News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by dragonwriter on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:18PM (#16243365)
> Illinois is bankrupt

No, it's not. Bankruptcy is a legal state, and one which is not open to US states.

It's not even insolvent, which “bankrupt” is often incorrectly used as a synonym for. It may have a projected future insolvency, but that's a different issue.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by admax88q on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:35PM (#16243465)
Yay it's time for HN pedantry!

Bankrupt can also mean insolvent, it is not limited to the legal definition[1]. But more importantly you know what the person you're replying to meant. That they think Illinois is essentially out of money and pretending they're not.

You could have furthered this into an interesting discussion on the financial health of Illinois, but instead you found a way to feel intellectually superior without actually having to engage in discourse and without having put forward any ideas that could be challenged.

Your comment illustrates a common theme on sites like Reddit and HN, where people want to "win" the conversation as fast as possible. They find a easy and superficial way to call out another comment or article as "incorrect" and avoid putting forward anything of substance or actually worth talking about.

[1] - https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bankrupt

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by bedhead on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:18PM (#16243685)
"Yay it's time for HN pedantry!"

Ha! Might be the defining characteristic of HN.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by rayiner on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:28PM (#16243428)
Insolvency means your liabilities exceed your assets, or you can’t pay your debt as it comes due. If you’re a state like Illinois that has a constitutional restriction on reducing future pension obligations through a change in the law, then you’re cooking the books if you don’t count them as liabilities. And if you do, Illinois is almost certainly insolvent under the first definition. And since it’s not able to pay its bills in due course, it’s probably insolvent under the second definition too.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by dragonwriter on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:36PM (#16243472)
> Insolvency means your liabilities exceed your assets, or you can’t pay your debt as it comes due. If you’re a state like Illinois that has a constitutional restriction on reducing future pension obligations through a change in the law, then you’re cooking the books if you don’t count them as liabilities. And if you do, Illinois is almost certainly insolvent under the first definition.

You seem to be discounting assets, like taxation power (now, the politicsl consensus necessary for the state to use that power may not exist, but that's unwillingness to use an asset, not lack of assets.)

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:06PM (#16243617)
> that's unwillingness to use an asset, not lack of assets

That’s like marking at 100 a bond trading at 30 while arguing the problem isn’t the asset, it’s buyers’ unwillingness to pay the right price. In any case, potential to raise taxes is like potential to raise prices. It isn’t an asset until it’s signed and producing.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by vostok on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:21PM (#16243707)
That's when you say that it's held-to-maturity and claim that it's not impaired.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by masonic on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:18PM (#16243683)

  assets, like taxation power
Now we go straight from a misdefinition of "bankruptcy" to outright fabrication of "asset". Each of us may have earning power, for example, but that doesn't make it an asset we can legitimately put on a balance sheet.

And taxation power is constrained by the US and IL Constitutions and even US and IL law.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by gamblor956 on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:37PM (#16243483)
Insolvency is a legal term meaning that one cannot pay their debts when due (see the UCC).

Illinois can currently pay its debts as they come due, so it is currently solvent. It is likely to become insolvent in the future, but that is not the current state.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by wombatpm on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:41PM (#16243503)
Actually they can't. They currently have somewhere north of 5 billion in unpaid invoices. Their slow payment on contracts have driven some organizations into bankruptcy themselves. Many small business owners I know now refuse to do business with the state because thay can't wait years to be paid.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by gamblor956 on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:38PM (#16243801)
Do you have a cite for that? Because the only articles claiming that size of a backlog predate the budget resolution they passed last year after 2 years of no budget. They're currently on track to be out of deficit-spending within 2 or 3 years (possibly this year, if the Trump is to be believed) due to a combination of massive spending cuts ($6 billion in total cuts between 2015 and 2017) and tax revenue increases.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by dragonwriter on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:33PM (#16243775)
> Actually they can't. They currently have somewhere north of 5 billion in unpaid invoices.

There's a difference between not having the money to pay debts as they come due (which is insolvency) and just paying late by choice, incompetence, or -- as happens with in some jurisdictions with budget delays -- legal prohibition on using existing funds [0] (none of which are insolvency, though they may be default on the individual debts).

[0] Which, looked at one way, is a subset of choice, since the actors not making the necessary choice to remove the legal roadblock are the political leadership of the state.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by dragonwriter on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:42PM (#16243510)
> Illinois can currently pay its debts as they come due, so it is currently solvent.

It almost certainly can, if it chooses to, but it hasn't been choosing to, if you consider the pension fund distinct from the state.

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by runwerks on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:29PM (#16243439)
isn't the US then the same by your reasoning? we should flee the US as well.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by apike on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:38PM (#16243487)
The US can always pay its debt because it is denominated in US dollars - it can print sufficient US dollars to meet its debt obligations. States do not have this ability.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by ww520 on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:36PM (#16243474)
US Federal debt is in USD term so it can always repay its debt with printed USD. Technically it is not insolvent.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by hackeraccount on Saturday January 27, 2018 @05:38PM (#16248503)
It might be if it had a constitutional amendment saying Medicaid, Medicare and/or Social Security were untouchable. It doesn't. There's no spending in the US that's not on the table. When or if push came to shove it's not hard to imagine some or all of those programs being cut just as it's not hard to imagine taxes going up.
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by cletus on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:36PM (#16243473)
Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by gpm on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:41PM (#16243504)
Bankruptcy is an English word that just means you are insolvent (unable to pay your debts) not a legal state. There just happens to be a legal state named after it in the US.

And a state can go rid itself of debt similar to a normal bankruptcy. Since they have sovereign immunity they can just declare that some or all of the debt is void and won't be paid back and not face any consequences (other than lenders possibly choosing not to lend them more money - just like with a normal bankruptcy).

Re:Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale by bogomipz on Friday January 26, 2018 @08:03PM (#16244207)
No, it also means "utter ruin, failure, depletion, or the like."[1]. A person can be said to be "morally bankrupt" and that would also be correct usage.

Maybe consult the dictionary before before engaging in such unproductive pedantry.

[1] http://www.dictionary.com/browse/bankruptcy