News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by Dangeranger on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:06PM (#15812131)
No, that’s not likely to have been the outcome without a union in place. The more likely outcome would have been a policy within their contract requiring the pilot to work in the case of a holiday period crunch, if the pilot were lucky enough to have any contract at all.

The 150% maximum pay was also likely a negotiation point between the airline and the union when agreeing on a contract.

You seem to think that negotiations between an at will pilot and an airline are on equal ground, they are not. The pilot is very unlikely to get a better deal outside of collective bargaining. That is why people are willing to pay a due and give up some freedoms in order to use them as leverage in compensation negotiations.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by vanattab on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:50PM (#15812366)
>That is why people are willing to pay a due and give up some freedoms in order to use them as leverage in compensation negotiations.

I am not ant-union but unless they live/work? in a "right to work" state I don't think they gave a choice but to pay dues or quit.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by nradov on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:34PM (#15813260)
State "right to work" laws are irrelevant here. Airlines are subject to the Railway Labor Act. Generally states have very little power to regulate airlines.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by vanattab on Thursday November 30, 2017 @11:50AM (#15817202)
Thanks for letting me know the airline labor regulations are covered by the Railway Labor Act and not the regular labor laws in the individual states that is interesting to know. So I guess I should have said that no matter which state they live in they don't have a choice but to pay their dues or quit/be fired since the Union contracts say that the airlines must fire anyone who does not pay union dues.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by emodendroket on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:27PM (#15812630)
But where does the union come from?
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by chimeracoder on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:32PM (#15812653)
> But where does the union come from?

Of all union members in the country, only 7% actually have ever cast a vote in favor of the union that represents them.

The vast majority never have the opportunity to vote one way or the other, because once a union is formed, it is legally granted authority in perpetuity. They only lose that right if a majority for decertification or deauthorization, but for a number of legal reasons, it's almost impossible for those elections to even be held, even in cases when the majority of workers oppose union representation.

So, to answer your question, "But where does the union come from?" - most likely, from the people who happened to work there years ago, when 50% (plus one) voted in favor of it. It may or may not actually represent the wishes of the current workforce, were an election to be held today.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by timecube on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:12PM (#15813412)
Of all employees in the country, certainly less than 7% actually have ever cast a vote in favor of the company that employs them.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by nitrogen on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:45PM (#15813534)
> Of all employees in the country, certainly less than 7% actually have ever cast a vote in favor of the company that employs them.

100% of people who accepted a job accepted the job...

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by dogecoinbase on Thursday November 30, 2017 @01:38AM (#15813902)
The majority of the employee pool in America is in a deeply economically precarious position. A month or two, or even a few hundred dollars make the difference between being able to house and feed their family or not. Employment in America is a gun to the head. The idea that choice is a factor in accepting (or doing anything to retain) a job is the delusion of a privileged few.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by emodendroket on Thursday November 30, 2017 @06:39AM (#15814988)
> Whenever I raise the point that it is immoral to shut us up in a close room twelve hours a day in the most monotonous and tedious of employment, I am told that we have come to the mills voluntarily and we can leave when we will. Voluntary! Let us look a little at this remarkable form of human freedom. Do we from mere choice leave our fathers' dwellings, the firesides where all of our friends, where too our earliest and fondest recollections cluster, for the factory and the Corporations boarding house? By what charm do these great companies immure human creatures in the bloom of youth and first glow of life within their mills, away from their homes and kindred? A slave too goes voluntarily to his task, but his will is in some manner quickened by the whip of the overseer.

> The whip which brings us to Lowell is NECESSITY. We must have money; a father's debts are to be paid, an aged mother to be supported, a brother's ambition to be aided, and so the factories are supplied. Is this to act from free will? When a man is starving he is compelled to pay his neighbor, who happens to have bread, the most exorbitant price for it, and his neighbor may appease his conscience, if conscience he chance to have, by the reflection that it is altogether a voluntary bargain. Is any one such a fool as to suppose that out of six thousand factory girls of Lowell, sixty would be there if they could help it? Everybody knows that it is necessity alone, in some form or other, that takes us to Lowell and keeps us there. Is this freedom? To my mind it is slavery quite as really as any in Turkey or Carolina. It matters little as to the fact of slavery, whether the slave be compelled to his task by the whip of the overseer or the wages of the Lowell Corporation. In either case it is not free will, leading the laborer to work, but an outward necessity that puts free will out of the question.

-- Sarah Bagley, 1845

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by username223 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:53AM (#15813783)
'Are there no prisons?'

'Plenty of prisons,' said the gentleman, laying down the pen again.

'And the Union workhouses.' demanded Scrooge. 'Are they still in operation?'

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Thursday November 30, 2017 @07:08AM (#15815103)
And 100% of people who accepted jobs in union shops accepted jobs in union shops. If accepting the job counts as a "vote" "for" the company, why doesn't accepting a unionized job count as a vote for the union?
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by djsumdog on Thursday November 30, 2017 @02:57AM (#15814117)
In a few cases I've had to ask for changes to the contract. I have never and will never sign a non-compete. I'll sign NDAs, and IP agreements and relinquish patent rights, but never will I sign something that dictates what I can or cannot do once no longer employed.

Once I walked away from a contract where they refused to remove the 1-year non-compete.

Another time I worked for a for a startup which had started out as an open source/volunteer project. After a big disagreement about the contract with the lawyer, the principal investor told me to 'sign the contract I wanted.' I refused to write my own contract and insisted the lawyer stop being insane and send me a contract without the non-compete section. She never did, but I started getting paid.

It worked out. The startup failed, I gutted the two commits that weren't mine and back-ported all the changes to the OSS version, keeping it all GPLv3.

TL;DR I accepted a job without accepting a job contract.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by URSpider94 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @05:53AM (#15814850)
I take your point to be that you negotiated on your own behalf, which is great.

I think it's fair to say that very few people have the savvy to know that offer terms are negotiable, and further that very few people are employed in high-demand careers where they can negotiate their employment terms 1:1.

The companies have information asymmetry on their side, since these negotiations are performed sequentially and in private. Mathematically, the Nash Equilibrium looks very different for n sequential negotiations of "who will sign this non-compete?" vs a single all-or-nothing negotiation where the company ends up with <n|zero> employees.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by lostboys67 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:54AM (#15814340)
But the members vote for the elected positions of the union and on the motions at conference :-)
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:17PM (#15812190)
> You seem to think that negotiations between an at will pilot and an airline are on equal ground, they are not. The pilot is very unlikely to get a better deal outside of collective bargainin

The pilots would most definitely get a better deal outside of the collective bargaining. That is, all the ones that get left out because of this contract receive no benefits at all.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by macromage on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:50PM (#15812368)
For anyone reading along at home, this is one of the oldest and most standard anti-union talking points. #1 on the list, in fact. [1]

[1] http://www.bankableinsight.com/ways-unions-hurt-the-economy....

[2] http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2011/03/17/unions-harmful-wor...

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:53PM (#15812384)
Because its true. Unions can only increase wages by reducing the amount of workers. Unions dont get wage increases by reducing the profits of capital in the long term.

If uber drivers unionized and made uber pay them more, then less capital would go to uber and eventually have less workers. Ultimately the return on capital will end up being the same, because capital looks for returns and will move. So in effect, it would only increase wages of drivers as long as it can prevent other drivers from showing up.

For anyone at home that wants to listen to someone that knows more about economy than any of us:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzYgiOC9cj4

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by gamblor956 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:11PM (#15812513)
Literally everything you said is FUD and a maliciously deliberate misrepresentation of the purpose of unions.

Unions exist to collectively bargain on behalf of workers in markets in which individual workers do not have sufficient bargaining power to achieve the same results. They remain in power in those markets precisely due to their continuing ability to achieve better-than-free-market rates for their members, as evidenced by the death/diminishment of unions in many fields where they are not able to maintain above-market compensation for their members.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by chimeracoder on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:47PM (#15812743)
> They remain in power in those markets precisely due to their continuing ability to achieve better-than-free-market rates for their members, as evidenced by the death/diminishment of unions in many fields where they are not able to maintain above-market compensation for their members.

They remain in power in those markets due to their legally-granted right to remain in power in perpetuity without periodic recertification or reauthorization elections.

That's not an opinion; that's legal fact, just like saying that the President of the United States is in power because the law grants him that right until January 2021. Unlike government, where politicans have to run for re-election every N years, once a union forms, there is no legal obligation to hold an election to keep them in power. (The process for petitioning for a decertification election is incredibly difficult, and unions are actually granted a great deal of leeway by the law in taking action to prevent these elections from happening. Furthermore, even in cases where they do happen, and the majority votes to decertify the union, the election results may be overturned by the NLRB.)

All in all, if you want to argue the case that unions successfully bargain for better results on behalf of workers, you can't really rely on the fact that they remain in power, because that's already the default - it takes an extraordinary degree of opposition to remove them.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by lostboys67 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:07AM (#15814400)
Union's have regular democratic elections for positions CEO's don't face a mandatory share holder vote every year or two do they
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by dotancohen on Thursday November 30, 2017 @01:54AM (#15813942)
I see that there is quite a bit of history and passion in what appears to be an old flame war, so excuse me if I'm asking the obvious.

Americans seems to favour "free market" at almost any cost, but you mention that Unions are not free market (for labor) yet they provide better results. So why the "free market" passion?

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:50AM (#15816644)
Would you make the same argument for companies that have monopolies? They achieve above free-market profits, so why the "free market" passion?

If you think of labor as a commodity, unions are simply a monopoly of labor. Everyone wants a monopoly of what they sell, and freedom of what they buy, this is no different.

I would be very hard pressed to find a good union case that didnt provoke some sort of restriction on other workes, either by wage fixing, protectionism or supply limiting.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by dotancohen on Thursday November 30, 2017 @01:11PM (#15818002)
I'm on neither side of the debate. Thank you for the perspective.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:04PM (#15812845)
The very link I posted tells that the union power comes from above free narket rates. I agree 100%. And it does so bu restricting supply. Unions have an arsenal of tools to achieve that.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by saghm on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:42PM (#15812715)
> Unions can only increase wages by reducing the amount of workers. Unions dont get wage increases by reducing the profits of capital in the long term.

Why do you think that it's mathematically impossible for a company to find the money some other way? Any profitable company by definition makes more money than it spends, so it's clearly possible for such a company to pay its workers more without having to reduce costs (i.e. hire fewer workers) or go into debt.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by gozur88 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:34AM (#15813716)
>Why do you think that it's mathematically impossible for a company to find the money some other way?

Depends on the industry. If there's a lot of foreign competition and workers aren't mindful of the health of the industry, they can easily kill it off. That's what happened to steel production in the US.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by zolthrowaway on Thursday November 30, 2017 @08:14AM (#15815422)
>That's what happened to steel production in the US.

*Some of the steel production in the US. I am certainly not making the argument that the steel industry in the US is as large or vibrant as the 70s or 80s. However, USX still does have several plants open and is doing fairly well. In my slightly knowledgeable opinion, this is because there is such a high up front cost of building a plant (especially a continuous pour caster).

The industry also made a very large shift from producing new steel to recycling scrap to produce slabs. Virgin steel is much harder to work with and produce than its recycled counterpart. This lowers the barrier to entry, increasing competition.

After this shift, I don't think there is any way that the U.S would have been able to compete with Chinese steel regardless of unions. Even if you removed all of the union CBA stuff and just left U.S compensation laws and OSHA, I highly doubt the margins are there to compete in regards to recycled steel.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:51AM (#15814329)
You're not wrong; if a foreign country can deliver a similar product without respecting worker's rights, it'll screw with the people working at normal income / safety standards. I guess that's one reason why import taxes are a thing, to protect the national workforce - hasn't worked I guess. I wonder if Trump and his cabinet have plans to increase import taxes.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by gozur88 on Friday December 01, 2017 @02:26AM (#15822507)
If I were king for a day I'd institute an across-the-board import tariff of 5% or so. Enough to keep domestic suppliers from gouging consumers, but also enough to tilt the playing field a bit in the direction of domestic manufacturing. It would hurt growth a bit, in the long run, but I think it's worth the cost.

Globalization increases equality between countries, but it also increases inequality within countries. There are places where unskilled labor pays a couple dollars a day. Doesn't matter what the safety standards are - there isn't anywhere in the US you can survive on that kind of money.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:20PM (#15812922)
If a company makes less money than others, it will stop investing investingn in itself and divert funds to more profitable ventures. The rate of profit will regulate the amount of capital. The amoubt of capital will regulate the amount of workers.

You cant reduce a compnies profits and think that will increase employment.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ethbro on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:16AM (#15813646)
> If a company makes less money than others, it will stop investing investingn in itself and divert funds to more profitable ventures.+

+ In a free market without monopoly in its industry

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @10:51AM (#15816661)
Is your argument that unions are effective against monopolistic companies?

Maybe, but it's an approach of looking into the abyss.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ethbro on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:42PM (#15819325)
I'm saying that statements like this:

> You cant reduce a compnies profits and think that will increase employment.

Have a lot of implicit assumptions about the market that company operates in, assumptions that may or may not be true in the modern global economy.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by maxxxxx on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:27PM (#15812625)
"Unions dont get wage increases by reducing the profits of capital in the long term."

Why not? Google could make half the profit, pay it workers more and still make a boatload of money.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:03PM (#15812839)
Google stock would plummet because people will sell to buy apple that is not following the same policy. So as soon as google does that, the stock dip will lower wages within and hire less.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by bobdole1234 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:23PM (#15813211)
Why?

It's not like Google or Apple pay dividends.

Google is currently handing out giant sacks with dollar signs on them to machine learning people far exceeding the meager means of most other companies, and the stock price is rising.

By your logic, shouldn't they be in the crapper for over-compensating these folks compared to what the market value?

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by ubernostrum on Thursday November 30, 2017 @07:12AM (#15815117)
A lot of people holding stock right now are probably doing so specifically in hope of tax law changes giving the companies more money, which will be used to buy back stock from shareholders.

(oops, I mean to make capital investments in the company and raise wages for average employees -- since a company in possession of a good fortune must be in want of workers to give raises to!)

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by jiaaro on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:59PM (#15813591)
Apple pays dividends.

Google is paying a lot for talent because of supply and demand - competitors are also paying high rates for the same talent.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by lostboys67 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:09AM (#15814410)
Employee salary is not a market in the same way shares are employers keep secret what they pay from potential employees.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by astrange on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:09AM (#15813627)
AAPL is no VZ, but it's paid dividends since 2012.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by sundaeofshock on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:51PM (#15813077)
How does a reduction in stock price lower wages?
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by bzbarsky on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:19PM (#15813196)
A significant fraction of compensation for Google employees is RSUs.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Friday December 01, 2017 @12:23PM (#15825411)
Lower stock means the company has less capital to invest in its own ventures, and less capital is less employment within the company. This is true even if no employee got stock whatsoever.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by lostboys67 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @04:05AM (#15814389)
Nope they can argue for a greater share of the profits of the company or better pension rights. Back when I was a union branch secretary I helped get several thousand people get a better deal from the BT pension scheme.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:49AM (#15814322)
TL;DR unions: a collective that can put pressure on businesses. Treat employees better, or they go on strike, see how the business can operate then. This will work for airlines, because if only half the pilots go on strike they'll have huge problems.

Doesn't work for Uber, because if half the drivers go on strike, pay will go up for the other half and more people are likely to work for Uber because the bar for entry is so low. Also no, uber would just raise prices. I'm fairly sure it was unions that made it difficult for just anyone to become a taxi driver though - protecting their own income, limiting competition etc.

Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by kalleboo on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:13PM (#15813172)
If unions gave people a bad deal, then why would anyone start working at a union shop? Unions would die out because workers would abandon the workplaces that are covered by them for more lucrative non-union workplaces.
Re:American Airlines Accidentally Let Too Many Pilots Take t... by conanbatt on Thursday November 30, 2017 @12:26AM (#15813676)
They do. That's why unions that subsist usually have some special command of power, normally enforced by the state.

For example, in argentina its impossible to hire pilots from other countries.