News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by patio11 on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:01PM (#1581585)
I know that somewhere in this wide world there must be a heartbreaking work of staggering genius remixing corporate logos, edgy speech, and full-motion video into a mindblowing coming of age story about tolerance and true love that could only possibly be shown in the Starcraft engine, but you know how I read this headline? Starcraft 2: More Zergs, Less Penis.

That is a tradeoff I can live with.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by zyb09 on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:27PM (#1581663)
No man, don't give up freedom on such short-sighted things like "we're better off them banning penis-maps". There are things nobody can imaging right now that also will never happen, because the environment is too restrictive for it. See, if Starcraft 1 would have had the same limitation that SC2 now has, the korean esport boom - a totally unexpected event - might have never happened and in effect SC2 might have never been developed.

It's probably silly to argue about ideology and principles in a video game, but this seems to be a trend that manifests itself in all facets of society. It scares me how people are willing to give up freedom, reasoning that it's probably not needed anyways.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by krakensden on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:04PM (#1581790)
It's a straw man argument, anyway- I played custom map games for WC3 throughout high school, and never once saw a penis map, race war map, or anything else particularly objectionable. There were a few copyright infringing maps, but most were either blizzard-derivative or bizarre and novel.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by CoryMathews on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:33PM (#1582098)
Which warcraft were you playing? it was constantly games where the map was just a nude pic. Really annoying.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by kingkilr on Saturday August 07, 2010 @05:44PM (#1584389)
Maybe this is because me and friends hosted a decent percentage of the games we played, but through thousands of rounds of Footmen Frenzy I've never seen a penis map. Starcraft I had a good deal of "sexy pics" maps, however I don't think I ever ended up in some unintentionally ;)
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by krakensden on Saturday August 07, 2010 @08:38PM (#1584652)
US West- it's possible it was different elsewhere.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by Gormo on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:14PM (#1582197)
You make a pretty good argument against a priori restrictions in general. E.g. who knows how amazing our cities would be today if urban development hadn't been forced into a static, prescriptive zoning paradigm for the past 70 years?

Too many people think about freedom in terms of individuals' rights in isolation, but its important to recognize that freedom alone encourages the kind of broad variation from which real, substantive improvement emerges, and is the true driver of human progress.

It's extremely important to make this point in any and every context in which it's relevant.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by dkarl on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:31PM (#1581675)
It's funny that a game about racial warfare with no way to seek peaceful coexistence could exclude "offensive content." Not that I don't cheerfully and shamelessly enjoy such games; I do. And I haven't played a sexually themed game since Leisure Suit Larry 2 when I was thirteen. I just think it's funny that they could get so worked up over penises that they would go beyond placating obnoxious prudish customers and actually advance the state of the art in prudery. Why in the world would they bother? Are they really that horrified by game mods containing nudity, or are they just control freaks?

P.S. What is the deal with "penis maps" anyway? Do people upload cool-looking maps that you enjoy until you're almost done and then BAM you get ambushed by a horde of huge, veiny penis monsters?

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by cynicalkane on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:18PM (#1582058)
When Alien-knockoff insectoids are fighting psychic space elves, that's not really a race war in the usual sense of the term...
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by goof on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:09PM (#1581804)
> Are they really that horrified by game mods containing nudity, or are they just control freaks?

I'm sure it's the latter. Having complete control over distribution makes it far easier to monetize the content. See the iphone app store for example.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by iron_ball on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:26PM (#1581661)
The file size limitation is the killer, if you ask me. Starcraft and Warcraft III both had huge mod communities which produced astounding content. In at least two cases, entirely new genres of gameplay: the tower-defense genre began with Starcraft mods, and the WC3 mod "Defense of the Ancients" has inspired several similar standalone games. Anything that limits the capabilities of mod designers is bad in my book.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by Retric on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:56PM (#1581763)
Sorry no: Tower Defense games began in 1990 when Atari Games released Rampart.[6] Early tower defense games later began to appear post-1997 in minigames for other platforms, such as Final Fantasy VII. By 2000, maps for StarCraft, Age of Empires II, and WarCraft III were following suit.[7] (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tower_defense)
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by wwortiz on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:02PM (#1581778)
Well tower defense was indeed further defined and expanded in warcraft 3 where it saw its biggest market, and this just further supports modding of games. DOTA however is from wc3 and it is especially amazing that there have been two independent games made from it, as well as many other interesting game types.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by ShardPhoenix on Friday August 06, 2010 @07:25PM (#1582619)
Given the large time gap between Rampart and the RTS maps, I find the link to modern TD dubious.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by iron_ball on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:33PM (#1582096)
Good point! I guess I never thought of those games as being quite the same thing, but clearly they're genetic ancestors in the "build-defend loop" family.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by SoftwareMaven on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:16PM (#1581835)
This is what I was thinking. Riot Games (makers of League of Legends) came into existence due to Defense of the Ancients. DOTA (and all the Warcraft licenses it sold) was only possible because they could build a mod of impressive size.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by metamemetics on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:33PM (#1581899)
DOTA is still a small file size (7.2mb) and there are already dota clones for StarCraft2.

The file size limitation for SC2 is only an issue if you want to include multiple custom 3D models for a total conversion.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by wwortiz on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:18PM (#1582057)
SC2 doesn't have as many characters as wc3 though so it may actually need quite a bit of custom 3d models to be on par with dota.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by metamemetics on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:55PM (#1582892)
The single player campaign has 3D models for every unit in the original StarCraft, as well as mercenaries, heroes, and unique campaign enemies that you might not have seen in previews or from playing multiplayer.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by iamdave on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:57PM (#1582300)
I was going to say, until I got to the end of your post, DoTA is a much better example than Tower Defense, which didn't start with Starcraft. Which after continued reading, I now see that someone has already mentioned.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by nochiel on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:17PM (#1582055)
"I know that somewhere in the wide world there must be a heartbreaking work of staggering genius..."

Works of genius that emerge from an openly (freely?) mod-able environment are not hard to find or point out: Consider "Team Fortress", a Quake mod and "Counter Strike", the brilliant mod of Half Life.

The kind of engineering and design effort that went into those two projects would have been impossible in the environment described in this article. Both those projects changed the world [of gaming].

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by guscost on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:31PM (#1582095)
i bought both of those (on source) after playing the original free versions. best game purchase ever, literally.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by wmf on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:27PM (#1582504)
So the creators of TF and CS are geniuses, but not genius enough to create standalone games? I realize that creating a mod is easier than creating a game from scratch, but doesn't talent always out?
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by gchpaco on Saturday August 07, 2010 @12:45AM (#1583070)
It is highly unlikely they would have gone to the effort had they been forced to write an entire game from the ground up. Both those games evolved from simplistic (sometimes very simplistic) origins to where they are today.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by gosub on Saturday August 07, 2010 @01:45AM (#1583116)
It's not just 'easier', there are different orders of magnitude of work involved. Modding a complete game is like fast prototyping game design ideas with a very specific DSL.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by njharman on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:31PM (#1581678)
> That is a tradeoff I can live with.

That is the attitude that has led to erosion of rights, that unfortunately, I'm force to live with.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by amanfredi on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:16PM (#1582344)
I appreciate that in general this attitude has led to erosion of rights. However...

I don't see how anyone other than Blizzard has any right to free speech on their privately owned gaming platform.

Even if Blizzard has created a new medium of expression in Starcraft II maps, why should they should be compelled to enable the distribution of any map they don't like?

I understand that people may not like Blizzard's decision to moderate their platform, but it's a big stretch to say that they are trampling on our right to free speech. Is a newspaper trampling on your right to free speech by choosing which editorials to print?

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by jasonkester on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:31PM (#1582376)
There are no rights here to erode.

It's the opposite actually. A few days ago you had no means to make Starcraft 2 maps of any description. Now you can, so long as you don't make an ass of yourself.

How is that not a good thing?

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by adamtj on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:12PM (#1581818)
Rights are inalienable, but their recognition by those in power is delicate and must be protected everywhere -- even when it doesn't seem like it matters.

Besides, how hard would it be to implement a reputation system instead of censorship? Bonus: they wouldn't have to pay the censors.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by teamonkey on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:57PM (#1582303)
> Besides, how hard would it be to implement a reputation system instead of censorship?

Impossible. They host the content, they're responsible for it, they're required to uphold the age rating the game is given.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by sigstoat on Friday August 06, 2010 @05:17PM (#1582345)
aren't there big notices on the box like "online interactions are not rated"?
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by teamonkey on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:21PM (#1582846)
It doesn't work like that. It's not some kid shouting obscenities down a crackly microphone. They're choosing to host the content, it affects the rating of the overall product. To keep the 'T' rating the content needs to be moderated.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by sigstoat on Saturday August 07, 2010 @02:25AM (#1583171)
i won't deny that mom and dad aren't going to care about the difference, a la penny arcade, but, from the ESRB:

"Online-enabled games carry the notice "Online Interactions Not Rated by the ESRB." This notice warns those who intend to play the game online about possible exposure to chat (text, audio, video) or other types of user-generated content (e.g., maps, skins) that have not been considered in the ESRB rating assignment."

has any game "lost" its rating, or had it modified, or whatever, because of user generated content?

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by rubinelli on Saturday August 07, 2010 @05:38AM (#1583333)
Rating boards aren't exactly impartial and scientific, as the "hot coffee" GTA incident showed. It would take exactly one report on Fox News about how young kids can be exposed to nude pictures while playing "SexCraft" to get Blizzard in trouble.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by Sukotto on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:11PM (#1581814)
I feel depressed to see you make such a shortsighted comment. Seeing it modded up makes it worse. :(
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by robobenjie on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:49PM (#1581737)
Does anyone remember the item that you had to carry around in the zerg single player missions in SC1? If that wasn't a giant penis I don't know what is.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by fendrak on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:31PM (#1581677)
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by lmkg on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:51PM (#1581747)
You were pre-empted by the article itself:

> "Keeping people from seeing your hate speech and obscene images on our private game service is not the same as relinquishing your constitutional freedoms in the hopes of increased personal/familial security," Bashiok continued. "Ben [Franklin] would tie you to a kite and let go of the string for making such comparisons."

While I don't necessarily agree that all user-made mods should be stored on Blizzard's servers, I also don't think that SCII map mods are a valuable or important form of personal expression. Blizzard isn't censoring an important channel for political opinions, they're making sure their game stays a game. This isn't necessarily a decision I agree with, but I think it's a defensible position to take.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by mfukar on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:19PM (#1582478)
If creation isn't an important form of personal expression, what else is left?
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by jsz0 on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:46PM (#1581728)
Does modding a video game really classify as an essential liberty?
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by Gormo on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:38PM (#1582253)
Why shouldn't it? Everything described at that level of specificity seems to be trivial in comparison to such grand notions as "essential liberty"; but if we want our concept of liberty to have any real substance, we have to understand what it means especially in the context of our superficially-trivial day-to-day endeavors.

Granted, given that this instance applies to a single PC game, and there are plenty of other games with thriving and robust modding communities, I'd hardly say this is an example of real oppression. But it's this kind of heavy-handedness - as we've also seen in their decision to eliminate LAN play - that has led to me not purchasing Starcraft II, despite looking forward to it for quite some time.

Which I suppose is just as well: Civ V will be out later this year, and I can't imagine Firaxis even having the inclination to treat their modders with such paternalistic contempt.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by gosub on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:10PM (#1581812)
Is a sub-case of the more general "freedom to tinker" with the things you own.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by m_myers on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:50PM (#1581954)
If I read the article correctly, you can tinker with it. You just can't use your tinkered version to host a game.

If I'm wrong, please correct me.

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by crystalis on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:19PM (#1582061)
Well, considering that their infrastructure also prevents you from hosting a game on your LAN or even playing it in an entirely singleplayer mode...
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by m_myers on Saturday August 07, 2010 @01:31AM (#1583111)
Really? Then that really does put quite a damper on things.

(I'm not much for MP myself; I don't think I've ever owned a game that didn't have a single-player mode.)

Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by nollidge on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:52PM (#1581751)
Or, they could, as the article suggest, not host all the content themselves, and then there's no need for a tradeoff.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by Charuru on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:26PM (#1581662)
This is not the issue at hand. Nobody would mind Blizzard taking down penis maps on their map browser, but that you CAN'T distribute your own maps by yourself is a big deal. This becomes a closed platform much like the Appstore. Seems like Apple is pioneering a few bad things...
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom by timtadh on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:33PM (#1581683)
patio11 reference: http://www.m.amazon.com/Heartbreaking-Work-Staggering-Genius...

see also catcher in the rye.