Re:Hockney–Falco thesis
by greglindahl on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @11:42PM
(#16012877)
Those aren't images of the tools that Tim used. And I totally agree that the tools used by Tim aren't found in middens or descriptions or drawings. Occam's Razor does apply, but, it leaves me wondering why The Music Lesson is so great. Or why the Girl with a Pearl Earring is 1:1.
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b0/53/42/b053425982ecb933ca4c...
https://www.easy-drawing-lessons.com/images/xpainter-using-a...
And their existence is part of critic's arguments against the Hockney thesis: many tools have been used in various ways at various times, and there's been little or no shame in acknowledging and documenting it.
To accept Hockney-Falco, you'd have to accept the opposite: that such devices were widespread amongst artists but kept secret or never mentioned. I think Occam's razor suggests that if such devices were commonly used, it wouldn't be so hard to find evidence of it.