News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by habosa on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:12PM (#15965340)
You'll notice the entire Bitcoin community has changed tone. It used to be "this is the currency of the future, down with cash/Visa!" but now you hear "Bitcoin is not a currency, it's a store of value".

The wild price swings, slow transactions, high fees, and loq merchant acceptance make it complete garbage as a currency. But as a store of value, none of those arguments apply. It only has to compete with gold bars, which are crappy in their own ways.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by simonsarris on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:04PM (#15966413)
Gold bars are only a store of value if they're in your possession. A gold bar in the hand is worth two in the bush as they say.

To be a good store of value its not enough that it exists and people value it, you have to be able to call upon it when you need it. That's where its back to approximating currency, and where Bitcoin's weakest link seems to be. This is probably just the beginning of the bad news.

King George used to lay claim to every pine in North America, to be called upon when he needed them for ship masts. For some reason or another he couldn't do that anymore. Historical examples abound, if you look for them, and they're not tulips: https://hackernoon.com/the-guns-of-bitcoin-1f779309a718 (disclaimer: I wrote that, which dances around a few historical reasons why bitcoin's value might not be so peachy)

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by randomsearch on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:04PM (#15966053)
How does the volatility not make it a bad store of value?! Surely by definition that is exactly why it is a bad store of value!
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by jcranmer on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:09PM (#15966078)
But that would mean it's good for nothing except warming the planet!
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by mproud on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:35PM (#15966555)
It’s really sad that so much power will be wasted on mining Bitcoin.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by dubin on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:00PM (#15966387)
“How can Bitcoin be a good store of value if its price is so volatile?” http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/12/can...
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by guitarbill on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @05:12AM (#15968410)
Quoting some articles does not an argument make. The summary argument:

> Volatility is a feature of Bitcoin, not a bug, and that is in part for reasons that have nothing to do with speculation or bubbliness, but rather follow from the contours of the utility function. It’s that latter point that hardly anyone understands.

I'd argue this is might be correct, but also irrelevant, as many people involved in bitcoin either wanted to use it as a payment method, or are only in it for speculation, or money laundering/covert transferring of wealth.

How useful is a value store where it's very difficult to actually get the value out remains to be seen, or what effect such a realisation will have on the price.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by xelxebar on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:02PM (#15966401)
I'm not intimately familiar with BTC prices, but they seem to have lots of high frequency volatility while the low frequency price changes are close to monotonic. If that's the case then it makes sense as a long term store of value.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by IncRnd on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @10:04PM (#15966678)
Yes. The number of bitcoins increases roughly linearly over time and will continue to do so for another few years. At that time, the bitcoin protocol will need to change or there will be no new bitcoins circulating. This leads to almost endless deflation, as long as bitcoin doesn't change from its current structure.

There really is no asset "there" when talking about Bitcoin. Bitcoin acts purely technically and can be traded that way. Unless Bitcoin's structure changes the price will either continue to rise as a trend, or it will crash forever. Long positions and scalpers do great with Bitcoin.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by malloryerik on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @10:04PM (#15966681)
"Store of value" here means "investment", but people are trying to keep the veneer of currency definition. And of course it's a highly speculative investment, although whose wild volatility contains a rare spice cherished by asset managers, "high alpha", meaning that it is not related to the broader markets. In musical terms, Bitcoin sings its own song, or dances to its own beat.

To diversify, as modern portfolio theory prescribes, investors seek assets whose prices don't change in relation to other prices, are uncorrelated. In today's world, most markets are highly correlated with each other, they are almost like separate instruments playing in a huge symphony.

But not Bitcoin. Not for now. Bitcoin moves according to bitcoin.

If bitcoin becomes more and more like "digital gold" and loses some of the volatility, however, it will also start to act more and more like physical gold on the world markets. Gold moves as a safe haven asset, and so will Bitcoin, and thereby lose its status as an investment uncorrelated to the broader markets.

If you're involved in trading, you can pretty much be given a single market quote like the S&P or gold, and generally guess the direction and possibly the amount of price changes in many or most other world markets, unless there were events specific to one or another market. Usually if gold went up, for example, the Japanese yen also gained. These relationships change over time, but they are very pronounced. You can ask maybe three questions and generally extrapolate what happened over the entire world except for cases where a local event in India caused its bourse to move independently, or for example a weather event moved an agricultural commodity. Even real estate does not escape the bonds of market correlation.

But... Bitcoin. Without a very large move in other assets, I doubt a well-versed market participant could tell you what happened to Bitcoin without hearing about Bitcoin itself (or maybe Ethereum...). To repeat myself, I believe this will change if BTC becomes established as a "store of value", it will join the symphony, but for that reason it will also lose its great appeal to institutional investors -- its uncorrelated quality, "pure alpha" as one well-known asset manager recently termed it (where alpha is independent returns and beta is benchmarked correlated returns).

So, with its volatility, Bitcoin is maybe being thought of by institutional investors as a kind of extreme spice that can add a bit of diversified risk into their larger stew. Just dab will do ya. But as more dabs are added, the "alpha" quality will wear off and it will begin to move more and more like plain old gold. Maybe less lustrous...

So maybe in investment terms as well, Bitcoin might have a scaling problem.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by jondubois on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:50PM (#15965649)
I don't see it as a store of value. It's just a very reliable network for sending very big transactions.

If you send 1 million dollars in Bitcoin, a $20 fee is negligible - The reliability of the Bitcoin network makes it worth it.

For smaller transactions you should just use a different coin.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by canoebuilder on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:34PM (#15966232)
If you're in good standing with the various governmental authorities, what are the scenarios that make it worthwhile to convert to some cryptocoin, "send a transaction," then convert back on the other end? There are traditional channels for sending money to various places, what do these extra steps get me?

You may feel a $20 fee is negligible, how about a 1% price move? 10%?

It's funny how often one sees these sort of high-dollar scenarios described for this "decentralized"! "currency of the people"!

Like, sending million dollar wires is a fairly niche market, and to my knowledge people regularly engaging in such things seem to be getting along just fine, there not crying out desperately for a better solution. And how exactly is bitcoin better for doing this if your million dollar transactions don't consist of the spoils from an exchange hack, exit scam or the like?

It's just a very reliable network for sending very big transactions.

Do you think the traditional channels for sending million dollar wires are unreliable? This seems like an area where the market is likely to converge on the very most reliable options and any service provider in this area with even a hint of unreliability would rapidly fade away.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by vkou on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:44PM (#15966293)
If you send 1 million dollars in bitcoin, the crazy volatility may mean that you only sent $950,000 by the time your transaction was confirmed.

The bitcoin blockchain is a great way to transfer a fixed amount of bitcoin. It is an awful, awful way to transfer a fixed amount of wealth.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by QML on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:01AM (#15968090)
If it costs $20 to move a million dollars, then why not use a $30 wire transfer? The way I see it is that Bitcoin's advantage should be to move any amount of value across the internet for a low flat fee; anything less then the hassle of using the Bitcoin network outweighs the benefit.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by lolc on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:21PM (#15965851)
The volatility affects all sizes of transactions in the same way. So sure, transactions with Bitcoin may be reliable. But converting them is not.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by CaptainZapp on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:59AM (#15967836)
Unless your million $ is dirty you would be stupid to not use proper channels for the transfer.

Beginning with a knock on the door and two gentlemen with badges asking why you transfer so much money over - well - unconventional channels.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by phnofive on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:20PM (#15965415)
The goal posts will stop moving in time with the music.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by thevardanian on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:11PM (#15965795)
Thanks. But no thanks. Even as a store of value it's crappy because of the public ledger. I would rather have some semblance of privacy in terms of my wealth.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by perseusprime11 on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:22PM (#15965855)
It has become a store of value, and there is nothing wrong to see it as a new asset class because of the attention it has been getting. IMO, bitcoin will rise till it finds an equivalent place like gold. Because of the limit, the value of bitcoin can technically reach anywhere between 400K to a million dollars. If they really wanted to see this as a currency, you would never design this to have an upper bound. You cannot realistically support or even augment the world exonomy with just 21 million bitcoins.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by thevardanian on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:54PM (#15966018)
Cool. What I'm saying is that it lacks privacy, and therefore is a poor store of value.

As for it being a store of value akin to gold? I don't think so. For various reason, even disregarding the historicity, and the physical nature of gold, the primarily reason I think it won't be comparable to gold will be because of the nature of technology. That being the lack of long term, and I'm talking centuries, hell even a few decades out, type of stability, and I just don't see Bitcoin being stable for such a long period of time. Technologies improve, and fundamentally demand constant change,and so superior competitors will emerge. Hell if anything even a state sanctioned E-Coin system would obliterate Bitcoin.

Fundamentally at this point Bitcoin is reliant on the network effect. As of even today the technology behind it is in constant flux, experimentation, and competition, what keeps bitcoin afloat is that it's a first mover, and a lot of people use it. The network effect is really a short term moat for most technologies, including Bitcoin, and as such it will not last long enough to be a Long Term store of value. So any sort of comparable "Long term store" of value in any comparable to gold is out of the question.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by canoebuilder on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:46PM (#15966308)
a state sanctioned E-Coin system

We have these, they're called debit cards, credit cards, paypal, etc.

For anything "state-sanctioned," centralized and "trustful" systems are always going to be more efficient, and chosen over less efficient and inferior options.

This is why it's hard to see where something like bitcoin would ever find widespread use, it's only good for non-"state-sanctioned" things.

If large numbers of people were to start doing non-"state-sanctioned" things, they wouldn't start using bitcoin, they would change the laws of the state.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by thevardanian on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:08PM (#15966433)
Well yes, but fundamentally it's backed and guaranteed by physical paper bills. So when I say E-Coin I mean a purely digital/mathematical abstraction like Bitcoin, or other Cryptocurrencies.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by headgasket on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:47PM (#15966314)
I think it's an organic reaction that makes a lot of sense. A distributed deflationary currency not run by any central authority is a dangerous concept. Another volatile store of value that might not be very liquid is a lot less dangerous. (Imagine cashing a 10th of the float, say) The forces of the status quo(or is it the invisible hand?) has responded to the threat, for now, by blowing this up to the stratosphere and making it impractical as a currency; it's even a better move than making it illegal. There will be more chapters to this, especially smart contracts. Interesting developments.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by omarforgotpwd on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @03:07AM (#15967872)
Even a $1 bitcoin transaction costs $25 in TX fees to send. At least I can pick up a gold bar myself for free. And price volatility makes it a terrible store of value. Let’s face it: in its current state bitcoin is pretty much useless except if you hold it and the price goes up. I own some Bitcoin and plan on holding it but there’s no denying the software in its state is not usable for anything. If the devs could figure out how to make it work like Venmo, that would be absolutely huge. Perhaps another implementation will get it right first, or already has.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:00PM (#15966388)
> But as a store of value, none of those arguments apply. It only has to compete with gold bars, which are crappy in their own ways.

There are lots of stores of value besides gold bars and Bitcoin; real estate, business equity, business and government debt instruments,...

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by Kinnard on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:32PM (#15965522)
Actually there's been a vigorous enough debate happening in the community about how to fix some of these problems and how to move forward toward what Bitcoin will ultimately be that the community and blockchain split.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by stingraycharles on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:41PM (#15965578)
Yes but these debates have been going on for years with very little progress being made. Bitcoin is growing faster than it can keep up with, it seems.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by etr-strike on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @06:45PM (#15965613)
I mean, segwit was activated. That doubles the capacity of blocks. People just need to upgrade.

Lightning Network is moving quickly. It is live on mainnet, tho still considered unstable.

Schnorr signatures are in development. This will further compress transactions.

Seems like progress is happening to me...

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by cohnnton on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:08PM (#15965774)
why would it be a (good) store of value? there are countless crytocurrencies. The only reason people think bitcoin is rare is a (blind) leap of faith
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by erikpukinskis on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:45AM (#15967549)
It’s the first and one of the simplest with the biggest brand. Those things matter somewhat.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by vkou on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @08:42PM (#15966287)
Gold bars don't require the electricity output of a small country to keep running.

Although I suppose digging them up also has serious environmental consequences.

Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by jameskegel on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @09:03PM (#15966404)
One might research the effects of cyanide byproducts from gold mining, and the lives lost harvesting it.
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by majewsky on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @07:56AM (#15969113)
This made me briefly consider the real-world environmental impact of the automated mining operation on my Minecraft server. :)
Re:There are now more than 200k pending Bitcoin transactions by LrnByTeach on Tuesday December 19, 2017 @07:35PM (#15965916)
>Bitcoin community has changed tone.

> It used to be "this is the currency of the future, down with cash/Visa!"

> but now you hear "Bitcoin is not a currency, it's a store of value".