News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:10PM (#1576185)
The main one I have heard is the slippery slope argument. If marriage is redefined as something other than a legal union between a man and a woman, where does definition of marriage come from?

In other words, if someone is for gay marriage, then on what grounds can they forbid polygamous or incestuous relationships or incestuous relationships?

Of course, this assumes that these other less popular alternative lifestyles should be forbidden as well.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by brianwillis on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:59PM (#1576355)
Marriage has evolved over time. If it didn't, then it probably wouldn't be around any more.

Examples: -Inter-racial marriage was once illegal in the US. Now it's not.

-Marriage was used as a tool to forge alliances between royal families in Europe. Now it's not.

-In Europe, it was once common for a bride's family to pay a dowry as a part of the marriage agreement. Now it's not.

My point is that elements of our collective cultures evolve all the time. The concept of marriage exists to serve culture that it's a part of, not the other way around.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:16PM (#1576939)
The relationship between marriage and culture and society is complex. A majority of the society in California voted for Proposition 8.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:35PM (#1576475)
It's about discrimination, there's no slope.

It's discrimination because non-gays can marry and gays cannot.

This does not apply to polygamous or incestuous relationships. Those are not recognized by law, but they are denied to everyone equally.

Also, "union between a man and a woman" does cover incest so clearly that's not the definition used by courts when deciding who can marry. Your premise is flawed and even if it wasn't, you're just trying to confound completely separate issues.

Again, it's about discrimination.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @09:34PM (#1576835)
Absolutely, it is about discrimination. Gays marriage choices are discriminated against based solely on the gender of their desired spouse. As ridiculous as it is, the law allows a gay woman to marry any man that they want.

However, the law discriminates against polygamous relationships based on the number of people involved and incestuous relationships based solely on who their relatives are.

The argument is, why is discrimination against gender bad, but discrimination against relatives is ok. If two brothers want to get married, why should that relationship be denied by the law?

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:01PM (#1576905)
You can't marry any sibling, regardless of gender. You can marry some people, but it's gender-dependent. It's called equal protection for a reason.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by cninja on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:12PM (#1576933)
Both gender and relationship to the potential spouse are attributes of a person that cannot be changed. Why is it ok to discriminate based on one but not the other?
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @10:13PM (#1576935)
That's irrelevant. No one can marry a sibling. Anyone can marry the opposite gender.
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by Jun8 on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:07PM (#1576395)
Exactly. This would be one of main arguments against the typical "it's a consensual adult thing, what is it to you!" argument for gay marriage. In fact, to many people, a polygamous relationship between a man and many wives would be more "natural"than gay marriage (e.g. some Muslim countries, where gayness may be punishable by death by Sharia law allows more than one wife).

Same logic applies to incestuous marriage, although this would be more extreme since there are very strong taboos against it (not throughout all history, though, e.g. in Ancient Egypt pharaohs mostly married their sisters).

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by kjksf on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @08:12PM (#1576586)
Your premise is flawed. The ruling stroke down the law as violating constitutional rights of gays because they are denied benefits that are given to non-gays. Period.

You're arguing a straw-man.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @06:55PM (#1576346)
don't forget bestiality. If a man and a consenting horse wish to get married who are we to deny them that right!
Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by MartinCron on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:00PM (#1576361)
-1 Horses can't give meaningful consent, silly.

+1 You spelled bestiality correctly.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by OpieCunningham on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:50AM (#1577417)
How about a man and a chicken? If you tell me a chicken can't give meaningful consent and therefore a man can't force a chicken into marriage, then what right do we have to eat them?

Seriously, I'm not joking.

It is a valid point when arguing against gay marriage to point to the "slippery slope" of bestiality. But it is also a valid point to state that there's really no good reason to make marrying a chicken illegal. Fundamentally, I believe most opposition to gay marriage is based upon disgust. And I'm confident the same is true for marrying a chicken. Disgust is hardly an adequate justification.

Re:California's Prop 8 (gay marriage ban) ruled unconstituti... by axod on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @07:04PM (#1576379)
How about a dolphin. They're pretty intelligent.