News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by bambax on Monday January 22, 2018 @01:36AM (#16202339)
> It’s a bit overkill, I think, to replace a checker or self-checkout stand with a hundred cameras that unblinkingly record every tiny movement. What’s to gain? 20 or 30 seconds of your time back?

My thoughts exactly. What's the point of all this? What is the problem that they're trying to solve?

Also, the monitoring done in that kind of store is very different from security monitoring systems we have today, because it knows who it's watching. The fact that it doesn't use facial recognition is pointless since it has your identity and account # the minute you enter the store.

It can study you: not just what you buy, but how you think.

I'm also curious if it would work with how I shop. Usually in small supermarkets I put my bag or trolley in one corner of the shop and bring products back to it. It's maybe a little inefficient but it lets me walk unencumbered. Would it know my bag is mine?

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by thinkloop on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:55AM (#16203189)
I don't understand this "20 or 30 seconds" comment, it takes more like 20 minutes to wait in line and scan all items, then pay. I use Uber mainly because I can walk out the cab without paying, and that's a real twenty seconds.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by seszett on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:33AM (#16203356)
20 minutes?

In France we have these manual scanners that you can carry around the supermarket and scan items as you put them in your bag. Then when you exit the store, semi-randomly an employee will rescan part of your items, or all of them (it happens more often if you often forget to scan things - which can happen, but it can also be wilful shoplifting of course). Then you pay and the gate opens.

Most of the time it does take about 30 seconds, also you don't have to get your stuff out of your bag and you know all along how much you're going to pay.

I think I haven't used the regular lines for years.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by jaclaz on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:22AM (#16203829)
>Most of the time it does take about 30 seconds, also you don't have to get your stuff out of your bag and you know all along how much you're going to pay.

And this latter has an interesting side effect.

At the time these readers were introduced the "message" to the public was "your convenience, faster checkout" (while actually the reason was "let us reduce the number of cashiers").

What was soon found out was that the "poor man's average shopping" was raised by some 10-15%.

Imagine you go to the supermarket and you only have in your pocket a single 50 Euro (or 50 dollars) note.

You put things in your basket making a mental calculation of the total amount in order to avoid, when you checkout, if the total is more than 50, to have to leave some item (and also to avoid the "social shame").

With the new method, where you can see your progressive total, that kind of shopping has raised from 42-45 to 48-50, i.e. people use "all they have" without risking to "look bad".

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by janekm on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @04:54AM (#16212238)
When I'm using the app-based version of this kind of system, I find myself much more likely to put an item back on the shelf when I see the price come up in the app (or when I notice how high my total bill is getting). Being surprised at the total spend after visiting a supermarket used to be quite common for me, and I'm sure I'm not alone in that experience! Of course Amazon are well aware of this psychology and only send you the bill after you leave the store...
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by adamio on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:54AM (#16205281)
who is this hypothetical poor man who's so bad at managing money that an exact total of the amount he's spending will cause him to overspend ?
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by jaclaz on Monday January 22, 2018 @11:28AM (#16205590)
>who is this hypothetical poor man who's so bad at managing money that an exact total of the amount he's spending will cause him to overspend ?

It is not hypothetical, it is a peculiar - but not so uncommon - man/woman with a limited amount of money in his/her hands (and of course no credit card or similar), the single 50 in the example (but it could be 20 or 100) banknote.

He/she is willing to spend the whole amount of money, but before didn't because he/she was afraid to be seen as having only that given limited amount of money and by making approximate mental calculation tended to undereestimate (or if you prefer preferred to be on the safe side).

With the barcode reader he/she can spend the whole amount of money he/she has available with no risk of appearing (to the cashier, to the people in queue) as "poor".

The poiont is not that with the new system this kind of "poor" people overspend, rather it is that before it underspent.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by melkiaur on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:23AM (#16204495)
> it does take about 30 seconds

As long as there's nobody in the queue, and the "scannette" (yes, that's how they're called) still has enough battery, and you haven't tried to buy razor-blades which require a manual action from an attendant to remove the theft-protection device, and the granny in front of you isn't trying to pay with coins.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by seszett on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:40AM (#16204631)
Never had a problem with battery or a queue that lasted more than a minute or so (either at Carrefour or Auchan, some of the largest ones in Lille).

The manual action doesn't take long because the attendant has little to do, and I don't use the lane where you can pay with cash, but the many others that only take a credit card.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by danmaz74 on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:01AM (#16203738)
Same here in Italy. I use them all the time.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by arkades on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:51AM (#16203964)
20-30s is just flat-out unheard of where I live (east coast). It doesn’t happen - not in Costco, not in Stop&shop, and certainly not at TJs.

Removing check-out times from my Saturday morning shopping routine - which, as it includes hitting three stores for the various best deals and exclusive products my household prefers, guarantees a wait of 20+ mins in at least one of the shops - would probably give me back 40-60 minutes in total.

That’s a /lot/ more than 30s.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by vertex-four on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:51AM (#16203423)
Wait what? Every time I've ever shopped in the UK, it's taken on the order of a minute or two. Are US stores really that inefficient?
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by kweks on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:00AM (#16204010)
Supermarket checkouts in France are woefully slow and ineffecient. I've lived here for 10 years, and it drives me crazy.

- Cashiers do not pack for you. (Most other countries, they will bag as they go. Groceries are plonked on the other side. - ..which means that the cashier cannot / will not progress with another client until the previous person has packed their stuff. This can take.. a .. long .. time. - You can still pay via cheque in a supermarket. This requires cutting the cheque, manually sighting two pieces of ID, scanning the cheque, processing the payment. The little scanner devices take.. 30 seconds to do a scan. - Stores are horribly understaffed. They constantly have 20% less people that they should.

So you move to the self-checkout machines, that constantly error if you place an item too quickly / slowly / on top of another item.

There are definitely pain-points to solve in this area.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by IanCal on Monday January 22, 2018 @08:58AM (#16204326)
We have to pack ourselves in the UK too, but it doesn't take long you just put things in bags as they're scanning the next one. Or in Aldi where they fire things through like a machine gun, put it in your basket / trolley and go and pack it elsewhere.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by mlevental on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:13AM (#16203490)
it depends where you live. in NYC I have waited in line for on the order of 10 minutes before. in podunk I have never waited (supermarket wait is actually one of the only things I complained about after moving to NYC)
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by b4lancesh33t on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:51AM (#16203962)
TJ's in Manhattan on Friday evening can have a line that wraps all the way around the store, even with forty registers going.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by jakobegger on Monday January 22, 2018 @02:37AM (#16202568)
I would love this! I usually go shopping with a backpack, and in a store like this I could put stuff into my backpack directly from the shelf, rather than trying to put all my items into my bag as quickly as possible at the checkout counter with half a dozen impatient people behind me.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by justonepost on Monday January 22, 2018 @03:36AM (#16202845)
Also, shoplifting. 1.7% of gross sales, which given 2% profit margins, you can see how profit can almost double with this. It's a 32B dollar opportunity.

Economy of scale will also help reduce worker costs.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by e40 on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:11AM (#16203484)
What’s to gain? 20 or 30 seconds of your time back?

Lines at my local Safeway are always really long. Yesterday I went in for a single item and there was no express checkout lane open. It took seconds to find the item, but 15 minutes to check out.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by dx034 on Monday January 22, 2018 @10:26AM (#16205019)
That's because they don't want to hire more staff. The kind of store that would invest in hundreds of cameras (plus other sensors) would already have enough checkouts to avoid queues.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by rtpg on Monday January 22, 2018 @03:36AM (#16202848)
An optimists view: being a cashier is not a great job, so we can make sure that nobody ever has to do it again.

(Supposedly this view is combined with basic income or something)

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by quadcore on Monday January 22, 2018 @03:46AM (#16202895)
I've replaced my job as software engineer for cashier and I like it much. No bullshit, no politics, no bully, no discrimination. Way happier.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by madeofpalk on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:51AM (#16203182)
> No bullshit, no politics, no bully, no discrimination

Heh. If you think that bullshit, politics, bullying or discrimination can't exist in a cashier job, then you're very very mistaken.

These things happen in workplaces, not industries.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by quadcore on Monday January 22, 2018 @09:07AM (#16204393)
The way I see it, some people' blows are easier to take than some others'. A dumbass doesn't hurt much, most of the time, if you'd pardon my french.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by sleepychu on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:33AM (#16203105)
I'm an SE because I like problem solving for my job. Did you find you missed that when you stopped doing it? Do you still do software for fun?
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by quadcore on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:41AM (#16203136)
I've found that most of the time, problem solving was not problem solving but working around problem. Good point though. Yes I still code for fun.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by thinkloop on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:57AM (#16203201)
Can you write a blog post about that, it seems very strange and unique. Isn't being a cashier a terribly tedious, mindless and repetitive job extremely ill-suited for a human?
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by Shivetya on Monday January 22, 2018 @07:20AM (#16203821)
We must be very careful in deciding what others find fulfilling. We are not all cut out for the same levels of social interaction and we don't all have the same aspirations. I have met many a cashier/grocery/retail worker who were very happy people and I have met some who weren't. it all comes down to filling your financial needs as well as your personal needs and more power to those who can

Anecdotal bit: Years ago I did programming/etc for a rent-a-cop agency. We had thousands of uniformed security people working across the country both armed and unarmed. Since I had responsibility for ensuring payroll runs were completed to include termination pay; some states required 48hr pay; I was initially appalled at the hourly rates some had.

Well after talking with more than a few; our local office was in the same building and we had one guard on hand for escorting women to and from the parking deck; I came to find out more than a few enjoyed the work. One even commented "I get to sit behind a desk all day and get paid" and students who did work got to study.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by pentae on Monday January 22, 2018 @05:07AM (#16203245)
I think the Author of the article misses the point. It's slightly more useful for consumers, but once this becomes commoditized and scaled out there will be massive cost savings compared to hiring a handful of checkout staff, and this system could run 24 hours without having to close down the store.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by sAbakumoff on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:03AM (#16203453)
They don't solve any problems, they are trying to record your offline life so that they have the full picture of your existence and manipulate it in order to maximise the profit of shareholders.
Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by tinokid on Monday January 22, 2018 @02:03AM (#16202428)
Agreed. we'll see if it catches on.

Existing stores could catch up a lot by improving the self checkout experience. Perhaps add a super-express method for single items with e-receipt only.

Re:Amazon’s surveillance-powered no-checkout convenience store by reacweb on Monday January 22, 2018 @06:58AM (#16203720)
I think the gain is the possibility to keep the store open during all night with almost no staff present or no staff at all (with a teleworker).