foo tax you collect form a business, you actually collect another $0.50 in related taxes from company employees - buying lunch, staying in your hotels, etc. Let’s call that your bar tax.

A new company wants to move in that earns 3x as much foo as any other business in your town, but they are also looking at other towns that tax foo at 0.5% or even don’t tax foo at all. You can choose to tell them to go elsewhere, or you can give them an incentive - you’ll cut your foo tax to 0% for 10 years, knowing that you’ll be collecting more bar tax with the company there than you would with them not there.

At this point the calculation is simple - will having New Company in your city cost you more than you’ll be getting in bar tax? And if so, might it still be worth it in the long run to take those losses for 10 years until the foo tax kicks back in?

If not, don’t do it. The point is, this is not clear cut either way.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by grecy on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:00AM (#16274809)
Yes, yes I have heard this explanation a million times, but it's utter nonsense.

The whole system was designed with what you said in mind. The company is supposed to pay their taxes (foo) AND the city is supposed to collect the taxes from employees (bar). The whole system needs everyone to contribute their right amount so there is enough money for schools, health care, police, roads, libraries, etc. etc.

Yes, Amazon's foo is very large, because they make a massive amount of profit!! Also the bar they create will be very large, because they have a lot of employees. The fact it's a large amount changes nothing. The city they are in needs BOTH of those to function correctly. With all those massive buildings and employees the city will need new schools, roads, more police, more libraries, etc. etc.

Amazon get to use the roads of the town, the water infrastructure, the elec infrastructure, the education, the police, etc. etc. to make their massive profit.

Who do you expect to pay for all of that, other than Amazon through their foo tax? That's precisely why the foo tax exists, and amazon get to avoid paying it they can make massive profit without paying for the basic stuff - so now the regular citizens need to!

The whole thing requires the full amount of foo+bar to pay for all of that stuff.

But of course we all know America has terrible tax-payer funded services compared to the other OECD countries.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by maxerickson on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:51AM (#16275238)
If you go look at the "design" documents for US municipalities, the various incorporation documents, you will see that they speak directly to abating taxes to incentivize development. Here's an example from 1898 (not sure if this charter is still in effect in the Baltimore):

https://books.google.com/books?id=UVuiQ5HKgqoC&lpg=PA152&ots...

So there are in fact legal mechanisms, deeply rooted in the laws of municipalities. The stuff you are claiming is foundational to making the system work is just wrong.

I didn't go digging for an example that would prove my point, I searched for a city I recalled competing for the HQ2 and went with the second one I searched (The first page of results for Austin didn't turn up an obvious document).

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by namelost on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:08PM (#16275392)
When the EU decided that Apple had not paid enough tax to Ireland, they made Ireland collect the extra tax. Giving tax discounts to favoured corporations is anti-social, and has long been punished at an international level (e.g. via countervailing duties). The amount of double-think required to accept it at a domestic level is astounding.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by maxerickson on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:32PM (#16275590)
Sure, favoring particular businesses is ripe for corruption and difficult to justify.

But the other poster is making an argument that tax abatement is somehow against the system, something that is pretty obviously wrong.

They don't want to stick to arguing that it is anti-social or foolish or whatever, they've decided that abating taxes is illegal (even though it is legal) and that it is contrary to how cities are supposed to fund themselves (even though it is written into the foundational documents of many municipalities).

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by ballenf on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:07PM (#16275380)
One question because I respect your position: do you believe that cities should have any tools available to incentivize "preferred" companies to come to the city?

I'm guessing your answer would be it can design its tax code so long as the tax code applies to all comers that meet the agnostic definitions therein.

The problem, however, is that opens up the question as to how fine-grained the definitions can become. It's not very hard to write tax regulations that are so narrow they only apply to one company while still on the surface appearing to be agnostic and naming no company.

IMO, it's a sliding scale of specificity and maybe you're right that there is a line somewhere that shouldn't be crossed, but it's more difficult than you suggest to figure out and describe where that line should be.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by i_cant_speel on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:30AM (#16275078)
That would be something that goes into the calculation of the tax incentives. If the added infrastructure is going to cost more than the bar tax, than it wouldn't be worth it. What makes you say that the bar tax would be insufficient to cover the extra costs?
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by mindcrime on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:24PM (#16275515)
But of course we all know America has terrible tax-payer funded services compared to the other OECD countries.

That's a feature, not a bug. Quite many of us, including many of the Founders, believed/believe that the proper scope for government is very narrow, basically just "protect individual rights". Quite a few of us think, to this day, that the government is involved in too many taxpayer funded services as it is.

You are, of course, free to disagree with that position. But understand that things (w/r/t taxpayer funded services) operate the way they do here for a reason and not just due to happenstance.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by scarmig on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:17PM (#16276078)
The "Founders" can go fuck themselves. Most of them believed in using state violence to enslave, rape, and murder non-whites, among countless other atrocities.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by mindcrime on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:01PM (#16276505)
The "Founders" can go fuck themselves. Most of them believed in using state violence to enslave, rape, and murder non-whites, among countless other atrocities.

I actually agree with you on that. My point was just that the US stance with regards to tax-payer subsidization isn't some accident. And, again, one can choose to disagree with those Americans who want an extremely limited government, but one has to acknowledge that this is a position that is held by many people, for very rational reasons.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:05PM (#16276536)
> Most of them believed in using state violence to enslave, rape, and murder non-whites, among countless other atrocities

And the rest of them believed that institutionalizing protection of the ability of the first set to do that was an acceptable cost of unity, such that the Constitution is riddled with elements contrived largely for that purpose, only some of which have since been purged by more enlightened successors to the Founders.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by strictnein on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:43AM (#16275179)
Your understanding of how things are funded in the US is very flawed. It's not surprising, since a lot of people outside of the US have very flawed views on how things work here.

The rest of what you're saying is also rather inaccurate as well.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by tabeth on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:49AM (#16275224)
Why don't you correct them if you believe it is inaccurate?
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by strictnein on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:23PM (#16276128)
Because I have far more important things to do than correct paragraphs of inaccurate statements.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:11AM (#16274908)
The comparison to bribery is, as you describe, inexact. Bribes are principal-agent breakdowns between the governing and the governed. Tax breaks for large companies don't fit that description. They are closer to an anti-competitive preference for large companies.

The problem is this anti-competitive preference counterbalances geographic incumbency bias. It's difficult to say which is worse--Amazon getting preferential treatment over a potentially-rivalrous upstart or the Midwest having no fiscal tools with which to fight coastal dominance.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:58AM (#16274797)
It's a business getting a payoff - worse, it's getting government assistance and Amazon is getting unfair treatment (if they give Amazon a x% tax break, they should give that same tax break to all other businesses currently in that jurisdiction + anyone wanting to start a business there - else they're unfairly giving Amazon an advantage, which is bad for competition)
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by desireco42 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:04PM (#16275356)
I actually agree with him. This is what got several US companies get fined in EU. Bribe is not only when you give money or favors to individual, companies do the same.

It is form of legalized corruption. It is not the same as stimulus for development of certain areas.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by andrewprock on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:23AM (#16275008)
Yes, characterizing it as bribery is incorrect. It's actually much worse.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by _pmf_ on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:07AM (#16274868)
> there are no mayors or city councils getting payoffs here

Don't be naive. Do you think mayors are getting their nice positions on company advisory boards after active duty because they are so capable?

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by uiti8484 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:57AM (#16274785)
Yeah it really is simple:

Richest man in the world

Richest company in the world

Plain history of boon doggles coming to town screwing locals

All this does is continue to validate corporateocracy

Fuck these clowns

Where is everyone else’s handout?

Here you go, Jeff, let’s boost YOUR wealth very plainly on the backs of others

There’s some free market competition huh? Are you rich? You win tax breaks!

Hey, why not give fat breaks to new players. Let them fill warehouses of crap to sell online. But no, kiss the rings

It’s simple and obvious and this mystifying with prognostications you can’t possibly validate because you’re no visionary with the ability to see the future (and are plainly ignoring the past [sports stadiums, etc]) is nonsense

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by codingdave on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:39AM (#16274648)
I agree, but protesting in the streets is not the right response. If we do that, businesses can just smile at us as they go about their business anyway. A better answer is to get involved in public government - instead of protesting, the residents of those cities should be packing their city council meetings and planning meetings, making their voices heard directly with the people who are putting these packages together for Amazon.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by grecy on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:52AM (#16274748)
It seems to work pretty well in places like for example France.

Have you seen what happens when a politician tries to take away a single sick day or reduce their already-world-leading maternity leave? .. millions march in the streets for days and you can bet your bottom dollar come election time the responsible politician is swiftly voted out.

Those people care about what is happening in their country and how it impacts them. They know it's more important than football and cheap beer.

Americans have forgotten how to participate in Democracy.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by gambiting on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:55PM (#16277460)
France is a lot more compact than US, which makes for much more effective protesting - that is also true of other European countries. You can get to Paris from pretty much any point in France in few hours by hopping on a relatively cheap train, and blocking the capital with marches and protesting is a huge deal that people have to listen to. I know the same approach works to some great results in Poland - even if you're a miner from a rural town, you can get to Warsaw on a train in 3-4 hours for about $10 and protest all day long right in front of the parliment and get back home the same night. In US the impact is lessened, because it's very costly and time consuming for a lot of people to get to washington to protest, and protesting in state capitals is not quite as effective(and can still be expensive to get to, depending where you live). Also people don't get such strong employee protections, in EU no one could ever fire you for protesting, but in US if you miss work to go to a demonstration you can be fired without recourse.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:44AM (#16274690)
It's not like those politicians are going to listen to the people in their city council meetings either. Local politicians careers are going to get made off of whether they get the deal not to count the money at stake. I've been slowly coming to the conclusion that all our methods of peaceful protest are basically no longer working, the people in power have effectively cut us off from influencing them without (1) a big chunk of money or (2) committing a crime (ie you must register protests in advance, you can't march anywhere unexpected, say, a politicians house, etc.)
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by codingdave on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:00PM (#16275890)
Maybe it depends on your town. Last time I saw my council taking a step I didn't like, I started knocking on doors around town, letting everyone to know to come to the meeting. Hundreds of people showed up, and the council changed the plans to match the will of the people.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by vvdcect on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:03AM (#16274832)
I think protesting could work only if you just don't leave til your demands are met, the problem with protests in general is that people tend to organize it for just a day.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by dogecoinbase on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:48AM (#16275217)
If business can continue as usual, you're not protesting right.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by uiti8484 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:04AM (#16274842)
Agreed

The best way to protest is tell people you know you disagree and don’t care if the relationship sours because of it

People have to push back against the nonsense their friends and family spew

When someone spews

“It makes sense,” says and outside, “to burden another muni with generational debt for jobs today so we can keep selling trifles.”

You tell them they’re absurd

Grandpa spouting jingoist nonsense? You slap him in the mouth like he did you for swearing

Stop being afraid of each other and push back on plain stupid

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by dictum on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:09AM (#16274879)
> Grandpa spouting jingoist nonsense? You slap him in the mouth like he did you for swearing

Do you want to be slapped by young people in the future, when your politics are no longer fashionable?

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by s73ver_ on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:06PM (#16276548)
This is a nihilistic false equivalence that fails to consider what the actual positions are.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by rayiner on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:02PM (#16275338)
Fun fact: the U.S. spends more on education per student than any country but Switzerland, Norway, and Luxembourg. We probably don’t spend more on transit, because most cities here aren’t designed for it, but New York for example spends more per subway rider than London. We also spend more public dollars on healthcare per person than Canada, Sweden, France, etc.

Our total government spending per person (excluding defense spending) is higher than Canada’s, despite the fact we provide less services.

Additional facts: countries like Canada, France, Germany, etc., tax their corporations less than we do. Our taxes are a lot lower, but mainly because we have much lower taxes for the middle class.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by thesmallestcat on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:25PM (#16276159)
I get the sense that proportionally more US education spending is lost to graft than in those European countries (from the top down to teachers who come in and don't teach).
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by afjl on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:24PM (#16275516)
Is the education spending comparing the actual dollar amount or is it adjusted for PPP? Or is it by percent of federal/state/municipal spending?
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by rayiner on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:50PM (#16275793)
It’s PPP adjusted: https://www.oecd.org/edu/EAG2014-Indicator%20B1%20(eng).pdf. See page 207. I was incorrect: it’s Norway, Luxembourg, and Switzerland ahead of the US.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by afjl on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:42PM (#16277369)
Gotcha. Thanks for the link
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by gamblor956 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:10PM (#16276589)
Additional facts: countries like Canada, France, Germany, etc., tax their corporations less than we do. Our taxes are a lot lower, but mainly because we have much lower taxes for the middle class.

Blatantly false. Our statutory tax rate may have been one of the highest in the Western World, but the effective tax rates before the Trump tax plan were some of the lowest after deductions and credits are taken into account.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by rayiner on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:31PM (#16276796)
Incorrect: https://www.npr.org/2017/08/07/541797699/fact-check-does-the....

E.g. the U.S. statutory rate was 38.9% (federal + the average of state and local rates), the highest in the G20. The effective rate (after deductions, etc.) was 18.6%, the fourth highest. Socialist France was 11.2%, and our neighbor to the north was 8.6%.

U.S. total tax burden is much lower than France, Germany, etc. If you look at where that difference comes from, it's not because those countries tax "corporations and rich people" more. It's because they impose massively higher taxes on the middle class. Look at tax brackets in Germany, France, Denmark, etc. It's typical for either to top bracket or the second-to-top bracket (just a few percent lower) to kick in around 70 thousand Euros.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by Cuuugi on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:11AM (#16274907)
You contradicted yourself there. It is legal, and therefore they are not getting out of their legal mandates.

The American tax code is far from perfect, with the scales favoring whoever can afford the best tax attorney. With that said, i think you are grossly oversimplifying the issue. The corporate tax rates (before the recent reforms) were the highest in the developed world. Amazon has every right to negotiate where they move their offices.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by muninn_ on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:40AM (#16274656)
One one hand I agree. On the other hand, how is a state like Indiana supposed to attract a company like Amazon?
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by throwaway1254 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:38AM (#16274641)
Are you sure you know what you are talking about?
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by grecy on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:43AM (#16274682)
The average citizens of America have to foot the bill for everything funded by taxpayers, while the uber-rich (Amazon in this case) get special exemptions and don't have to pay for that stuff. As a result, things that are tax-payer funded in the USA are lacking compared to other OECD countries.

It's madness that a multi-billion dollar company doesn't have to help pay for things they get direct benefit from, and frankly it is supposed to be illegal. I'm not allowed to not pay my taxes, and that's a drop in the bucket compared to what Amazon should be paying.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by jack6e on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:00AM (#16274806)
> I'm not allowed to not pay my taxes

But you ARE allowed and entirely free to move to cities with lower tax rates, or states with no income tax at all, or any other location that provides you a better balance of income to tax costs. Amazon is an entity with the same rights to make decisions about re-locating to the locality with the most advantageous income/cost ratio.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by grecy on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:04AM (#16274844)
> But you ARE allowed and entirely free to move to cities with lower tax rates

Absolutely. But I can't negotiate with those places to get a special tax rate just for me. There is no "Dan's tax rate" that is different from everyone elses.

Oh, but if I just get rich enough.... they I won't have to pay taxes the same as the common-folk.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by maxxxxx on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:19AM (#16274978)
That's what's bothering me too. Give the same conditions to all businesses not just a favored one.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by pzh on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:54AM (#16275265)
> But I can't negotiate with those places to get a special tax rate just for me. There is no "Dan's tax rate" that is different from everyone elses.

That’s only because your tax contribution is very small and you don’t have leverage. If 60% of the residents of a city leave, you can bet the city will quickly lower or remove taxes to try to attract more people.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by jasode on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:46PM (#16276372)
>If 60% of the residents of a city leave, you can bet the city will quickly lower or remove taxes to try to attract more people.

That's exactly right. E.g. Michigan has designated NEZ zones[1] offering tax breaks (e.g. sometimes half the tax rate) to attract potential homeowners to distressed neighborhoods like inner city Detroit.

Sure, residents in another wealthy city (like Bloomfield Hills) in Michigan might complain they don't get the same tax subsidies as downtown Detroit but it still doesn't change the fact that governments will offer tax incentives for certain people (not just companies) to justify a desired economic outcome.

Detroit has to make those tax concessions because residents are fleeing and the city suffers from a lower tax base. The more desirable cities like San Francisco don't have to make the same tax concessions.

(I make no comment on whether NEZ actually works as intended or whether it is a net positive economically.)

http://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/2016/06/22/detroit-...

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by mbell on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:40PM (#16275689)
> The average citizens of America have to foot the bill for everything funded by taxpayers, while the uber-rich (Amazon in this case) get special exemptions and don't have to pay for that stuff.

Not that there aren't issues with our tax system but this is completely inaccurate[1]. It can certainly be argued that the top end of earners should pay more, but they already do carry the overwhelming majority of the income tax burden.

[1] https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-...

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by lolsal on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @11:08AM (#16274871)
> It's madness that a multi-billion dollar company doesn't have to help pay for things they get direct benefit from, and frankly it is supposed to be illegal.

Amazon will absolutely be helping pay for things that they get a benefit from. I think you're misunderstanding the exchange that is happening. To oversimplify, it's basically this:

City: We'll give you tax breaks, decent infrastructure, low property prices and a good pool of local technical talent

Amazon: We'll give you tech jobs, lots of tax revenue from the business, lots of tax revenue from our employees and raised property values.

> I'm not allowed to not pay my taxes, and that's a drop in the bucket compared to what Amazon should be paying.

Not paying your taxes and receiving tax breaks are completely different. Do you take deductions on your taxes? Even the standard deduction? Those are tax breaks.

Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by ams6110 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:57AM (#16274792)
All the Amazon employees pay taxes, as you note. Taxing Amazon itself on top of that just leaves it with less resources to pay employees. And why should a city reap an extra tax windfall when an Amazon decides to locate there? Amazon isn't really going to add much burden to city services.
Re:Amazon HQ2 finalists should refuse tax breaks, say nearly... by s73ver_ on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:10PM (#16276585)
So it’s ok that Amazon just passes their tax burden onto their employees?