https://qz.com/1125690/big-pharma-is-taking-advantage-of-pat...
http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/outdated-treatments-and-dr...
The solution is to make cannabis legal for everybody in every state for medical use and since it cannot be patented there will be many suppliers who compete with the quality and price just like it happens with almost everything that is not under very strict government regulation.
I'm from the Netherlands so you won't hear me disagree with the argument that criminalizing cannabis and drugs is not the solution[0].
Having said that, the typical undertone on HN of "regulation is bad by definition" really irks me. I can imagine that if the only perspective one has is a dysfunctional government, one might think that, but please take a look abroad and see how things work over there. Government regulations are a tool that can be used for good and bad.
[0] Also, in the US these laws are historically very much set up to target poor and black people (and I wish I had a clear picture of how things are in my own country regarding that, actually; I'm sure there's a few laws sneakily screwing over migrant workers or something), but I digress.
That $5 billion advertising spend is going to get paid for elsewhere in the health industry ecosystem, and probably several times over once all of the associated costs are considered.
There's also all of the various forms of pharmaceutical marketing aimed at doctors (with figures around $22 billion per year) and incentives for prescriptions (https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/03/17/4706794...).
I wonder some days just how much economic damage will have to be done, just how many millions of lives will need to be ruined, before the American public starts to accept that unregulated capitalism is dangerous in almost every market.
Perhaps it's just the separation of government in general. People can only pay attention to so much and the attraction of national politics pulls attention away from state politics. That's just not something that happens in many other places.
It's the worst of both worlds, where states have a flaccid independence (they can legislate but not control their borders, thus cannot avoid the free-rider problem). Nation-wide standards that don't fall under the commerce clause have to be bribed into half-ass existence, and then only for a political season.
We're structurally incapable of benefiting from economies of scale or standardization in government.
> larger federal government
I find both of these positions frustratingly vague, and I'm eager to blame them for making the problem appear intractable. They're perfectly intuitive enough to make people have a gut-feeling for what it means without actually thinking about what it means, and in that sense avoid actually debating that, which would be productive.
What does "large" and "small" even mean? Governments are complex social/cultural/legal systems, no matter what the "size". I'm pretty sure waterbed theory applies here[0].
(This is not a critique of your post, but about the US discourse surrounding this in general. At least how it comes across to me as a European)
[0] "the observation, ascribed to Larry Wall, that some systems, such as human and computer languages, contain a minimum amount of complexity, and that attempting to "push down" the complexity of such a system in one place will invariably cause complexity to "pop up" elsewhere.",
Transit is almost entirely publicly owned and operated in the U.S. For example, Amtrak is both owned and operated by the government. In contrast, Deutsche Bahn and Eurostar are are private companies (though subsidized by the government). SNCF, though owned by the government, is run like a private company. E.g. in contrast to Amtrak, where only a single route produces an operating profit, 80% of SNCF's routes produce an operating profit. Japan's key railroads are privatized, and the biggest one (JR East) receives no public subsidy.
Anti-development housing policies that drive up prices are all done by the government (compare to Japan's lax zoning laws).
Healthcare is really the only thing that's more privatized in the U.S. versus other OECD countries, though it's less than you might think. About 50% of healthcare spending in the U.S. comes from direct public money, comparable to Korea, versus 70% in Canada or Spain, and 75-85% in Italy, Germany, France, and the U.K. However, if you account for indirect expenditures (public subsidies for health insurance), the total comes to about 65%, not much less than in Canada or Spain: http://www.pnhp.org/news/2016/january/government-funds-nearl....
I think you just notice that undertone more because of your predisposition. I notice just as many pro regulation as anti regulation comments, and I think of myself as a capitalism moderate (since there are negative externalities that do not get included in the price, regulations act as corrective measures to move markets slightly in the direction they would be if those were included correctly, at least when done well).
Mea culpa, I blame negativity bias[0]. US-centric thinking annoys me in a "don't be short-sighted" way (Eurocentric thinking too, but I have more blind spots there), and as a European, the "neutral" position for regulation is probably far more on the regulation side of things (just like how the "neutral" political leaning being very left compared to the US, for that matter).
I also suspect that hathawsh comment elsewhere is right about discourse taking more extreme positions in general, although I doubt the polarization in the US is the lone cause. Stronger opinions are always more vocal, so it is the nature of the internet, and public discourse in general to show apparent extremities within public opinion[1].
[0] perception bias where negative experiences, which includes annoyances, are given more weight, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negativity_bias
This is pure ancap, "Austrian school" ideology. They define regulation as bad by definition, because supposedly it goes against "freedom". This works as a clutch so that if you say anything bad against capitalism they will retort "it is regulation", even thought nobody ever saw (and never will see) an economic system without laws and regulations.
And because modern economies are to a large part composed of government granted monopolies, with almost all problems being in that part¹, nearly all "capitalism is bad" commentary is simply bullshit.
1 - Both governments tend to grant monopolies on problematic areas, and anything that a government grant a monopoly on becomes problematic. So, it can hardly be different.
Apologies for misinterpreting if this was not your intent, but based on what I just wrote, I don't think it's a stretch to interpret that message as implying that regulation is bad in general.
I wish there'd be some consistency.
there might be a forum for legitimate hackers who are genuinely stymied by government regulation, but HN isn't it, at least not anymore
YC itself isn't much of a change agent anymore either, it has devolved into a private club for people who won in Silicon Valley
I'm pretty sure for medical use, it will more closely resemble ibuprofen or cough medicine if it is without prescription. With prescription it'll be more like generics. It might still be a monopoly, since these drugs have to go through all the FDA testing. Heck, if you want fluoride in your toothpaste you have to go through animal testing - same for menthol in cough drops. I don't know why folks think it should be different for medical cannabis, though some folks will just use their own supply instead.
Outside of medical use, I'll guess it'll be regulated much like alcohol or tobacco. These aren't exactly lightly regulated either, though it is a much easier market to break into.
Besides, there is lots to patent. Hybrid plants, GMO plants, extraction methods for pills. Brands will be a thing, I'd think. And it doesn't mean all the other stuff won't be necessary - pot isn't a cure all, though should be an option in the arsenal. Folks will still make their money, I think.
Opium and poison sumac are plants. Should it be legal to sell both for smoking, or mix them in with other goods entirely unregulated?
https://www.sentencingcouncil.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/Drug...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
When you say "government", I hear "of the people, by the people, for the people".
When you say "regulation", I hear "market protections", eg property rights, fair & impartial courts, rule of law. In other words, no regulation means no market.
My sole notion (so far) for a more fair society is some sort of balance of power, modeled after our constitution (executive vs legislative vs courts), where regulations somehow have a third pillar. So instead of just us vs them, like government vs business, there's a third seat at the table. Like maybe producers, consumers & regulators, where the consumers have equal voice.
It went poorly.
https://archive.org/details/jungle00sinc
The correct response to bad regulation isn't no regulation but GOOD REGULATION.
There have been similar circumstances as concern snake oil, opium, cocaine, radium, asbestos, lead, safety belts, air bags, ABS, screw and nut sizes, fire exits (and suppression equipment, and risk mitigation, and alarms -- look up the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory some time), and Jim Crow, and poll taxes, and "separate but equal", and CFCs, and C02, and ....
But I think I've made my point.
I agree with legalization. And with a freer market for growers and sellers and entrepreneurs.
Our government is plenty sinister too. And government is actually "people".
If there was a free market for drugs (legalization), I suspect we would not be in a crisis.
But some mix of laissez-fair, small-government, complete reliance on decisionmaking at the individual level (except where corporations can impose their preferences over individuals, communities, regions, states, nations, or globally), very strong defences of some kinds of property rights, and an exceptionally high level of un-accounted externalties, seems to capture much the flavour.
What's worse? Morphine flooding a our society as a recreational drug? Think how easily highschoolers can get beer and cigarettes, but with opioids...
But our current approach has lead to the widespread adoption of the cheapest, most concentrated, and most dangerous opioid imaginable: Fentanyl. This which has rapidly become the continent's foremost public health plague as it kills a terrifying number of people every year.
Would freely available morphine or heroin be better?
If not in direct crisis we'd always be on the knife's edge of one.
So legal opioids would presumably mean the same: more abuse, more misuse, but safer and without the cartels.
If this sounds kind of creepy and dictatorial to you, you've got a good head on your shoulders.
This semantic distinction is important because a lot of modern leftist rhetoric about fascism is based on a misinterpretation of the term as used in current academic literature and in Fascist ideology of the 1920s and 30s. A defining feature of fascism is corporatism, but this does not mean the unbridled power of big business corporations and certainly is not a good description of current American society. Rather, it refers to the way that undemocratic systems co-opt the organized associations that represent interest groups ("civil society" in current political science literature). See for example the way that the Chinese Communist party traditionally ran the only trade unions, women's rights organizations, etc. in the country; or the way that the Hitler Youth and the League of German Girls replaced the Scouts and Wandervögel in Nazi Germany; or the way the Italian Fascist regime ran the economy through a council of hand-picked, compliant representatives of employers and workers. In essence, civil society is transformed from a way for groups to band together and advance their interests, into a transmission belt for the state to control those groups.
For more on this topic, including non-Fascist uses of the term, see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporatism
Right up there with socialism, ironically. There needs to be a trendier name for regulatory capture.
This isn't solely a feature of capitalism. Any system is going to devolve into the strong eating the weak unless the strong identify with and have solidarity with the weak.
I have recently become much more willing to listen to ethno-nationalists of all ethnoses based on this realization: stripped of any imperialistic impulse it may be the best way to generate cross class identity in a given political unit. I tend to think size/scale matters as well, perhaps more so, so that the strong are forced into closer quarters with the weak and so that social interactions are iterated, leading to a better stable state.
(Indeed, the ironically-pan-nationalist ethno-nationalism of today is largely foreign to America and is opposed to the consensus of American nationalism developed during and after WW2 and on into the civil rights era... Of course this is a thing that hasn't been entirely resolved.)
It seems like smaller, more homogonous political units is the best way to avoid conflict, and I don't see why that has to be malicious. My main problem with most of the ethno-nationalists that I read is that they are really racialists or pan-europeanists, which strikes me as almost (almost) as useless for generating inter-class solidarity as appealing to universal humanism.
Doesn't the empirical reality of large cosmopolitan cities provide evidence that multiculturalism will work just fine?
New York City, for instance, has 8.5 million people of every race, color, creed, citizenship, language, etc. crammed pretty tightly together. That's more than the population of about 3/4 of US states. It has cultural enclaves - there are places in the city where you'll look and feel out of place if you're not, say, an Orthodox Jew, or black, or of Chinese ancestry, or whatever. (Being none of these, I've been to these places and consciously felt, well, not that I wasn't welcome to visit, but that it was someone else's home and not mine.) But it doesn't have squabbling. There's definitely been ethnic violence in the city's history, but the city generally lives together and works together just fine; it's not more violent or more dangerous than you'd expect any city of its size to be. And places which have had violence (e.g., Crown Heights after the 1991 riot) have worked pretty successfully to find ways of living together that involve neither one cultural group leaving and ceding the area to another, nor any cultural group losing its particular identity.
It seems to me like the american continent, anyway, is large enough to give everyone what they would like, without either interfering with one another politically.
The evidence, as far as I can tell, is that multiculturalism is a perfectly stable approach, and people who say that we need cultural isolation are only saying that because of belief and not evidence. Of course the continent is big enough to support giving people what they want, whether or not they're rational to want it. But to the original topic of how to prevent the strong from taking advantage of the weak, I don't think there's any reason to believe that dividing people by race to force an alliance of each race's strong and weak is going to be successful, or that avoiding multiculturalism is going to be necessary.
I must admit that I have a more pastoral and conflict-adverse personality, so the idea of New York as an ideal is difficult for me to comprehend. I'm OK with that: there are obviously many people to whom this idea is obvious as well. My long term conclusion is we should allow these types of folks to separate and establish different political units that satisfy these needs: some of these could be relatively ethnically homogeneous, some less so. I would expect, but am willing to admit this is speculation, that you would find higher trust and cross-class identity in the more homogeneous political units.
I appreciate you taking the time to thoughtfully reply to my comments.
I still don't get this. I don't think that NYC is a high-conflict place at all. I'm not sure I'd quite call it "pastoral," really, but the outer boroughs are much closer to medium-sized cities in the rest of the US than to Manhattan - houses with yards and garages, strip malls with large parking lots, etc. Sure, there are areas where you're surrounded by skyscrapers and enough bright lights to ensure the city never sleeps. But that's a pretty small part of the residential population of NYC.
Or in other words, I think you'd be perfectly happy living here, given the preferences you've expressed, as long as you didn't live in Manhattan (and not wanting to live in Manhattan far from unusual!). If you find that merely being in a subway car or in line at a store with someone of a different race/culture uncomfortable, maybe NYC isn't the place for you, but I have no reason to believe from your comments that you're that sort of person.
(And you might still prefer rural areas where there are acres of land between you and your closest neighbor - which is fine! I'm not saying that we should cover the world in New York Cities. I'm just saying that it's empirical evidence that multiculturalism is stable, and not just for people who voluntarily choose in adulthood to move to a dense cosmopolitan city.)
I think you're right that there is a lot more informal, self-directed ethnic/cultural affinity than I was selling. But none of that has any level of structure that gets anywhere close to ethno-nationalism, with independent political entities and representation and policy between the ethnic enclaves. There are things like Hatzolah, yes, but there is one NYPD for all neighborhoods. There's one housing policy (and one affordable housing lottery). There's one minimum wage. There's one policy on how much to cooperate with ICE. And so forth. And there's one set of elections for influencing those things. (I would actually argue that there isn't enough political autonomy for the boroughs, but for the reason that smaller political entities are less prone to corruption and more likely to give opportunities for meaningful representation, not because different boroughs have independent and distinct cultures that require different political goals. I don't think we should have, say, two different police departments in Crown Heights for the black and Jewish communities, but I do think the police department in Crown Heights should be a smaller entity - with a smaller budget and smaller political influence - than the NYPD as it is today, possibly a Brooklyn Police Department, possibly even smaller. So I'd agree with your point above regarding size/scale, but I don't think that division on cultural or ethnic grounds is required.)
I'd believe the argument that NYC doesn't offer evidence that people will voluntarily give up ethnic/cultural identities as a way of living day-to-day. But I think it does offer strong evidence that people with these separate identities can be happy, successful, and peaceful with a single government.
I don't think we should let the pendulum swing too far and say "squabbling ethnoses are the inevitable end-point." That is not certain, either. People actually had to work at (spend lots of time and money) making our recent national unity start to turn into squabbling ethnoses. I fail to see why I should make their job easier by granting the inevitability of that outcome.
The second is that in practice this just causes the weak to identify with and have solidarity with the strong, which isn't the direction you want. There's a lot history of public policy in America that's been targeted at getting lower-class "white" people (for whatever the current definition of "white" is) to believe that their self-interest is more aligned with the success of the white race than with the success of the lower class regardless of race. You can see this clearly in the history of things like Bacon's Rebellion, and the establishment of slavery in the US as a racial-superiority thing as a way to avoid a combined revolt by white indentured servants and black slaves against the upper class. But I think you can see the same thing happening in the present day.
By the way, I appreciate you taking the time to thoughtfully respond to my comment. It is difficult to say what I think may be the truth (with, I hope, no maliciousness) in todays environment, so thank you.
People shoot guns. But guns being available is half the problem.
Capitalism has it's unique characteristics when paired with people.
It doesn't intentionally do it, because capitalism isn't a person, but when everything is monetized by our creative entrepreneurs, it grows; our problems being no exception.
Once someone makes money, they want more of it. Capitalism demands more of it. And we stretch every line of the law, even cross it, just to get more from where that came from.
Unfortunately one person suppressing their unethical behavior is inconsequential. If an opportunity exists, eventually someone will use it.