[1]: https://www.popsci.com/new-technique-could-double-plutonium-...
With different reactors, creation of more Pu-238 would not be a huge problem.
The issue is just that there seems to be very little interest in pushing forward any areas and as so often the case many of these technologies are mutually supporting.
I would really love a real push forward on Molten Salt reactors that would give you the ability to filter out a number of important substances that have a hole host of different uses. It would also go a long way in solving the nuclear waste problems.
Here is some exploration of what is contained in nuclear waste:
They determined that: "For latitudes close to this optimum latitude (31" north), photo- voltaic power systems exhibit mass- and volume- based performance that is comparable to that of nuclear fission power systems. For global access for human Mars surface missions, nuclear power is required either in the form of fission reactors or radioisotope generators."
...further noting: "...solar-based Mars surface power systems should be seriously considered as an alternative to nuclear fission surface power."
The way I read the study, if you're happy with staying around the "near-equatorial north", you should use PV solar... if you want to site your colony somewhere else, you should use nuclear power.
Nuclear thermal rockets aren't that great either, the temperature and thus the specific impulse is not very high, and they have high dry mass and would be really expensive to develop and hard to make reliable.
In space you have 1.3 kW per square meter sun power constantly without the atmosphere or clouds in the way, and solar cells improve constantly.
Regarding the many comments in this discussion about accidents during initial launch: if nuclear thermal rockets are fueled with uranium 235, and don't reach criticality until after the risky chemical-booster ascent out of atmosphere, they should be quite safe. Uranium 235 has a 700 million year half life, hence very low radioactivity. The fission products from a live reactor of course include very-short-lived, very-high-radioactivity nuclides. But you can have nuclear power in space with extremely low risks to the terrestrial environment if you use it only for missions that leave Earth orbit, and turn on the reactor only after the risky initial ascent on chemical boosters.
That said, I agree that it would be expensive to develop nuclear thermal rockets. It's very expensive to test them on Earth, since the exhaust carries away some small amount of fission products and people don't just tolerate such radioactive pollution like back in the 1960s. You'd need some very expensive/elaborate test facility that can capture the hot, radioactive exhaust, or you'd need to do all the actual testing in space (also expensive/elaborate).
A chemical hydrogen-oxygen rocket might have exhaust velocity of 4.5 km/s so mass ratio is exp(6/4.5) = 3.8.
A nuclear rocket with exhaust velocity 9 km/s gets a mass ratio 1.9.
Most likely the nuclear rocket uses hydrogen only, meaning the tank is likely bigger than the chemical rocket's! The thrust to weight ratio of a normalish solid nuclear engine is about ten times worse than a chemical one.
You do save on the oxygen mass, but that's it. It's probably bigger, heavier, more complex and definitely more expensive and dangerous than an ordinary chemical rocket.
For higher velocities, it starts making more sense...
On Mars, solar power per square meter is a bit over 550W.
We use solar cells at Jupiter distances nowadays (various reasons for that though).
It's an unusual methodology to begin by looking up the power output of the sun, which is worked out using the reverse of your calculation. Might you have erroneously divided out the entire of Earth's surface area (which is 4 times the area of a circle the size of the Earth)?
You don't have gravity so you don't have convection or separation of gas and liquid. Hard to test such systems on Earth.
You can't make repairs easily.
Solar cells start to look really good really fast.
Maybe on Mars surface they could make some sense, or on the Moon where the night lasts for two weeks. Though on the Moon one would preferably settle near the poles without such problems.
But even on the surface, just regular batteries look really good on the simplicity front, and fuel cells beyond that.
That nuclear powered space travel is more economical and efficient at large scales isn't disputed by experts. The barriers reaching that scale are funding and political, not the engineering ones you've highlighted.
If you can invent any kind of technology at will, sure, it can be great. Then let's have light and reliable space nuclear power plants. At the moment we are very far from that.
It might have looked like a good choice forty years ago, but solar cells have improved a lot, as well as batteries.
We do have some newish things on the nuclear side that could help, like gas cooled reactors or supercritical power cycles. You need to get the temperature up (to make the radiators small) and the power density too.
We are much closer to the tech for efficient nuclear rockets than we are to the tech for an (even partially) self-sustaining colony on Mars.
This is what I thought. To my (admittedly fairly uninformed) knowledge, nuclear power is really nuclear steam engines, at least the ones I know of. As awesome as a space steam engine sounds, it doesn't seem too feasible for the reasons you presented.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_ge...
A steam turbine nuclear reactor is a Rankine cycle heat engine, their efficiency is above 40%.
The reason RTG are used is simplicity and no moving parts, but efficiency greatly suffers. If we could figure out more efficient thermocouple all sorts of opportunities open up, haven't seen much work in this area.
Though nowadays you could maybe improve them with advanced quantum technology, like long wavelength solar cells. The cell itself still has to be cooler than the source, so you still need radiators... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermophotovoltaic
People have done the calculation and nuclear would be way, way better then solar for a mars colony.
(What's all this about cloud cover?)
It never made sense to me. Why setup all of this massive capital investment for mere ore?
I think one of the very first space industries is going to be automated mining, refining, and production of nuclear fuel. Once freed from the widespread and totally irrational fear of nuclear technology here on Earth, the magnitude of advantage of nuclear power is stunning. Before the regulatory regime killed nuclear investment, it was well on its way to becoming cheaper than coal.
Cheap, abundant energy solves virtually every human problem, whether on earth or in space. A stable supply of space based nuclear fuel will lead to exponential growth in space based activity and greatly simplify colonization of our solar system... and beyond.
Look, I'm pro nuclear, but I"m also really tired of seeing this straw man. Responsible management of nuclear power requires institutions that can act responsibly to manage risk on time scales of the order of centuries. Recent history shows that many of our institutions fall short of what's really needed to do that. An event like Fukushima was a statistical certainty, and warnings prior to the event that warned of exactly what would happen were ignored.
I don't think the answer to this is to turn our back on the potential of nuclear power. I do think we should be unflinchingly real about how hard and dangerous it is.
What was the death toll from Fukushima? Zero. Everything at Fukushima went wrong, and yet only 8 out of 2400 workers were exposed to out-of-tolerate levels of radiation. None of the plant's neighbors got sick, and no discernible increase in the rate of cancer deaths is expected. Radiation is everywhere in the real world, it is a natural part of life, yet we treat it like any amount is a lethal danger, when in low doses it is not a meaningful threat.
Fukushima was a non-event, and yet it caused a movement to shut down all nuclear power. Fear of nuclear is totally irrational. The more we embrace nuclear power, the greater its benefits to human well being.
Nuclear is safer than every other form of large scale energy generation ever devised. The only concern with nuclear plants is a large release of radiation, which is unlikely due to the layers of shielding and containment. The scaremonger's goto example of chernobyl lacked such safety measures because the Soviets didn't care about human life.
Also worth reading is The Health Hazards of NOT Going Nuclear: https://www.amazon.com/Health-Hazards-Not-Going-Nuclear/dp/0...
I again believe it is entirely dishonest to call fear of nuclear power irrational.
Was it a mistake for Germany and Japan to shift generation away from nuclear? Yes IMO. But it's absurd to call an event that required mass evacuation harmless.
The amount of fear that exists is competently out of proportion to the real problem.
But you also have to consider that materials stratify based on their density and chemical affinity. The Goldschmidt classification of an element defines sort of chemical cliques for the elements.
Lithophile elements like to oxidize into minerals and float on top of any dense metal core. For instance, the dominant aluminum ore bauxite is frequently found close to the surface of the earth. To find those elements in space, you look for a rock-dominant (oxidized) asteroid.
Siderophile elements like to form solid solutions with iron, and may not oxidize to lighter minerals readily. Elements like gold and platinum are considered rare on Earth not because the planet does not have a great quantity of them, but because the vast majority of that mass is way down in the iron core, where we cannot yet reach it. The mass near the surface is only there due to quirks of geology. To find those elements in space, you look for a metals-dominant asteroid.
Chalcophile elements like sulfur, and on Earth their rarity (in terms of the amount we can dig up) is between lithophiles and siderophiles, because they tend to stratify above the iron-lovers and below the oxygen-lovers.
The only elements that may be difficult to find would be those that form volatile molecules, because they typically get gradually blown away by solar wind, or stripped away all at once by a catastrophic cosmic event.
Uranium and thorium are lithophile elements, so they shouldn't be too difficult to find on rocky, oxygen-heavy asteroids. Just look for low albedo and alpha particles from pitchblende. But beware that absent the ore-concentrating processes of large planets, you may have to process a lot of rock to get a usable quantity of fissile elements.
From what I've read, it is very unlikely that uranium ores will be found on asteroids, because concentrating uranium into economically mine-able quantities is believed to require long running thermal process in a planets core.
That would mean looking for uranium on larger bodies, like the moon.
Calculations here suggest 20 kW/m^2:
http://www.nss.org/settlement/nasa/spaceresvol2/thermalmanag...
If the fissile material could be acquired by asteroid mining, then it would never need to pass through the Earth's atmosphere. I know that still sounds way out there, but I think that uranium or thorium would actually be a great material for kicking off asteroid mining. A small amount will pay off in a big way, it is a very dangerous thing for humans to mine on Earth, and, like the parent mentioned, we really don't want to fly it around where it can fall on us.
Even if rockets were as reliable as airplanes, it still wouldn't be good enough. We've had several major plane crashes just in the past decade. Now imagine if each of those made a nuclear explosion. Do you think that would be acceptable?
We don't have fission-powered rockets because the math works against them, not because of humans' "irrational fear of nuclear power."
Nuclear power to use on ion thrusts would only be used in Space.
https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/16608/how-does-the...
It's the distribution that matters. A little bit of ocean floor over Florida would be much more radioactive than today if it was scattered with Pu-238.
On a larger scale we should have nuclear reactors in space. If we ever want a mars colony, nuclear is way, way better then solar. Elon Musk is gone try with solar but he really doesn't have any other options.
NASA is the one place there can actually be progress on this stuff, no private company can reasonable attempted this stuff because of regulation. We need more nuclear batteries, we need small reactors for space and we need nuclear thermal rockets engines.