Because in the US, the 'free press' is an extension of the First Amendment, which protects individuals from government interference with speech. It has no bearing on the behaviors of private parties.
FWIW I'm not taking a pro-monopoly stance here. Just think it's important to educate the public that the First Amendment is a lot more limited than the average American believes that it is.
Not true. While the First Amendment does provide many protections for free press and there are no national press shield laws, many states in the US provide additional free press protections: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shield_laws_in_the_United_Stat...
Please stop trying to hijack discussion of free speech and free press (both of which are human rights / social institutions that extend beyond the scope of protections provided via the court due to the First Amendment) into being discussions of the First Amendment in the name of "education".
>Please stop trying to hijack discussion of free speech and free press (both of which are human rights / social institutions that extend beyond the scope of protections provided via the court due to the First Amendment) into being discussions of the First Amendment in the name of "education".
At the end of the day, whatever you choose to identify as "human rights / social institutions that extend beyond the scope of protections provided via the court due to the First Amendment" don't really matter unless they're institutionalized and codified. Rights that have explicit protections written into law are the only rights that are backed by the State's right to use of coercive force.
reminds me of 15 year olds born after the PATRIOT ACT exclaiming "this isn't the America I grew up in"
Because, sadly enough, in this day and age the average American doesn't know and doesn't care. When the people who want this to pass are the people you get your information from, you walk away with a very, VERY different viewpoint than hearing from someone who doesn't have a horse in the race.
I'm so cynical that any type of revolt, even moderately "violent", would be squashed before it ever had a chance to fully form.
It truly is an interesting time. Initially, corporations were to have a definite lifespan (something like 70 years). Of course they got rid of that.
Our system wasn't designed for corporate influence of this magnitude. Our forefathers were pretty smart dudes..I wonder how they'd change the constitution knowing what we know now.
Playing devil's advocate, possibly the most populist-friendly protection is the 2nd amendment, in that there's a school of thought that says escalating the conflict to put the pressure on the people pulling the trigger - rather than letting them just forcefully disband an unarmed protest - is what it would take to get the soldiers of the government to refuse to carry out death sentences against their fellow citizens. However, historically the US government has not been shy about coming down hard on armed resistance, so it's unclear that it is any real use.
One of the more interesting (and either depressing or hopeful, depending on your perspective) lessons of a study of early American history is it's not some ideal period with no discontent and everything since has been decay. In many ways it's definitely better now. Human history, globally, is not pretty.
Which isn't to say we should stop trying to improve, but important to recognize that it will, and has always, taken a lot of struggle.
> On Thursday the FCC will vote on Pai’s proposal to eliminate
> the 42-year-old ban on cross-ownership of a newspaper and TV
> station in a major market.
This already exists. Newspapers are all now websites (basically), so CNN is effectively a newspaper/website that owns a TV station (or vice versa)... No significant newspaper is limited to a major market and I'm unsure of the benefit of a 42yo rule that has a limited relevance to our current reality.Under current regulations, BuzzFeed can buy WNBC in NYC but The NYTimes cannot? Unfortunately, Pai's logic seems to make some sense.
> more than 39 percent of U.S. television households
But the above 39% thing is totally baffling. From the Justice Department: > The agencies generally consider markets in which the HHI is between 1,500
> and 2,500 points to be moderately concentrated, and consider markets in
> which the HHI is in excess of 2,500 points to be highly concentrated.
A Herfindahl-Hirschman Index including this one company (@ 40%) would be 1,600 (40%^2). That one company causes the market to be "moderately concentrated" and we're removing this limit. That's completely insane.I see every loss that occurs as a step back and no progress only side stepping afterwords...
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996
Not sure about movements, but maybe build products and systems and infrastructure that would enable smaller newspapers and tv stations to make money while staying independent? Better crowdfunding, micropayments, better paywalls, better media distribution channels, tools for local communities to get involved? Bottom-up solutions like these are hard to implement, because they are decentralized and require an active base, but can be done.
> Pai is also expected to call for an initial vote in December to rescind rules that say one company may not own stations serving more than 39 percent of U.S. television households, two people briefed on the matter said.
Despair seems like an appropriate response here, but hardly useful. This is probably as bad for society as any of the changes to the net neutrality laws.
Getting out into the streets, blacking out websites, commenting on the FCC site... those things are just meaningless it seems and weren't even a response to these last two pieces.
How in the hell is monopoly ownership of the press still considered a free press? Shouldn't this constitutionally protected industry have its own set of anti-trust laws? In the Information Age, how can we be so careless about the management and structure of our core information distribution systems?
Are there any movements to combat this and prevent more local papers and tv stations from becoming smaller delivery mechanisms for the same partisan bullshit?