News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:57AM (#16115854)
What the elected, Republican majority legislature voted for is not "crass disregard for the democratic process". It's actually the democratic process. If the legislature passes a bill that's unconstitutional, then it's up to the judicial branch to rectify that.

By population, NC is a 50/50 red/blue state. Even by county, which is what a non-gerrymandered legislature would look like, it's all red outside of Charlotte and Raleigh, and 50/50 in places like Greensboro or Fayetteville.

I'm against HB-2 as well, but it's up to the judicial to rectify that.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by Harimwakairi on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:03AM (#16115905)
> What the elected, Republican majority legislature voted for is not "crass disregard for the democratic process".

The fact that the judiciary has the power to stop them does not make what they did any more or less acceptable. Gerrymandering the state specifically to subvert the will of the voting population is crass disregard for the democratic process.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:09AM (#16115987)
Which is why the judiciary deemed it unconstitutional! You make my point for me.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by cardamomo on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:21AM (#16116160)
It should not be the goal of any elected official or member our federal or state governments to pass laws that violate the U.S. Constitution or state constitutions. I agree with you that judicial review is an important tool to remove such laws after they've been passed, but the current trend in U.S. federal and state legislatures is to find both blatant and subtle ways to circumvent our constitutions.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by nikkev on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:22AM (#16116168)
You're grossly missing the point. If your kid steals money from your wallet, you catch them and punish them. That does not make what they did right just because they were punished and you deemed their behavior unacceptable. What if you didn't find out? Or what if you decided to look the other way because it was only five dollars?
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by heavenlyblue on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @04:21PM (#16119183)
Sadly, but a morally speaking you're then getting into the same territory as it is with the sex offenders; who having offended once are stained for the rest of their lives.

There is a reason why there's a statute of limitations, but neither does it mean that the current punishment is enough.

Let's talk children, as you say - you would punish a child, yet you would not mark him as a morally corrupted person forever; the punishment just needs to be severe enough.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by tw04 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:12AM (#16116028)
So if the Republican majority legislature voted Trump the King of North Carolina with unchallenged authoritarian rule, that would be your idea of "the democratic process"? A democratic body taking action isn't "part of the democratic process" just because they're the ones doing it. That's not how it works.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by mfringel on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:12AM (#16116029)
In an elected legislature, the voters should choose their representatives, not the other way around.

If the sitting legislature changes the districts in order to choose their voters, we move away from the ideal of an election.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by gglitch on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:37AM (#16116372)
I'm reminded of a time in Chicago when I saw one of a group of three teenagers deliberately and casually drop his trash on the floor of a public bus. Both of his peers looked at him askance and he said, "What? I pay taxes."

The existence of a body charged with cleaning up messes is not an excuse for acting in bad faith. _Nothing_ is an excuse for acting in bad faith.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by IgorPartola on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:15AM (#16116078)
This is some weapons grade bullshit. "The legislators can pass whatever unconstitutional law they want, so long as the judges are there as a failsafe."

I lived in NC. The senators there that introduced a state constitutional amendment to deny marriage equality all ran in districts where they had no opponent running at all.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by tjstankus on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:11AM (#16116013)
I think your argument is focused too far along the timeline. Yes, the Republican majority was elected. What's in dispute is the legitimacy of how they came to be elected, given the proven racist bias of how districts came to be. Different (fairer) districting might not change the Republican majority status, but it probably wouldn't be so lopsided. (BTW: Asheville is almost completely blue, too.)
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:15AM (#16116070)
Yup, I forgot about Asheville.

> proven racist bias

That goes both ways (Charlotte, Greensboro and Fayetteville). I really don't think the Democrats are going to be happy with the outcome of a rebalancing, because the Republicans will still have a huge legislative majority, maybe even more so.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by hyperpape on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:21AM (#16116163)
How do you get to a huge legislative majority from the voting pattern, except via unrepresentative districts?
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:26AM (#16116235)
When you divide the state up geographically instead of by population, it's way red (as is with every state in the union). While the current gerrymandering is ridiculous, I don't think it has much of an effect on the overall outcome.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by hyperpape on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @12:44PM (#16117060)
"When you divide the state up geographically instead of by population, it's way red (as is with every state in the union)."

So don't do that. Land doesn't vote, people do. If you give every 600k people a congressional district, the state is slightly more red than blue.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @02:04PM (#16117827)
Any country with our agricultural exports and requirements that decides to do that will collapse upon itself.

When every policy decision is decided by the needs of the residents of a few, highly populous cities, with no thought to the different needs of those living in rural areas, being a farmer, miner, logger, etc. becomes completely disincentivized.

When all those people in those cities (and the rest of the country) require incentivized agriculture to supply their basic survival needs, the system falls apart. The whole reason we have a Senate is so people in states that produce our agricultural products aren't disenfranchised.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by hyperpape on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @03:25PM (#16118697)
Leave aside the argument that people outside of agricultural states will not understand that the billions of dollars worth of agriculture are valuable, which seems false.

Even so, California is our largest agricultural producer, and it's disenfranchised by the Senate. Other major producers include some small states like Nebraska, but also other large states like Texas, Illinois and North Carolina.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by throwawayjava on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @02:31PM (#16118119)
> Any country with our agricultural exports and requirements that decides to do that will collapse upon itself... incentivized agriculture to supply their basic survival needs

Ugh.

This is a huge pet peeve of mine. The agricultural industry does not exist in isolation, so its most immediate practitioners do not deserve a minority-rule electoral power.

Farmers use Wall St money to fund the planting of seeds geo-engineered by folks living in cities, harvest the resulting crops using tractors designed/built by folks living in cities, then ship the product on freight designed/built by folks living in cities. Throughout the whole process, farmers depend upon a whole set of energy informatics products (from weather prediction to oil discovery) made possible by a tour de force of scientific and engineering talent designed/built by folks living in/around cities.

Farmers are not rugged individualists, and an individual farmer is no more "critical to the survival" of city folk than a Deere software engineer or an Exxon scientist is "critical to the survival" of the modern farmer. And yet, you don't see those folks asking for a non-representative democracy...

The myth of the rugged farmer as the pillar holding modern society is just that -- a BS mythology.

And all of this before even considering that city folk help pay for all the public infrastructure that makes farming possible in the first place -- everything form rural roads and interstates they never directly use to subsidized crop insurance they don't immediately benefit from to concessions in international treaties that directly harm their industry in return for concessions that boost our agricultural industry and thereby contribute to our own food security.

Going back to the article, farmers don't deserve to be the dictators of a minority-ruled psuedo-democracy because farmers are just one more cog in a huge machine, a machine that farmers depend on to support their own way of life and, in many cases, even survival.

> When every policy decision is decided by the needs of the residents of a few, highly populous cities, with no thought to the different needs of those living in rural areas, being a farmer, miner, logger, etc. becomes completely disincentivized.

There are lots of people in cities who depend on and know a lot about the agricultural industry. Some of them grew up on farms and went on to work in knowledge industries supporting farming. Many of these city folks know more about farming/logging/mining than even the most skilled farmer/logger/miner. And many have more at stake in the success of America's agricultural industry than the folks actually working the land.

Presuming that someone who doesn't work the land can't know the needs of the agricultural/mining/logging industry is a somewhat conceited viewpoint.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @03:18PM (#16118637)
> an individual farmer is no more "critical to the survival" of city folk than a Deere software engineer or an Exxon scientist

Utter, pompous nonsense. And I say that as a software engineer.

> farmers don't deserve to be the dictators of a minority-ruled psuedo-democracy because farmers are just one more cog in a huge machine

What they don't deserve to be is permanently dictated to because their profession requires that they live in less population dense areas.

> There are lots of people in cities who depend on and know a lot about the agricultural industry.

What percentage of people living in New York have worked a farm? I think you're pulling your conclusions out of thin air.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by throwawayjava on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @03:30PM (#16118755)
> Utter, pompous nonsense. And I say that as a software engineer.

One hundred years ago maybe. Not today. And the Exxon scientist/Deere engineer is meant to be read in a prototypical way. The point is, modern food security depends on the proper functioning of a lage, inter-dependent system.

It would be pompous to claim that the average software/petro engineer understands farming better than a farmer. But I didn't make that claim. I made the claim that some of these folks understand a related industry that is as important to US food security as is the actual act of farming a particular piece of land.

I also provided concrete and specific ways in which Farmers rely on a larger social fabric and, in particular, engineering/scientific/financial expertise that tends to concentrate in large cities.

Instead of calling names, provide counter-points those concrete and specific dependencies. Explain how a modern modern farmer could do his work, in an economically and ecologically sustainable way, without those other industries.

Also, in addition to the dependencies I've already pointed out, I'll provide an actual counter-example to your claim. Plenty of countries with many more farmers per capita than the USA have far worse food security than the USA, even given excellent farmland. So clearly, farmers are only part of the story!

And also a counter-example in the other direction: plenty of countries that don't use insane gerrymandering to give a minority of voters out-sized political influence have excellent agricultural systems. So clearly, farmers don't need minority rule in order for a society to enjoy a stable agricultural sector.

So no, we are not going to starve if rural folks lose their ability to push policy on abortion and bathroom usage. Both rationally and empirically, the claims you're making about the supremacy of the farmer's vote don't hold up to observed reality.

> What they don't deserve to be is permanently dictated to because their profession requires that they live in less population dense areas.

That's true. But they also don't deserve more say because they live in a less dense area, which is what you were originally claiming.

And even if farmers did have some unique secret sauce understanding of the inter-connected system that ensures US food security, your argument still does not justify giving rural folks in general an out-sized voice in governance. You do not make the case that the average rural McDonalds employee should have more voting power than the average urban McDonalds employee. The proposition that your argument actually defends is that that (farm) land ownership/stewardship should determine voting power.

Ew.

Each person should have one vote, equally weighted, and without respect to geographic location. No?

> What percentage of people living in New York have worked a farm? I think you're pulling your conclusions out of thin air.

Well, New York has a lot of agriculture ;-)

WRT NYC, That's not the correct question. The correct question is: what percentage of people in New York understand OR[1] contribute to some industry or process that's critical to US food security? That's a good question, and sounds difficult to answer with any specificity, so I stand by my original claim: "a lot".

[1] Mere understanding is sufficient here, because your claim was that farmers need a bigger electoral voice to ensure food security. My claim is that many people in cities understand what's necessary for a functioning agricultural system, and will vote accordingly (seeing as they like eating and all)

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by FireBeyond on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @12:17PM (#16116767)
While I get some of the merits of this method in the beginning, it really does subvert democracy.

"Los Angeles and New York get less proportional representation, just because many people choose to live there."

"What about the people of rural South Dakota, don't they get a vote?"

Absolutely they do.

Geographic systems are based on a flawed predicate. Democracy should be based on "1 person, 1 vote", not "1 square mile/foot, 1 vote".

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by mikestew on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:26AM (#16116224)
If the legislature passes a bill that's unconstitutional, then it's up to the judicial branch to rectify that.

Tell me you go ahead and stick your hand in table saws because the safety interlocks will save you, and I’ll accept this statement as a justification for such undemocratic behavior.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by unclebucknasty on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:06AM (#16115962)
To quibble with your logic, if the legislature were to consistently pass laws that directly concerned the democratic process (i.e. voting) and those laws had to be overturned as unconstitutional, then their actions could certainly be construed as a disregard for the democratic process.

That another element of the democratic process (the courts) intervened to correct the legislature's disregard does not exonerate that disregard.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:12AM (#16116025)
Then it's up to the people to elect different representatives that promise not to do that. That's democracy.

You don't get to blow up the system because it's not functioning how you want it to. You're supposed to work in the system. The judiciary is correctly functioning by declaring this gerrymandering unconstitutional.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by pohl on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:19AM (#16116127)
Then it's up to the people to elect different representatives that promise not to do that.

It sounds to me as though you have not fully internalized that gerrymandering – and other associated voter suppression tactics – are precisely designed to thwart the remedy you recommend here.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by mikestew on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:33AM (#16116335)
elect different representatives that promise not to do that

If that’s your response, I assess that you’ve either reached the point of supporting a narrative, or you don’t understand the impact of gerrymandering, which is specifically designed to work around this. You snarkily mentioned something was “U. S. government 101”, which it wasn’t, but gerrymandering they taught me in grade school.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by wffurr on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:23AM (#16116177)
If the state is 50/50, why isn't the legislature? The whole point of the democratic process is for the lawmaking body to be representative of the people. One person, one vote. Gerrymandering undermines the very foundation of democracy.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:37PM (#16120165)
> Even by county, which is what a non-gerrymandered legislature would look like

No, it's not; legislative districts must be equal size because of one-person-one-vote; counties very much are not equal size. What things look like by county has little to do with what a “non-gerrymandered” legislative map would look like (which isn't even a uniquely objectively answerable question, since while there are some clear established improper goals in districting, there's no single accepted standard for correct goals, so there is a very wide range of potential non-gerrymandered ways of districting, which produce very different maps.)

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by zeveb on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:07AM (#16115970)
> If the legislature passes a bill that's unconstitutional, then it's up to the judicial branch to rectify that.

I don't really agree with that, nor do I think does the Constitution. The legislature may not pass laws which are inconsistent with the Constitution; the executive may not execute actions which are inconsistent with the Constitution and the law; the judicial may not render decisions which are inconsistent with (firstly) the Constitution and (secondly) the law.

As a practical matter this means that the judicial branch often is reviewing the law, but it doesn't absolve the other two branches of obeying their oaths of office.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:10AM (#16116002)
And who decides that the legistlature passed "laws which are inconsistent with the Constitution"?
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by mfringel on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:16AM (#16116097)
The legislators themselves, as per the oath taken by every legislator in North Carolina, as noted in the NC State Constitution: Article 6, section 7.[1]

Sec. 7. Oath.

Before entering upon the duties of an office, a person elected or appointed to the office shall take and subscribe the following oath:

"I, _______________, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and maintain the Constitution and laws of the United States, and the Constitution and laws of North Carolina not inconsistent therewith, and that I will faithfully discharge the duties of my office as _______________, so help me God."

[1] https://www.ncleg.net/legislation/constitution/article6.html

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by wffurr on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:25AM (#16116217)
There should be sanction for violating one's oath. Legislators that directly undermine by the democratic process by gerrymandering and other means should be removed from office.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by zeveb on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @12:51PM (#16117126)
Likewise, who decides if the judicial branch has rendered decisions which are inconsistent with the Constitution?

It's turtles all the way down: the legislature's laws are reviewed by judges or ignored by the executive; judges & members of the executive branch may be impeached by the legislature; ultimately the voters decide what they're willing to let their government get away with.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by stupidcar on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:04AM (#16115920)
Total nonsense. While it's true that in a liberal democracy the judiciary is supposed to be a check against the power of the legislative and executive branches, its mere existence doesn't give them carte blanche to ignore basic principles of sound democracy.

These people are representatives. They are supposed to represent the interests of all their constituents. Deliberately redrawing the electoral map in an attempt to help voters only of their own party is a gross violation of basic democratic norms. It is putting party before country in the worst possible way.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by indubitable on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:34AM (#16116337)
All political systems with a modicum of success, including ours, have worked to align interests without relying on a moral compass. Magnetic north tends to wobble quite a bit more in politics. The idea of our republic is that the only responsibility of people would be to elect congressmen they feel will represent them, or continue doing so. And similarly, to not reelect people that do not represent them. This thus coerces representatives into representing the people for fear of finding themselves without seat come next election campaign.

That this has failed is in fault a part of the system, but largely our own fault. You can see this very thread degenerating into partisanship. And this partisanship ensures that representatives don't actually need to worry about representing the people that put them into office. All they need to do is make the people scared enough of the alternative that they'll vote against their self interest 'because it's better than the alternative.' The most recent election was quite a radical example, which I suspect will only get more extreme in elections to come. How many people genuinely felt Hillary was the sort of person that would truly represent them and their beliefs? How many people voted for her because they were terrified instead of Trump? And vice versa for those that voted for Trump and their terror of Clinton as opposed to those voting with belief Trump would effectively represent them?

It's also the same reason our 'representatives' pander left and right to corporations and special interests. We do a pretty awful job at being swayed by anything resembling merit, but massive advertising, attack ads, and other stuff is what really gets us going. Corporations and special interests provide the "donations" to fund those campaigns. The average voter does not. They simply go out and emotionally, or tribally, cast their votes, get their sticker and 6 pack, and go home and root for their team like a sports game - much to the benefit of the 'players.'

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by stupidcar on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @02:40PM (#16118226)
> All political systems with a modicum of success, including ours, have worked to align interests without relying on a moral compass.

I would agree with most of what you said, particularly your diagnosis of the dysfunctions of the US system, but this part simply isn't true. There are plenty of successful democracies (almost all in central and northern Europe, admittedly) where political partisanship exists within a moral framework, and politicians adhere to certain moral and democratic norms, even when it is against their immediate interests to do so.

I think it's easy to overgeneralise the problems of the closest example to hand as being representative of all, and being fundamental and unavoidable limitations of human nature. But there are always counter-examples. There are always places where government actually delivers to people, and where the political system avoids the worst systemic dysfunctions that plague other regimes.

I'm not sure the US will ever reform its political system to achieve the same results, but, at the very least, we shouldn't let politicians (and the people who elect them) off the hook for underperforming vs. what we know is possible.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by indubitable on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:45AM (#16123325)
Most of the democracies of which you're referencing use proportional voting systems often paired with a parliamentary system. That system in particular makes it phenomenally easy to replace politicians and tends to work most effectively as a coercive device against bad behavior. The reason for this is that it minimizes the necessity of strategic voting.

In the US it doesn't matter if the #1 candidate only got 10% of the vote. As long as the #2 candidate got less than 10%, then #1 gets 100% of the seats and political power. Because of this, voters have to factor in the insidious 'electability' into their decisions. Fewer people than ever identify as republican or democrat, yet they retain very near 100% of seats at all levels. This is what I was alluding to when mentioning that part of the problem is our system. Compare this to a proportional system where if there are 10 seats available then gaining at least 10% of the vote, in general, tends to guarantee you representation. This makes strategic voting much less of a concern. Even the 'Pirate Party' has managed to win representation in a variety of nations similar to those you allude to.

And for the sake of brevity, I'll omit more precise discussion of population size and diversity here. But those factors need also be considered. Compared to the nations you're mentioning, the US is huge and incredibly diverse. Democracy is redundant in populations where views tend to remain fairly similar throughout as any action would tend to be the will of all. On the other end, in a nation where everybody held views often mutually exclusive, democracy would be dysfunctional at best as any action would please one group to the offense of all the rest. Of course every nation's reality lay somewhere between the opposite extremes, but where the nations you describe may lay closer to one end, I suspect the US lays closer to the other.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by dang on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @01:19PM (#16117397)
Would you please stop posting political rants to HN? Assuming you're 100% right, it doesn't justify the damage of taking HN threads into flamewar red. Moreover such discussions are always all the same, which means they don't gratify intellectual curiosity, which means they're off topic here.

It's complicated, of course, when the topic is itself politicized. But it's possible—and because possible, necessary—to discuss it without getting either generic or uncivil.

You've posted some excellent comments but I also see quite a few in which you've taken swipes at the person or comment you're replying to. That's against the rules here. We have these rules because of long experience with what fosters discussion quality and what degrades it. If you'd read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the spirit of this site to heart going forward, we'd really appreciate it.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by stupidcar on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @02:17PM (#16117962)
I'm sure I've crossed the line into personal swipes before — who hasn't, at one time or another? I get emotional about this stuff because I care about it, and I'll admit it angers me to see people spreading ideas that I consider not just wrong, but dangerously so. When that happens, its difficult to respond like some perfect critical-thinking debate bot.

But I'm somewhat baffled that you consider what I posted in this case a "rant". Fair enough, saying "total nonsense" was probably unnecessary, but it is still a comment on the quality of the argument, not upon the person, and as such seems to be within the rules. As for the rest, what exactly is uncivil about it? I absolutely would make these same arguments face-to-face if somebody made the original argument. In fact, I'd be probably be rather less civil about it in person.

I consider the post I responded to to be spreading a genuinely dangerous idea. Such ideas need to be rebutted, and, practically speaking, the force of the rhetoric needs to be increased commensurate with the dangerousness of the idea, in order to avoid giving an impression of false equivalence between it and other, more harmless ones. If it isn't commensurate, then surely that is what the community moderation is for? But in this case you seem to have acted unilaterally to hide my post.

I'm all for HN to be a bastion of constructive discussion. But that shouldn't be an excuse to allow toxic ideas to go unchallenged, or to be treated with a degree of respect that they do not deserve. The failure of intellectuals to vigorously contest destructive ideas, confining their criticism to a passionless and academic vernacular, has been a recurring historical problem. In the long term, it contributes directly to the rise of situations and movements that curtail any debate, anodyne or otherwise.

HN does not exist in a political vacuum. The type of discussion you say you want to foster is only possible because of a set of political principles and circumstances that are by no means "normal", historically speaking. Failing to defend those principles, or censoring those who do, helps those who would destroy them, and will harm HN eventually.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:08AM (#16115977)
Do you have any idea how many laws have been overturned because they were unconstitutional? It's U.S. Government 101.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by dang on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @01:56PM (#16117750)
Would you please not do flamewars on Hacker News? especially political flamewars? We're hoping for something different here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by unclebucknasty on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:14AM (#16116058)
>Do you have any idea how many laws have been overturned because they were unconstitutional? It's U.S. Government 101.

What you're missing is that the laws being overturned here are themselves directly concerned with the democratic process.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by fortythirteen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:18AM (#16116124)
Are you surprised that the legislature creates laws about how the democracy functions? What do you think a constitutional amendment is?
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by roywiggins on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:25AM (#16116207)
Well, constitutional amendments aren't laws, for a start.
Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:33PM (#16120142)
Yes, the Constitution is the Supreme Law of the Land, and amendments to that law are themselves laws.

They aren't statutes, which are a lesser and more-common form of law.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by unclebucknasty on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:21AM (#16116157)
>Are you surprised that the legislature creates laws about how the democracy functions?

You seem to be deliberately missing the point.

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by dang on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @01:56PM (#16117755)
Please don't do flamewars on Hacker News.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map by unclebucknasty on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:29PM (#16120122)
I didn't. At least, I don't believe I did.

The GP was consistently ignoring the salient point that I and others repeatedly made; instead pursuing the same line of attack as if we hadn't pointed out the inconsistency.

Hence, it seemed to me that he was not interested in engaging in honest dialogue, so I pointed to his approach to the discussion. There was no personal attack.