1. Secrecy is part of the culture.
2. Engineers work hard at Apple, and many teams are surprisingly small. There are no 20% projects at Apple because nobody has the time.
EDIT: Going on the Apple jobs listing for Cupertino, there is plenty of openings for engineers.
One of the assertions in the article is that a hacker culture is a necessary ingredient for a successful technology company. I see Apple as a counterexample to this argument. And it's a counterexample that shouldn't be ignored. Apple is driven by design (industrial design, product design, graphic design). They think about products, not technology. They often invent new technologies to enable their products, but that's very different from thinking primarily about technology (a mistake, I would argue, that Google is guilty of frequently).
Taking as an example a project like Google Wave, I would even go as far as to say that a strong hacker culture and an obnoxious elitist culture of hiring only the best programmers can be serious detriments to a technology company. YMMV, but, culture-wise, I'd much rather build (and work for) an Apple than a Google.
Edit in reply to your reply: I thought it was any company that needs to have good software. But even so, surely Apple doesn't pay significantly more than Google (a hacker-centric company) and surely they're in roughly the same domain (iOS/Android, iAd, etc.). I think the real problem is in your next sentence: Otherwise you can't attract good programmers to work in a suit-centric culture. That's a big false dichotomy. Sure, suit-centric technology companies will fail. And hacker-centric technology companies sometimes succeed. I think Apple shows that a culture that is neither suit-centirc nor hacker-centric is the best option of all. If many of your YC companies are trying to build great technology companies, they should take that to heart.
I would actually disagree with the last part of that. I think Apple is always thinking about technology, but in the context of design. The Apple difference is not simply that design comes first, technology second, but that design is the gatekeeper for technology.
The iPod is the shining example. Could Apple have made a music player before the mass-production of the 1.8" hard drive? Sure, but it wouldn't have been the wonder to hold in your hand that the iPod was. It was when the technology was ready for the design requirements that they pounced on the opportunity.
Same thing with the iPhone. Apple could have made a smartphone before affordable capacitive multi-touch screens, multi-gigabyte flash drives, and fast-enough-for-desktop-browsing SoCs, but they likely didn't feel they could make a user experience to their standard with anything less.
No it isn't. I said that you either need that or to pay people a lot or to be in an interesting industry where there are no competitors who have hacker cultures. If Apple doesn't have a hacker culture, then it would probably be an example of the latter.
Although this may not be as nice as a hacker-centric culture (if you are a hacker), it is still leagues better than an utterly non-hacker centric culture, because the devs are respected for what they do at Apple. This seems to be a critical difference necessary for producing great products.
Two essential qualities of good hackers is an abundant ability to synthesize elegant solutions from disparate details, and a desire to create great things. Jobs may not write code but he clearly has these two qualities. So even if Apple does not have an engineer-centric culture, a design culture driven by Jobs can be directly compatible. You see the differences of course, in the products Google and Apple make, but I think the point is that great hackers can work at Apple because they can get behind Jobs vision.
Contrast this with a "suit-driven" company where decisions are made by looking at statistics and market research, and executives strategize about how to maximize sales based on the superficial product understanding they have. Even worse, places where you actually have people in power who couldn't give a crap about the product as long as they have a $500k+ salary rolling in every year.
Exactly. Apple isn't really about winning or losing; they're rewriting the game. Does it really get more "hackerly" than that?
I'm not going to venture more complete definition here, but I think a lot of the themes around "unix culture" (e.g., small pieces loosely joined), open source (e.g. bazaar vs. cathedral approach to design and architecture), and even agile methodologies (e.g. "the simplest thing that could possibly work") could apply. But there's more to it than that.
From this perspective, I agree that you could easily characterize Y Combinator as "hacking" VC. I just don't see what Apple is doing as hacking.
In fact, in some ways it seems to me that Apple is doing the opposite of hacking (or at least trying to give that impression). Apple seems to want to create an impression of "intelligent design" around their products--they've got it all figured out and are delivering it to you complete, fully-formed and flawless. To my mind "hacking" connotes a more evolutionary approach: let's just try this and iterate.
This isn't a value judgement on either approach, I just have a hard time aligning Apple's behaviour as an organization with my personal understanding of "hackerly".
My girlfriend studies industrial engineering and knows quite a bit about innovation and product development. If I combine everything I've heard from her with everything I've heard about Apple, then I conclude that Apple simply excels at leveraging/executing all the well-known 'best practices'. There's nothing 'hackerly' required to do proper innovation and product development, unless you expand 'hackerly' to include 'doing business the way it should be done'
The "dictating specs to programmers" practice seems to stem from the silly notion of applying manufacturing processes to software development. In the view of companies with this notion, programmers are little more than unskilled translators - the parallel of line workers in manufacturing jargon.
In my experience, one of the worst abusers of this "square peg/round hole" paradigm are internal IT departments.
I read a study in IEEE Computer sometime in the Summer of 2001 or 2002 that showed how bad the application of Waterfall was for software development. Does anyone know of a study on the application of manufacturing processes to software development?
Very pitifully few of Google's projects have either created new markets they can dominate, or have penetrated existing markets to the point they can drive billion dollar business units. Gmail, Maps and Android exception to that point, but Google is woefully incompetent in most other respects. And the first two in that list are simply different takes on the search paradigm while Android is a knock-off of the iPhone OS (a really good knock-off, but certainly not a game changing original new idea).
Those are very big exceptions.
I've not seen that many software products which were so obviously disruptive; it's no wonder they became giant-killers. Facebook is the only other one I can think of.
On the other hand, some of their other big products have not be a huge success precisely they haven't been game-changers. Google Docs, for example, might be a good example of a web office suite; but it's hardly a game changer as far as office suites go, because it doesn't do some of the core things that people do daily with office suites. It was clear from the beginning that it would be a slow starter. Whereas Maps for example, you knew at the beiginning that nothing else could touch it
Google's products are mostly software running on servers in datacenters. Facebooks products are the same way. Yahoo's products were mostly software.
Apple's products are not mostly software. Apple sells consumer devices run by software. It's an important distinction, and looking at it that way lets you compare with different sorts of companies, like the technology startup Emotiv Systems[1][2]. They're developing consumer devices that read brain activity like an EEG. They likely spend a lot of time developing their SDK and other software, but they also have to focus on the physical product, like Apple does.
Sometimes people forget or don't realize that "hacker culture" has always had a contingent of hardware guys building solar-cars and robots[3] and kites with cameras.
How can you be so sure about their thought process? Maybe it is the other way around, they just turn it around when it comes to presenting it to the public.
How long did their core OS not have protected memory, or pre-emptive multitasking?
Apple still see's their OS as a package with the hardware. I would think this is part of their attachment to iOS (that and the massive markup and market penetration they've had so far).
The iPod gen 1 through gen 4 was not a hacker platform.
" Apple did not develop the iPod software entirely in-house, instead using PortalPlayer's reference platform based on two ARM cores. The platform had rudimentary software running on a commercial microkernel embedded operating system. PortalPlayer had previously been working on an IBM-branded MP3 player with Bluetooth headphones.[4] Apple contracted another company, Pixo, to help design and implement the user interface under the direct supervision of Steve Jobs.[4] As development progressed, Apple continued to refine the software's look and feel. " -- Wikipedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc.#1986.E2.80.931993:_R... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod
Edit: I could go on longer, for example, OSX coming from BSD and NextStep etc but I'm done. :)
About until Steve Jobs came back. But the Apple of 1985 to 1997 was not the Apple of today. That Apple is long dead. The Apple of today is basically NeXT, plus the branding and whatever other assets NeXT could salvage from Apple. As far as that company is concerned, their core OS had protected memory and preemptive multitasking since 1989.
The Mughal India of the 16th–19th centuries was not the India of today. That India is long dead. The India of today is basically the British Raj, plus the branding, mix of religions and whatever else the British could salvage.
The Republican party of 1860–1970 was not the Republican party of today. That GOP is long dead. The GOP of today is basically the unholy mix of Kristol & Podhoretz foreign & economic policy with Jerry Falwell & Pat Robertson social policy, plus the branding and whatever panders to fiscal conservative constituents they could salvage from the party’s historic base of support.
The field of economics of 1780–1950 was not the economics of today. That economics is long dead. The economics of today is basically the Friedmanite Chicago school, plus the branding and whatever other assets they could salvage from economics.
Now, in all three of these cases, there’s some little bit of truth behind the wholly oversimplified (to the point of wrongness) analysis. But taking these statements at face value obscures more than it reveals, and reflects a poor understanding of how cultural assimilation works in any institution or society. (And denies evolutionary change, as well; Apple today is not exactly the same as Apple of ca. 2000)
* * *
In short: you’d better have some better analysis to back yourself up here, because as it stands I think your claim is, to the first approximation, false, even if there is a tiny bit of truth to it.
It's certainly true that Apple is now more NeXT than it is what it was. Perhaps it's something different enough from both of those--but it followed NeXT's evolutionary path more than Apple's.
You’re right that early versions of OS X looked much more like NeXTStep than they did like previous versions of Mac OS (being built on NeXT’s codebase), and still today is in many small details a regression. But as OS X has matured, it has felt ever more like "classic" Mac OS, not less. I think if NeXT had been independently successful and turned NeXTStep into a consumer OS, it would have evolved in a dramatically different direction (though of course that’s counterfactual).
I don’t really know what it was or is like to work inside these companies, but I doubt that the feel of NeXT could be quite like the feel of the modern Apple, if only because modern Apple is so much bigger.
But as OS X has matured, it has felt ever more like "classic" Mac OS, not less.
Past the transition from public beta to release and maybe a couple small points after that, I don't see how this is true at all, and I've extensively used both. What similarities do you notice?
(It’s not a change since OS X 10.0, but....) Right from the beginning having the menu bar at the top was better than the NeXT per-window menu bars (there were legal reasons for the NeXTStep behavior, sure, but a menu at the top feels so Mac-ish to me, that that difference alone is huge). Much of the conventions for menu organization/structure and so on (and definitely conventions for keyboard shortcuts, for the overall keyboard layout, &c. &c.) is much more Mac-alike than NeXT-alike.
Hardware finally caught up with the software (and the software was optimized better for performance), so that the interface is as “snappy” as OS 9 used to be on then-current hardware. (Early OS X felt terribly sluggish by comparison.)
The mouse acceleration curve reverted to something much more like the classic Mac version (in 10.3 maybe?).
The menus at some point (10.1? 10.2?) returned to the proper behavior of allowing diagonal selection. The alternative is a fundamentally broken interface, and every time I use an operating system that does it wrong I want to stab the guy responsible.
Finally in 10.4, the corners of the screen properly activated the Apple/Spotlight menus (taking advantage of “Fitt’s Law”).
Drag & drop support improved and was properly widely adopted.
AppleScript support by first-party apps got much better.
Dialog boxes got better writing, including somewhat more consistent use of verb buttons.
Did ⌘. (command-period) work everywhere (anywhere?) for cancel in dialogs in early versions of OS X? I don’t remember.
OS X print dialogs still aren’t my favorite, but they’ve improved relative to 10.0 print dialogs, adopting some of the feel of earlier dialogs.
Save dialogs improved a lot since 10.0. I don’t think ⌘D properly went to the desktop in early OS X versions, but I’m not positive about that.
Places where (in NeXT tradition) early OS X used “inspectors”, for instance in the Get Info window, later OS X reverted to the better "classic" Mac OS behavior. (This happened in various first-party apps too, but I’m not thinking of examples off-hand; it’s been a while).
NeXT-ish UI elements like drawers have been gradually phased out, in favor of UI elements which seem more spiritually Mac-ish. Oh, and remember early OS X Cocoa tab view widgets? Wow, were those dumb. Little wonder they’re pretty much gone.
I think support for Mac file aliases was sorta crappy in early OS X versions, but I don’t remember the details.
Cocoa applications started properly dealing with references to files rather than to path locations, for things like re-opening saved files, etc. etc.; early versions of OS X were filled with apps which would behave improperly when a user moved a file.
Exposé feels much more like a culturally Mac-like feature than the use of the Dock, etc. Though Spaces seems more NeXT-ish to me (I don’t remember if NeXTStep had multiple desktops... did it?).
The appearance of OS chrome tended back towards the simplicity of classic Mac OS (obviously not to the precise appearance, but to the feel), with every OS version further away from pinstripes, distracting transparency, slow unnecessarily flashy animations, etc. And not only the overall window ornamentation. Take a look at the folder icons, for example, which look like OS 7.5 icons (I always hated the ones from OS 8–9).
The Finder never regained its spatial-ity (as John Siracusa periodically laments), but it got much better at remembering window state in each version from 10.0 to 10.3.
Disks get properly mounted on the desktop by default (I don’t remember precisely the history of this, but I believe the default was not to show them on the desktop at some point; maybe I’m just confusing early OS X with Windows here).
The Finder at some point (10.4? 10.5?) finally allowed icons to be spaced closer together as in "classic" Mac OS.
The Finder got back color labels in 10.3, an OS 7 feature, which I believe were missing altogether from 10.0–10.2.
Finder keyboard and mouse selection behavior, especially in list mode, improved dramatically from 10.0 to 10.4. In general, the mouse and keyboard behavior of list widgets – rows, disclosure triangles, heading sorting and column resizing, etc. – improved quite a bit.
* * *
I’m sure there are dozens of other such things (if you read through Siracusa reviews and John Gruber’s notes about each OS version I’m sure you’ll find a bundle), but listing more here doesn’t accomplish much. I’m not trying to argue that "classic" Mac OS feels the same as the current OS X does, or that OS X doesn’t also include many very NeXT-feely features like the Finder column view, &c. I do think though that OS X is somewhere between a NeXTStep/Mac hybrid and its own thing altogether, both in specific features and in less tangible “how it feels” aspects.
Basically, they merged the branch back into the trunk.
It's a mistake to say that. All the work that went into the LLVM/Clang, low-level development that's done OS X and iOS isn't something that you can do without hackers; neither are the algorithms used by Aperture or even iPhoto.
I got called from Google during 2006. The HR guy screened me on the phone with all TCP/IP questions. I was amazed because he knew so much about TCP/IP and UNIX socket. It turned out that he was a former software engineer in Bell Lab/Lucent. It has been the best initial phone screen that I ever have.
I can imagine a software engineer who is suffering from carpal tunnel syndrome switches jobs from writing to keyboard to talking on the phone.
One of the latest tactics that the headhunters have been using is to begin with a line like ``Hey, I used to be an engineer! But now I'm hanging out here doing recruiting, cool huh?''
Maybe I should follow JWZ's step. Selling alcohols is more lucrative than programming!
Next both Google and Yahoo brought in professional executives or "suits" to run the firms, speak to Wall St. etc. Eric Schmidt is a professional CEO, not a hacker. He was at Sun, then he tried to revive Novell and then was tapped for Google.Yahoo is also run by a professional CEO now. How does that compare to the single minded life long vision of Steve Jobs? What role the leadership and their personalities plays in running the companies beyond the culture? Remember Apple was a "has been" company with plenty of suits and they even fired Steve Jobs at some point.
There is a fundamental flaw in PG's argument, he is trying to have a rational explanation about an irrational path to success of failure.
I don't know much more about the two men, but I'm 100% certain that Schmidt did a colossal amount of programming in his day, and I really doubt that Semel ever did, though I can't be sure of this. This has to have a serious effect on the hacker culture. If nothing else, Google's choice sends a message to programmers that technical ability matters all the way to the top. Yahoo's says it doesn't, at least not enough to be a required attribute of the highest ranking person at the company.
Lex − A Lexical Analyzer Generator
http://staff.ustc.edu.cn/~shzhang/staff/lesk-lex.pdf
and Google's Eric E Schmidt was only 20 at that time according to Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_E._Schmidt
He got BSEE on Princeton in 1976. OK, both Bell Labs and Princeton are in New Jersey, but it's still quite impressive to be the developer of lex in Bell Labs as a 20-year old Princeton student.
Of course even more impressive is being 129th richest person in the world in 2006.
It's impossible to tell without working there (and once you work there you probably lose the privilege of speaking openly about this stuff) but it seems Apple is just a generalized, multidisciplinary example of what pg's talking about.
"...but they didn't have the kind of single-minded, almost obnoxiously elitist focus on hiring..."
Apple seems to want to hire the best, but the best being based on actual capability instead of the school you went to.
You sure about that?
From http://www.apple.com/jobs/us/welcome.html:
"Whether you want to be an iPod engineer, a Concierge at an Apple Retail Store, or a sushi chef on an Apple campus (yes, we have sushi chefs), we’re looking for the best. People who are smart, creative, up for any challenge, and incredibly excited about what they do. In other words, Apple people. You know, the kind of people you’d want to hang around with anyway."
Googling "apple hiring process" turns up this:
http://www.ifoapplestore.com/stores/hiring.html
"And lastly, the competition for jobs is intense! Sr. v-p Retail Ron Johnson has said it's tougher to be hired than being accepted by Stanford University--literally. During one talk he said Apple hired 978 store employees during 2002 from an applicant pool of 16,438, or less than a 6% chance of being hired (Stanford accepted 12.6 % for 2005). Put another way, only 1 in 17 applicants is hired."
Sure that's just retail, but it seems reasonable to guess that a similar hiring process exists for other fields.
Steve Jobs is the conductor and Apple is the orchestra. Jobs can bring all the right people into a room, sell them his idea, and have them rabidly strive to produce.
The real difference here is the management's competence.
As it should be since for the most part, Apple has been conspicuously absent as an internet and web company, especially during the period discussed in the article. I have many reservations about the conclusions and generalizations PG draws, but it seems silly to fault him for not including Apple. He didn't mention General Electric either.
Of course, if you want to extend the idea of hacking so that one can speak of user experience hackers, then Apple would definitely qualify as having a "hacker-centric culture".
The article is about Yahoo and in a round about way the move of internet marketing focus from 90s banner advertising to search marketing in 00s. I didn't find Apple Computers Inc. (as it was) to be missing, indeed I'm kinda at a loss where you think Apple fit in to this article.
There are already plenty of articles about Apple.
Even though they make great hardware, his position seems to be that its the software that delivers the product experience.
Check, but it's quite far off from being Yahoo and IMO wouldn't add to this article.
Apple's software always runs on controlled environments. I wonder if they can pay that much attention to detail if they build for Web (Google) or any random hardware (Microsoft). Apple somehow avoids the added complexity of supporting the majority. For now it works, though.
Not really. Please do not confuse Apple's successful products with anything else. Microsoft still delivers on software products in a way (admittedly a hardware company)Apple never could. Oh and as for comparisons with Google, thats even more ludicrous.
...the kind of single-minded, almost obnoxiously elitist focus on hiring the smartest people that the big winners have had.
Is Apple a big winner, like Google, Microsoft, and Facebook (the other companies he mentions repeatedly)? Bigger. (Check the last 1, 5 or 10 years on Google finance for the GOOG or MSFT comparison. FB is not public, but...) Do they have this obnoxiously elitist focus? No. They still manage to hire great engineers, though.
So which companies need to have a hacker-centric culture?... any company that needs to have good software.
I wouldn't say that Apple is dominated by a hacker culture at all. It's dominated by Steve Jobs and a focus on design and attention to detail. Yet that seems to produce much better software than Google or Microsoft, IMHO. That's very subjective, I realize, but the market seems to agree. At any rate, Apple does produce good software.
So are the hacker culture and the elitist focus really necessary for a technology company to succeed? Is Apple a complete anomaly while Google, Microsoft, and Facebook are typical? What say you, pg?
I realize it's borderline suicidal to post an HN comment that simultaneously calls out pg and lauds Apple, but it's criminal to completely leave the best (imho) technology company out of a discussion about attributes of great technology companies.