News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @10:48AM (#15914952)
The amendment repeatedly says "State", it isn't talking about the Federal government.

There's still due process to consider at the border, but applying border controls is pretty well established as due process.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:51AM (#15923193)
I'd missed that .. so they're not State borders, they're federal, and States don't enforce those laws.

Border controls wouldn't be wrong, it would be if you did unlawful searches and such that would be wrong.

Out of curiosity what legal move makes the State not obliged to prosecute the Federal government under this amendment for breaking the State law? States wouldn't be able to ratify it (it seems to me: otherwise they'd be making laws allowing unequal treatment of persons), so it must be pretty early and high-level - presumably there's a blanket Feds can do as they please (wrt state laws) that makes this possible?

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Thursday December 14, 2017 @10:58AM (#15923245)
Yeah, Federal law trumps state law:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supremacy_Clause

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:56PM (#15915945)
> The amendment repeatedly says "State", it isn't talking about the Federal government.

True, but the Supreme Court has repeatedly decided that the 5th amendment imposes both due process and equal protection requirements on the federal govt, just as the 14th imposes them on the states. E.g., see Lawrence v. Texas.

> "...applying border controls is pretty well established as due process."

This is a pretty vague statement, but it not really true in any sense. The constitutionality of our current border control practices is still being vigorously litigated.

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @01:54PM (#15916478)
Which physical border search has been ruled unconstitutional?
Re:What are you banned from? Why? by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @02:50PM (#15917007)
United States v. Cotterman, for example, declared a major piece of CBP's policy (forensic examination without probable cause) unconstitutional.

However you seem a bit confused. You started talking about due process, but now you appear to be shifting the goalposts to 4th amendment issues.

Your statement, "applying border controls is pretty well established as due process", doesn't really make sense. Due process is only one of the many thorny issues that embroil the border search exception, and the exception's constitutionality along due process lines has not been decided by the supreme court one way or the other. Perhaps I should ask you, how did you arrive at "pretty well established"? Can you provide a bit of case history?

Re:What are you banned from? Why? by maxerickson on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @04:10PM (#15917684)
Aliens are detained upon arrival and may be detained at length. If the arbitrary permitting of entry that follows that detention wasn't considered due process we wouldn't have border controls.

My other response was a somewhat sarcastic reply to The constitutionality of our current border control practices is still being vigorously litigated.. It's the details that are being litigated, not the overall detention and search of foreign nationals.