Gold is just about the only thing around that acts somewhat like money but isn't premised on much of anything except social constructed value. Though even there, there are jewelry and electronic uses.
I could believe that we could could get something else like gold that would be bootstrapped into having a relatively stable purely social constructed value. But as you point out, there isn't just one altcoin that has solved (some of) the problems of bitcoins, there are lots.
There are huge incentives to issue new altcoins and for speculators to buy new altcoins in hopes of being the winner. And those speculators and creators are all hoping for this huge volatility (albeit in one direction) while what's strongly preferred for a medium of exchange is value stability.
I don't see how we get there from here. What process or trends out there look convergent and stabilizing to you?
You've got it half right. In most countries, private individuals and organizations are also required to accept the state currency for at least some purposes. In the USA, for example, creditors are required to accept US banknotes in payment of debts. This places US dollars firmly at the core of the US financial system. This doesn't create any legal obligation for US businesses to accept dollars, but it does create a very strong incentive for them to accept dollars in some form. That's the currency in which their finances will almost certainly need to be conducted if they want to have access to things like banking.
That creates a situation where the US dollar isn't just valuable insofar as you can use it to pay your taxes. It is, de facto but also very nearly de jure, backed by virtually the entire United States economy.
Bitcoin, on the other hand, really is backed by nothing but its own popularity. And the problem there is, it's really not that popular. It does have a lot of users worldwide, and those users can communicate over the Internet, but the same is true of Esperanto.
That said, daily, local, transactions were likely done either using simpler copper tokens or basically a verbal or written IOU.
No, at least not always.
IIRC, in Ancient Greece the money was the precious metal itself and its value of a coin was reckoned based on its weight and purity. The stamp was just an indicator of purity. The very largest amounts of money were measured using weight units (e.g. talents).
It would have been impossible for it to be otherwise, since there were so many competing coin standards (e.g. a drachma in one city could be made to a very different standard to another, with standard weights possibly varying by as much as 50% or something).
I believe there was an episode of Connections that I saw as a kid where he explains why gold was used as currency. I'm searching for it and will link if I find it.
This is becoming standard in the USA. I am glad to know that this is how they work.
Most places using chips for payment is a continuation of the magnetic strip and pin, only that now the chip can attempt to verify that the payment terminal and bank connection is functioning correctly before accepting the pin and approving the transaction details the terminal is sending to the bank.
In the end the transactions are basically ledger entries, be them manual or digital.
A chip can't be copied like a mag strip can, so it is safe from the classic skimmers. Also a pin is worthless on its own.
I have however read about a kind of mitm attack that was demoed in the UK. It involved a device sitting between the card and the terminal, and it made the chip think the terminal was doing a signature payment, while the terminal thought the chip had validated the pin.
However the concept is more generic than that. Banks could easily supply customers with their own smart cards to do this. Indeed chipped credit cards could be used for this. Although as others have noted, these chipped credit cards still have the classic card numbers printed on them which act as the private key. My local banks also supply chipped credit cards, however you can disable transactions with just the numbers via a checkbox on the bank's website. Surprisingly some banks already disable it by default, so you have to go out of your way to enable transactions with just the numbers.
--
Not that I think bitcoin and others are truly deflationary, as the presence of derivatives and fractional reserve deposits means that overall they could still be inflationary, in the same way that M0 could experience deflation while M2 experiences inflation.
I think crypto is in a huge bubble, and I think ICOs are dumb and will eventually die off or be killed off, but saying that there are 1000+ cryptocurrencies is pretty misleading. It would be like saying that due to the various stock exchanges we have millions of fiat currencies. It's only true given a particular definition of cryptocurrency.
Outside of ICOs, there are probably only a couple dozen cryptocurrencies that are not piggybacking off of some other cryptocurrency's smart contract infrastructure.
Think disagreement between miners, changes to algorithms, forks of blockchains. Gold does not have the same risk.
One nitpick: I think the SEC ruled ICOs to be comparable to certificates from what I understood. This is quite different to stocks. I could be wrong.
Any of them solve the fact that you have a eternal database fully replicated across hundreds of thousands of machines which could, by design, grow to infinite size? How about the fact that every one of those machines have to verify the integrity of every transaction ever made? Any of those could scale to handle even hundreds of transactions per second?
How about any that solve the absolute piss-awful amount of energy wasted by PoW? Any of those not pre-mined scams designed to enrich the people who "invented" the coin? Any of those useful for anything outside of paying for murder, fentanyl, or unlocking cryptoransomware?
What real-world problem, exactly, does any of this solve anyway? All of the problems we have in the financial world are political and social problems. You gotta solve those before you can start throwing tech at it...
Blockchain, on the other hand, is awesome and will continue to be a key piece of tech for things like voting and records where trust can be shared amongst all the users.
These inflammatory questions have legitimate answers, and the fact you ask them in this forum mean you haven't done any honest work to find them and would rather just post it on Hacker News and look intelligent.
So, respectively:
Yes, Yes, Yes. I hope this is a helpful answer.
Currencies have certain values as currency. This includes factors like limited supply, having some level of enforcement of its use as a currency, ease of use, and also factors such as if it has other applications.
Take a gold coin. Low ease of use, but high limited supply and gold has numerous other uses. Depending upon the actual coin, and the ability to authenticate, it could be worth only its weight as gold, or it could be worth more because of rarity.
Take a dollar. High ease of use, mostly limit supply, has the US government backing it, has almost no other use.
Crypto has value as well. Harder to use in many situations, but easier in some. It has greater ability to remove the identity of the user and their funds, which is something most other electronic payment systems don't have. It doesn't have much backing it except the crypto algorithms (which most don't understand), but it does appear to have a limited supply.
I think crypto currencies do have intrinsic value.
But there is a problem. Years ago this intrinsic value wasn't known. As we slowly worked out what value crypto provides, its price has gone up. This has attracted some people who place value in it not as a currency, but as an asset that rises in price. As more people see it as an asset to invest in instead of a currency, it further drives up the price. At the same time, the intrinsic value of crypto is still being discovered.
So the question becomes, for any given crypto-currency, is the discovered intrinsic value + increase in value from being used as an investment greater than, less than, or roughly equal to the future intrinsic value.
If the intrinsic value that will be discovered ends up being far less than the current price inflation driven by using it as an investment asset, we will eventually see a correct/crash. When, and how far it goes before then, is something I'm not at all comfortable predicting, even if that was the case.
But I will say, when people with no tech interests are coming to me asking about bitcoin and investing in it, it makes me think it is over-hyped.
There is also the possibility of value in just possessing it, but I personally think this is near 0 for crypto (unlike foreign currency where some people pay a little just to have a framed collection of bills on our wall even if those bills have no value).
This is true. However, most traditional currencies started out as something that was an abstraction for value, but was backed by something of tangible value (e.g. gold standard). This isn't true anymore, we aren't on the gold standard, but if nothing else that lack of transition from tangible to "imaginary" value never happening with bitcoin is part of what fuels the uncertainty and skepticism.
Bitcoin will likely continue to succeed even with its lack of "intrinsic" value and no backing by a traditional organization/govt simply because it was first. I don't think any of the alt-coins that don't also bring something else to the table are going to succeed long term though.
I don't disagree that there are a variety of wins for crypto systems, I'm just a moderate skeptic of most of the specific systems I know anything about (obviously, being software systems, many of the things I view as problems can be coded away).
Just because that's how it works now doesn't mean it has to always work that way. There's no reason why the "private key" couldn't be different for each transaction.
I just wired money from my brokerage account to my checking account at a different institution. It happened in thirty minutes and I was charged no fees. Digital cash has been the bulk of cash for many, many years.
It is absolutely possible. Sweden is close to achieving it [1]. The hurdle isn't technological. People like physical cash. Consider the shitstorm that would erupt in America if the Treasury announced it would stop printing and minting physical currency.
> it's still a very interesting technological development
I agree.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/jun/04/sweden-cash...
Also, I've never had a wire settle in under 24 hours. It's typically 2 - 7 days depending on destination and currency.
They're probably doing an ACH [1] transfer, which is net settled [2]. They take longer but are cheaper than wires. Fedwires, once transmitted from the sending institution, take seconds to be received [3]. They're real-time gross settled [4], i.e. faster but costlier [5]; many institutions waive (i.e. eat) these fees for clients with more than ~$50,000.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_Clearing_House
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_settlement
[3] https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fedfunds_about...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real-time_gross_settlement
[5] Why? Because they're immediate and irrevocable. The first part means the bank has to use actual funds on hand, versus hoping a countervailing transfer cancels out the work or letting a profitable (relatively speaking) investment pay out. The second part means mistakes are more resource-consuming.
It may be the leader in consumer hype of technological development, but dear deity so much of the actual daily operations seems almost third world.
Maybe they're just trying to avoid being faster than Bitcoin.
While this may be the case in some wire transfers into Coinbase/GDAX, this is certainly not the case in all cases. I've made three wire transfers of differing amount within the past three months and in each case the funds were deposited into my Coinbase account within 36 hours. Two close associates of mine have had similar experiences depositing via wire transfer in the mid- and late-December, 2017 time frame.
Granted, I have not deeply investigated all of the "my wire transfer has been pending for multiple [days/weeks/months] and still hasn't been deposited" complaints I've read on Reddit or the Coinbase forums, so it could be that I'm an unusual case vs. the norm.
A true digital cash transaction would only need communication between the two parties involved, rather than a working connection to a third entity.
What cryptos do you believe have solved these problems?
The code was forked to create the Steem blogging platform, and now EOS is in development to essentially back Ethereum-like smart contracts with the DPoS model.
Ethereum is trusted, and Vitalik is a great project leader. If they can solve distributed smart contracts with his new plans, that would be huge. For now, it seems like the middle ground is where it's at.
NEO, for example uses dBFT consensus (which is a type of dPoS), and trades off availability for consistency (the opposite of Bitcoin). It has a block time of about 20 seconds and can do thousands of transactions per second.
IOTA, uses a block DAG (which it calls Tangle) instead of a chain, and uses a novel PoW mechanism to validate transactions that allows for parallelism, and it's throughput grows with the size of the network. (I don't know what you mean by "isn't even real cryptography.")
There is a huge amount of research in this area, and some of the ideas coming out are really interesting (from a distributed consensus perspective.)
(/me worked on paxos-based consensus systems for a decade.)
But all the speculation right now cares about none of that. They only care about optimizing how quickly people can be convinced to throw money at the coin. They don't need to do the math right, they just need it to sound right. IOTA is a prime example.
IOTA does cryptography like a literal cargo cult does aviation. They just went through the motions without understanding what they're doing. They rolled their own hash function, in ternary for some dumb reason. It turned out to be vulnerable to attacks known for decades the moment a cryptographer looked at it. The spin they've come up with after that indicates that they don't fundamentally understand why not to roll your own crypto, especially not a hash function.
They are amateurs, screwing around. Any research you've read in distributed consensus, I guarantee you that the IOTA team doesn't understand it.
The fact that you included IOTA in your list undermines the credibility of your entire list, and makes me at least think that you haven't applied your expertise in consensus systems to looking at what these coins actually do.
More information: https://www.media.mit.edu/posts/iota-response/
Sure, right now bitcoin is not a good day-to-day currency because of high transaction fees and slow verification speeds. But there are new altcoins that have solved both of these, that exist right now!
The real win for cryptocurrencies, in my opinion, is that it's public-key internet money, while debit cards are private-key internet money. With debit cards, you have to give someone your private key (16 digit combo+exp date+security code) in order to transact. Giving away your private key is prone to fraud, and the fraud-protection mechanism is to give a centralized authority access to everything you've ever purchased, and they look for anything "suspicious". On the other hand, with public-key money, when you give someone funds, there's no risk of them exposing you to fraud or unwanted transactions afterwards. Even though I understood the public-key mechanism for bitcoin early on, I didn't realize the full implications for the financial system until recently.