News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by danschumann on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @05:18PM (#16065819)
The problem with hate speech laws are, it means you can't insult everyone equally. If you call someone stupid, they could accuse you of a crime, but you're not calling them stupid because of their race.

And I want people who actually are racist to talk, so I know who I don't want to be friends with. If they're all keeping their racist opinions to themselves, I might waste a bunch of time being their friends. And I can't correct them when they're wrong if they don't expose their opinions.

And what about having an argument? Someone could accuse you of a crime if they misinterpret what you say. That's the real problem here. You can say something with no hateful intent, but people can interpret it with vigorous hate. It's a really stupid law.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by King-Aaron on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:08PM (#16067963)
> If they're all keeping their racist opinions to themselves, I might waste a bunch of time being their friends

I have several friends who I know hold some less-than-sociable opinions, and they do tend to keep them to themselves.

I don't quite know how to frame what I'm about to say, but I feel it's equally dickish to think that becoming someone's friend is a "waste of time" just because you don't agree with their opinion.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by Tactic on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:02AM (#16071344)
To be fair being racist is more than an opinion, it demonstrates your character. It reveals part of who you are and the framework with which you deal with the world. I agree that it is valuable knowledge in determining who you want to create lasting bonds with.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by gspetr on Saturday January 06, 2018 @01:15AM (#16084118)
I'll agree with the latter assertion (framework), but not with the former (character). People tend to default to conformism when they don't know any better.

By that standard the older the man, the worse he is and you'll arrive at the conclusion that nearly everyone flawed character in the olden days when racism was mainstream.

But we need not even go any further than Charles Darwin:

"The variability or diversity of the mental faculties in men of the same race, not to mention the greater differences between the men of distinct races, is so notorious that not a word need here be said."

"Nor is the difference slight in moral disposition between a barbarian, such as the man described by the old navigator Byron, who dashed his child on the rocks for dropping a basket of sea urchins, and a Howard or Clarkson; and in intellect, between a savage who uses hardly any abstract terms, and a Newton or Shakspeare. Differences of this kind between the highest men of the highest races and the lowest savages, are connected by the finest graduations."

http://heretical.com/darwin/darwin4.html

Sources cited at the bottom of that page.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by tuxxy on Thursday January 04, 2018 @04:32AM (#16069033)
I don't think that not wanting to be friends with someone because they want your kids to die for being Jewish is necessarily a dickish thing.

It's an extreme example, yet an unfortunate practical one today.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by raisspen on Thursday January 04, 2018 @06:21AM (#16069485)
Or you could take the route which others have taken, and show them why their ideas are wrong through your actions. There are plenty of examples of extremists being converted through friendship.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by zimpenfish on Thursday January 04, 2018 @06:50AM (#16069638)
> There are plenty of examples of extremists being converted through friendship.

But equally there are plenty of examples of extremists killing people who are trying to show them why their ideas are wrong.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by kadenshep on Thursday January 04, 2018 @04:38PM (#16074302)
>and show them why their ideas are wrong through your actions.

Why are you assuming these people are rational actors?

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by gurkendoktor on Thursday January 04, 2018 @05:23PM (#16074656)
They don't need to be rational for it to work. They can both either become more rational over time, or you can influence them in irrational ways. Both often go together hand-in-hand in good diplomacy (e.g. letting the other save face even if they don't "deserve it").
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by sattoshi on Thursday January 04, 2018 @03:32PM (#16073793)
Trudeau? Is that you?
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by mc32 on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:21PM (#16068016)
I think there is something to the idea of "safety valve". That is allow some venting in order to prevent full-blown animus.

However, the difficult part is two-fold. One how to define the line of unacceptability (for example, calling for actionable violence against someone) and how to enforce that line and keep it steadfast (unwavering in the face of both antagonists --the ones for more control as well as the absolutists).

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by labster on Thursday January 04, 2018 @12:02AM (#16068174)
The internet is a terrible safety valve to vent at, because it's too easy to pretend what you say doesn't have consequences. One tweet by a dude having a bad day can help normalize stereotyping to 50 people. And there's always that other guy who takes things too far.

I know that people might intend Twitter or blogs to be for friends, but it's mass media nonetheless.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by mc32 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @12:09AM (#16068192)
See, philosophically stereotyping doesn't have to be a "bad thing". When I went to school there we "polack" jokes, blond/e jokes, yo mamma jokes, etc. They were not "mean" or meant to denigrate people. They were ways to "break the ice" as it were. But nowadays people are super sensitive, unless it's a majority or almost majority population, or it has power, unless it has power but it's also seen as being singled out by another more powerful player... it's become tragically political.

I know some foreign parents who have a preference for their home country and will tell their kids that <some thing> from their home country is better than <same thing> from neighboring but "rival" country. In a way this is stereotyping --but I'm seeing you say these parents should not talk to their kids about having some favoritism to their home country because this kind of connection building can "stereotype" the people from their (ancestral) neighboring country.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by jsjohnst on Thursday January 04, 2018 @09:24AM (#16070467)
> They were not "mean" or meant to denigrate people.

I don’t know how things were where you lived, but where I grew up, those types of jokes were definitely meant to be mean and hurtful. I speak from experience when I say that the repeated mental abuse from peers taken as a child can have long term effects on one’s psyche.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by Pica_soO on Thursday January 04, 2018 @02:54PM (#16073461)
The old tradition of mammals to kick one in the group - usually the social weakest- to feed him to the wulfs. By now we are the wulfs - and still they kick.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by averagewall on Thursday January 04, 2018 @02:46AM (#16068667)
Sure, that kind of stereotyping by parents teaching their children to be bigots is probably harmful overall! Harmful neighbor country rivalries last centuries, probably because of just this kind of reinforcement. Then every now and then you get a Kosovo or a holocaust.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by mc32 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @12:06PM (#16071945)
I think those are misattributions. Civil wars break out both among same ethnic groups as well as different ethnic groups.

Wars can then force people to see other stereotypes as characteristics of bad things. Kind of like the caricatures of Nazis and Japanese Imperialists. When Japan went into Nanking, they didn't need some psychological trick to enable them to go on their campaign any more than the US or USSR needed psychological tricks to bomb Dresden or East Berlin.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by wernercd on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:07PM (#16067961)
> I want people who actually are racist to talk, so I know who I don't want to be friends with.

It's more important and wide than "I don't want to be their friends"...

How can you attack ideas if they aren't brought out into the open? How can you convince the racist? Or the people that have those thoughts but don't mention them?

They corner stone of freedom is discussing ideas.

I want the most vile pieces of shit to have their chance to speak... so that I can talk to them. I can talk to those who will listen. I will combat their ideas.

Cowards hide from ideas and words. It takes strength to fight them head on and out in the open.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by BearGoesChirp on Thursday January 04, 2018 @09:29AM (#16070501)
There is also issues with what is discriminatory/hateful language.

If I point out that the vast majority of criminals are men, that is simple fact. If I suggest it might be because of something related to being male, few would call that hate speech and few would bring up alternatives such as bias in the legal system. Only when I get to the point of saying all males should be treated as criminals will I get significant push back of people saying that I'm wrong.

Now, replace gender with some other demographic, and people become much more hostile to my points, and I am considered to be dancing much closer to the line of hate speech.

What about if I have legitimate criticism? There are many legitimate criticisms of some sects of different religions. If I happen to speak to broadly, say using Christian or Protestant when I'm really talking about Calvinist, should that really count as hate speech? Or should someone ask if I'm really generalizing the larger group and give me a chance to qualify which subsection I'm speaking about?

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by fao_ on Thursday January 04, 2018 @01:11AM (#16068403)
> I want the most vile pieces of shit to have their chance to speak... so that I can talk to them. I can talk to those who will listen. I will combat their ideas.

While this idea is admirable, fascist/Nazi dialogue has shown again and again that fascists are not interested in "fair" debate. All they want is a larger audience so they can pass on their views -- and look at America. Do you really think that the hundreds of thousands of people debating Richard Spencer[0], Steve Bannon[1] and Milo Yiannopoulos[2] has stopped the spread?

No! In fact, it has enabled them to spread their sources of propaganda further into the world. Now even centrist friends of mine are linking to Breitbart as if it is a valid source of information[3]. Some viruses and infections you can only kill through isolation. Fascism is one of them.

[0]: In case that you have any doubt that Spencer is a Nazi:

  Instead of asking how we can make reparations for slavery, colonialism, and 
  Apartheid or how we can equalize academic scores and incomes, we should
  instead be asking questions like, "Does human civilization actually need the
  Black race?" "Is Black genocide right?" and, if it is, "What would be
  the best and easiest way to dispose of them?" With starting points
  like this, wisdom is sure to flourish, enlightenment to dawn.
  -- Richard Spencer, "Is Black Genocide Right?" (2012)
(https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Richard_Spencer)

[1]: Bannon has voiced support for UKIP and Front National. The former is an close offshoot of Britain First, one of whom murdered a British politician a year or so ago (He had a golden eagle statue and a shrine to Nazi literature). The latter was literally founded by a member of the SS, Pierre Bousquet. FN has also been known to murder French politicians. (https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Steve_Bannon)

[2]: https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Milo_Yiannopoulos

[3]: https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Breitbart.com

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by baud147258 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:37AM (#16071655)
> FN has also been known to murder French politicians.

Do you have any sources on that? With all the things the media in France is saying about the FN, I don't think they would have missed something so important.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by fao_ on Thursday January 04, 2018 @05:22PM (#16074643)
> https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Front_National

  Nevertheless, and notwithstanding the racist
  murders committed by some members (see Brahim
  Bouarram thrown in the Seine, and Ibrahim Ali,
  shot), the FN continued its progress and even
  managed to gain some towns in 1995, such as
  Toulon and Orange, where, once more, such mayors
  managed to show their crass incompetence[3] and
  got booted in 2001 by the electors.
Source for Brahim Bouarram mentioning FN: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/05/paris-crowds-gather-m...

  On May 1, 1995, skinheads rallying with the
  far-right National Front (FN) threw Brahim
  Bouarram, a 29-year-old Frenchman of Moroccan
  descent, into the River Seine and disappeared
  into the crowds. [...] At the time of Bouarram's
  death, Jean-Marie Le Pen described the incident
  as "minor". [...] "The FN is an anti-Semitic,
  racist, xenophobic party," said Abdallah, also of
  the ATMF. "The normalisation of the ideas of the
  NF is worrying us. Even more so, it scares us
  that a large proportion of the army, gendarmerie
  and police vote for Marine Le Pen. We are scared
  for our kids who have brown, black and Arab faces
  when they get stopped by the police."

Source for Ibrahim Ali mentioning FN: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Ibrahim_Ali

Root Source for Ibrahim Ali mentioning FN: https://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/20/france-shooting-a...

  [Ibrahim Ali] was walking with a group of ten
  other young men in Marseilles' XVth
  arrondissement, when they encountered three
  supporters of Jean-Marie Le Pen's Front National
  party, armed with guns, who had been posting
  campaign signs nearby. The latter group opened
  fire on them. Ibrahim Ali was shot in the back.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by baud147258 on Friday January 05, 2018 @03:57AM (#16077450)
Thank you for your answer.

That could be constructed as racist hate crime by party "supporters" (not even members), and could have nothing to do with the party itself. On the other hand, since it align with the party's ideology, it can be said that the FN has a part in it.

But I don't see how it shows that the FN has murdered any politicians, which was what I was asking about

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by fao_ on Sunday January 07, 2018 @05:51PM (#16093214)
> That could be constructed as racist hate crime by party "supporters" (not even members), and could have nothing to do with the party itself. On the other hand, since it align with the party's ideology, it can be said that the FN has a part in it.

If your political party is inspiring murders, the party is at fault for that.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by Retra on Thursday January 04, 2018 @03:24AM (#16068771)
>How can you attack ideas if they aren't brought out into the open?

You attack ideas by suffocating them, not by repeating them. Children learn words by hearing them spoken. Nothing more needs to happen; the brain is quite good at drawing the intended implications out. To promote an idea, you need only put it in people's heads over and over again.

The major problem with hate speech laws is trying to separate propaganda from education or intellectual discussion from dogmatic bigotry. It is trivial to mask one as the other and vice versa. And while an honest and critical person can make a good distinction in narrow contexts, nobody has been able to do it effectively on a cultural scale.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by InternetUser on Thursday January 04, 2018 @05:00AM (#16069134)
> To promote an idea, you need only put it in people's heads over and over again.

As a voracious consumer of news, I spent hundreds of hours from summer 2015 to November 2016 having my mind exposed to headlines, articles, images, and videos on TV (both on TV news programs and late-night comedy shows), and on news websites (NYT, WaPo, Yahoo, MSN), and on social media (in 'Trending' sidebars of Facebook and Twitter) telling me that Trump is a crazy, racist, misogynistic, fascist maniacal idiot who is totally unqualified to be president, and whom "everyone" hates except for white racists and uneducated rednecks. Well, it didn't convince me, and didn't convince a majority of voters in 30 other states. That being said, I'm very open to consuming just as much anti-Trump and pro-Democrat content as soon as the Democratic primary begins in early 2019, or even before then. Maybe I can be persuaded that time around.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @06:47PM (#16066635)
> The problem with hate speech laws are, it means you can't insult everyone equally.

As far as I can tell, that's not true of the German law in question, though if you think it is true of that law (not some abstract hypothetical “hate speech” law straw man), please explain how, citing the relevant provisions of the law and explaining how they produce the unequal results that concern you.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by hateduser2 on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:24PM (#16067794)
There are lots of quotes in the OP article that side with GP. Without having done research myself I think it’s plausibly true and the article is full of quotes that suggest this is the case. Your tone is hostile and that makes me disinclined to take your view. Overall I would side with GP over you and I’d hope other users who haven’t done research themselves would too. Don’t let your biases inform your opinions!
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by yorwba on Thursday January 04, 2018 @12:36AM (#16068295)
There are actually several different laws involved here. The newest one is the NetzDG [1] (network enforcement act), that requires all reports of illegal content to be checked within 24 hours. The incentive structure is messed up because there are fines for failure to delete illegal content, but none for unjustified deletion. So the barrier was shifted from "obviously illegal" to "not obviously legal". The quotes in the Reuters article are all about that aspect of the law and of Twitter's enforcement.

The other laws that are involved here have been essentially unchanged for a long time and are not really controversial. They are just a bit more subtle than a random Twitter censor is going to appreciate, because they are intended for consideration by a judge. Under these laws, you can absolutely insult everyone equally, and Volksverhetzung is equally illegal, no matter which group it is directed against.

Edit: [1] The German text of the NetzDG is here: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/netzdg/BJNR335210017.html

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by kadenshep on Thursday January 04, 2018 @04:41PM (#16074332)
>Your tone is hostile and that makes me disinclined to take your view.

>Don’t let your biases inform your opinions!

These are not complimentary positions, they're pretty exclusive of each other. Methinks you just wanted to take the high ground with some generic platitude and misdirect the conversation.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by hateduser2 on Friday January 05, 2018 @02:09AM (#16077099)
They can’t be exclusive of each other if I successfully hold both at once
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by kadenshep on Tuesday January 09, 2018 @01:22PM (#16108407)
Yes they most certainly can and are.
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by echlebek on Thursday January 04, 2018 @01:25AM (#16068450)
This is not true. Hate speech laws are designed to address speech that promotes violence against identifiable groups of people.

For example, Canada's hate speech law: http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/page-73.html#h-...

Section 318 says that you can't incite genocide. Fair enough right?

Section 319 says that you can't say things that willfully promotes hatred against an identifiable group. (Unless those things happen to be true, or even if you reasonably believed them to be true. Or if it was a private conversation. Or the things you're saying are in the public interest.)

This means it's actually really hard to convict someone of hate speech, at least in Canada. Under section 318, you have to get the governor general's approval to even bring the case.

I can't comment on the German law since I don't know German, but I'd imagine it's similar in nature.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by soziawa on Thursday January 04, 2018 @06:44AM (#16069605)
> I can't comment on the German law since I don't know German, but I'd imagine it's similar in nature.

Not at all. This forces Twitter to remove things that could be hate speech within 24 hours or face a fine. If they remove things that are not hate speech for being hate speech they don't get a fine. Of course they'll remove as many things as possible. That's the problem with the new german law.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by InternetUser on Thursday January 04, 2018 @05:06AM (#16069162)
I have been and still am friends with people who have all sorts of prejudiced views, ranging from those who hate particular ethnic groups and nationalities (including my own), to those who disparage and insult those with different interests of educational backgrounds (such as one friend who is an I.T. guy and who constantly refers to non-I.T. people, even within his own family in shocking misanthropistic terms). Everyone has their own views, and I believe in acceptance. If someone expresses or suggests violent impulses, that is one thing, but to just express hatred is part of humanity. Do you hate anyone? To turn it around, there are plenty of people who hate themselves, but are all of them physically masochistic and/or suicidal?
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by kikimaru on Thursday January 04, 2018 @05:59AM (#16069368)
Is it "fucking USERS, man"?
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by InternetUser on Friday January 05, 2018 @01:27AM (#16076962)
Is that a movie quote or something?
Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by Mithaldu on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @06:11PM (#16066363)
> I want people who actually are racist to talk, so I know who I don't want to be friends with.

I keep seeing this statement, but all i can think is:

Fuck, i wish i was lucky enough to have so few racists around me to be able to think i can spare the time and mental health for additional ones.

Good for you, be glad you apparently have few to none racists around you, so you don't know what it's like when there's tons of them and they all talk unhindered.

Edit: LMAO, i do wonder what kind of people i managed to upset with this.

Re:German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire ac... by Mithaldu on Thursday January 04, 2018 @03:52PM (#16073978)
Small note here: I was told the above reads like sarcasm, and i'd like to state that the lines above the edit are 100% not sarcastic and meant exactly as stated.