It would be awesome an art historian would look at a bunch of paintings for those defects, or if someone could work out how many portraits are 1:1 scale, like Tim's second "Claire with a Pearl Earring" experiment.
Now imagine that we found a half-burned-down painter's workshop in the countryside, with a bunch of artifacts. Or a woodcut or drawing of a painter's workshop with these devices in use. Those would be very convincing to a critic. But we don't have those.
Hopefully we will find a workshop somewhere with a bunch of photographic equipment and crack this puzzle.
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b0/53/42/b053425982ecb933ca4c...
https://www.easy-drawing-lessons.com/images/xpainter-using-a...
And their existence is part of critic's arguments against the Hockney thesis: many tools have been used in various ways at various times, and there's been little or no shame in acknowledging and documenting it.
To accept Hockney-Falco, you'd have to accept the opposite: that such devices were widespread amongst artists but kept secret or never mentioned. I think Occam's razor suggests that if such devices were commonly used, it wouldn't be so hard to find evidence of it.
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2000/01/31/the-looking-gl...
It looks like the article preceded publication of Hockney's book and originated at a time when he was still rehearsing and refining his argument.
His main antagonists in the article are the art historians who come off a bit like stuffy reactionaries. I was firmly in Hockney's camp by the time I had finished the article. It was one of those ideas that changed the way I look at the world slightly.
Never read the book. Tim's Vermeer was the coup de grace for me and I was gratified to see Hockney make a cameo in it.
There's virtually no discussion of the design of Vermeer's paintings, which was elaborate to say the very least. I was so hopeful that time would apply his technique to some other subject, but it stays almost myopically focused on the rendering process.
http://www.sonyclassics.com/timsvermeer/