News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:37AM (#15994852)
Some actors grew up poor but I wouldn't go around telling poor people they can all become world-famous actors.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by putnam on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:42AM (#15994881)
You think being a consultant is as rare as becoming an actor?
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by ineedasername on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:05PM (#15995021)
Not everyone can be in the top 1% of paid professionals in their field. That extends to acting or consulting. And there simply aren't enough clients that can pay that much to support a significant increase in the # of folks pulling down those fees, regardless of the quality of the service offered. If 100 Michael Jordans showed up tomorrow, that would just increase competition for the same scarce resource of NBA player slots, not the number of slots. Professional sports or acting make these dynamics more transparant, but they're at play in all professions.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by chrishacken on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:34PM (#15995187)
Not everyone can; but anyone can.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by yequalsx on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:34PM (#15995499)
As an extreme counter example can a person with an IQ or 50 do it? Clearly not. So not everyone can. There’s a range of abilities and personality types. I suspect the number of people with the ability/personality type necessary for $10,000 a week gig is much less than you imply.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by chrishacken on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:54PM (#15995935)
Personalities are built; you're not born an introvert. Anyone can be built into a leader; go join the Marine Corps if you don't believe me.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by yequalsx on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:51PM (#15996193)
I didn't say anything about being an introvert or any other personality type. I don't know patio11 or anyone else who commands high consulting fees. But clearly it is more than just knowledge that gets patio11 high fees. There is personality too. If patio11 were a raging asshole then his employability would decrease.

I've met Marines that were assholes so I'm guessing that 'join the Marine Corps' isn't as great advice as it first appears. Recently a Marine drill instructor was implicated in the abuse of Muslim recruits. That isn't a good leadership skill for the corporate environment. Your notion is too simplistic. It doesn't apply to everyone. It applies to some people but not all.

People lie on a spectrum in terms of abilities and personality. Not everyone can be molded to have the requisite knowledge/personality type to command high pay. It's simply not possible. Just take extreme examples and one can easily see this.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by chrishacken on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:38PM (#15996391)
You're completely missing the point. Being an asshole is a choice. My point is that anyone can be a consultant that puts their all into it. Being an asshole isn't in your DNA.

A Drill Instructor being a dickhead is also a choice. It doesn't make him any less able to be a leader. My point was, joining the Marine Corps turns weak individuals into respectable men that can command dignity and respect into people. What they choose to do with that transformation is up to them.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by yequalsx on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:53PM (#15996745)
I'm not missing the point. You are. Take a person with a 30 IQ. This is a person with severe mental retardation. That person clearly will never learn enough to command a high salary doing software consulting. That's an extreme example. There's a spectrum of ability and talent. Not everyone is capable to learning a given topic. No matter how much time/effort they put into it.

Peoples' personalities are also not always so malleable. My wife is a psychiatrist and she deals regularly with people who simply do not have the choice to change. Forces inside their brain are beyond their conscious control.

The Marine Corps sometimes turns weak individuals into respectable men. And sometimes it pumps out assholes. It doesn't work for everyone. This is obvious.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:00PM (#15996486)
Even if we generously assume this is the case we still have the problem that the demand is limited.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by chrishacken on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:32PM (#15996619)
Hence.. the "not everyone can" bit still applies.. but not everyone will. So that's not even relevant.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by perl4ever on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:34PM (#15996131)
You can't teach any arbitrary thing (nor temperament) to any arbitrary person. For a specific example, consider: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teichm%C3%BCller_space

I can say that not only would I never get anywhere with math at that level, but some of the related mathematical pages on Wikipedia surpass my ability to even tell if they are real or the work of cranks.

For any random person, there are things they can't do or learn because of the way they're made, any more than a cow can do calculus.

What's deceptive is that people constantly tell you that you must believe in yourself. But the reason isn't that believing in yourself is sufficient for success - the reason is believing in yourself is necessary to succeed so everyone who is successful attributes their success to that.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by chrishacken on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:45PM (#15996424)
Given enough time and training, anyone who puts their all into learning it, is capable of understanding that.

It may take them 20 years to learn math from the ground up, but they can do it. Saying someone can't do something is bullshit. That's sheep mentality.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:59PM (#15996479)
Many people do put their lives into things without ever becoming world-class talents.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by chrishacken on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:40PM (#15996665)
Understanding an algorithm or concept is not a world-class talent.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by yequalsx on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:57PM (#15996764)
There are lots of concepts whose understanding is a world class talent. In mathematics one would be hard pressed to find 10 people who have read and really understand Hironaka's Resolution of Singularities. There are many, many concepts whose understanding is a world class talent.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by lj3 on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:25PM (#16000904)
> you're not born an introvert

There's a substantial body of research suggesting otherwise.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by p1esk on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:11PM (#15995691)
Great comment.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by kamaal on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:33PM (#15995176)
>>Not everyone can be in the top 1% of paid professionals in their field.

The whole point of the 1% is the remaining 99%. The axiom of this game is there are filters enough to filter out the 99%.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:26PM (#15995129)
I would argue that increasing the number and quality of great actors increases the profitably of movie studios, and thus the number of movies made.

Similarly with sports, there is a huge range of player incomes and assuming the sport becomes more interesting to watch and thus profitable their would be room for more highly compensated players.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:34PM (#15995184)
Today's pro sports players are, as a rule, far better than pro sports players in the past. Why isn't this happening already? People only have so much time and attention. Also, many leagues operate with salary caps.

You also mentioned movies, but a lack of competent actors is far from the biggest reason there aren't more movies being produced.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:59PM (#15995960)
Plenty of great movies had a ~20 million dollar budget, but few moves with that kind of a budget had high returns.

In terms of movies, studios look a lot like a VC firm with a term sheet from hell. However, plenty of studios died over time and would be making moves today if their past movies where more profitable. Sure, you needs a direct / script / special effects etc, but low budget movies with simple scripts and great actors also work without X00 million dollar budgets. So, their is clearly some wiggle room in terms of number of movies produced per year.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:01PM (#15996489)
There are also countless starving aspiring actors so I doubt actor supply is your problem
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Saturday December 23, 2017 @10:13PM (#15997681)
Raw supply may not be the problem, it could be training etc.

Plenty of people are in a move, it takes something else to have the kind of run of a Robert De Niro or Anthony Hopkins. And generally people that have those kind of long runs are significantly more talented that many others.

They also often have family in the business, who presumably pass on more than just a foot in the door.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @10:28PM (#15997734)
Acting skill and fame/box office draw are, let's say, not perfectly correlated.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Sunday December 24, 2017 @05:37AM (#15998973)
Sure, but my argument does not need perfect correction. I suspect but can't prove that if Arnold had been a better actor his movies would have made more money.

Extend that across all actors and you presumably get more profit without higher costs anywhere which should result in more movies. But, even without more movies higher profits mean actors are simply worth more and collectively would get paid more pushing up compensation for the full range.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Sunday December 24, 2017 @08:37AM (#15999445)
Unless you suddenly get more people spending more time in the theater, something depending on other factors than just how good the movies are, it doesn't matter how great the movies are.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Sunday December 24, 2017 @09:40AM (#15999707)
If you look at annual and more importantly monthly fluctuations movie quality has a huge impact on ticket sales. https://www.the-numbers.com/market/

So, again it need not be 1:1, but a significant increase in overall sales including for home entertainment can happen because people have options outside of moves like video games.

PS: Major 6 put out 128 movies in 2006, but only 78 in 2013.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Sunday December 24, 2017 @10:24AM (#15999887)
I don't see how this is controversial. Maybe we are not at capacity but if thousands of Citizen Kane-level masterpieces were being released in every genre monthly people wouldn't have time to see them all. There is a limit somewhere.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Sunday December 24, 2017 @10:53AM (#15999999)
Ahh, ok. To use an analogy I am saying we are far below the laffer curve inflection point so talking about it's limit is not really meaningful.

So yes there is diminishing returns and actor quality would eventually stop being a meaningful constraint. But, again all I am saying is it's currently a meaningful constraint; not that it's always going to be one.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Sunday December 24, 2017 @11:59AM (#16000252)
I honestly do not think that is near the main problem. The best actors in the world are wasted when studios are just churning out safe crap for teenagers.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by njarboe on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:29PM (#15995798)
Are you saying there is not an upward trend in sports salaries? They have been skyrocketing for decades and decades.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:58PM (#15996472)
No, the discussion is about whether if you had a thousand Tom Bradys they could all play quarterback in the NFL.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by s73ver_ on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:42PM (#15995231)
For that to happen, they would have to increase the number of teams. This requires new stadiums/arenas to be built, and expansion teams to be created. This requires rebalancing of conferences and divisions within the league.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by Retric on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:52PM (#15995931)
I don't think athletic ability directly translates to higher revenue. But, their is also showmanship which more closely relates to revenue.

Some players make 50x+ what other players are making. Having linemen make 10 million per year does not involve adding linemen it involves linemen that are worth being paid 10 million / year.

At the same time football has added new teams over time and increased both the number of players and minimum salary significantly from inception.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:47PM (#15995269)
It also requires a fanbase.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by walshemj on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:51PM (#15995594)
Your assuming that every where else follows the socialist model that American sports do i.e. a pre entry closed shop for franchises with no consequences for failure - a premier league footballer has far more incentive to play well to stop his team getting demoted and facing a massive drop in his salary.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by ineedasername on Saturday December 23, 2017 @09:53PM (#15997620)
Most leagues in the U.S. have fairly open methods of getting on the team with the athletic talent required. For the NFL, anyone can pay a tryout fee and walk on to one of (usually) 8 spots. The other 45 are normally used by the veteran players good enough to have a multi-year contract or the new draft picks from college ball.

And the consequence for failure are huge: 90 players start the pre-season, and after training & a few pre-season games, teams have to drop that to 53. 10 extra can be part of a training squad, which represents a 75% pay cut compared to the league minimum for the 53.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by walshemj on Sunday December 24, 2017 @07:37AM (#15999275)
I was taking about the teams compare this where the bottom 2 teams from the top flight football get relegated each season - this is like the bottom 2 teams in the nfl get dropped and replaced each year
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:02PM (#15996496)
You should be required to pass a test on what the word "socialist" means before you're allowed to start throwing it around like this.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by walshemj on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:12PM (#15996535)
I think I have a better idea than you do and your seelioning here BTW the way the NFL etc are set up is very similar state controlled enterprises where run under more socialist regimes British Leyland ICL and so on.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @07:17PM (#15997126)
I don't think you do because the NFL is a system where surplus value is captured by the owners of the teams
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by kemitche on Saturday December 23, 2017 @01:10PM (#15995388)
And, over several decades of the NFL, all of that has happened several times.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by AFNobody on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:01PM (#15995003)
A consultant making 5 figures a week, in practical terms, is a unicorn that is not reliably repeatable. Most people cannot maintain that level of marketing while maintaining an income (as a consultant) effectively. If they could, every programmer would try to transition into making 5 figures a week as a consultant instead of making $100-200k with a stable job.

The $4k/week thing isn't since pretty much any decent consultant can command $100/hr which is what that weekly billing works out to.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by maneesh on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:36PM (#15995189)
I used to have a similar scarcity mentality --- thinking that because other people were successful, it was like the lottery -- based purely on chance.

But I learned over time to develop a abundance mentality -- rather than say 'it can't be done' -- to change my mode of thinking to say 'how did they do it, and is there anything for me to learn.'

A consultant making 5 figures a week is not a unicorn, it's not even that uncommon. But it's not just coding -- there's other steps that are also necessary but not sufficient. Building a reputation, building a following (a blog or email newsletter is a good way to get started), meeting people who open doors, etc.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by AFNobody on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:46PM (#15995897)
Please provide literally any evidence you have that the average consultant can reliably and repeatedly generate 5-figures-a-week-individual consultancy. I can already tell you no such evidence exists but if you want to search for it, you are free to do so.

> I used to have a similar scarcity mentality --- thinking that because other people were successful, it was like the lottery -- based purely on chance.

> But I learned over time to develop a abundance mentality -- rather than say 'it can't be done' -- to change my mode of thinking to say 'how did they do it, and is there anything for me to learn.'

You probably should look up 'reliably' and 'repeatable' and the definition of those words. You really should not attack a straw man.

I just understand the probability of X event is Y and I'm not naive enough to try to talk myself into wasting energy on low probability paths.

The 5 figures a week consultancy path is exactly such a low probability path.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by maneesh on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:41PM (#15996163)
5-figures a week is a high number, no doubt.

But are you saying there is NO way to improve one's position in life and income? That, if a path can't be shown repeatedly and reliably in a double-blind clinical study, there is no value in attempting to improve oneself?

Do you believe income is fixed, and that if you can't hit a five figure mark, well -- you might as well not try?

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by AFNobody on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:10PM (#15997882)
> But are you saying there is NO way to improve one's position in life and income?

I never stated that was the case.

> That, if a path can't be shown repeatedly and reliably in a double-blind clinical study, there is no value in attempting to improve oneself?

Money, beyond a basic level of ~$1k/week is mostly useless other than speeding up retirement.

> Do you believe income is fixed, and that if you can't hit a five figure mark, well -- you might as well not try?

You seem to think money = improving yourself = important.

I'm honestly more worried about you as a fellow human being and the misalignment of your goals than I am about whether I make $10k a week or $1k a week.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by patio11 on Saturday December 23, 2017 @02:35PM (#15995834)
There are plenty of reasons to take a steady job over running a business, even a very lucrative business. I’ve done both; no stressing over Christmas on whether a check will arrive soon enough in January or February to pay for my tax assessment in March has non-zero value to it. Paternity leave was pretty nice. I get to devote a supermajority of my professional efforts to work rather than devoting 10% to business administration and 20% to sales/marketing.

Consultants with relatively high rates are not unicorns, any more than lawyers or doctors with high rates are. This is not just repeatable, this is a fairly reasonable career path, much like “work at AppAmaGooBookSoft” is a lucrative but well-trod career path. (Which, btw, have in-the-door offers for mid-career professionals which are reasonably competitive with running a full-time consultancy at $30k/week.)

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by AFNobody on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:17PM (#15997914)
> Consultants with relatively high rates are not unicorns, any more than lawyers or doctors with high rates are. This is not just repeatable, this is a fairly reasonable career path, much like “work at AppAmaGooBookSoft” is a lucrative but well-trod career path. (Which, btw, have in-the-door offers for mid-career professionals which are reasonably competitive with running a full-time consultancy at $30k/week.)

You are seriously going to engage me with the argument that $600k+ (20 weeks of paid engagements @ $30k/week) a year in income + benefits is common?

I think you have a greatly inflated opinion of what the top 25% of software developers get paid let alone what is reasonable and repeatable.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by unreal37 on Monday December 25, 2017 @08:53PM (#16006604)
It honestly sounds like you think $100/hr is the upper limit of consulting earnings.

There are at least some people making $250/hr+ as a technical consultant. Is it 0.01%, 0.1% or 1%? Who knows.

But it's possible, and it's possible to get there if you're strategic about it.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by AFNobody on Thursday December 28, 2017 @03:49PM (#16024773)
> Is it 0.01%, 0.1% or 1%? Who knows.

I said it wasn't common which you are acknowledging. Simply because less some small percentage of people can mange it doesn't make it repeatable.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by mgkimsal on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:12PM (#15995063)
That person making 5 figures per week often doesn't need or want to be working 'repeatably' or have a full schedule. A couple folks I know charge $15k-$20k/week, but they only care to take on a few of those per year, while pursuing other interests (other business ideas, etc). Even $30k/week is still selling time for money, and "isn't scalable" - maxing out at $1.5m/year even fully booked, which few are.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by AFNobody on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:22PM (#15997930)
I'm talking about number of people able to do it rather than the specific individuals who have gotten into that position.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by putnam on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:34PM (#15995182)
Are they in-person jobs?
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by putnam on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:33PM (#15995173)
Why can they not maintain that level of marketing? What is stopping them?
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by CyberDildonics on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:49AM (#15994928)
He used an exaggerated metaphor to illustrate that pragmatically, not everyone can market themselves to become well known, no matter how good they are at writing software. You then turned that into an irrelevant comparison of the difficulty of becoming an actor vs a consultant.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by putnam on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:55AM (#15994970)
Thank you. Do you think that someone who is good at writing software can not learn to market themselves to become well known?
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by mgkimsal on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:09PM (#15995047)
Not the OP, but my own experience is that it's a more uncommon skill than I first thought. I know plenty of skilled developers, but only a handful have a combination of business savvy and enough social skills and graces to be able to talk to a variety of people in business settings without ... hosing it up somehow.

I'm not at all saying all 'consultants' are great at this either - 'consultants' work for 'big 5' firms and are just sent out on engagements, which isn't quite the 'consultant' we're talking about here (the word means many things).

I've worked with people on projects who couldn't sense when the other people in the room were veering off topic and not understanding a response. Also worked with people who could not ever understand they themselves were going offtopic and/or not understanding what the clients were saying. Talking to hear yourself talk is a big one. Not being able to adjust yourself to the project is a project (if you're working with a small $2m company of 10 people, repeating anecdotes from your $100m engagements isn't impressive, it's ... annoying and/or off-topic).

Not delivering when you say you will. Not calling people back when you say you will. Blaming everyone else but yourself - these are all problems I've seen (and experienced) myself as an independent consultant. Easier to mask/hide when you're "just" doing development as an internal employee someplace.

Also... you posted this and have asked a lot of questions. If you want to talk more offline, email me.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by BeetleB on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:16PM (#15995078)
>I know plenty of skilled developers, but only a handful have a combination of business savvy and enough social skills and graces to be able to talk to a variety of people in business settings without ... hosing it up somehow.

Of course most are like that: How much effort did they put in to become skilled developers, and how much on the business savvy? I'm guessing years on the former, and perhaps hours on the latter?

It's not that people can't develop those skills. It's that few want to, or realize that they have to.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by mgkimsal on Saturday December 23, 2017 @03:18PM (#15996061)
> It's not that people can't develop those skills. It's that few want to, or realize that they have to

I sort of agree, but ... we all know the people who try to get in to programming/development, but just never get it. They can try, and maybe even land a jr role some place, but it never really clicks, regardless of how long they work at it. I think the non-tech skills are like that in some measure as well.

Also, while I'm probably switching examples a bit, I'm not sure how much experience you need practicing skills like showing up on time, or answering emails (and without being rude or condescending). There may be people who need to "practice" not insulting clients' employees in emails to the same client, but I'm not sure how much practice one should need to have basic empathic ability. If you don't have some of that, how many years do you need "practicing" those skills?

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by BeetleB on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:47PM (#15996432)
>I think the non-tech skills are like that in some measure as well.

The difference is that to do very well in tech/programming, you have to be well above the average.

For a lot of non-tech skills, merely being a bit above the average will get you far. In the context of this discussion, the primary skill the consultant has is still his technical skills. He merely upped his non-tech skills enough to prevent it from being a barrier.

Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by mcguire on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:40PM (#15995214)
Then there's that old joke about getting a girlfriend and having your .emacs go to shit.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:24PM (#15995112)
Some can, some can't, but realistically, even if everyone were turning out articles as good as Steve Yegge's they couldn't all achieve the same name recognition. If you want another example look at mobile app stores. Surely there were thousands of games just as good as Flappy Bird that you've never heard of.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by putnam on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:39PM (#15995204)
Who is Steve Yegge?
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by emodendroket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:48PM (#15995274)
Formerly one of the most prominent programming bloggers but he has been inactive for a while.
Re:How I went from programming to consulting (2012) by mcguire on Saturday December 23, 2017 @12:37PM (#15995196)
"Can not learn?" No.

Not interested in / willing to spend the time to do it? Marketing yourself is a full time job.