News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by supreme_sublime on Monday January 08, 2018 @11:48AM (#16097951)
Why not both? Why can't we have strong border security and legalize drugs? I'm hoping with the recent Sessions announcement that he will be enforcing federal law in states where marijuana is "legal" that will put pressure on congress to legalize it. Or at least repeal all federal laws on it and truly leave it up to the states.

This is a pretty good short video about how building a wall can help Mexicans. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VLv8Z6bsI24

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by dang on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:32PM (#16098687)
It looks like you've been using HN primarily for ideological and political arguments. That's actually an abuse of the site, and we eventually ban accounts that do it. See https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

HN's core value is intellectual curiosity. That's the first casualty in ideological battle—actually it evaporates before the battle even begins—so we have to be proactive about this. If you'd please read the site guidelines and also https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html and take the spirit of this site to heart, we'd appreciate it.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by supreme_sublime on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:18PM (#16099256)
Ah, I was afraid of this. I wasn't really intending on starting flame wars or anything. They are just the posts I feel I have something to add. I'll attempt to diversify my comments.
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by wooter on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:21PM (#16099302)
reading through your history there is an obvious bias in who you choose to say this to based on your personal ideology. not to mention your various strictly ideological and political submissions. disappointing as that seems like an abuse of the guidelines and your power.
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by dang on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:58PM (#16099793)
People's image of HN mods' political bias is entirely predictable from their own ideological affiliation. Strong rightists think we (and HN itself) lean left, strong leftists think we (and HN) lean right. Since the conclusions you all draw are so contradictory, I don't think these charges have much informational value—at least not about us. There's clearly a cognitive bias at work here.

If you don't believe me, here are some quite typical posts that run the contrary direction to yours:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16019694

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15307091

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15034119

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14529468

These people are having the same reaction as you are, they just start from the opposite end of the football field.

That doesn't mean we're magic centrists in a centrist fairyland. It means the situation is affected by other factors, some of which aren't obvious. If you want to look at this objectively you have to work to suspend your own political feelings, which is not easy to do and not something many people want to.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by wooter on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:17PM (#16100004)
this isn't a mathematical proof. a few counter-examples are easy to create. i looked pretty comprehensively at your history and i think the bias is beyond obvious.

> If you want to look at this objectively you have to work to suspend your own political feelings, which is not easy to do and not something many people want to.

And something I think you have failed at doing. (As you believe of me, so I guess agree to disagree.) However, you are the one bringing it up in a moralistic and pedantic way from a position of power as a moderator.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by mythrwy on Monday January 08, 2018 @06:40PM (#16102033)
LOL. You guys do an excellent job overall but you are in tech in the Bay Area no? An area where gravity is different and the poles are reversed. Where whirlpools spin backwards. An area unlike any other. In an international industry filled with young, intelligent, usually college educated people.

And, if the above is correct it's totally fine. Almost every community will have a majority opinion and the cool part is that the staff at HN doesn't let it get too far out of control. And I have seen posts complaining about large numbers of "fascists" on HN for instance which blew my mind, but apparently it is largely a matter of perspective.

Incidentally, I keep saying this and people don't apparently agree, but not everything fits neatly in boxes of left and right. My belief is that people who are really thinking will find, given time that they don't eternally fit neatly in either category.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by javajosh on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:21PM (#16098223)
Both good suggestions. Personally, I wouldn't mind leaving legalization up to the states, similar to gambling.

The problem with increased border security is, in my view, is that big federal security apparatuses (apparati?) are security contractor cash-cows engaged in security theater. The DHS in general and the TSA in particular are cases in point. In other words, I don't think government should be a meat-grinder into which you feed people you don't like. a) false positives are far too frequent, and b) literally no-one deserves to be put into "the system" as it stands. Maybe if the justice system were reformed, maybe if politicians (particularly the GOP) showed some adherence to actual values instead of tribal, angry populism, I could get behind that.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by supreme_sublime on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:52PM (#16098430)
In general I agree, especially with the TSA. I'm not a fan of the amount of foreign intervention we do. Such as in Syria, it is sad to see how terrible things are there, but I have no idea how it is of any strategic importance to our country. I'd much rather we just let Russia do as they see fit considering it is much more in their interest to stabilize the region than it is ours. It is akin to Russia intervening in Venezuela.

That said, borders are what makes a country. If you cannot do something so basic as controlling who comes into your country, it would be pretty difficult to call yourself a sovereign nation. So I think that should be a much higher priority in terms of national defense than interfering in conflicts thousands of miles away.

Since I'm quite libertarian, I'm not a huge fan of government action in general. However, I do see a role for government and defending the borders of the country from foreign invasion (which is essentially what illegal immigration is) should be the government's highest priority as it is the most basic role of government.

While it has become a meme, building a wall, at least along the easiest places to cross, would make the job for our border guards much easier. It would also have maintenance costs, but if we do it right it very well could be worth it in the long run. Especially if you take into consideration how many government resources illegal immigrants take away from the rest of the population.

A little anecdote I saw a while back during the "immigrant day of absence" to show how necessary "immigrants" (that term is very muddied since people insist on lumping legal and illegal immigrants into the same bucket) are a lot of kids didn't show up for school. A teacher tweeted about it saying how much easier class was that day because of how many fewer students there were to teach. So to some people that day had the opposite effect as to what was intended by the organizers.

Anyway, no other country on the face of the planet are as courteous and welcoming as the US is to people who aren't in their borders legally. I do not see us owing them anything, and while they do have certain rights, we shouldn't treat them like cockroaches, they have broken our laws and should be dealt with in the same way we would deal with any of our own citizens who would break the law. In addition to being deported at the end of their confinement.

As for criminal justice reformation, I more or less agree, depending on what you are referring to since that's quite the broad statement. Ending the war on drugs would be a great thing. But I see a lot of our problems to be more societal and stemming from illegitimate children, fatherless homes, than any other single source.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by dpc59 on Monday January 08, 2018 @09:12PM (#16102940)
> I have no idea how it is of any strategic importance to our country

It is of strategic importance because Assad was about to start selling oil in another currency than the USD. The moment the USD stops being the main oil trade currency the monetary bubble will explode just as it did in the late 60s (after which the current petrodollar system was instituted) and america won't be able to run on printing money anymore.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by notfromhere on Monday January 08, 2018 @11:55AM (#16098010)
Congress is going to do diddly squat about legalization while the GOP runs the place.
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by briandear on Monday January 08, 2018 @03:14PM (#16099972)
Let's be fair here. How much did Democrats do when they controlled the House, Senate and White House?

These arguments are popular when someone's preferred party is out of power, but reality is that there is a bipartisan opposition and bipartisan support for legalization. About 28% of Democrats oppose legalization, while 30% of Republicans support legalization. The numbers are actually fascinating. [1]

For example, Hillary Clinton was all over the 1994 crime bill that her husband signed into law -- with a Democrat Congress (Republicans didn't actually take the majority until Jan 1995 after sweeping the 1994 midterm elections.[2] She promoted the law, she supported it. She even famously called African American young men "super predators" -- while stumping for Bill Clinton on the 1996 campaign trail. That super predators line came when Hillary was trumpeting the success of the 1994 crime bill. [3]

So to imply that "Congress is going to do diddly squat about legalization while the GOP runs the place" -- that's intellectually dishonest.

And the reason I mention Hillary Clinton is because the implication with these sorts of comments is that Democrats would legalize if Trump and the GOP weren't in power. Since Hillary was the alternative, her background is very relevant.

[1] http://iop.harvard.edu/survey/details/political-issue-mariju... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/apr/15/bill-c... [3] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/aug/...

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by notfromhere on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:23PM (#16101321)
Dems haven't had a filibuster-proof majority in decades, and spent all their capital during the obama years on healthcare reform. Legal weed wasn't happening back then.

If Clinton was president, they would have most likely kept the Obama-era policy rather than reverse it after multiple states voted for legalization

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by cryptonector on Monday January 08, 2018 @12:44PM (#16098384)
You say that. I'm not so sure, and I'll make no predictions. But when the Republican Congress decriminalizes marijuana ahead of the mid-terms, I'll be back to check what you have to say then. I think these guys have the power to think outside the box and surprise you.

I agree with grandparent that Sessions' action will tend to increase pressure for federal decrim., and that might even be Sessions' (and/or President Trump's) goal.

What would the effect of Federal decriminalization be on the mid-terms? Don't you think it would help Republicans? Do you think they don't think so? Of course they think so.

I don't know if it will pass, but my guess is that a reasonable bill would decriminalize marijuana possession and trade, but would keep it illegal for interstate commerce (this would be a sop to those States that want to keep it criminalized). Sort of like the 21st Amendment, but as a statute. Such a compromise would help Republicans in States where legalization is popular and... would not hurt them in States where it is not. It would also help with the federalist types.

This should all be blindingly obvious. The only reason I wouldn't make a prediction is that Republicans sure know how to shoot their feet off.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by wfo on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:44PM (#16098798)
The theory that a party that has consistently screamed bloody murder for the last 60 years about anything that even smells like toning down the war on drugs or carceral state is somehow playing 1000 dimensional political chess and cracking down on drugs because of their secret plan to legalize them is... well, how do I put this... wildly speculative?

Do you think your theory is really more likely than this being Sessions simply doing exactly what he's explicitly said he has wanted to do every single moment of his entire adult life, crack down on people who use pot?

Crushing states where pot is legal will lose them the most heavily blue seats that they would never win anyway, but why should they care? It will give their base what they say they want whenever you ask them, the thing that they want most, that drives them to the polls. It is an assault in a culture war against the smug, pot-smoking coastal elites and despised pot-smoking minorities, hippies, college kids. Perhaps they see the drug war for what it is, for how it was designed: not a war on drugs, but a war on the demographic groups of people who tend to use them. And that's why they support it.

At best, I'd see them allowing a vote on it then let their vulnerable reps in purple/blue states vote yes but make sure it fails anyway: "I'm on your side, I promise, see, I tried".

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by throwawayjava on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:38PM (#16098742)
> But when the Republican Congress decriminalizes marijuana ahead of the mid-terms

With what votes, and what leadership?

The entirety of the GOP house leadership opposes any form of legal cannabis. Messer, the policy committee chair, even opposes medical cannabis for vets prescribed by their VA doctor and residing in states where medical cannabis is legal.

Concretely, which GOP representatives do you think will vote for decriminalization? I'm incredulous, but curious to hear a rational argument that this is a remotely reasonable expectation.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by cryptonector on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:33PM (#16099488)
I can't make a "rational argument" about what people I don't know might do. I am saying that it's very much in their interest and that I would not be surprised if they do it. How about we check in here again when it happens / fails to happen?
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by anigbrowl on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:31PM (#16101407)
Just because they have a rational interest tells you nothing about the probability. It's a little rude to throw out a bold claim ('when the Republican Congress decriminalizes marijuana ahead of the mid-terms' as if that were highly probable) and then suggest tabling the discussion when you get refuted.

Sure, if you think they should do it, totally valid opinion. Talking as they are going to implies knowing something that everyone else doesn't, which is why you're being challenged about it.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by dpc59 on Monday January 08, 2018 @09:05PM (#16102884)
You could say I'd have a rational interest in becoming a doctor because I'd stand to make on average 300k a year. I won't do it for other reasons which aren't pondered.

It's easy to make something look rational when you pick and choose axioms. The republicans don't have a rational interest in decriminalization because their financial backers don't want it, and they have moral qualms about it since 100 years of government lies convinced them it's the devil's plant.

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by stephenboyd on Monday January 08, 2018 @01:35PM (#16098711)
There are already walls at the border where it makes sense. Do you want a wall separating Texas from the Rio Grande?
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by supreme_sublime on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:15PM (#16099224)
What I've seen are short fences at best. Barely enough to stop a paraplegic. Gates are possible to build, not to mention a lot of the Rio Grande wouldn't need anything built near it because of the natural geography and the sheer cliffs that are practically unscalable.
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by toomanybeersies on Monday January 08, 2018 @11:59AM (#16098045)
Has anyone done a survey to determine if there's broad congressional support for the legalization of cannabis?
Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by zolthrowaway on Monday January 08, 2018 @02:54PM (#16099756)
Yes. Gallup does this ever year. It's been over 60% for the last two years[1].

[1] http://news.gallup.com/poll/221018/record-high-support-legal...

Re:Losing Faith in the State, Some Mexican Towns Quietly Bre... by mastax on Monday January 08, 2018 @05:44PM (#16101506)
American support for legalization != congressional support for legalization, see https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/09/29/meet-...