News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRC necromancy by jaequery on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:39PM (#15730854)
irc is so useful that i cant believe it is dying, and aside from freenode perhaps even dead.

so what killed the IRC? its not like theres any other alternative out there. slack seems to come close but its still very different and for a different purpose.

Re:IRC necromancy by LocutusOfBorges on Saturday November 18, 2017 @06:10PM (#15731193)
Discord, overwhelmingly.

Every IRC community I used to be a part of even a year ago has made the jump. It's just more convenient for all concerned- the only holdouts are people clinging to their CLIs and people objecting for ideological reasons.

I wish it hadn't come to this, but IRC's just stagnated for too long. The barrier to entry's too high, using it on mobile devices is a chore, the feature set's extremely limited, etc. Had IRCv3 managed to get off the ground and made some strides towards creating a modern user experience maybe two years ago, Discord wouldn't have had such a vulnerable market open for it to stroll in and snatch up.

Discord provides seamless cloud message logging, mobile notifications, intuitive clients, a huge ecosystem of easy-to-use bots, and integration with games that just works without the user having to set anything up. Even non-gaming-related communities have been switching to it for convenience's sake.

Re:IRC necromancy by astrobe_ on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:33PM (#15731751)
> The barrier to entry's too high

I don't understand this statement. One finds IRC clients everywhere. One literally has to know just one command at the beginning: /join. And then if you Google "IRC commands" or something like that, you get the rest of them easily (if your client lacks in the help area).

> the feature set's extremely limited

I don't understand this mindset. Why should a program have an extra-large set of features? Is the value of a program measured by the number of features it has?

> Had IRCv3 managed to get off the ground and made some strides towards creating a modern user experience maybe two years ago, Discord wouldn't have had such a vulnerable market open for it to stroll in and snatch up

Apples and oranges. Discord did have serious opponents named Teamspeak, Skype, Mumble and other VOIP clients - but certainly not IRC. And if my memory serves, the first thing they did was to make sure to dislodge those programs from the gamers community.

Re:IRC necromancy by debaserab2 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:03PM (#15732183)
> One literally has to know just one command at the beginning: /join. And then if you Google "IRC commands"

If your UX requires needing to google for syntax to type into your program in order to use basic features of the app, there is absolutely no way you are going to take off with people that are used to programs like twitter, gchat, skype, and facebook messenger.

I grew up on IRC and have a lot of fond memories of it. I don't particularly miss all the constant rolling brown-out connection issues and functionality/syntax that differed depending on what server you were connected to. It's no wonder someone came in and easily stole the thunder out from underneath IRC. Engineer types might have been keen to how transparently most IRC clients exposed the protocol, but I suspect for the vast majority of users IRC was tolerated, not embraced.

I don't think Discord deserves all the credit either, I really think it started with slack being adopted within developer communities and open source projects. Discord got the gamers, Slack (initially at least) got the developers.

Re:IRC necromancy by DiThi on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:43PM (#15731967)
> One finds IRC clients everywhere.

Yet I find myself using the web interface of Freenode when I need it, instead of installing a client in my Linux machine with a single command, any of the ones I used for a long time.

> Is the value of a program measured by the number of features it has?

I'd say by the number of features reliably shared by everyone else. This is why XMPP never took off and basically Google killed it.

> Apples and oranges.

Discord specifically targeted communities that used IRC, at least initially. The main difference with the other chat services is that you can enter a room from a browser, so it's almost friction-less to bring someone. IRC natively doesn't support that but many servers could and did (and I think it's the reason IRC remained somewhat popular).

For the record, I don't like Discord for its proprietary and centralized nature (despite calling the communities "servers"). Instead I'll be supporting Matrix and Riot as soon as Riot issue #4488 is fixed.

Re:IRC necromancy by SOLAR_FIELDS on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:42PM (#15731777)
I’ve been a software engineer for several years now and I still have trouble with MiRC and Adium. I tried Irssi and eventually gave up with it. The problem with IRC is that even the “simple” clients never just work. There’s always some little infuriating quirks that you have to dive super deep into configs to figure out if it’s even possible to resolve without some sort of PR to the repository.
Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:46PM (#15731786)
Well, quassel for example doesn’t even have configs, everything is done in simple ways via the UI, and everyone, including the devs, uses that. It’s rocksolid, just works, and if you use the core/client split version, you can also connect a webinterface and mobile client to it.
Re:IRC necromancy by 0xVi on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:07PM (#15732196)
I"m a big fan of irccloud. It's the simplest client I've found and it's free, aside from subscribing for power-user features.
Re:IRC necromancy by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:43PM (#15731969)
These kinds of comments almost make me not want to live on this Earth any more.
Re:IRC necromancy by astrobe_ on Sunday November 19, 2017 @12:48PM (#15734936)
Most comments really just say:

"IRC is like email. An old boring tool that just does its job. I'm not having fun with it, I'm not feeling special when using, so I need a 'modern' alternative."

Re:IRC necromancy by debaserab2 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @09:25PM (#15737332)
I don't think what these comments are saying at all. IRC didn't do it's job well, that's why it was replaced.
Re:IRC necromancy by Linuturk on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:05PM (#15732037)
Having setup and attempted to administer an IRC server, I'd say that's where the barrier exists for someone wanting to create a new community outside of the huge Freenode network.
Re:IRC necromancy by jiggunjer on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:43PM (#15732305)
Why would you want to go outside freenode? They're run by a charity promoting free communication and have encryption for registered users.
Re:IRC necromancy by lambada on Sunday November 19, 2017 @12:28PM (#15734811)
So I want to create a new set of channels on freenode. From the home page (on mobile) I’m presented with the following page

https://freenode.net/groupreg

Which is a) very wordy. B) appears to essentially say “only certain kinds of groups are welcome”. C) doesn’t have a simple way of doing so instead being “reach out and discuss with us and then maybe we’ll let you set up shop here”

Re:IRC necromancy by emmelaich on Sunday November 19, 2017 @03:44AM (#15732941)
> /join

and /password or was that /msg notify something or ??? If you get it wrong, congrats, you've just published your password to the world.

IRC wasn't even very good compared to other cli oriented programs such as the Unix shell or muds/moos.

Re:IRC necromancy by pavel_lishin on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:59PM (#15731642)
> Discord, overwhelmingly.

A community I'm a moderator of recently set up shop in Discordland, due to its superior user management stuff. Both I and another person independently the similarities to IRC; I said that we're re-inventing IRC practices from the ground up.

Re:IRC necromancy by reificator on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:07PM (#15732193)
But with rich previews, seamless device handoff, persistent messaging when offline, including notifications, and of course VOIP/Video on top.

Now, you can get some of that in IRC via a bouncer, but it's nice to just have it baked in.

Of course, it is a centralized system, with all the issues present there.

Re:IRC necromancy by kakarot on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:21PM (#15731490)
I just wish this wasn't a battle of decentralization vs centralization. Discord seems cool and all but channel operators lack reasonable amount of ownership over their channels and Discord touches every message that comes through its network.
Re:IRC necromancy by ryandrake on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:08PM (#15731673)
Unfortunately it seems to be an irreversible trend: Decentralized/federated services with many compatible client options are dying and being replaced by many competing and incompatible centralized services, each with few (or one) client options. It's like programmers are all constantly asking the question: "How can we make the Internet worse?"

If E-mail were invented today, there would be 5+ competing protocols, owned by 5+ competing companies, you could only use clients written by those companies, and you wouldn't be able to send E-mail to someone on a different service than the one you were on. Kind of like the current text chat app cluster-fuck we have to live with.

Re:IRC necromancy by pavel_lishin on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:01PM (#15731645)
I'm not necessarily disagreeing, but do you mean ownership over Discord channels or Discord servers?
Re:IRC necromancy by kakarot on Sunday November 19, 2017 @03:29AM (#15732894)
I mean servers. The protocol is locked to the platform.
Re:IRC necromancy by jaequery on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:17PM (#15731870)
I think Discord only hits the gaming community. What I liked about IRC was the diversity. I loved talking #basketball on Efnet, and so on.
Re:IRC necromancy by blibble on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:31PM (#15731535)
discord has also had $80 million dollars in funding

an IRC network developed entirely by volunteers can't really compete with that sort of funding

Re:IRC necromancy by pavel_lishin on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:59PM (#15731643)
What did Discord spend that money on?

I'd wager that most of the value gained was in marketing.

Re:IRC necromancy by dijit on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:23PM (#15731721)
Odd argument. I run an irc network. Quite a large one. My funding is less than 0.00001% of that. It doesn't take much to out compete monetarily. Even if a large amount of your total money goes to marketing.
Re:IRC necromancy by Fjolsvith on Sunday November 19, 2017 @09:48AM (#15734081)
Does Discord provide easy collection of communications to the NSA?
Re:IRC necromancy by loeg on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:47PM (#15730888)
We use IRC sort of interchangeably with Slack at my work. The nice thing about IRC is you can host it on-premise and Slack doesn't have all of your company's confidential information. The downside is that it doesn't come bundled with a pretty webapp with GIFs and emojis.
Re:IRC necromancy by jancborchardt on Saturday November 18, 2017 @05:30PM (#15731025)
There’s always Riot https://about.riot.im/ which is a nice and fully open source app so you could set that up on-premise too. :)
Re:IRC necromancy by loeg on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:37PM (#15731555)
Yep. Perhaps emphasis on the "bundled with."

Unfortunately, I suspect Slack use at my company grew largely out of IT's unwillingness to spin up a web-facing IRC solution, and their unwillingness to expose internal services to the web. The latter is very convenient for sales or on-call employees. As a result of that security posture, we instead share tons of company secrets on a 3rd party service. It's kind of a weird local maxima.

Re:IRC necromancy by scaryclam on Saturday November 18, 2017 @06:10PM (#15731189)
Not sure why you're getting voted down. I'm looking for something to replace hip chat at the moment (we replaced slack with hipchat as slack didn't work well for us either), so I'm genuinely curious why a suggestion for riot is unpopular. Anyone care to comment?
Re:IRC necromancy by e12e on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:09PM (#15731447)
What part of slack didn't work out for you? We're using slack at my workplace - and I think it's okish. Not a fan of it being a web app - but not frustrated enough yet to try the irc bridge with weechat (which is on my todo-list. Seems like a sane way forward, the last irc client I used was BitchX, and I don't think I'll likely to trust such an old c codebase with anything if I can help it..).

Now that everyone "knows" what slack is, I wonder if it's time to blow some dust off of Apache (née Google) wave...

Re:IRC necromancy by loeg on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:40PM (#15731567)
The Slack IRC bridge works pretty well, IMO. I use it with irssi. The only negative I can think of is it joins you to every Slack channel you're in every time you reconnect. (Including #general, which you can't permanently leave.)

(I guess the other caveat is: it's a 3rd party hosted application; an internet outage or service outage could take it down, and it's potentially vulnerable to massive information leak in a way that your company isn't.)

Re:IRC necromancy by abhirag on Sunday November 19, 2017 @02:09AM (#15732692)
Try the wee-slack plugin[https://github.com/wee-slack/wee-slack], it uses the Slack API and I have been using it on my Android phone(using Termux) and my Linux laptop, works great :)
Re:IRC necromancy by awirth on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:53PM (#15730915)
At work we have an onsite Zulip instance which meets both those requirements for us (including SSO integration). It's surprising to me that there aren't more places using it.
Re:IRC necromancy by starkruzr on Sunday November 19, 2017 @02:59PM (#15735620)
I've been meaning to stand up Zulip at home. Are there good mobile clients for it?
Re:IRC necromancy by loeg on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:34PM (#15731545)
That's a good suggestion, thanks.
Re:IRC necromancy by lscotte on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:07PM (#15731440)
To me, that's not a downside but a positive feature. At work, I connect to slack via the weechat wee-slack plugin, and it's great to filter out all that gunk. I want plain text chat, and this way I can still get it.
Re:IRC necromancy by CJefferson on Saturday November 18, 2017 @06:10PM (#15731191)
For me, it is the fact that most people connect with multiple devices, and want to have a smooth transition between them, and to be able to see history on all of them.

There is no easy way of doing that with IRC, which kills it for me.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:54PM (#15731809)
> There is no easy way of doing that with IRC, which kills it for me.

Yes, there is! This is exactly what Quassel is made for.

Just run the core anywhere (we’re looking into offering it hosted, too), connect with the web ui, the desktop client (Linux, Mac, Windows - uses Qt5, and is only a few megabytes, uses almost no RAM at all. A true native client), or the Android client.

As many devices as you want under one account, a smooth transition from one to any other, shared history (just scroll up - all devices remember where the others left off, and you always see exactly the same on all of them).

With some minor extra effort, you even get nice and fast fulltext search – this video is recorded on a 2$ OVH VPS, searching through 3 years and 6GB of logs in 65ms: https://s3.kuschku.de/public/quassel-rest-search.mp4

All of this under GPL.

Re:IRC necromancy by CJefferson on Sunday November 19, 2017 @04:02AM (#15732979)
I'm glad you are working on that, but "Just run the core anywhere (we’re looking into offering it hosted, too), connect with the web ui," really doesn't count as easy to use -- now everyone on my IRC channel needs to run a server which is is accessable to the internet, worry about security updates, both for the server and your software specifically.

Whereas with slack, I just do "make account, login, done". Until it's as easy as slack, I can't pursade people I work with to move over.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Sunday November 19, 2017 @10:00AM (#15734142)
> now everyone on my IRC channel needs to run a server which is is accessable to the internet, worry about security updates, both for the server and your software specifically.

Well, the beautiful thing about this is that you can run one quassel core, for dozens, hundreds, or potentially even thousands of users.

LDAP login is also supported, and I might add later on automated connecting to a pre-configured network.

You can probably imagine that this is very useful already.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Sunday November 19, 2017 @09:29PM (#15737345)
Disclaimer: I’m just a normal contributor, I don’t have any control over the Quassel project.
Re:IRC necromancy by zanny on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:01PM (#15731825)
On the bright side from all the proprietary locked in sell-your-data platforms that were mentioned as IRC successors, Gitter and Matrix are popular and open, and the later is federated. I'm not aware of any major feature IRC has the Matrix protocol doesn't provide, and it has all the niceties of Discord without being the proprietary product of a for profit company.
Re:IRC necromancy by na85 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @06:51PM (#15731382)
Change aversion killed IRC. A lot of the opers on the big networks are extremely conservative and default to poo-pooing ideas because it's simpler.

IRC with good mobile/push support could have taken off, but using it from a mobile device is painful because of the constant drops and the need to have your device responding to ping pongs every few seconds kills your battery.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Saturday November 18, 2017 @08:47PM (#15731791)
> IRC with good mobile/push support could have taken off, but using it from a mobile device is painful because of the constant drops and the need to have your device responding to ping pongs every few seconds kills your battery.

You mean, something like IRCCloud, or what I’m moving Quasseldroid to right now?

Re:IRC necromancy by metabrew on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:42AM (#15733475)
Random irccloud/quassel anecdote for you: when I started working on what is now irccloud, I was originally just going to write a (mobile-)web front end for quassel core, since I was using Quassel on KDE at the time (and had been for some time). This predates Quasseldroid I think, at least I don't remember there being a good mobile app for quassel back then.

The protocol between the quassel core and clients looked to be some sort of serialized Qt objects (iirc), so I abandoned that idea and wrote the irc client backend in erlang, with a json protocol.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Sunday November 19, 2017 @06:53AM (#15733513)
The protocol are serialized Qt objects (I've started documenting it), but compared to Json, this gives a huge performance advantage.

It's planned to be replaced it with protobuf relatively soon, though.

Re:IRC necromancy by na85 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:09PM (#15731843)
Yes, except irc cloud is a 3rd party platform and requires payment as far as I'm aware.

"Something like irc cloud" should have been baked into the ircd/protocol so that there's a lower barrier to entry.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:32PM (#15731925)
Well, Quassel is the same, open source, under GPL, self-hosted. (Disclaimer: I contribute to Quassel occasionally)
Re:IRC necromancy by na85 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:05PM (#15732190)
Again, it needs to be baked into the server, otherwise it's just another barrier to entry.
Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Sunday November 19, 2017 @10:02AM (#15734151)
That’s not really possible, actually.

The push notification systems used by Android and iOS only allow the same person that can authorize updates for an app to send push notifications to this app.

This means either every IRC app would need to operate an open gateway for notifications, or you’d need to give every IRC server the same certificate that you use to sign your app updates on the Apple AppStore.

Push notifications on mobile devices are designed to only work for situations where the same company controls all servers, and apps.

Re:IRC necromancy by na85 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @12:52PM (#15734963)
Okay, well, now we've discovered a big obstacle to irc adoption on mobile.

Things like this are the reason slack and discord ate irc.

Most users simply won't sign up for 3 services just to chat.

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:33PM (#15735142)
Well, rather, we've discovered why everything is becoming centralized, not just IRC.
Re:IRC necromancy by curioussavage on Saturday November 18, 2017 @06:16PM (#15731228)
I think it may be partly that it was largely created and used by people who don’t care about ease of use and appearances, maybe partly because it kept out the masses. Make it hard for new people and eventually your old users are gone with no one to replace them.

Personally I try to keep most of my workflow in the terminal but I haven’t been able to find an irc client I like and the rooms I join are always silent. I don’t the etiquette and have zero incentives learn

Re:IRC necromancy by kuschku on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:42PM (#15730869)
Gamers moved from Quakenet to Discord, open source projects moved from Freenode to Slack, and that’s it.

Luckily, most projects are left on Freenode, as an open source project relying on a proprietary service is something few people can stomach (outside of some people that already accepted the commercialization of the net)

Re:IRC necromancy by yumaikas on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:25PM (#15731509)
There is still #xkcd on foonetic, #ludumdare on afternet, as well as #lobsters and #proglangdesign on freenode. They may not be active 24/7, but there are good conversationa there if you lurk for awhile.