Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom
by jsz0 on Friday August 06, 2010 @01:46PM
(#1581728)
Does modding a video game really classify as an essential liberty?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom
by Gormo on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:38PM
(#1582253)
Why shouldn't it? Everything described at that level of specificity seems to be trivial in comparison to such grand notions as "essential liberty"; but if we want our concept of liberty to have any real substance, we have to understand what it means especially in the context of our superficially-trivial day-to-day endeavors.
Granted, given that this instance applies to a single PC game, and there are plenty of other games with thriving and robust modding communities, I'd hardly say this is an example of real oppression. But it's this kind of heavy-handedness - as we've also seen in their decision to eliminate LAN play - that has led to me not purchasing Starcraft II, despite looking forward to it for quite some time.
Which I suppose is just as well: Civ V will be out later this year, and I can't imagine Firaxis even having the inclination to treat their modders with such paternalistic contempt.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom
by gosub on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:10PM
(#1581812)
Is a sub-case of the more general "freedom to tinker" with the things you own.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom
by m_myers on Friday August 06, 2010 @02:50PM
(#1581954)
If I read the article correctly, you can tinker with it. You just can't use your tinkered version to host a game.
If I'm wrong, please correct me.
Re:StarCraft 2: help us mourn the death of content freedom
by crystalis on Friday August 06, 2010 @03:19PM
(#1582061)
Well, considering that their infrastructure also prevents you from hosting a game on your LAN or even playing it in an entirely singleplayer mode...