Ugh. National IDs are common in Europe as well as other places where identity theft is mostly an exotic concept featured in the news about America. It's hard to call Belgium a totalitarian regime.
Whereas in countries without national IDs, people are forced to provide personal details to scores of vendors big and small who use these details for their purposes and may lose them to online criminals. But hey, we are protected against a hypothetical tyranny.
This is America in a nutshell. Most of it's efforts are spend protecting against what it can't see and not on the problems in front of it.
You can't base your reasoning about something like this solely on what's happening in some countries right now. That's how SSN mess started in the first place. They weren't intended as a global identifier, there were concerns that they will be used as such, but those concerns were ignored.
Also, I'm not convinced that spinning up a new ID system is necessary to solve the issue at hand.
In Germany there is no such requirement, even though many Germans also think that you have to carry it with you. But the Ausweispflicht (Obligation of identification) only means that you have to own an ID, but you can leave it home most of the time (which I do).
So yes, you don't have to carry ID on you in Germany, but only in the most pedantic sense. You'll just get a free police escort back to where you keep your ID in case you need to identify yourself. That hardly qualifies as not needing to carry ID when going about your business in the sense that Americans would be familiar with.
Thus any interaction with them could result in you needing to put a stop to anything else you're doing as you're escorted back to your house to fetch your ID, unless you're carrying it in the first place.
But the example I provided wasn't such an example, since there was a fine involved. However just having compelled ID changes even that situation. If Germany didn't have that I'd probably been able to just pay the fine on the spot without need to establish my identity.
I don't believe there's anything equivalent to that in the US. Furthermore since there's no national ID system they don't even know if you have a driver's license, social security number or passport, so their options for compelling you to produce ID are limited.
The idea of being legally required to provide government-issued identification to a law enforcement official under any circumstances is simply verboten in the US.
As long as you're not within 100 miles of the border inside the "limited civil rights zone". [1]
Personal experience is that border patrol officers feel no need for "probable cause" before pulling you over and searching your vehicle.
[1] https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone
I was with a friend in the same situation (he forgot his ticket and had no ID). I just had to witness that he was indeed the person he said he was and it was fine.
There are many situation where in the US the police will immediately arrest you while the German police will just write down your identification and let you go for now. I will rather take the German approach.
So even though, as an American, I'm not required to carry my driver's license around at all times, I almost always do, and many of the few times I've left it at home I ended up regretting doing so.
Based on my visits to Europe I'd imagine Germans would find this whole situation ridiculous.
More than 23 states require that someone be able to prove their identity (probably with a government-issued card) "if there is reasonable suspicion of a crime"[1].
Given that a book called "Three Felonies a Day" which cites facts such as the number of crimes in the US Code, the fact that most people haven't even started reading it nor have it memorized, nor have the legal skills required to determine whether (if it's even deterministic without a judge/jury) they have committed a crime, I would argue that a clever police officer probably has the ability to use that law as a tool to create a crime where none existed before.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_identify_statutes
There might be a country somewhere in Europe that has that law, but it's certainly not normal.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belgian_national_identity_card
This joyous setup is the result of the Schengen zone. When national borders were "abolished" (not really, they came back due to the migrant crisis) the way governments got police and immigration forces on board with it was to say that everyone had to have their ID on them at all times and an ID check could be done anywhere at all within the zone. I've never heard of anyone getting in trouble for not having ID on them though.
But if you actually have to carry around your ID all the time depends on the laws country you're in. Here in Germany you don't.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area#In-country_check...
It is the obligation of everyone travelling within the area to be able to show a fully valid form of personal identification approved by other Schengen states.[98]
and
Although travellers within the Schengen Area are no longer required to show documents at an internal border (although there have been some controversial instances when they have, and it is fairly common at major land border crossings with Switzerland), the laws of most countries still require them to carry identity documents
Your interpretation of this doesn't seem to be correct. The whole point of Schengen is that you don't have to show ID at internal borders, which were supposed to cease existence. Rather, you have to be able to show your ID at any time whilst travelling ... where "travelling" is such a general concept that it effectively means at all times unless you are e.g. at home.
Additionally, it could just have been chance.
In general, yes, you should have your ID/passport on you, but there is no real punishment for not having it other than being required to later show up at a police station and/or being escorted by the policeman to your apartment/hotel to show your ID.
A bigger problem is usually not having a drivers license on you, that gets some of the people in the police riled up (but again, no real punishment as long as you show up later at the police station)
Why? What about people that just don't have / need a drivers license?
Not in general.
In Germany you just have to own an ID be able to produce it when legally required. However only under a very narrow set of circumstances it is legal to ask for an ID.
The police may ask for an ID only during a "Identitätsfeststellungsverfahren", which is only legal to do if you're suspect of a crime or if you happen to be within an area of specific public vulnerability, i.e. crime hotspots designated for vetting operations. Other than that it is in fact illegal for the police to ask for your ID. But even under that circumstance it is absolutely lawful not to carry an ID with out; worst case scenario is, that the police has to escort you to whereever you have placed your ID and you be able to show to them there. Depending on circumstances this might create (major) inconveniences, but has no legal consequences.
In addition to that there are certain business transactions where an ID must be produces. For example when checking into accomodation, closing a contract with a telephone company (that's new since this year, and totally ridiculous) and opening a bank account.
That makes it ok for some identity purposes (age, name) but not sufficient for crossing a national border.
(I'm not sure this is relevant, but I'm explaining the situation here.)
If you do a post-ident or anything official, you need your proper ID.
So let's skip all the hypotheticals about having to recover one, unless you can point to an actual case from the EU, instead of Hollywood?
NO.
The reason SSNs are "failing" is because they have been adopted by the public and private sectors because they are a de facto "username".
SSNs serve the same purpose as driver's license numbers and passport numbers, only they have less authentication, but are still more common (because most young children don't have DLs or passports).
Your citizenship isn't tied to the ID, either.
Am I wrong to presume the Belgian National ID is not used for identification and verification by Belgian creditors?
I also wonder (just thinking out loud, not part of my question) what would prevent US creditors from shirking the responsibility and withholding the required resources to establish an identification and verification system which does not rely on a national ID (different from a Social Security number).
EDIT: remove extraneous word, add parenthetical to last sentence.
Only credit information is kept, nothing regarding defaults on rent, unpaid medical bills etc...
Getting a record of your own credit history is completely free, either online, by writing a letter, or just stopping by the bank.
Yes, national ID is used for that purpose. I've only very rarely heard of identity theft by strangers, there are many hoops to jump through, like photo ID and a physical letter sent to the corresponding address for verification.
What would prevent that? Privacy laws. Keeping and sharing blacklists is not forbidden but regulated in Europe. Creditors also are obligated to use the central credit agency.
I know that the monstrous institutions thriving on the FICO score are an exception. In most countries, it's the usual payslips, bank statements, stuff like that. No one needs weird stuff like secured credit cards or asking their relative to "piggyback" on their credit score.
I know that the US credit agencies tried to "educate" the local business communities in some countries on the importance of the credit score and are currently occupying a small obscure niche.
Proving the Senator Point.. I am sure you believe Europe is free, it is not. Europe is very very very very very Authoritarian and restrictive.
> It's hard to call Belgium a totalitarian regime.
Belgium is Totalitarian. Seemed pretty easy to me, I just typed things on my keyboard and they appeared like magic on my screen....
National ID is the first step to https://www.aclu.org/ordering-pizza
A national ID is by no means required for something like this. If businesses wanted to, they could already identify us uniquely enough to pool all their information and be able to do something like that.
There are 1 billion possible social security numbers. There are roughly 300 million people in the USA. So roughly 1/3 possible SSN’s is currently in use.
A: No. We do not reassign a Social Security number (SSN) after the number holder's death. Even though we have issued over 453 million SSNs so far, and we assign about 5 and one-half million new numbers a year, the current numbering system will provide us with enough new numbers for several generations into the future with no changes in the numbering system.
The federal government was never intended to administer services or benefits directly to all US citizens. The US Constitution enumerates a very limited set of federal powers: defense, foreign policy and regulation of interstate commerce, none of which concerns the average citizen day to day. It was intended for state and local governments to directly serve the people in almost all circumstances.
The New Deal was a terrible imposition of big government on the country and we're dealing with the cascade of problems and constitutional issues to this day, SSNs being a very visible example.
OTOH, if we had more federalism, I think the West Coast states might have been implementing their own full-fledged public healthcare system right now, instead of trying to come up with some compromise that the other half of the country can maybe accept (like ACA).
All that said, I don't see a problem with national ID. It's just as useful to the states as it is to the feds, and it's clear that something like that can only be run by the feds.
That sounds pretty nice actually.
No I think "why the hell didn't they put a sunset provision in all those bills?"
As an aside, one could construct a pretty good argument that the new deal was the result of all the Europeans who got off the boat in the prior decades throwing away freedom they really hadn't come to appreciate in exchange for the government playing the role of a lord who has some responsibility to prevent his peasants from hitting rock bottom (lest they revolt) with the catch being that said lord also has a ton of control over their freedom.
Even if you did, it doesn't matter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn
It is the US Constitution that is bad, by making entrenching dysfunction and hindering reform.
The patchwork nomic-style lawmaking that leads to eventual entrenched dysfunction and resistance to reform was assured. The US will not likely last half as long as Rome. We're 1 economic collapse away from fractionating into new aggregations.
I'd argue our style of law making is no different than other western democracies. How do you feel law making should be different?
The US doesn't have mechanisms for removal through accountability. This would mediate any need for an optimal cycle (which doesn't exist due to factors like breadth of initiative). Legal controls on "good faith" grace periods would be an effective control, but we don't even get that due to corruption. The US legal system has festered for too long imo.
Easy solution: make the national ID optional, just like a passport.
Let financial institutions decide whether they want to risk extending credit to anybody, or just people with secure national IDs.
If you have any questions I can relay it to them directly.
It's from the government who brought you Novapay and it's a piece of shit. No one uses it to manage identities and you don't really need to because there are only 4 million people there anyway. Their problem set is much more manageable.
Please never use RealMe as a real world example of anything done right. Please also never use RealMe if you can avoid it.
NZTA don't even bother, and just require your drivers license number and version, which is useless security, I could change ownership of anybodies car, just to be a dick, or possibly even to steal a car.
RealMe is a RealMess. I find it's usually easier to just ring up the relevant department that requires me to login to RealMe.
The privacy commissioner (that's a thing) had this to say: "the proposal to oblige drivers to carry the licence at all times while driving would mean, in effect, ... provide ideal conditions for government agencies, police officers, retailers and other businesses, to ask for the card as standard identification in a variety of dealings unrelated to road safety." https://privacy.org.nz/news-and-publications/reports-to-parl...
Ask anybody who immigrated to the US, it's a royal pain. (Especially since you have global brands - like e.g. Mastercard - incapable of referencing their data from outside the US).
You start with a secured credit card for $200. Next, you buy a clunker of a car for all-cash. At that point, you have enough history to get a CC with $500-$1,000 limit. Now you pay everything through that CC. And make damn sure you're always 100% on time - a single slip costs you a lot of time setting up that history. After a year or two of that, you usually get a CC covering one or two months of income. Keep building.
It's a really painful process.
This was ~6 years ago so YMMV
Basically, I can only conclude that we are encouraged to be 'good citizens" by borrowing money and paying interest on it while slowly paying back the principal. People who live on a cash-only basis, which was considered to be a respectable practice not that long ago (borrowing was shameful) have terrible credit scores.
So what, you may ask?
There are very real and increasing disincentives to having bad or no credit. Creditworthiness (in the form of a nice, easy to understand number) is being taken more and more by various entities as a sign of responsibility and even good character.
A credit score is now used by some entities, beyond the mainstay car dealers, to judge risk and character: apartment rentals and employers, to name two.
I'm not suggesting that all employers and apartment management companies do this, only that the trend (I have no citations but it should be searchable) is on the increase.
The bottom line is that in the USA today, credit scores depend on how - and how much - you borrow and repay.
Furthermore, the higher your credit score, the better you are treated, to a degree: better rates on loans, no problems getting a job (all other things being equal), and so on. The opposite is true for bad scores.
This is one of the many ways we are corraled into greasing the gears of the economy, and it is a wasteland for cash-only operators (unless, I suppose, they have a huge amount of cash).
Welcome to the new consumerism.... Being Thrifty, having savings, and generally being responsible with your income is bad. The Government does not like it and punishes you with low/no interest on savings and inflation that outpaces that savings, Banks hate it because they would rather you spend spend spend so you need their loans to live above your means so they can not only get interest but maybe you will also over draft on your checking and they can kill you in fees.
Retail shops hate it because they need to sell you increasing amounts of cheaply made poor quality product you must replace every 12-18 months
The economy lives and dies with debt. If everyone started saving and living with in their means tomorrow the national economy would come to a screeching halt and we would have a depression that would make 1929 looks like a boom year
The only exception is mortgage which is usually the only loan people take their entire life. And it’s possible to get it without having a credit score. You’ll need your complete history of employment and addresses and based on that bank can borrow you money. Perhaps car leasing is another loan people might take but that works similar way.
Borrowing money to buy everything seems to be an American fetish (but also present in U.K. which is most America like part of Europe and Asia, not continental Europe though). It always seemed insane to me to have to borrow money from bank to buy a latte or groceries.
The only place I use a credit card is online. So i can pay quickly and worldwide.
[1] Not actually true, because I find the convenience of the card is worth it - but I understand people taking the opposite position.
It was annoying as even though I setup automated direct debit I simply didn't have peace of mind. I don't trust HSBC systems to be bug free and a bug in their software which would not process by direct debit is something I'd keep worrying about. Much better not to have this additional subconscious stress.
But if you are in UK or Germany or country like that there is no need for credit card really. Debit cards are ubiquitous and work everywhere (UK banks will give you a proper Visa/MC debit card, not some Mickey Mouse debit card which only works in ATMs).
There's no need, indeed. But as I said, a month's grace on paying for everything and free plane tickets every so often.
The fallacy of needing to use debt for day to day living is ruining people.
For instance, you did not refer to yourself as "we".
I'm not the same person I was when I was 30 years younger, and I'm not the same person here that I am in person. Those differences are differences in Identity. It doesn't matter if you want to call the 'different facets', because the only thing that matters is that they are distinguishable, and thus not the same identities. Your understanding of Retra is as much an understanding of me as it is an understanding of 2-year-old me.
And “an ideal solution”. How long until we have semantic awareness in autocorrect?
The GOP would never let it happen because it would make it too difficult to suppress black and poor voters by making registration unnecessary.
The purpose of voter ID laws is to suppress voting by poor people, especially African Americans, who lack ID because they do not drive, or have a difficult time meeting the standard of proof for getting an ID, or have difficulty going to the one DMV that supports their geography an hit away without a car. It’s the most recent of techniques used to suppress voting since the poll taxing and literacy tests of the reconstruction era.
Unfortunately my comment wasn’t well-received, but that doesn’t take away from the reality. A federal ID, unencumbered by the bullshittery imposed in many states, would be opposed bitterly.
I would prefer a smart token/card with a PIN on it.
And the government should not do anything stupid like try to put a GPS on it "for security purposes", which even if it was technically a good feature for that and not just another backdoor through which intelligence agencies can spy on everyone, it would kill the whole idea immediately.
What do you think is inside the token?
I believe most Americans are opposed to a national ID, so SSNs have been used as a (utterly terrible) workaround. Some reasoning for this, to quote an ACLU article on the subject[0], 'Former Senator Alan Cranston has described the national I.D. card as "a primary tool of totalitarian governments to restrict the freedom of their citizens." '
The Brazil solution mentioned seems pretty reasonable though. I like the built in expiration and ease of reissue. Anyone have experience with or thoughts about this sort of system?
[0] https://www.aclu.org/other/national-identification-cards-why...