News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by vinylkey on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:50PM (#15724826)
Mostly good info in there, but I see a few problems:

> There is also no E#. It just doesn't exist. Get used to it. Those are the 12 notes.

Technically not true. There is an E#, it's called F. If you are playing in F# major[1], the scale has an E# in it.

> Musicians never play notes one at a time. They always use chords.

Most lead guitar parts are not chords. Typically playing in a band context will create a chord from multiple instruments, but that isn't always the case.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F-sharp_major

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by lwhalen on Friday November 17, 2017 @08:06PM (#15727216)
> Musicians never play notes one at a time. They always use chords.

This guy has also obviously never met the strange and rare creature known as a 'bass player'.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by barkingcat on Friday November 17, 2017 @08:50PM (#15727363)
Also violin/string players (when not playing double stops)

Singers who are not overtone singers (pretty much everyone).

What kind of weird musician is this person limited to?

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by jerf on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:43PM (#15727793)
If you want to get a bit more wild, though, a lot of solo music still contains chords by implication, and can be very easily harmonically analyzed. I don't know how popular solo works are in the 20th century since atonality flung the music locomotive gleefully through the "Bridge Out Ahead" sign and into the canyon [1], but if we discount that it would certainly include almost all Western solo music.

[1]: Yes, it's an opinion. Yes, it's an informed opinion, and implying in one way or another that I just must Not Get It will not faze me. I do Get It, and that's why I find it distasteful.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by acjohnson55 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:37AM (#15729084)
I used to think that, but when I had to study atonal music, it became clear to me how much of an impact it had on film music and how it shows up in fragments in pop music.

Then, I took a class on electronic music composition. For my own project in the spirit of the avant garde, I wanted to challenge myself to write something "musical" without resorting to the traditional concepts of pitch-based melody and harmony or quantized rhythm. It turns out, there are many other levers you can play with to create the effect of an musical arc. Not to pat myself on the back, but I think the end result is evocative in a similar sense as tonal music. If I had the time, I would do more.

Check it out here, if you like: https://soundcloud.com/acjohnson/wanderers

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by jerf on Monday November 20, 2017 @08:48AM (#15739816)
If we want to play "wave the credentials" at each other, I minored in music composition, and my objection is a great deal philosophically deeper than "I don't generally like how atonal music sounds". There's a parallel world where atonal music is still explored but I wouldn't characterize it as "flinging music off a cliff". Atonality was merely when the cliff-jumping occurred.

I have neither the time nor the desire to fully explain my point in an HN post, but I would note that the music community itself has been asking questions in this direction in the last decade or so, if you want to follow up on it, as the academic music community asks themselves exactly how they got to where they are now, so disconnected from the rest of the world at large and so utterly irrelevant to almost anything musically occurring today. (Not just pop music; that is structurally inevitably insipid, really, so who cares, but irrelevant to anything other than their own very little world.)

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by perfecot0r on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:59AM (#15729734)
also lo-fi sound chip music, but chord progressions may be emulated with fast arpeggiato (sequential instead of parallel chord notes, the name is from the harp, which exhibits this effect). There's probably a limit at which slow speed we don't notice notes as connected, but violin is surely fast enough. Speach pretty much seems to rely on an aliasing effect like that, too, when frequency clusters (iirc) are enough to identify words in speech analysis. So order would not matter as much as chord, if I am not mistaken. But then I might be as things get more complex than single progressions. I wonder if interleaved arp progressions have been explored.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by burmer on Saturday November 18, 2017 @10:49AM (#15729400)
lol, also every wind and brass instrument. Also drums.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by stephengillie on Saturday November 18, 2017 @02:06PM (#15730185)
There is a technique where the brass player hums while playing. In this way an extremely skilled brass musician can accompany herself.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by peterburkimsher on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:27PM (#15727752)
Oh! Thank you; I hadn't realised that.

I learned this by asking a friend in the CouchSurfing meetup who brings a guitar or a roll-out piano. And as I say, I can't play any instrument myself.

Maybe if I want to learn, I should choose an instrument that uses single notes, it might be easier.

Regarding singing though, my ex-girlfriend told me to sing more quietly in church because it sounds so bad.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by leejo on Saturday November 18, 2017 @03:17AM (#15728227)
> Maybe if I want to learn, I should choose an instrument that uses single notes, it might be easier.

It's not just limited to bass/lead guitarists either - finger style acoustic guitarists don't play just chords. OK, often the fingerings are chord patterns, or arpeggiated chords, but that's not always the case. Checkout the title track from Bensusan's album, "Intuite", that is mostly just a single note melody: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=di1qQsGcaIc (it would appear the ending is cut off this track here, but it gives you the idea).

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by brooklyn_ashey on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:41AM (#15732621)
That's nuts. That's like asking a beginning programmer to stop coding because their code is garbage. The only way to be a great singer is to be a bad singer first.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by Joeboy on Saturday November 18, 2017 @07:32AM (#15728739)
> I should choose an instrument that uses single notes, it might be easier.

I'd say the easiest / most immediately rewarding way is to pick up a guitar or similar (banjo / uke / banjolele / mandolin etc) and learn a few chords. Although people who can do that aren't exactly in demand so there's a case for learning the onde martineau or glass harmonica or something - that way if you get decent at it you can actually get paid to do it.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by baddox on Friday November 17, 2017 @08:37PM (#15727325)
Or nearly all wind instruments....
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:33PM (#15727766)
Or any instrument that isn't tuned to 12-tone equal temperament. In just intonation there are no enharmonic notes, for just one example. C# isn't always the same thing as Db!

And that's without mentioning oddities like most varieties of bagpipes or the hurdy-gurdy, where a constant drone is present. It doesn't exactly form chords with the other notes, but it's still more than one note being played at a time!

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by baddox on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:39PM (#15727782)
Well, instruments in just intonation or other tuning systems can surely still play one note at a time!
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by SAI_Peregrinus on Saturday November 18, 2017 @01:05AM (#15727951)
Bagpipes and Hurdy Gurdy physically can't, the drone is always there.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by bambax on Saturday November 18, 2017 @04:40AM (#15728403)
Also, most wind instruments (that are played with the mouth -- organs excluded) are monophonic: trumpets, clarinets, saxophones, oboes, flutes, etc.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by cup-of-tea on Saturday November 18, 2017 @11:14AM (#15729531)
Or any solo player including a singer. It's a ridiculous statement.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by thomasfortes on Friday November 17, 2017 @08:44PM (#15727348)
Also know as the guy with the long guitar.

Source: I am a bass player

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by mdesq on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:02PM (#15727699)
Or most instruments played in a symphony orchestra.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by xkcd-sucks on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:29PM (#15727464)
> There is also no E#. It just doesn't exist. Get used to it. Those are the 12 notes.

Whoa... Plus, they're identical only in equal temprament

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by jimmaswell on Friday November 17, 2017 @08:02PM (#15727205)
> Musicians never play notes one at a time. They always use chords.

What kind of weird statement even is that? What about the first few notes of Fur Elise?

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by mtpn on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:18PM (#15727435)
There are several statements you could pick out like that in this article. Like

> There is a chord called "C major", but it's totally different to the note called "C".

... the E and G of the C major chord are prominent overtones of the note.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by jcelerier on Saturday November 18, 2017 @05:32AM (#15728495)
> ... the E and G of the C major chord are prominent overtones of the note.

depends on the instrument. A pure sine wave at the frequency of C does not have any overtone.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by mtpn on Saturday November 18, 2017 @06:04AM (#15728570)
That’s a fair point. But still, the relationship between the root, 5th, and major third are very much connected to the fact that they are specific multiples of that root frequency, and are the loudest overtones typically audible when the note is played. The root is not totally different from chords built on it.

I meant to add more to my top comment. I think the author does fairly well at their mission despite potential nit picks like that. It is really cool to see somebody learning and being excited about putting all the pieces together. The beautiful thing about music is you can go deeper and deeper as much as you want, and there are various competing ideas about what it is and how to talk about. Programming has a similar kind of depth to it.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by brooklyn_ashey on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:47AM (#15732633)
plus one to this!
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by perfecot0r on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:09PM (#15729774)
there are no pure sine waves without resonance, though
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by colordrops on Friday November 17, 2017 @08:20PM (#15727270)
Or wind instruments for that matter.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by LeonB on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:18PM (#15727726)
And if you're going to say there's no E# you'd want to also pretend there's no B#. Otherwise it sounds like E is totally exceptional.

Down with E exceptionalism.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by jwfxpr on Saturday November 18, 2017 @02:22AM (#15728136)
Manifest destin-E.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by ML_MS on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:25PM (#15727449)
Yeah. Some of the stuff said in this is stated very poorly.

> A machine learning program is also called a "neural net".

A neural net is just one example of a machine learning model.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by dizzystar on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:50PM (#15727536)
It goes along with this line... "For some reason I don't totally understand, some have 2 names (e.g. C#=Db, D#=Eb, F#=Gb, A#=Bb)."

It would probably blow the authors mind to know that some scales have sharps and flats, including the ones

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by rainbowmverse on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:10PM (#15727708)
I get the feeling this mistake was out of ignorance...not accidental.

sorry

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by peterburkimsher on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:24PM (#15727743)
Yes, the mistake was out of ignorance.

It was not an "accidental"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accidental_(music)

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by xxpor on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:55PM (#15727550)
And he didn't mention the obvious corollary... B# (aka C). (and Cb, Fb)

The dude's mind is going to be blown when he learns about double sharps and flats.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by peterburkimsher on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:17PM (#15727722)
I got really confused by that at first, because I saw Abb in a note table.

When I looked it up, I saw that it's just another name for G.

https://www.basicmusictheory.com/a-double-flat-note

The fact that the same thing has 2 names, but then the same name (e.g. C) can mean 3 different things (note, chord, key) really confuses me. I'm a beginner (can't play any instrument), so this is just about trying to cover the basics and generate a machine learning dataset. If I weren't so confused already, I might try to learn an instrument. It seems to be really time-consuming to practice though, and I'd need a teacher to listen and correct my mistakes. I wouldn't notice when I get it wrong if I try to teach myself.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:50PM (#15727809)
I'd suggest starting with the tin whistle. They're very cheap, very easy (you can learn the basics in a day or two, a week at most to get your first tune down), and any Irish session will either have someone willing to teach or someone who knows where you can get a teacher. The Session[1] is an excellent resource for it.

As for which whistle to buy, get one in the key of D. A Walton's little black should be about $6, one of their slightly better brass whistles around $11, and a Generation nickel D is about $12. If you really want to splurge Susato makes a very nice high D for $50 (their Kildare S series), but it's quite loud and more for if you are playing before an audience. The most expensive whistles around are probably Burke's, at $230 for a high D. So even if you end up collecting Burke whistles obsessively and getting one in every key he makes you'll still be out less money than buying some high-end guitars!

The one disadvantage is that they're diatonic instruments. That means you can play in one key, and only one key, without cross-fingering the whistle.

For tuning, I recommend either an electronic tuner or the program Flutini[2], assuming you get a tunable whistle (the cheap ones aren't and it probably won't matter much).

[1] https://thesession.org/ [2] http://www.novasession.org/Flutini/

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by fenomas on Saturday November 18, 2017 @12:37AM (#15727904)
Non-musician who taught himself all this stuff here, I feel your pain.

That said, Abb isn't another name for G - it's a distinct thing which, when played on typical musical instruments, is played the same way as a G. Basically note names to note frequencies is a many-to-one mapping.

If you want to understand the hairy details start by googling just vs equal temperament. But I went down that rabbit hole, and it hasn't made my procedural music any better, so I wouldn't really recommend it.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by acjohnson55 on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:52AM (#15729138)
It's not a fixed mapping. It's more like a function that produces a mapping. It depends on the selection of:

- A pitch standard, like A440, which anchors one arbitrarily chosen note to a specific frequency.

- A tuning system, which defines the frequency ratios between notes.

Almost all modern music assumes _A440_ and _12-tone equal temperament_. In 12TET, adjacent flats and sharps map to the same frequency. It's said that they are _enharmonic_. But there are many other systems where this isn't true. In _just intonation_, notes are defined by simple frequency ratios, and there is no enharmonicity at all. Every number of sharps and flats map to different frequencies.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by madhadron on Saturday November 18, 2017 @01:11PM (#15729994)
Even this is not quite right. For keyboard instruments, that have a fixed set of pitches that notes map to, you have to choose a temperament, a fixed set of pitches for each note (unless you're on a clavichord, where you can adjust it a bit by how hard you strike the key). Fretted instruments may or may not be tempered. Guitars are, since the frets on it limit the pitch range of a given note, though it is still a range. Viols aren't, because the frets are soft gut and used to brighten the sound, so the pitch range is much wider for a given note.

For string or wind instruments playing without keyboards, there is no temperament. Each note represents a range of possible pitches, and what pitch you choose depends on the notes around it. For example, if you are repeating or holding a note, you don't want it to change pitch. But if the harmony around that note is changing, it may be in tune at one point in time, then out of tune at a later one. String quartet playing involves a great deal of working out compromises about what pitch each note should have.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by acjohnson55 on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:57AM (#15732658)
Good point! I admittedly was writing this off as "performance details" of music written in a modern 12-tone paradigm, but you're definitely right that plenty of music is written specifically for ensembles with continuous pitch with those nuances in mind. See also, a cappella vocal music, particularly barbershop. Even for guitar, some players tune to favor particular chords shapes sounding maximally consonant, even though the frets are designed for 12-TET.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by brooklyn_ashey on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:53AM (#15732645)
its also about chord spellings within a context- how a musician, especially in a string quartet, thinks about how to play the note based on how it is spelled (eg is it the third, fifth, seventh or some extension of a chord?) the spelling tips you off to its context based on the key and other factors you feel but don't have time to contemplate when sight-reading.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by rainbowmverse on Saturday November 18, 2017 @09:23AM (#15729036)
Something I think a lot of people don't realize when starting out in music: you don't actually have to know how to play an instrument to make music. You don't even need music theory.

Knowing a little about how instruments work and learning some music theory can help tremendously, but you can actually just start poking around in a MIDI roll or tracker and go a long way.

Unless you're really into a specific instrument, starting off with any modestly priced keyboard with pressure sensitivity and MIDI out (USB-based if it's modern) will let you have fun with synths and sampled instruments you'd probably never be able to afford.

If you really want to learn a physical instrument that's easy to pick up, you can get a $20 plastic ocarina and find lots of tutorials on YouTube.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by toddkazakov on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:44PM (#15727797)
Just try playing any instrument - you'll soon realize that we're quite good at figuring out what sounds good and what not.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by fenomas on Friday November 17, 2017 @09:41PM (#15727504)
There are plenty of not-quite-correct things in this article, but I think both lines you quoted were meant to be more or less tongue-in-cheek.
Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by peterburkimsher on Friday November 17, 2017 @11:23PM (#15727737)
Thank you. That's exactly right.

Indeed, those lines are dramatically oversimplifying, but it makes the comments section more exciting and the article shorter.

Perhaps it'll scare off people who were planning to do machine learning audio analysis. But at least they'll get an idea of how complicated it can be.

Re:Show HN: Chord Progressions by brooklyn_ashey on Sunday November 19, 2017 @01:30AM (#15732595)
actually, there is an E#. It's called E#! There is also a Cflat! F is the enharmonic spelling of E# and B is the enharmonic spelling of Cflat.