News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by sidcool on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:09AM (#15914251)
Can't verify the truthiness of the story, but the US has become one hell of a paranoid state.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by slazaro on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:18AM (#15914308)
What bugs me the most is that a single ignorant person can have this much power, with almost zero recourse from the victim. But hey, "land of the free".
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by erispoe on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:21AM (#15914337)
There is major difference in the rights you have before and after you cross the border. That's true for foreigners, but for citizens too.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @10:11AM (#15914677)
The text of the Constitution disagrees:

>No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

Note how the early part specifies citizens, the latter part specifies persons. At border control a person is in jurisdiction of the USA legal system and so, according to the literal text deserves equal protection of the law.

I'm aware the established interpretation differs, however, the writer of the amendment clearly meant to extend the rights and protections to all IMO.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @10:48AM (#15914952)
The amendment repeatedly says "State", it isn't talking about the Federal government.

There's still due process to consider at the border, but applying border controls is pretty well established as due process.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:51AM (#15923193)
I'd missed that .. so they're not State borders, they're federal, and States don't enforce those laws.

Border controls wouldn't be wrong, it would be if you did unlawful searches and such that would be wrong.

Out of curiosity what legal move makes the State not obliged to prosecute the Federal government under this amendment for breaking the State law? States wouldn't be able to ratify it (it seems to me: otherwise they'd be making laws allowing unequal treatment of persons), so it must be pretty early and high-level - presumably there's a blanket Feds can do as they please (wrt state laws) that makes this possible?

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:58AM (#15923245)
Yeah, Federal law trumps state law:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supremacy_Clause

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:56PM (#15915945)
> The amendment repeatedly says "State", it isn't talking about the Federal government.

True, but the Supreme Court has repeatedly decided that the 5th amendment imposes both due process and equal protection requirements on the federal govt, just as the 14th imposes them on the states. E.g., see Lawrence v. Texas.

> "...applying border controls is pretty well established as due process."

This is a pretty vague statement, but it not really true in any sense. The constitutionality of our current border control practices is still being vigorously litigated.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @01:54PM (#15916478)
Which physical border search has been ruled unconstitutional?
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @02:50PM (#15917007)
United States v. Cotterman, for example, declared a major piece of CBP's policy (forensic examination without probable cause) unconstitutional.

However you seem a bit confused. You started talking about due process, but now you appear to be shifting the goalposts to 4th amendment issues.

Your statement, "applying border controls is pretty well established as due process", doesn't really make sense. Due process is only one of the many thorny issues that embroil the border search exception, and the exception's constitutionality along due process lines has not been decided by the supreme court one way or the other. Perhaps I should ask you, how did you arrive at "pretty well established"? Can you provide a bit of case history?

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @04:10PM (#15917684)
Aliens are detained upon arrival and may be detained at length. If the arbitrary permitting of entry that follows that detention wasn't considered due process we wouldn't have border controls.

My other response was a somewhat sarcastic reply to The constitutionality of our current border control practices is still being vigorously litigated.. It's the details that are being litigated, not the overall detention and search of foreign nationals.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by exelius on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:24AM (#15914357)
Hungary might as well be Zimbabwe in the mind of most Americans (especially the type to be working as border guards at the US-Canada border). They don't really grok that modern civilization exists outside the US, England, Germany and France. I wish I was joking.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by strictnein on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:57AM (#15914571)
Whenever I see these sweeping statements about a characteristic of Americans, I'm always struck by how ignorant they are.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by cafard on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:54AM (#15914556)
There are enough Americans of Hungarian descent in the US Rust Belt that the expression "Hunky" used to be heard there. I haven't been to Buffalo except passing through, but I bet the phone listings include a fair number of Novaks, Spisaks, etc.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by true_religion on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @10:03AM (#15914614)
He was a single guy with no family, no employer, no paid return ticket home that he'd lose by staying, who was crossing on foot from a country he wasn't resident in. Border guards will always get suspicious of that.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by thieving_magpie on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:45AM (#15914495)
That might be the most ridiculous statement I've read on HN. To the point that I can't even figure out what you're suggesting. Are you saying Americans aren't aware Hungary is a modern civilization? I'd say that was pretty off base.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by ionised on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @10:25AM (#15914774)
He's suggesting that most Americans don't own a passport, or have ever travelled outside the US, and have a tenuous grasp of world geography/geopolitics.

I'd find it hard to argue.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by thieving_magpie on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @11:04AM (#15915070)
Yes it can be very hard for non-affluent Americans to travel if they're not near a border. Like anywhere else.

Americans knowledge of geography could certainly be improved. I don't think it means anything negative about the people though.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by JBlue42 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @03:43PM (#15917482)
How is it not negative to be aware of the world around you, especially when you're (for now) the most powerful country in it and can vote for people that enact policies that have severe repercussions on many people?

Celebrating ignorance is one reason we have the current administration and Congress.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by thieving_magpie on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:21PM (#15919482)
You're putting a lot of responsibility on some regular people. Do you go around to Inuits quizzing them on Southeast Asia too?

Ordinary citizens do not vote on issues affecting an individual country. I'm sorry, you're just going to have to accept the fact that not all Americans are well educated.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by JBlue42 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @10:35PM (#15919755)
>You're putting a lot of responsibility on some regular people.

Putting nuclear weapons at the finger tips of someone is a big responsibility.

>Ordinary citizens do not vote on issues affecting an individual country.

They vote on representatives that tend to have a policies that might. See for example those running on platforms on building border walls, kicking out immigrants, banning people from other nations from entering them, pulling out of climate change agreements, etc.

>I'm sorry, you're just going to have to accept the fact that not all Americans are well educated.

I accept that's the fact now. I don't accept that that should be a fact for the country's future.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by thieving_magpie on Thursday December 14, 2017 @09:24AM (#15922412)
You'll have to explain to me how a guy in Oklahoma having a passport and knowing the capitol of Hungary is relevant to nuclear policy and the threat of nuclear war. Your argument is all over the place. We're not all rich here in America, many of us weren't given great educations and have the money to travel. It isn't like Europe where another country may be within a couple of hours drive or train ride.

I also accept that we should do better in Geography. That'd be swell.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by vilmosi on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:17PM (#15915617)
I don't think it's that ridiculous.

When you have tweets like this [0] from politicians it gives the impression that people do actually think like that.

[0] https://twitter.com/BernieSanders/status/705171336381923328

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by jprince on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:50AM (#15914525)
...well, I mean, it IS just next to Zimbabwe. Can't be that great, can it?

/sarcasm

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:20AM (#15914330)
I would say this kind of denial is par for the course over at least the last 20 years.

Entry without a visa also represents a relaxation of policy that existed 30 years go (just 10 years for Hungary!):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visa_Waiver_Program#History

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by lucideer on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:30AM (#15914396)
This may be true, but in this case (and I'm sure many like it), entry with a visa would be highly preferable. At least you can plan accordingly if your visa application is rejected and have a more complete record of the application/rejection/reasons given.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @11:06AM (#15915078)
As the submitter, my thoughts as well.

Regardless of the truth of the particular story related, there are sufficiently many similar stories I've heard that this one rings true.

And it's hugely negative for the US and its reputation abroad.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by weberc2 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:18AM (#15914314)
Anecdotally, I got roughly the same treatment when I visited England except that I was eventually permitted entry.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by iagooar on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:25AM (#15914361)
Your "except" makes this story 99.99% different from the one of the OP.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by weberc2 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @03:05PM (#15917166)
Of course, this is nonsense. Here's another data point; in this case, a female, American conference speaker was jailed at the UK border: https://medium.com/@rachelnabors/wtfuk-73009d5623b4