News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by joshuaheard on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:00PM (#16207862)
The headline is a little misleading. The state is not implementing rules or regulations for net neutrality. It is simply requiring, as a condition of contracting with the state, that ISPs abide by the principles of net neutrality. If an ISP does not have any state contracts, it is free to do whatever it wants under the federal law.

Many jurisdictions attach such conditions to entering into a contract with the jurisdiction, ie paying a living wage, hiring a certain percentage of minorities, etc.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by dboreham on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:13PM (#16207954)
I live here and have some familiarity with the ISP landscape. I'm going to bet that all* ISPs operating in the state are going to have contracts with the state.

*Well, all ISPs of any consequence.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by client4 on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:21PM (#16209102)
Hey Now! ...but that's fair, the little ISP's were already for Net Neutrality. *

* ISP Owner in MT

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by dboreham on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:49AM (#16213502)
>* ISP Owner in MT

Same, until last year. We never had state customers and of course we ran traffic shaping that didn't look at source address.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by devindotcom on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:07PM (#16209486)
Good to hear, since the FCC was so loud about a handful of small ISPs like yours being vaguely against the Title II rules.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by davidp on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:58PM (#16209838)
Title II != net neutrality. Title II is a highly bureaucratic strong-oversight-in-all-things tool aimed at a completely different problem space, namely providing a legislative solution to the case-law-derived 1980s consent decrees with AT&T & IBM. It covers things that have nothing to do with what ISPs want to deal with as part of their businesses, and places the expensive burden of proof and compliance on the ISP. So yes, it makes sense that small ISPs would not want to compete with the AT&Ts and Comcasts of the world with their armies of compliance officers. You'd never see another small ISP formed again.

Instead Congress needs to create a separate Section III (or whatever) to address net neutrality specifically, and empower the FCC to act within that purview. The FCC does not get to decide on its own that it wants more authority than was previously granted it by Congress.

Congress (and the various involved presidents) deserve to have all the cannons aimed at them. As it stands, people directing their ire at the FCC chairs (on either side) are letting Congress get away with being irresponsible.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by eldridgea on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:51PM (#16210182)
This is a common talking point against the FCC retaining Title II classification. While I don't disagree in principle, until Congress acts, Net Neutrality is only achievable in the US via Title II enforcement by the FCC. The FCC reclassifying ISPs as Title I without a corresponding push to have an alternative Net Neutrality plan in place was irresponsible, unethical, and against the will of the constituents of all parties. Ire at Congress for not acting is completely reasonable, but acting as if what the FCC did was in any way acceptable is not.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by crazy1van on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:54PM (#16211104)
> and against the will of the constituents

It's Congress's job to be responsive to the will of the constituents, not the FCC. Congress has done a masterful job over the past several decades of outsourcing all the hard and potentially unpopular decisions to a regulatory body and then beating them up for their decisions.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by tzs on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:48PM (#16210821)
> It covers things that have nothing to do with what ISPs want to deal with as part of their businesses, and places the expensive burden of proof and compliance on the ISP. So yes, it makes sense that small ISPs would not want to compete with the AT&Ts and Comcasts of the world with their armies of compliance officers. You'd never see another small ISP formed again.

The 2015 net neutrality rules applied Title II with forbearance. It left out those things you mention.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:28PM (#16220082)
Partially applied laws are the building blocks of tyranny - Rule by law instead of rule of law.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by darkarmani on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @11:36AM (#16214859)
> You'd never see another small ISP formed again.

Except the FCC was only enforcing the NN part of it.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by joe_the_user on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:01PM (#16208368)
Sure but if push came to shove, if a non-net-neutral approach became a profit center for an ISP, they could afford to jettison those contracts.

You would think the state of Montana would/could also put conditions on contracts for using municipal telephone poles in the state (since states have imposed the condition that, say, municipalities can't operate their own ISPs). You'd think but you think incorrectly given the way things work in the US.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by toomuchtodo on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:45PM (#16209311)
Bootstrappy conservative state rolls up sleeves and delivers municipal/coop Internet after being forsaken by for-profit corporation. The news story almost writes itself.

I’m unable to find any financial issues with Montana’s budget, and their bond ratings appear to be adequate to receive a great interest rate in order to borrow for a build out.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by gonational on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:43PM (#16210795)
The reason Montana is in the position they’re in is precisely because they don’t do stuff like that.

Take a look at California, a state that implements just about every idea under the sun without a care in the world for the tax payers’ money (latest example is Hyperloop). Not coincidentally, California is also a state that is broke, crime riddled, filled with toxic waste and pollution, just about burned to the ground (say what you want - that’s a result of bad land management), running out of drinking water, and just about every other thing you could cram into a B-rated dystopian movie.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by njarboe on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @11:04PM (#16228656)
Wish it was for Hyperloop research and implementation. We did pass a proposition for a $40 billion high speed rail system in 2008. Musk started thinking about the Hyperloop concept because when the plans for the California high speed rail came out, it was the slowest and most expensive high speed rail system on Earth. A decade later, no trains are running and the cost is up near $100 billion (who really knows what it would cost?).
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by gonational on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:08AM (#16230813)
Ah, thanks for the clarification. This over-budget high-speed rail is what I was attempting to refer to by Hyperloop. I forgot that Hyperloop was the new Musk idea.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by ScottBurson on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:13PM (#16210936)
Yeah, yeah, god it really sucks here, nobody should move to California. Thanks for helping to get the word out!
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by sarah180 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:04AM (#16214082)
The states with the most violent crime? Alaska, Nevada, New Mexico, Tennessee, Louisiana, Arkansas, South Carolina, …. I'm not sure that your hypothesis checks out.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by IIAOPSW on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:52AM (#16211571)
I must have spaced out. When did the state agree to build the hyperloop?
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by felipellrocha on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:38AM (#16231504)
Are we talking about the same state here?
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by joe_the_user on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:54PM (#16209377)
Twenty one states have enacted laws against municipal broadband, including ... Montana. The FCC under Obama overturned these. Given broadband providers now are effectively getting their wish-list, it seems like these laws may come back in force.

https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/qkvn4x/the-21-law...

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by devindotcom on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:09PM (#16209499)
They may, except the FCC is also abandoning considerable authority by throwing away Title II, so it may not be able to overturn (or over-overturn, or whatever) those and other rules — and perhaps may not even be able to enforce its prohibition against state/city net neutrality rules.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by at-fates-hands on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:09AM (#16214125)
This is kind of interesting considering the state did provide broadband service from 2010-2014:

http://broadband.mt.gov/default.aspx

The Program was funded through the State Broadband Initiative (SBI) program, administered by the U.S. Department of Commerce, National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA). It ran from Jan 1, 2010 through Dec 31, 2014.

I'm guessing the funding either ran out, or the program was discontinued due to cost?

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by tzs on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:55PM (#16210858)
It's a conservative town rather than a whole state, but something like this?

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/06/what-...

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by twothamendment on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @12:41AM (#16211301)
The state will stay out of the ISP business. I already have a coop with fiber to my house and I'm out in the sticks. Not everyone in the state is that lucky, but that isn't a real Montana-like thing to do.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by zer0t3ch on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @07:21AM (#16212994)
"they could afford to jettison those contracts"

Don't they have to have a contract with the state to have access to the cables? IE: any ISP would have a state contract. If it ceased those contracts, it wouldn't be able to function as an ISP.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by joe_the_user on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:58PM (#16218162)
No, those contracts are with cities and counties; the owners of the land that telephone poles sit on.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by RangerScience on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:59PM (#16209427)
I like both Montana's plan, and this plan.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by takk309 on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:59PM (#16208350)
Also a Montanan and I second this opinion. We are a small state (population) with few ISP's, especially in the rural areas. I am sure they all do some sort of business with the State.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by twothamendment on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @12:42AM (#16211306)
Yeah, I'm pretty sure my ISP is the only one in the county, so there is a good chance the serve the schools and government buildings.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by jjeaff on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:06PM (#16208414)
So if they choose not to abide by net neutrality, the state will just do without internet service?

Seems like the state would be in the same place most consumers are, we don't like it, but there are no alternatives.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by betenoire on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:48PM (#16208820)
I'm not in Montana, but I'm close, and the thought of scaring away the only two realistic options I have for internet sounds... well it sounds intoxicating. I would love a disruption of service and for new things to start shaking out.

the interim would suck... but so what.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by takk309 on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:19PM (#16208537)
Two of the best ISPs in my area here in Montana are Montana owned. One is even a co-op. I don't think it would be too painful to have Charter or Century Link leave the state.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by jnordwick on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:57PM (#16208906)
So then this would seem to be a good argument against the idea of Comcast or Century Link being a monopoly and a serious argument against the idea that net neutrality needs laws to enforce it.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by s73ver_ on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:22PM (#16209115)
Not in the least. There are still plenty of areas where there is only one option.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by rootusrootus on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:15PM (#16209072)
I am guessing (perhaps wrongly) that for most commercial addresses there are other options available for Internet service that do not rely on carriers which also serve residential customers. If the state can't get Comcast to agree to their terms, they might have to buy a different class of service than cheapo Comcast Business.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by joshuaheard on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:24PM (#16209608)
I hadn't considered that outcome, but it's certainly possible. However, state governments are large customers to most vendors, so I would think some ISP would step up and get the business.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by hammock on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:06PM (#16210277)
Has there ever been a successful telecom that did not have government contracts?
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by colejohnson66 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @06:41AM (#16212758)
I may be wrong, but what about Google Fiber?
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by PopsiclePete on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:27PM (#16217872)
He said "successful". Google Fiber gave up.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by colejohnson66 on Wednesday January 24, 2018 @01:43AM (#16220840)
They were still successful in multiple areas. Also, AFAIK, they didn’t “give up”; They switched from fighting over poles to microtrecnching and wireless.
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by rocqua on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:29AM (#16212390)
Would you consider small (local) WISPs that are profitable succesful?
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by TimesOldRoman on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:41PM (#16209266)
Do we know if this can be federally overturned under the almighty Commerce Clause?
Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by topspin on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:52PM (#16208861)
> The headline is a little misleading.

The headline is clickbait.

Re:Montana becomes first state to implement net neutrality a... by skynetv2 on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:35PM (#16208126)
its pretty routine and accepted policy.

you should see the conditions San Francisco city attaches to its contracts.