A user would want to see an aggregate of all the programs s/he likes, not go to one app to see what's new on ABC, and another for NBC… that's where the Google TV model is interesting I suppose.
I'd think that something more like Google Reader (conceptually, not in terms of UI obviously) might be more fitting: a bunch of feeds for shows you like. You can "star" the ones you'll always want to keep around, let others disappear if too old…
To be YC-centric, it seems that the recently-launched Teevox got that right by merging listings between Netflix and Hulu.
In fact, if it did, syndication wouldn't be successful at all. But we all still seem to be watching Cheers and Seinfeld.
The game changer would be interactive iAds for each product placement.
For instance, a local advertiser would be able to advertise on their local broadcast version of a tv show using CG. The local advertiser can have his/her product or logo place somewhre within the context of the tv show.
Also, this can work with larger companies. Instead of Coke or Pepsi being used by an actor, the soda can can be CG'ed, and the respective company would bid on the placement by locality (city, state, region, etc).
This would allow smaller mom & pop brands a chance to advertise within their locality.
Not sure what would happen when a show goes into syndication, though. I guess, sell new CG advertising.
[1]http://abovethecrowd.com/2010/04/28/affiliate-fees-make-the-...
Quality programs can still be made and just like movies consumers will pay to watch them. Also look at the DVD market it was huge; ppl payed 15 bucks per DVD.
Sounds like you have a personal investment and or making your money off the cable pig that needs to be slayed. If your here reading HN then think out of the box to increase ur profit and solve the problem of the cable pig!
But giving the networks the ability to require an app as a gateway to their programming? Sorry, but that just an invitation for abuse, and begging for new ways to shove ads down our throats. Think javascript popover ads are annoying when browsing the web? The networks already abuse the screen real estate when you are just trying to enjoy a program. Imagine if they could do this in an app instead...