Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by coldtea on Thursday December 14, 2017 @04:54AM
(#15921096)
But most Germans don't care for the english track in the first place, being used to subbed dialogue.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by egeozcan on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:29AM
(#15921230)
There are a lot of immigrants, like me, who can speak and understand German but miss a lot when watching movies.
Subtitles would help a lot but even that is missing with a lot of providers (I wonder what people with hearing disabilities do).
Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by distances on Thursday December 14, 2017 @06:52AM
(#15921567)
At least Netflix has always German subtitles. For series, English subtitles too most of the time, but practically none of the movies have those in English which I find quite weird.
Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by chrisper on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:08AM
(#15921152)
But there is no technical reason not to include other languages in 5.1? I would get the argument for DVDs and maybe live TV, but not for streaming...
Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by jhasse on Thursday December 14, 2017 @05:06AM
(#15921147)
It's changing. I'm seeing movies in English a lot more often in cinemas than I did 10 years ago.
Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by jonny_eh on Thursday December 14, 2017 @07:49PM
(#15928851)
Are you saying it isn't ridiculous? It's always ridiculous to not have the original language track in the best quality/format. It would be ridiculous for Japanese films distributed in the US to have the Japanese track in 2.0 and the dubbed English in 5.1
Re:How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
by freeflight on Thursday December 14, 2017 @11:00PM
(#15929588)
> It would be ridiculous for Japanese films distributed in the US to have the Japanese track in 2.0 and the dubbed English in 5.1
A far worse offender, for me at least, are Blu-Rays in that regard. During their introduction, they were hailed as allowing distributors to pack dozens of high-quality different language tracks and different subtitle options on the disc.
While the reality these days looks like this: Most Blu-Ray releases are still regionalized, very often with limited audio language options (in 2.0 quality) and sometimes not even subtitle support for one language.
I think a lot of that has to do with distributors pretty much forming cartels by region, thus having only rights to distribute only specific versions in specific regions.