News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Deestan on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:15AM (#1590640)
A useful and somewhat though-provoking test.

But, it feels really frustrating not being able to argue back; especially when the test starts claiming logical conclusions regarding my beliefs and opinions based on technical definitions ("irrevocable proof", "justifiable", etc) that I disagree with. :-)

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by plorkyeran on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:46AM (#1590690)
The one part that annoyed me is when it asserted that an omnipotent god must be able to do things that don't make any sense, which is not what I thought the earlier question was asking. It doesn't do any good to point out an inconsistency that's caused by a poorly worded question.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by scotty79 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:58AM (#1590710)
No hits. My two bullets:

##

You stated earlier that evolutionary theory is essentially true. However, you have now claimed that it is foolish to believe in God without certain, irrevocable proof that she exists. The problem is that there is no certain proof that evolutionary theory is true - even though there is overwhelming evidence that it is true. So it seems that you require certain, irrevocable proof for God's existence, but accept evolutionary theory without certain proof. So You've got a choice: (a) Bite a bullet and claim that a higher standard of proof is required for belief in God than for belief in evolution. (b) Take a hit, conceding that there is a contradiction in your responses.

You chose to bite the bullet.

##

You've just bitten a bullet! In saying that God has the freedom and power to do that which is logically impossible (like creating square circles), you are saying that any discussion of God and ultimate reality cannot be constrained by basic principles of rationality. This would seem to make rational discourse about God impossible. If rational discourse about God is impossible, there is nothing rational we can say about God and nothing rational we can say to support our belief or disbelief in God. To reject rational constraints on religious discourse in this fashion requires accepting that religious convictions, including your religious convictions, are beyond any debate or rational discussion. This is to bite a bullet.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by anthonyb on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:11AM (#1590728)
I got bitten by that second one too. My reasoning was that rationality (or at least part of it) is likely to be a product of the universe in which you live. Assuming that God created it, they might be just as likely to create a different one where square circles might exist.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:49AM (#1590791)
The problem is, neither squares nor circles exist in our world. Talking about a world where square circles exist is meaningless.

Squares and circles are mathematical concepts. They often are a model of parts of our world. Of course, the fact that we created these concepts is a product of our universe. But the concepts themselves are independent of any universe. Therefore, they are independent of the will of God (if she exist).

The definitions of squares and circles alone are sufficient for us to tell that no square is a circle, and no circle is a square. That conclusion is likewise independent of our world and the will of God.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by anthonyb on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:07AM (#1590826)
How do you know that squares or circles are outside our world? I guess it's hair-splitting, which is what the questionnaire was trying to avoid (ie. it's not a rational/refutable proposition), but how do you know for certain? It might be hard to conceive of such a world - much like trying to think about five-dimensional objects - but that doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:38AM (#1590879)
> How do you know that squares or circles are outside our world?

I know it because of my overall education. If I had a different education, I might have believed otherwise. Anyway, I'm pretty darn sure of myself, and I have actual arguments to back it up.

Have you ever seen a circle? A real circle, and not just a clever disposition of graphite on a sheet of paper. Likewise, have you ever seen a number? A real number, not just a decimal representation of it.

Even better, have you ever perceived a circle or a numbers in any way? Do you know of anyone who has? Do you know of any experiment that could assess or falsify the theory that circles or numbers exist in our world?

I don't.

Because they are mathematical concepts. Mathematical concepts aren't meant to describe things that exist in our world, unlike the concepts of "rock", "human", or "electron". Therefore, you can't make a statement about our world using only mathematical concepts. They help, but they are not enough.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Locke1689 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @06:38AM (#1591075)
Depends on whether or not you consider yourself Platonist. Still, you fall into the same trap here that the ontological argument makes. Simply because a perfect instance can be posited in a system doesn't mean that such an instance must exist in that system.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by loup-vaillant on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @11:02AM (#1591646)
I'm lost here. I know neither Platon nor ontology. Your last sentence sound right, but I don't see how it connects to my previous posts.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Locke1689 on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:00PM (#1592381)
Sorry, fell into a little philosophical opaqueness there. Platonist is meant to refer to the ancient philosopher Plato. What he may be most famous for is his theory of Forms. The idea is that there are two worlds: the material world which we can perceive directly and another realm that is "intelligible" but not directly perceivable. We can refer to these as the sensible and supersensible realms. The supersensible realm is accessible through thought and abstraction: it is a world of perfection. It is this realm where perfect circles and shapes and ideas lie. In the Republic, he uses the allegory of the cave to describe the relationship between the supersensible realm and the sensible realm. In a sense, the sensible realm can be imagined as the shadows of figures on a cave wall, where we are unable to turn around and see the figures themselves and only to perceive their projections into the sensible realm. The most modern reinterpretation of Plato's philosophy is present in Judeochristian philosophy. Many would go so far as to say that Christianity is simply a dressed-up reinterpretation of Platonism.

My second section was meant to deal with a proof of God's existence known as the "Ontological Argument." I'm going to reproduce it hear and quote liberally from Wikipeda (I'm kind of lazy):

1. If I am thinking of the Greatest Being Thinkable, then I can think of no being greater 1a. If it is false that I can think of no being greater, it is false I am thinking of the Greatest Being Thinkable 2. Being is greater than not being 3. If the being I am thinking of does not exist, then it is false that I can think of no being greater. 4. If the being I am thinking of does not exist, then it is false that I am thinking of the Greatest Being Thinkable Conclusion: If I am thinking of the Greatest Being Thinkable, then I am thinking of a being that exists

I know that you are not attempting to prove the existence of God, but the argument bares some similarity, simply replace "Greatest Being" with "Perfect Circle." If there is no circle more perfect then, by the same argument, such a circle must exist. The trouble is this argument is deceptively simple. Bertrand Russell notably said, "The argument does not, to a modern mind, seem very convincing, but it is easier to feel convinced that it must be fallacious than it is to find out precisely where the fallacy lies."

Perhaps my favorite refutation comes from David Hume:

[T]here is an evident absurdity in pretending to demonstrate a matter of fact, or to prove it by any arguments a priori. Nothing is demonstrable, unless the contrary implies a contradiction. Nothing, that is distinctly conceivable, implies a contradiction. Whatever we conceive as existent, we can also conceive as non-existent. There is no being, therefore, whose non-existence implies a contradiction. Consequently there is no being, whose existence is demonstrable.

In this way we can see that conception (of a form or of God or of a mathematical concept) does not lead directly to any statements of existence or non-existence: they simply "are."

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by loup-vaillant on Wednesday August 11, 2010 @03:47AM (#1594141)
I may have not made myself clear. It looks like I suggested that numbers, squares, and circles exists somewhere, just not in our world.

I didn't want to.

The problem comes from the word "exist", which does not mean the same thing when I talk about the physical world and when I talk about mathematical concepts. For instance, when I say "Do unicorns exist?", or "cars do exist", I am talking about actual existence, in our world, such that it could change my life: if unicorns existed, I might see one. If cars did not exist, I would be riding instead of driving.

When I say "do odd numbers exists", or "there exists no even prime number greater than 2", I am talking about mere ideas. See, numbers "exist" by definition. In Peano arithmetic for instance, I declare that natural numbers exist because: (1) I declare that zero exist, (2) I declare that if a number n exist, then a different number, n+1, also exists. (There are other laws, but we'll leave them.) In short, numbers "exist" because I decided it. This is not the same kind of existence than unicorns. No matter how hard I decide, unicorns don't exist.

Now the fact that everyone agrees that numbers "exist" just means that everyone follows the same convention.

I actually agree with David Hume. He's right because of a very simple, now easy to guess, reason: mathematics doesn't even talk about existence of the unicorn/car kind.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:56AM (#1590801)
The second one bit me, but I disagree with it because I assumed that the previous statement of God's ability to do anything was necessarily within the constraints of a consistent universe
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by roel_v on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:34AM (#1590873)
Yeah me too. Whoever created this test has obviously never programmed in C or C++. The question says 'If there is a god...' but after that point you are outside of the Standard! And we all know that when you leave the well-defined territory of the Standard, all behavior is implementation-defined! So there may or may not be square circles, we have no way to tell :(
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by wazoox on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:56AM (#1590915)
I bit exactly the same. However I feel somewhat cheated by the first "bullet", because of the way the question's formulated. I actually don't think that you need "irrevocable proof" to believe in God any more than to believe in something else. However we actually need extremely strong evidence in both cases; evolution has very strong evidence in its favour, while there isn't any evidence that God exists.

Same thing for the second bullet : I stated that God has the freedom to achieve the logically impossible, BUT I don't think that it carries any weight because God doesn't exist and therefore it is all empty chit-chatting anyway. So rational discourse on the subject of God is of course somewhat hard to take seriously anyway, after a certain point.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by cema on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:15AM (#1590736)
I think the authors did not think of all possibilities. "Arguing back" might help them to improve the logical engine. I guess what I mean to say is that, rather than arguing back, we could contact them with suggestions.

Eg one thing they did not seem to consider is (my case) some of the implications of differences between the natural and the supernatural (say, God and the hypothetical Loch Ness monster).

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:57AM (#1590804)
uhmmmmmm, how would the Loch Ness monster be any less natural than God? ;)
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by adam-a on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:39AM (#1590882)
I got tripped up on this question too and I agree with the comment above. Loch Ness is a physical lake and Nessie, though perhaps a musical dinosaur, is allegedly tangible and physically there. It's not possible to get a submarine and go searching through God's lake because he probably doesn't live in one and if he did he may well decide to turn invisible just as you got close.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by cema on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @12:33PM (#1592076)
Why, the other way, of course. But my point was, the authors have not considered all the (potentially) important aspects, and we may help them with this. Or just have fun.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by sliverstorm on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:18AM (#1590644)
You don't have to get very technical to use the meaning of "irrevocable proof". Interpreting the definition to mean 'proof that cannot be refuted' is pretty straightforward, and not a technicality at all.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by andymorris on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:58AM (#1590709)
What about the everyday meaning of "proof" and "irrevocable proof" as "strong evidence" and "stronger evidence" respectively?

If I saw someone leaving the house of a woman (not his wife) with lipstick on his face and messed up clothes, I think I'm justified in calling that proof of an affair. It's not "irrevocable proof" though.

"Irrevocable proof" would then be actually seeing him in the act. Logically, though, it's not - maybe I was hallucinating? Maybe he has a twin? Etc. - the point is, language is rarely definite in everyday use.

I got tripped up on a few of these as well. I said that evolution is correct despite not being fully "proven", yet it was foolish to believe in God without irrevocable proof of his existence. My intent was to say that believing in a God would require a huge amount of proof, not that it could be "proven absolutely", whatever that means. The game decided that I was arguing that God needed to be literally proven in order to prefer the God theory.

I don't even know what would constitute "irrevocable proof" in any area bar "I think therefore I am" - and I believe even that has been shown to not necessarily hold!

-- Ayjay on Fedang/philosophy

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Deestan on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:08AM (#1590827)
(btw I probably meant to write "irrefutable")

A irrefutable proof in mathematics is no problem - no theoretical possibility of being incorrect exists.

But, if the phrase "irrefutable proof" in "softer" context is to have any meaning at all, it can't mean the same as in maths, since there will always be a possibility of being incorrect.

By using the phrase at all in eg. biology, it must therefore mean "the possibility of being incorrect is vanishingly small", otherwise we're just talking gibberish.

Generally, different context give the same phrase different meanings, so taking literal logical paths through a series of different statements is silly and pointless and best left to philosophers. :)

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by anthonyb on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:21AM (#1590746)
I'm not so sure that "irrevocable proof" really makes that much sense. How do you prove something and then revoke it?

Something like "irrefutable proof" would be better.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Deestan on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:09AM (#1590831)
Yes, that's what I meant to write. English is such a moving target.