News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by LeifCarrotson on Thursday December 07, 2017 @06:37AM (#15869225)
Fair skin is a lot better than skin cancer!
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by tomhoward on Thursday December 07, 2017 @06:55AM (#15869301)
Sure, but higher melanin (ie, darker skin pigmentation) is correlated with lower cancer rates [1][2]. So the point is that cultural changes are causing people who were previously were at lower risk of cancer due to their skin pigmentation/higher melanin, to now have reducing melanin/pigmentation, therefore increasing rates of skin cancer.

[1] https://www.cancer.org/cancer/skin-cancer/prevention-and-ear...

[2] https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/skin/statistics/race.htm

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by kgwgk on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:08AM (#15869642)
Aren't those links about "people with naturally darker skin"? I'm not sure how cultural changes can affect that. Rich people may eat caviar, but eating caviar won't make you rich...
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by Sean1708 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:17AM (#15869706)
> The tan is caused by an increase in the activity and number of melanocytes, the cells that make the pigment melanin. Melanin helps block out damaging UV rays up to a point,

It's not particularly clearly worded but to me that seems to suggest that tanning increases melanin and that melanin helps prevent cancer regardless of whether your dark skin is natural or tanned.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by kgwgk on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:26AM (#15869762)
But if tanning also produces cancer it remains to be determined which effect dominates (unlike for people with naturally dark skin, where the effect can only go in the beneficial sense).
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by Fishkins on Thursday December 07, 2017 @12:45PM (#15872145)
Every source I've seen clearly states tanning always increases your chance of skin cancer. Tanning does provide a small amount of protection against burning (around 3 SPF worth), but no protection against cancer.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fact-or-fiction-a...

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by Retric on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:38PM (#15873275)
They studied based on 2 weeks of tanning which is very minimal.

You clearly get more than SPF 3 with a deep tan as you can spend 8 hours in direct sun without obvious problems. Without any tan you get a burn in under an hour suggesting ~SPF 10+.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by Bartweiss on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:12AM (#15870648)
Broadly, my understanding is that a major change in skin tone is 'worth' about 15 SPF, so tanning would fall somewhere below that.

For a fixed amount of sun exposure, spreading out the duration is better both to establish a tan and to allow more time for skin recovery. But there isn't really a case where tanning increases safety, because you get the tan via exposure.

It's like saying pilots who practice a lot are safer; for any given flight it might be true, but cumulative risk can only rise.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by Sean1708 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:30AM (#15870870)
I thought it was burning that was associated with an increased cancer risk, not just tanning in general?
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by scott_s on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:12AM (#15870645)
Indoor tanning is associated with higher rates of skin cancer: https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/skin/basic_info/indoor_tanning.ht... I suspect outdoor tanning is as well.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by tomhoward on Friday December 08, 2017 @04:06AM (#15877577)
We know that genetics and environment both play a significant role.

So think about it this way:

If you're genetically predisposed to having very dark skin, you will be able to tolerate more UV exposure without significantly increasing your risk of cancer. And by continuing to be exposed to high UV levels, your body will continue to produce melanin to keep you protected. It's a feedback loop.

If you're genetically predisposed to having pale skin, but then expose your skin to higher levels of UV than your low melanin levels can guard against, you will sustain significant sunburn, and if you do this repeatedly you'll significantly increase your risk of skin cancer. But if you gradually expose yourself to moderate levels of UV you can gradually increase your melanin levels more safely, but only as far as your genetics allow. (This is theoretical of course; we know very well that it's very hard for fair-skinned people to expose themselves to UV light from the sun or tanning beds without overdoing it, hence the widespread occurance of skin cancer.)

My educated guess about the notion that dark skinned people are experiencing higher levels of cancer would be that if a dark-skinned person keeps avoiding UV for long enough, their melanin levels start to decline (due to it not being an optimal use of resources), but then if/when sun exposure happens, the protection isn't as strong and the risk of cancer is higher.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by angry_octet on Friday December 08, 2017 @08:27AM (#15878477)
The notion of 'building up a tan' is dangerously wrong advice. Even for people with darker skin it is unwise to have significant bursts of UV exposure.

I'm curious as to whether your educated guess derives from a clinical background, or reddit?

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2671032/

http://www.skincancer.org/prevention/skin-cancer-and-skin-of...

https://theconversation.com/amp/sun-damage-and-cancer-how-uv...

http://enhs.umn.edu/current/5103/uv/molelcularmech.html

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by tomhoward on Friday December 08, 2017 @09:31AM (#15878793)
The notion of 'building up a tan' is dangerously wrong advice.

I know, I acknowledged that in my comment.

My main point was only about the extent to which people with genetically high melanin levels are at much lower risk of cancer (which your first link confirms), but how their risk might increase if their melanin levels drop.

I don't dispute that it's a complex and dangerous topic. And as someone with genetically very pale skin, I most certainly steer well clear of direct sunlight and make no efforts to develop a tan.

I'm curious as to whether your educated guess derives from a clinical background, or reddit?

That's a low blow :)

I rarely go anywhere near Reddit, certainly not for anything to do with health. I have spent 10+ years researching health topics for reasons to with serious, chronic, illnesses I've endured, and have now largely overcome thanks to what I've learned.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by angry_octet on Friday December 08, 2017 @10:09AM (#15879110)
It was a low blow. Sorry. I've been watching my uncle and father die slowly from melanomas, chunk by chunk cut out of their faces, their backs. My uncle still has a healthy deep tan.

And even last year I heard girls talk about building up a 'base tan' before summer. Roasting like rotisserie chickens under the solarium lamps.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by spraak on Thursday December 07, 2017 @11:10AM (#15871259)
That's what the above poster already said.

> people who were previously were at lower risk of cancer due to their skin pigmentation/higher melanin

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by kgwgk on Thursday December 07, 2017 @01:18PM (#15872531)
Unless the above poster means “due to their [acquired] skin pigmentation” I don’t see how the comment can make any sense. Why would their rates of skin cancer be higher now?
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by loeg on Thursday December 07, 2017 @01:45PM (#15872779)
Maybe OP is referring to spray tans? That's my best guess.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by macawfish on Thursday December 07, 2017 @09:52AM (#15870409)
I've known about the sunscreen misinformation for a long time.

My dad died of malignant melanoma. He wore sun screen all the time. He didn't swim. He would wear sun hats. He was paranoid, and likely had premonition of it. Unfortunately, his prevention methods might have actually exacerbated his odds even further because he was depriving his skin of one of its few natural healing modalities.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by angry_octet on Friday December 08, 2017 @08:40AM (#15878528)
I'm sorry to hear you dad died of melanoma. But I can guarantee that reducing his UV exposure did not increase his risk. It's possible that intense and closely repeated sun exposure as a child had already caused DNA damage.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3409870/

Anyway, please wear shades and a hat.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by macawfish on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:49AM (#15880007)
You're right, my father had bad sunburns as a child. Shades and hat are a good tip, as is reducing UV over-exposure.

My point is that moderate sun exposure is healthy and good melanoma prevention. From what I've seen, there is quite a bit of research to back this up.

I think that better education about this would encourage people to develop healthy relationships with the sun at a young age. Right now the conventional wisdom seems to be "just throw sunscreen at it" / "stay out of the sun unless you are wearing sunscreen" and I think this totally misses the point.

My caution is that it's unwise to tell people to avoid sun exposure in total. While sunscreen does seem to be helpful in slowing sun damage, it'd also be unwise to suggest that sunscreen will protect people from overexposure, there isn't really evidence for that. There is a whole body of research. Take a look at some of the studies cited in this article http://m.jabfm.org/content/24/6/735.full

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by GalacticDomin8r on Thursday December 07, 2017 @01:41PM (#15872727)
What does that have to do with the price of tea in China? Not smoking doesn't mean you will not get lung cancer.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by macawfish on Thursday December 07, 2017 @06:24PM (#15875329)
I know you probably meant that as a comment about correlation vs. causation, which is understandable. I agree that this is a complex issue, and that there are more factors than just sun exposure. But just so you're aware, your analogy rubbed me the wrong way. My father's death was definitely related to sun exposure in some way or another, and probably other factors like diet (he ate a lot of sugar), psychology/hormones (he experienced a lot of stress), and yes, genetics.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by jimjimjim on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:42PM (#15873304)
it's not misinformation. one anecdote in one direction does not counter thousands in the other direction.

Talk to some people in the southern hemisphere (australia and nz). There is a LOT of awareness of sun damage in these countries.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by macawfish on Thursday December 07, 2017 @06:21PM (#15875310)
There is misinformation about sunscreen. I'm not going to go and advocate that people don't use sunscreen, rather, for my own self, I've decided that it's important to have positive, moderate exposure to the sun in order to develop a healthy tan, to avoid overexposure, and to use sunscreen and protective clothing if I'm sure to be out in heavy sun.

It's a complex, dynamical issue and there is conflicting evidence about the effectiveness of sunscreen to just blanket reduce melanoma: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22994908

Not only that, there have been some controversies about sunscreens themselves containing questionable ingredients, some of which might actually be carcinogenic. If you're going to market your product as cancer preventative, but go and put carcinogens into that very same product, my trust level in your industry has been reduced by somewhere in the range of 25%-75%.

Somehow, in all this, there are people who think any raw sun exposure is going to cause cancer. That's actually misinformation. Melanin is known to be a protective. How can one go about increasing melanin? By tanning in moderation, letting your skin adapt to the sun. Of course there are people who simply don't tan easily, and yes, they should be cautious. But I'm fortunate to have skin that tans, and I'm going to let it do that!

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by angry_octet on Friday December 08, 2017 @08:52AM (#15878585)
You are misrepresenting the studies findings. It did not show that sunscreen itself is ineffectual, but that as a population measure for children that it's effectiveness was variable. Anyone who has children will attest to the difficulty of applying and maintaining the required level of sunscreen, especially as it is invisible.

If you have concerns about the chemical sunscreens, please use zinc oxide. It is totally non reactive.

Sun damage is cumulative, a tan is a reaction to damage. People with a tan have sun damaged skin.

Naturally very dark skinned people are different, and also have enhanced mechanisms to allow damaged cells to self-euthanize.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by JoeAltmaier on Friday December 08, 2017 @08:54AM (#15878596)
Not quite right? A tan is a reaction to sunlight, independent of damage.

Ah! Research, gotta love it. UVA darkens directly as a result of action on the melanin. UVB damages DNA resulting in long-lasting production of more melanin.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by macawfish on Friday December 08, 2017 @11:26AM (#15879804)
Right, it concluded "there is still no evidence of a protective effect of sunscreen against MN development in children". Melanocytic Nevi are precursors to melanoma, and childhood sunburns give people an early start in developing them.

Here's another study arguing that sunscreen might inhibit the inflammatory response without actually reducing the burn. Their abstract concludes "As such, sunscreens might promote instead of protect against melanoma." : http://journals.lww.com/melanomaresearch/Abstract/2005/02000...

SPF is actually measured by reduction of redness. That study points out that reduction of redness doesn't necessarily come with a reduction of damage!

If people are preventing their body from expressing its natural sun defenses and going out and overexposing themselves to the sun, believing themselves to protected... If that protection is illusory, that's kind of a recipe for disaster. People could be getting burned and not even know it... They won't even know to put aloe on.

Take that one with this one, which postulates that sun exposure isn't what causes malignant melanoma, sunburns are:

> Although there is convincing evidence that nonmelanoma skin cancer is related to cumulative sun exposure, there is less evidence of that association with CMM. If CMM were related to cumulative sun exposure, one would expect that outdoor workers would have a greater incidence of CMM than indoor workers. However, that is not the case. The incidence of CMM is actually increasing among indoor workers who receive three to nine times less solar UV radiation than outdoor workers. Furthermore, there is a higher incidence of CMM among whites living in northern states such Delaware, Vermont, and New Hampshire (>30 per 100,000), which enjoy less year-round sunlight and UV radiation than southern states such as Texas, Florida, Arizona, and New Mexico (<25 per 100,000). In California, whites living in San Francisco had a CMM incidence of 30.5 per 100,000, whereas those living in Los Angeles had an incidence of 24.9 per 100,000. There are a few studies that suggest that chronic, low-grade exposure to sunlight may be protective against CMM. In one Austrian study, those with chronic sun exposure without sunburn had a reduced incidence of CMM compared with those with recreational sun exposure. In Germany, outdoor activities during childhood, in the absence of sunburn, were associated with a lower risk of melanoma. Chronic, repeated sun exposure may allow the skin to accommodate to UV radiation by increasing melanin production, thereby reducing the risk of sunburn. An English study published in 2011 showed that regular weekend sun exposure had a protective effect against CMM, and the researchers postulated that this may be mediated by photo-adaptation or higher vitamin D levels.

http://m.jabfm.org/content/24/6/735.full

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by ChristianGeek on Thursday December 07, 2017 @07:44PM (#15875760)
It's going to take a lot to convince me, at 56 and very aware of sun damage to the skin of my friends who spend more time in the sun than I do, that "healthy tan" isn't an oxymoron.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by macawfish on Friday December 08, 2017 @01:29PM (#15880726)
"Tan" doesn't necessarily mean that someone got that tan through healthy sun exposure.

Check out JoeAltmaier's comment.

If you spend some time in the sun without getting a tan, it's still good for you even if you don't tan, as long as you're not burning.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by jimjimjim on Friday December 08, 2017 @02:18AM (#15877242)
gah! yes there is misinformation everywhere but 99% of it doesn't come from experts.

do some product research and pick a reputable brand. but don't try to scare people off sunscreen by implying that it causes cancer!

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by coldtea on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:05AM (#15870550)
Sun exposure != skin cancer.

It's like avoiding eating food altogether because you might became obese, or worse (given the odds) choke on it.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by lostlogin on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:40AM (#15870970)
When the time it takes to get a burn is 10 minutes or less, you might as well treat it as exposure = burn.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by kaybe on Thursday December 07, 2017 @11:53AM (#15871636)
After I met an albino woman travelling I really appreciate my very-white-but-not-albino-skin.

Sun lotion can only prolong your safe time, but 0 times whatever is still zero, as in her case. So there is a difference.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by coldtea on Thursday December 07, 2017 @12:00PM (#15871704)
That's when sunbathing on Venus. Or if you're a ginger or similar.

On good old Earth, one can sit in the sun for hours on end without a burn. In fact people frequently do, like all the time.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by khedoros1 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @04:54PM (#15874709)
With some SPF30 sunscreen, or sufficiently dark skin, sure. I'm not especially pale, but I'll start burning in under an hour of direct sunlight. "Hours on end" would be a recipe for painfulness.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by davidbanham on Thursday December 07, 2017 @04:02PM (#15874177)
It depends where you are and what time of year it is. Go to Tasmania in summer and give that a shot. Ozone layer depletion is no joke.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by lostlogin on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:07PM (#15875895)
Where do you live? I suspect it isn’t in the South Pacific.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by coldtea on Friday December 08, 2017 @04:51AM (#15877714)
In Southern Europe and SE Asia. Does that count?
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by lostlogin on Friday December 08, 2017 @05:11PM (#15882534)
No for Europe but closer for SE Asia. The South Pacific is worse due to the ozone hole which mainly effects regions below the equator. It has a savage effect on UV that gets through. Obviously a bad year, but check the below image and you’ll get the idea of the pattern.

https://www.livescience.com/46701-andes-highest-uv-index-mea...

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by jimjimjim on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:43PM (#15873327)
Nothing in the world is binary/yesno/truefalse!

More exposure to UV (eg sun exposure) leads to a greater chance of developing skin cancer.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by Spooky23 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:14AM (#15869683)
People who work outside don’t get skin cancer. People who cook themselves for fun do.

If they did, we would know, because workers compensation would be paying for it.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by dragonwriter on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:28AM (#15869772)
> People who work outside don’t get skin cancer.

Yes, they do.

> If they did, we would know, because workers compensation would be paying for it.

While state workers comp laws vary in ways which make this different from state to state, workers comp is paying for it for some subset of people who work outside.

http://blogs.findlaw.com/injured/2015/06/can-i-get-workers-c...

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by seanmcdirmid on Thursday December 07, 2017 @09:12AM (#15870069)
Many of them (like my uncle a few years ago) don’t last very long, so it isn’t workers comp that you should just look at. It is definitely something that happens.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by chrisbennet on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:30AM (#15870872)
Yes, they do. My father, a life long outsdoorsman and forest ranger for many years regularly had/has skin cancers removed once he got into his 70's. The cancer causing sun damage from your youth/working years doesn't tend to catch up with you until you're older I believe.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by kgwgk on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:34AM (#15869825)
Don't they?

"However, compared with the general population, the rates for certain diseases, including some types of cancer, appear to be higher among agricultural workers, which may be related to exposures that are common in their work environments. For example, farming communities have higher rates of leukemia, non-Hodgkin lymphoma, multiple myeloma, and soft tissue sarcoma, as well as cancers of the skin, lip, stomach, brain, and prostate."

https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/a...

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by jessaustin on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:45AM (#15871007)
Ag workers were routinely exposed to ridiculous levels of dangerous pesticides for most of the 20th century.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by mturmon on Thursday December 07, 2017 @02:34PM (#15873234)
This is a pretty well-known anecdote: men in drive-on-right countries tend to get more skin cancers in their left sides than their right sides.

This is believed to be due to sun exposure of the left side while driving.

See: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3117975/

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by psychometry on Thursday December 07, 2017 @10:05AM (#15870549)
Cancer is a complex, heterogeneous disease caused by varying degrees of interaction between inherited and exposed risks. It's just not as simple as you make it out to be.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by jsmthrowaway on Thursday December 07, 2017 @09:14AM (#15870079)
My electrician father who spent several years working on rooftops in Houston and developed skin cancer on his hand at 51 would beg to differ.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by bluGill on Thursday December 07, 2017 @11:38AM (#15871499)
Antidotes are not data. We have no reason to believe from your story that your would not have got skin cancer if he had spent all his time in a cave. Or maybe he wouldn't have, because he would have died of something even worse at 45.

Science is trying to work this out, it is complex. We know that sun exposure both protects from and causes skin cancer depending on the study. This is a complex subject, the only thing I think I can safely say is don't get a sunburn.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by King-Aaron on Thursday December 07, 2017 @07:44PM (#15875759)
You're completely incorrect:

https://wiki.cancer.org.au/skincancerstats/Settings:_Workpla...

It is estimated that around 200 melanomas and 34,000 non-melanoma skin cancers per year are caused by occupational exposures in Australia.[1]

http://www.cancer.org.au/content/pdf/PreventingCancer/BeSuns...

The 2006 Report on indicators for occupational disease highlights there was an increase in skin cancer claims per million employees/persons over a six-year period to 2004. The report says that given the long latency period associated with exposure and the onset of skin cancer, it is also likely that compensation claims greatly understate the real incidence of occupational skin cancer6 .

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by moheeb on Thursday December 07, 2017 @01:36PM (#15872679)
In this case his one point of data would be enough to refute the original claim.
Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by King-Aaron on Thursday December 07, 2017 @07:41PM (#15875743)
> People who work outside don’t get skin cancer.

That's a bit of a blasé thing to say... I have lost direct family members through melanoma due to their work requiring them to be in the sun all day, and clearly many other people here have too. I can't fathom how you would form such an opinion.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by ataturk on Thursday December 07, 2017 @08:42AM (#15869866)
People who work outside generally do not do it in bare skin unless they are idiots (of which we have many, many, many examples). You don't typically see military folks wearing shorts and t-shirts even in the hottest weather unless they are out doing PT because the work they do can be harmful and so they use clothing to protect themselves. This used to be common sense. Why do bedouins wear long, flowing robes in the desert? Same reason.

My father, who worked outdoors most of his life, always wore long pants and long sleeves even on the hottest summer days. I did not understand why when I was younger. I now get it.

Re:The Big Vitamin D Mistake by khedoros1 on Thursday December 07, 2017 @05:03PM (#15874784)
Because surely all of those farm hands will be able to prove that it was their outdoors work that caused the cancer 30 years later! And surely the insurance will pay to right those wrongs!