News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by tome on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @05:40PM (#1576027)
Are there any non-religious anti-gay-marriage arguments?
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:18PM (#1576221)
I'm against gay marriage and my reasons are completely non-religious.

Currently, marriage consists of a default package of contractual rights given from one partner to another (e.g. default will, medical proxy) and I have no problem extending this to gays. In fact, this part of marriage can already be pieced together with a few legal documents.

Marriage also consists of laws which force single people to subsidize married couples, for instance the non-working spouse of a worker gets SS benefits that neither spouse paid for. Gay marriage supporters are in the unique position of thinking about this issue and recognizing the unfairness of it. But rather than advocating for fairness, they simply want to be allowed to join the favored class. I'll draw an analogy to the civil rights: think of an Asian American in 1960 saying "I'm not against Jim Crow, I just want Asians to be classified as White rather than Colored."

As a single person, I'm in the same boat as gay couples. Gay marriage supporters want to throw me overboard in order to join the favored group, forcing me to subsidize a slightly larger group of people. Why should I do anything but oppose that?

Marriage fairness (i.e., no subsidies), I'll get behind. Gay marriage, no.

[edit: I thought my last line was clear enough, but from the responses it apparently was not. I favor ending marriage, or at least ending the subsidies for it. I also favor ending the penalties for it, which apply in certain circumstances.]

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by tzs on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:22PM (#1576607)

    As a single person, I'm in the same boat as gay couples.
    Gay marriage supporters want to throw me overboard in
    order to join the favored group, forcing me to subsidize
    a slightly larger group of people. Why should I do
    anything but oppose that?
Assuming you are straight, your being out of the favored group is your choice. At any time, you are allowed to go out and find someone who you find sexually and romantically attractive and who finds you the same, and marry them, thus getting the benefits of the subsidies you listed.

Gays aren't given this option. If they want the subsidies, they have to marry someone they aren't attracted to.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:48PM (#1576691)
Due to their preferences, gays find heterosexual marriage undesirable. Many straight people also find heterosexual marriage undesirable.

I fail to see what the difference is, apart perhaps from the magnitude of the desires. In either case, one must go against one's preferences to get a subsidy.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:51PM (#1576878)
Magnitude of desires? Unless you're asexual, you're not going against your sexual preferences by marrying a heterosexual woman. I have no interest in getting married and neither does my girlfriend. She's opposed to it on philosophical grounds (related to Prop 8, actually), and I just think the whole thing is a ridiculous sham. But, I would never throw an oppressed minority under the bus just because I think marriage is a joke.

I humbly invite you to go seek out a handful of people who identify as gay or lesbian and ask them why they feel like they should be allowed the right to marry, regardless of their intention to actually do so.

It shouldn't be very hard in the NYC area to find a handful.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:08PM (#1576921)
Unless you're asexual, you're not going against your sexual preferences by marrying a heterosexual woman.

Some people are in fact asexual, and prefer no sex. Others may prefer not to be married, even if they do wish to have sex with people of the opposite gender.

These are both preferences; what makes them less deserving of protection than a preference for gay marriage over straight marriage?

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:16PM (#1576940)
I understand that some people are asexual, which is why I mentioned that. Asexual people get a raw deal, there's no question about that.

I'm all for eliminating marriage subsidies, but let's take it one step at a time and recognize that there are literally millions of people in the United States who are being discriminated against by the state.

Saying that gay and lesbian individuals shouldn't be extended the rights enjoyed by the rest of the adult population of the United States because the entire institution is unfair misses the point.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by OpieCunningham on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:37PM (#1576653)
How about if we take it one step at a time?

First, remove the discrimination against one of, if not the most discriminated upon groups, gay people.

Second, remove subsidized marriage.

Since the second is a much larger hill to climb, let's be decent human beings and support the first in the interim.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:48PM (#1576329)
So would you be against gay marriage if marriage didn't have the side-effect of favoring married couples over singles (or so you claim)?

If yes, then you would have to amend your reasons for being against gay marriage.

If no, then first you're not really against gay marriage, just against marriage in general. But by opposing just gay marriage you're being selective which is discrimination i.e. you want to deny gay couples the same rights that are given to non-gays. Whether you like those rights or not is irrelevant - they're already given and accepted by society.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:04PM (#1576375)
Without the subsidies, marriage would be nothing but a default contract. So in that case, I'd favor making the contract more general and including gays.

Incidentally, gay marriage activists also favor discrimination against the single. I didn't want to start a fight pitting one unfavored group against another, the gay marriage activists did. Now that the fight is on, I'm obviously going to support my team. But I'd much rather join with gays and fight for fairness rather than against additional discrimination.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by jtheory on Thursday August 05, 2010 @08:21PM (#1579795)
gay marriage activists also favor

Ah. Have you talked to any outspoken pro-gay-marriage people, AKA activists? Like, all of the people in these threads who are telling you "yes, of course we're against marriage subsidies too, but pragmatically that has to be a future goal"?

You are not on a "team". You are making political statements (and probably actions, if you vote, canvass, or engage otherwise in the political process) that have real-life consequences for individuals with widely varying views.

"The Gay Marriage Activists" do not have weekly meetings that end with unanimous votes about how they hope the federal government supports tax cuts and special legal rights for married couples for ever and ever.

Maybe you just haven't quite explained it right yet, but I'm getting a strong fishy smell from what seems to be an argument that you'd "much rather join with gays and fight for fairness" -- except that you found out (somehow?) they all disagree with you on an issue that's, well, important but currently pretty irrelevant given widespread cultural norms.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by BRadmin on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:41PM (#1576308)
Based on that argument I'm not quite sure how you can oppose gay marriage. It would appear you would have to rally against marriage subsidies, or at least marriage as a whole, etc. - because singling out a facet of the group (or a facet wanting to be part of that group) you have reason to dislike strikes me as discriminatory.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:50PM (#1576338)
"It would appear you should rally against marriage subsidies,"

From my post: "Marriage fairness (i.e., no subsidies), I'll get behind. Gay marriage, no." In case that wasn't clear enough, I completely support eliminating all subsidies for marriage, and view gay marriage as a minor sideshow to the real issue. (See also my edit.)

I only single out gay marriage supporters because they are being jerks about the issue. Instead of pushing for fairness, they push for unfairness in their favor. Most people ignorantly accept the status quo, having never thought about the issue.

Gay marriage activists are not ignorant. They have thought things through, recognize that it is unfair, oppose the status quo, and still favor an unfair system. "I'm not against corruption, I just want the opportunity to participate in it." Why should I support them?

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by dieterrams on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:02PM (#1576368)
There might be gay marriage activists that are all about the subsidies, but this really isn't what the pro gay marriage movement is about. I understand that you see these subsidies as grossly unfair, but given that not everybody agrees, or even considers the subsidies to be the primary motivation for supporting gay marriage, calling supporters jerks as though they were all intentionally pushing for increased unfairness is kind of a dick move.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:07PM (#1576392)
To make an analogy: if there was law against selling alcohol to asians, I could use your reasoning to support that. I would say:

"I'm against selling alcohol to asians, because people who drink cause harm to themselves and to the society, for which I, as a non drinker, have to pay with my taxes. Reforming alcohol laws - that I'll get behind. Selling alcohol to asians, no. Asians are not ignorant. They have thought things through, recognize that it's unfair and still favor an unfair system. Why should I support them?"

In that hypothetical scenario I would be missing the same big point that you're missing: equality is much more important. Equality is about treating everybody (be it a good or bad treatment) the same. The opposite is discrimination. Your dislike of marriage in general does not justify in any way discriminating against gays by denying them marriage.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:21PM (#1576432)
In your analogy, the only discrimination is against asians, unless you mean to imply that there are subsidies for drinking (in which case, I'd favor ending both subsidies and anti-asian laws). In the circumstance under discussion, there is discrimination against both gay couples and single people, and I favor eliminating all discrimination rather than moving a small group from the unfavorable to the favorable group.

Suppose I reversed things. I want to allow single people to stop subsidizing married straight couples, but still require gays couples to pay subsidies. Would you favor that? Somehow, I doubt it.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by Karzyn on Thursday August 05, 2010 @06:21PM (#1579532)
In your analogy, the only discrimination is against asians

He's implying that non-drinkers are being financially discriminated against in a way analogous to single people regarding marriage financial benefits. Regardless if it's subsidies for drinking, as you mentioned, or otherwise the non-drinkers are being burdened.

What it comes down to is which is worse: A specific group being denied a right or a burden which that particular right imposes on the population that does not participate in it. Where you're running into trouble, in my opinion of course, is conflating these two issues together. Gay marriage and your problems with the financial aspects of marriage aren't an either/or thing, they're a completely different battle. Based on your comments I believe that the subsidy issue aside you really have no problems with gay marriage itself. So be happy that some people got more rights and gear yourself up for the separate subsidies battle.

Regardless, thanks for taking the time to single-handedly take up an unpopular opinion here.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by jetsnoc on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:49PM (#1576337)
Since you do not want to subsidize a favored class wouldn't it be more accurate to say you're /against marriage/?
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by madair on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:24PM (#1576245)
Regarding the social security benefits...in actuality married people in the U.S. pay what's euphemistically called the Marriage Tax, because the rules as codified actually require married people to pay more than if they filed separately.

Regarding the rest of your arguments, I suppose they work assuming an extremely weak social contract. Or at least, in my opinion it would require a very weak one. It's hard question to test in relation to marriage since marriage is a legally sanctioned relationship in all countries, but i am most certainly not well read on this topic.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:36PM (#1576294)
That's true for some couples, but not all by any means. It also completely ignores the marriage subsidies.

According to the CBO, 51% of married couples received a marriage bonus, and only 42% paid a marriage tax. In total, $32.9B was paid in marriage bonuses, and $28.8B was paid in marriage penalties. Data is from 1993, sorry, a quick google search couldn't find anything better.

http://www.cbo.gov/doc.cfm?index=7&type=0

Note that in 2004, Bush eliminated the marriage penalty for everyone besides the rich, so I expect the numbers are more skewed now.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by tzs on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:31PM (#1576633)
In the case he's talking about, where you have a working spouse and a non-working spouse, the couple likely pays considerably less in taxes than would a single person with the same income.

For any given income, a couple filing jointly with that total income pays less than a single person with that income, because the joint tax tables are lower than the single tax tables at any given income level. The so-called marriage tax is simply an artifact of the fact that we have a progressive rate structure, so that if both spouses work, their combined income is in a higher marginal bracket, which in the case where both have full time jobs can be enough to overcome the tax break they get from filing jointly.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kenjackson on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:34PM (#1576286)
That's a good point, regarding SS. See: http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/issuepapers/ip2003-01.html
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kenjackson on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:30PM (#1576269)
The problem with this argument is that I'd like to see data that single people subsidize married people. I suspect it is that wealthier married people subsidize everyone else.

But again, maybe you actually have the data that shows that single people subsidize married people.

One way to handle this is to separate out the economy into single vs married economies. Effectively different tax pools. Although I suspect the burden of single parent households on the single tax pool would be pretty weighty... especially if you get rid of child credits.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by gcheong on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:05PM (#1576384)
The problem with your argument is that you can join the "favored class" at any time so one could find that only gay singe people eventually subsidize all heterosexual marriages. So why not let gay people get married and if it gets to the point that the subsidies are so onerous then one would think single people - gay or straight - would be coming out of the woodwork to change that particular part of the law. You can't change everything at once and I think this is much more important from a non-religious ethical standpoint than any economic reason.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:14PM (#1576414)
Gays can also join the favored class at any time. As far as I know, there is no law saying a gay man cannot marry a woman.

Gay's don't want to join the favored class and neither do I. The only difference between myself and a gay person is the strength of our desires and the existence of desirable substitutes.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by gcheong on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:38PM (#1576479)
True, gay people can enter into heterosexual marriages. As for the subsidy, I doubt that will change unless the affected group decides it has become too onerous and starts putting pressure on their representatives to remove it. Which means that more people getting married could shed more light on how unfair the system is for single people. It shouldn't have to be this way but unfortunately that seems to be how it goes.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:09PM (#1576568)
That's a very cynical point of view based on seriously flawed premise i.e. that the biggest reason people get married is to obtain some financial benefit.

People mary because they are in love and they want to assert that loving relationship in the society and with government. What comes with that is a rich array of benefits and obligations. Most of the benefits (like the right to vist your spouse in the hospital) only have value if you actually care about your spouse.

So yes, technically gays can do fraudulent, non-gay marriage with a random person, but don't use it as an argument for discrimination by denying the marriage with people you actually want to marry (for a host of reasons that have nothing to do with the financial windfall you claim to exist).

Also, if there really is such a financial benefit to getting married, how come we don't have an epidemic of fake marriages? Your basic claim of financial benefit to marriage is not supported by observable facts.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by bmm6o on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:05PM (#1576380)
> I'll draw an analogy to the civil rights [...]

Who are you in this analogy? The only thing I can come up with is not flattering.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by bmm6o on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:11PM (#1576579)
Hey downvoters, it's an honest question. It makes him sound like "if I don't get mine, I'll keep you from getting yours", but I'd like to hear an alternate (more positive) interpretation.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:43PM (#1576672)
If it's truly an honest question, the mapping for my analogy is { "white" : "straight married", "asian" : "gay", "black" : "single" }. Since I'm single, in the analogy I would be black.

(Admittedly, it's a confusing analogy if you are unfamiliar with US history.)

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by icarus_drowning on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @05:41PM (#1576038)
I haven't found many. A vast majority are "natural law" arguments, which I think are exceedingly weak.

A better approach (from a conservative/libertarian side) is to just ask the question why government is defining marriage in the first place.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by eli on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:07PM (#1576165)
I'm totally with you there.

I was really surprised that to get married in New York, the officiant pretty much has to be a judge, the town clerk, or a religious representative of an "official" religion with an established place of worship. Seems awfully unfair that atheists have fewer options than members of popular religions. What possible interest does the state have in vetting wedding officiants anyway?

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:10PM (#1576771)
It is a legally binding ceremony so presumably you don't want that to be performed by just anybody. The idea that it's performed by someone who is licensed with the state and therefore officially accepts obligations that come with the right to marry other people seems reasonable to me.

As to unfairness, maybe it would be unfair if it would be a trouble to find an officiant that is not a religious representative. The way I see it is that allowing religious representatives to perform a wedding ceremony as accepting societal reality that many people are religious and are more comfortable when wedding is performed by a religious representative but in no way it constitutes harm to non-religious people.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by dieterrams on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:40PM (#1576305)
I disagree that this is a "conservative/libertarian" question, but I agree that this is the better question to ask.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:10PM (#1576185)
The main one I have heard is the slippery slope argument. If marriage is redefined as something other than a legal union between a man and a woman, where does definition of marriage come from?

In other words, if someone is for gay marriage, then on what grounds can they forbid polygamous or incestuous relationships or incestuous relationships?

Of course, this assumes that these other less popular alternative lifestyles should be forbidden as well.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by brianwillis on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:59PM (#1576355)
Marriage has evolved over time. If it didn't, then it probably wouldn't be around any more.

Examples: -Inter-racial marriage was once illegal in the US. Now it's not.

-Marriage was used as a tool to forge alliances between royal families in Europe. Now it's not.

-In Europe, it was once common for a bride's family to pay a dowry as a part of the marriage agreement. Now it's not.

My point is that elements of our collective cultures evolve all the time. The concept of marriage exists to serve culture that it's a part of, not the other way around.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:16PM (#1576939)
The relationship between marriage and culture and society is complex. A majority of the society in California voted for Proposition 8.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:35PM (#1576475)
It's about discrimination, there's no slope.

It's discrimination because non-gays can marry and gays cannot.

This does not apply to polygamous or incestuous relationships. Those are not recognized by law, but they are denied to everyone equally.

Also, "union between a man and a woman" does cover incest so clearly that's not the definition used by courts when deciding who can marry. Your premise is flawed and even if it wasn't, you're just trying to confound completely separate issues.

Again, it's about discrimination.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:34PM (#1576835)
Absolutely, it is about discrimination. Gays marriage choices are discriminated against based solely on the gender of their desired spouse. As ridiculous as it is, the law allows a gay woman to marry any man that they want.

However, the law discriminates against polygamous relationships based on the number of people involved and incestuous relationships based solely on who their relatives are.

The argument is, why is discrimination against gender bad, but discrimination against relatives is ok. If two brothers want to get married, why should that relationship be denied by the law?

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:01PM (#1576905)
You can't marry any sibling, regardless of gender. You can marry some people, but it's gender-dependent. It's called equal protection for a reason.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:12PM (#1576933)
Both gender and relationship to the potential spouse are attributes of a person that cannot be changed. Why is it ok to discriminate based on one but not the other?
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:13PM (#1576935)
That's irrelevant. No one can marry a sibling. Anyone can marry the opposite gender.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by Jun8 on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:07PM (#1576395)
Exactly. This would be one of main arguments against the typical "it's a consensual adult thing, what is it to you!" argument for gay marriage. In fact, to many people, a polygamous relationship between a man and many wives would be more "natural"than gay marriage (e.g. some Muslim countries, where gayness may be punishable by death by Sharia law allows more than one wife).

Same logic applies to incestuous marriage, although this would be more extreme since there are very strong taboos against it (not throughout all history, though, e.g. in Ancient Egypt pharaohs mostly married their sisters).

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:12PM (#1576586)
Your premise is flawed. The ruling stroke down the law as violating constitutional rights of gays because they are denied benefits that are given to non-gays. Period.

You're arguing a straw-man.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:55PM (#1576346)
don't forget bestiality. If a man and a consenting horse wish to get married who are we to deny them that right!
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by MartinCron on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:00PM (#1576361)
-1 Horses can't give meaningful consent, silly.

+1 You spelled bestiality correctly.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by OpieCunningham on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:50AM (#1577417)
How about a man and a chicken? If you tell me a chicken can't give meaningful consent and therefore a man can't force a chicken into marriage, then what right do we have to eat them?

Seriously, I'm not joking.

It is a valid point when arguing against gay marriage to point to the "slippery slope" of bestiality. But it is also a valid point to state that there's really no good reason to make marrying a chicken illegal. Fundamentally, I believe most opposition to gay marriage is based upon disgust. And I'm confident the same is true for marrying a chicken. Disgust is hardly an adequate justification.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:04PM (#1576379)
How about a dolphin. They're pretty intelligent.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by mynameishere on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:20PM (#1576226)
The practical purpose of marriage is to give protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing. This doesn't apply to gay "marriage", except in contrived cases. I'm actually yet to hear an argument in the favor of gay marriage that doesn't do one of the following:

1. Torture the definition of "equal". As if a law specifically designed to cover a specific relationship between a "man and a woman" is somehow invalid, whereas laws that cover specific relationships between a "lawyer and client" or "doctor and patient" or "parent and child" or "employer and employee" or "clergyman and worshipper" or 1000s and 1000s of others are never considered unconstitution.

2. Appeal to emotion. Ie, domestic partners can't automatically visit each other in the hospital when one is incapacitated, etc.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by Niten on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:29PM (#1576463)
> The practical purpose of marriage is to give protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing.

[citation needed]

Accepting that for the sake of argument — suppose I'm sterile, then. Or I just don't plan on having any kids. Do I still have a right to all the benefits that heterosexual couples obtain from legally recognized marriage? If so, then on what basis are those rights granted to me, but not to my gay neighbors next door? (I'm seriously curious whether you'll say no, sterile couples don't deserve those rights, or whether you'll just engage in more special pleading toward the prescribed end of denying marriage rights to gay couples.)

But back in reality, those of my friends who've gotten married already had many reasons for doing so, and "giving protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing" certainly wasn't at the top of their lists.

And dismissing discussion of crucial benefits such as the right to visit your husband or wife in the hospital as "appeals to emotion" is nothing short of absurd.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by MartinCron on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:59PM (#1576354)
The practical purpose of marriage is to give protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing.

That is maybe one practical purpose of marriage, but it's not the legal basis, and there's a lot more to it from a societal perspective.

I think the lawyer/client and doctor/patient argument is interesting, but feels a little hollow, because people are in a position to choose to become doctors, lawyers, clients, and patients freely. There is no inherent discrimination in those relationships. Would you expect a special class of legal relationships between a black man and a white woman? I wouldn't.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by GiraffeNecktie on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:34PM (#1576469)
I can't believe you're being voted down. The idea that marriage is solely for the purpose of childbearing is patently absurd. Marriage is a lifelong partnership with a myriad of benefits and responsibilities, some of which are recognized and codified by the state. The state also recognizes that marriage provides enormous good to society, not only child care, but also care of the aging, the unemployed and the infirm. It is also a partnership that is deeper, longer lasting and more important to society than that between any lawyer/barber/personal trainer and client.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by tzs on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:47PM (#1576685)
> The practical purpose of marriage is to give protections to the woman who bears a greater liability in childbearing.

Got a cite for that? If protection of childbearing women were such a great concern, wouldn't we expect societies to have historically provided much more protection to children born by non-married women, too? Yet historically when the Lord diddled the maid, neither the maid nor her bastard received any protection at all. Why single out married women to receive protection?

It seems far more likely to me that marriage was to provide a stable framework upon which to build a predictable system of inheritance of land. When the Lord dies, you really want to have a clear transfer of ownership, for the good of the estate and the commoners who depend on it.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:06PM (#1576390)
If I could upvote this 100 times, I would. Well put.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by chc on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @05:48PM (#1576065)
None with much plausibility. There are a lot of secular anti-gay-marriage arguments put forth by religious people, but they are, without fail, far less rational than the religious arguments.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by rubashov on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:08PM (#1576397)
You don't have to be religious to notice that exclusively vanilla heterosexual marriage has been common to all advanced societies. There are plenty of other models, but any culture that rose to power picked the one.

It seems to me perfectly reasonable to assert that there will be unknown consequences to screwing with a system that has worked reasonably well.

The last time marriage was tinkered with back in the 60s, no fault divorce and alimony as normal were tacked on. Infidelity was also decriminalized. I find it very easy to believe millions of broken homes and fatherless children were a direct consequence. The social consequences in lower socio-economic strata have been severe in a way that educated people generally don't comprehend.

In conclusion, the conservative impulse to "conserve" social institutions that have a long track record of success is not fundamentally religious. It comes from the same place as environmentalism: don't go screwing with complex systems you probably don't fully understand.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by chc on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:34PM (#1576645)
Why don't we apply to the same logic to every potential decision? Many Republican tax cuts have been unprecedented, so (il)logically conservatives should have opposed them. The iPhone is a disruptive technology will have "unknown consequences", so clearly it should be banned.

The reason we don't apply this idea (except to things we already disagree with) is because it's completely illogical. Caution is one thing, but simply dismissing every idea that could have "unknown consequences" is a great way to make sure that literally nothing gets done. It is certainly not rational. It is, in a word, FUD.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by rubashov on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:44PM (#1576676)
Communications technology is to fundamental social institutions and mores as apples are to oranges.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by chc on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:10PM (#1576773)
It's about as similar to social institutions as marriage is to divorce, which you tried to equate. Probably more similar, actually, since marriage and divorce are opposites while communication is a keystone of society that's intimately involved in most of its institutions.

At any rate, saying America's current implementation of marriage is a social institution going back through all of history and geography is just plain weird. Even in the modern age, marriage means very different things to different cultures, and that's ignoring all the "marriage" constructs that have existed in the past. Outlawing polygamy was a greater offense to the history of marriage than allowing gays to marry.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by madair on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:21PM (#1576234)
There are rational arguments, mostly coming from evolutionary psychology and similar domains. The arguments tend to fall apart under rational scrutiny when used to shape human behavior rather than simply explain it.

A couple recent articles by Robin Hanson about polygamy cover similar terrain in interesting ways. The arguments, particularly in the second article, more or less break it down to the problems of utilitarianism.

http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/07/polygamy-hypocrisy.htm...

http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/07/hypergamy-and-polygamy...

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by jberryman on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:13PM (#1576196)
Well I can see the idea of a gay couple raising a child sounding like a strange and dangerous idea to someone who hasn't been exposed to it, religious or not. For example: couldn't this lead to children being confused about their own sexual identity?

But one of the reasons for this ruling was that it was shown in the court-room that children do as well when raised by a same-sex couple as by a heterosexual one. It then follows that recognizing those couples would be even better for those families.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by MartinCron on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:37PM (#1576295)
We live in a hetero-normative society. Hetero couples are everywhere in media and popular culture. I'm pretty sure that kids being raised by same-sex parents can see that different people have different sexual orientations and work that out.

I'm sure it's harder for young gay people to have straight parents than for young straight people to have gay parents, yet nobody ever worries about that scenario.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by defen on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @05:55PM (#1576100)
We (culturally) have thousands of years of social and legal experience with heterosexual marriage. It's a very complex institution. Making a radical change to it may have unintended consequences.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by lmkg on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:10PM (#1576180)
My view is that allowing gay marriage is itself a consequence (probably unintended but still welcome) of other radical changes to the institution of marriage in Western society in the last century or two. Such changes include the view of a marriage as a personal unit rather than an economic one united by love rather than mutual economic and social benefit, and the general increase of women's rights and convergence of gender roles (for example, women can own property, and are not treated as being property themselves). The whole "soulmate" thing is a relatively recent idea, but is the current ideal for marriage.

We have thousand of years of experience with a variety of institutions that share the name "marriage" but aren't very similar to each other. The current institution that bears that name has arguably only been around for about forty years, most recently being re-written by the sexual revolution and the increasing social acceptance of divorcing and re-marrying. Considering how flexible we as a society have become with respect to gender roles, this change is hardly "radical" by comparison.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by jwhitlark on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:36PM (#1576293)
No, actually we don't. Marriage throughout history had very different social and legal rules. Inheritance rules, power, authority, and care-taking of children are elements that have changed radically over the years.

It would be accurate to say we've had experience with many different kinds of heterosexual marriage, but once you're lumping in, say, 16th century English marriage laws and customs with 21st century Californian ones, gender starts to look like a minor detail.

We talk about "marriage" as if it's a simple, single idea, but historically, it's been applied to a wide range activities.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by GiraffeNecktie on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:38PM (#1576480)
Where is the radical change? Allowing a tiny sliver of the population to enjoy the same privileges and responsibilities as the rest of us?

Let's be clear here: compulsory gay marriage would be radical. Allowing gay people to marry is not.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:57PM (#1576726)
It clearly can be debated what is and isn't radical change.

However, "Allowing a tiny sliver of the population to enjoy the same privileges and responsibilities as the rest of us?" can be a radical change. For example, it's exactly what happened when we abolished slavery.

I'm not trying to equalize slavery with gay marriage, just to point out that something that fits your criteria can be considered a radical change.

As to gay marriage rights, given that a majority of US population is against it (as was proved in California, one of the most progressive states, with Prop 8), the fact that courts suppressed Prop 8 is pretty radical. It pushes the equality goalpost a little bit further.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by GiraffeNecktie on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:12PM (#1576781)
Well either you are comparing the abolition of slavery to gay marriage or you aren't. The abolition of slavery was a radical change by any measure. The adoption of gay marriage has had no discernible impact in any country or jurisdiction where it has been tried. Except that a tiny vulnerable minority of the population is a whole lot happier and more secure. The rest of us haven't noticed a thing. It's just not that big a deal, except for the people who need and deserve it.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:10PM (#1576930)
actually, it has had a discernible impact: geographies that have allowed it have or will see increased economic activity: http://www.missourirecord.com/news/index.asp?article=10072

Repliers: don't bother citing the contradictory NOM study. If you believe anything they have to say, there is no room for conversation between us. The study hinges on an argument from Tony Perkins' Family Research Council, which is about as biased as any organization can be.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by Legion on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:13PM (#1576194)
I really hope nobody tries to use the internet to promote that argument.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:46PM (#1576324)
I'm against gay marriage for non-religious reasons. Civil partnerships fine, have the same rights and freedoms as married couples, just call it a civil partnership instead.

But IMHO this isn't hacker news and will pretty quickly get nasty.

edit: Also for same reasons as http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1576226

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:55PM (#1576349)
From what you wrote you're against gay marriage for no reason at all. You stated a preference for how things should be, not a reason for that preference.

And you seem strangely preoccupied with semantics. If marriage and civil partnership meant the same thing, what would be the point of having a distinction?

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:12PM (#1576403)
I think arguing that it must be called 'marriage' is petty. Redefining that word and stretching it to encompass more things is just stupid and less useful.

Sure, give them the same rights if you like, but just call it a 'civil partnership'.

If it was just about the rights, then I'd expect people to be happy with that. But it seems to be more about forcing an opinion onto others, which I disagree with.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by thingie on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:03PM (#1576548)
So instead of just using the word marriage for something that IS a marriage, we have to invent another term that doesn't mean anything else than marriage, but of two people who are of the same sex. Just because we have to. And that isn't petty.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:36AM (#1577389)
It may be a 'marriage' as you like to define the word, but that doesn't magically make it so.

Shall we use 'marriage' to also cover the union of a man to a horse? man to a table? man to a child? They have civil rights too!

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by thingie on Thursday August 05, 2010 @03:55AM (#1577481)
I've seen many things described as a marriage. Like special diplomatic relations between countries, business mergers, even product announcements. And I think that people can understand this. Once again, try to describe civil partnerships to somebody. What are you going to do? Say 'It's like a marriage, just don't call it so, because I don't like it'

(In the same way, I'd even describe your reason as 'religious, just there are no gods and churches and other deities involved'. We are also used to call fanboy disputes between the text editors or operating systems as religious wars. And it's a very good description.)

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Thursday August 05, 2010 @05:12AM (#1577588)
>> "(In the same way, I'd even describe your reason as 'religious, just there are no gods and churches and other deities involved'"

I'd be happy calling my argument 'historical'. I don't like changing things that have served us well for centuries.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by thingie on Thursday August 05, 2010 @08:01AM (#1577837)
That's exclusive, not inclusive 'us', I believe. This thing isn't serving me well. In fact, it is serving me very badly (gay marriage isn't going to improve that very much, though any remedy is welcome).
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by ErrantX on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:13PM (#1576407)
I remember in about '06 there was a really complicated debate I mediated on the civil partnerships page. It basically boiled down to how civil partnerships were viewed; some editors were so dead set against not equating civil partnerships to marriage (in terms of them meaning essentially the same thing, just that marriage has a historical and social aspect to it).

Point is; the argument really did just boil down to your summary - there was no actual argument just lots of folded arms and grumbling.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by lutorm on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:32PM (#1576640)
Civil partnerships do not have the same rights. The federal government does not recognize them and as a consequence gay/lesbian people are not able to sponsor their partners for permanent residency. I know some international gay couples who can't live in the US due to this.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by Jun8 on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:34PM (#1576470)
First of all, religious arguments against or for anything should be irrelevant in civil arguments, it's a question of human rights. For example, the recent discussions on wearing burqas does center on whether their use is religiously dictated or not but rather the trade-offs of the rights between wearers and society at large.

This trade-off point is my main counter argument. Specifically, this means that gay marriage can have drawbacks for the society, e.g. (i) as others point out, the same logic (consenting adults, personal rights, etc.) can be used to argue for polygamy and other forms of relationships that are outside current society's norms; (ii) it may have adverse affects on the couples children.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:33PM (#1576643)
You're missing the main point: it's about discrimination.

A law that would forbid wearing a burqa as a societal trade-off would apply to everyone equally hence it wouldn't be discrimination. Even though it would affect the most people of a certain religion, it would also apply to secular burqa wearers.

The main issue with a law that forbids gays to marry, and the reason it's discrimination, is that it denies them a right that everyone else has.

Whether polygamy is legal or not has nothing to do with it. The law forbids a specific behavior (polygamy) and it applies to everyone so is not discriminatory. Constitutionally, it's in the same league as a law that forbids smoking in public places or, for that matter, killing people.

So you're left with only one potential argument: that gay marriage causes specific, societal harm that is not caused by non-gay marriage. I would like to see a solid proof of that. "It may have" is not one.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by shotmaker on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @05:57PM (#1576108)
1. The people voted and agreed on California's definition of marriage to be one man and one women. The people's vote should count not over turned by 1 gay judge.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by shotmaker on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:18PM (#1576220)
down vote all you want. If you want to know some of the reasons people oppose this look at this http://www.massresistance.org/

There is an agenda there...

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by theBobMcCormick on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:27PM (#1576821)
I'm downvoting you because you're a bigoted shithead. That's all.