News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by sliverstorm on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:18AM (#1590644)
You don't have to get very technical to use the meaning of "irrevocable proof". Interpreting the definition to mean 'proof that cannot be refuted' is pretty straightforward, and not a technicality at all.
Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by andymorris on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @02:58AM (#1590709)
What about the everyday meaning of "proof" and "irrevocable proof" as "strong evidence" and "stronger evidence" respectively?

If I saw someone leaving the house of a woman (not his wife) with lipstick on his face and messed up clothes, I think I'm justified in calling that proof of an affair. It's not "irrevocable proof" though.

"Irrevocable proof" would then be actually seeing him in the act. Logically, though, it's not - maybe I was hallucinating? Maybe he has a twin? Etc. - the point is, language is rarely definite in everyday use.

I got tripped up on a few of these as well. I said that evolution is correct despite not being fully "proven", yet it was foolish to believe in God without irrevocable proof of his existence. My intent was to say that believing in a God would require a huge amount of proof, not that it could be "proven absolutely", whatever that means. The game decided that I was arguing that God needed to be literally proven in order to prefer the God theory.

I don't even know what would constitute "irrevocable proof" in any area bar "I think therefore I am" - and I believe even that has been shown to not necessarily hold!

-- Ayjay on Fedang/philosophy

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Deestan on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:08AM (#1590827)
(btw I probably meant to write "irrefutable")

A irrefutable proof in mathematics is no problem - no theoretical possibility of being incorrect exists.

But, if the phrase "irrefutable proof" in "softer" context is to have any meaning at all, it can't mean the same as in maths, since there will always be a possibility of being incorrect.

By using the phrase at all in eg. biology, it must therefore mean "the possibility of being incorrect is vanishingly small", otherwise we're just talking gibberish.

Generally, different context give the same phrase different meanings, so taking literal logical paths through a series of different statements is silly and pointless and best left to philosophers. :)

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by anthonyb on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @03:21AM (#1590746)
I'm not so sure that "irrevocable proof" really makes that much sense. How do you prove something and then revoke it?

Something like "irrefutable proof" would be better.

Re:Are your beliefs consistent? Take the test... by Deestan on Tuesday August 10, 2010 @04:09AM (#1590831)
Yes, that's what I meant to write. English is such a moving target.