News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Gravityloss on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:33AM (#15550959)
It's not so easy to make space nuclear power light and reliable. Most likely a nuclear powered spacecraft with electric thrusters would be a dog.

Nuclear thermal rockets aren't that great either, the temperature and thus the specific impulse is not very high, and they have high dry mass and would be really expensive to develop and hard to make reliable.

In space you have 1.3 kW per square meter sun power constantly without the atmosphere or clouds in the way, and solar cells improve constantly.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by philipkglass on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:40PM (#15552206)
Nuclear thermal rockets have low specific impulse compared to electrical propulsion, but better ISP than any chemical rockets. They also provide orders of magnitude more thrust than electrical propulsion does. I don't think that they are in the sweet spot for uncrewed probe missions, but the combination of higher-than-chemical ISP and higher-than-electrical thrust seems like a good match for crewed missions to Mars or beyond.

Regarding the many comments in this discussion about accidents during initial launch: if nuclear thermal rockets are fueled with uranium 235, and don't reach criticality until after the risky chemical-booster ascent out of atmosphere, they should be quite safe. Uranium 235 has a 700 million year half life, hence very low radioactivity. The fission products from a live reactor of course include very-short-lived, very-high-radioactivity nuclides. But you can have nuclear power in space with extremely low risks to the terrestrial environment if you use it only for missions that leave Earth orbit, and turn on the reactor only after the risky initial ascent on chemical boosters.

That said, I agree that it would be expensive to develop nuclear thermal rockets. It's very expensive to test them on Earth, since the exhaust carries away some small amount of fission products and people don't just tolerate such radioactive pollution like back in the 1960s. You'd need some very expensive/elaborate test facility that can capture the hot, radioactive exhaust, or you'd need to do all the actual testing in space (also expensive/elaborate).

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Gravityloss on Thursday October 26, 2017 @03:47AM (#15557079)
Let's say you have a velocity requirement of 6 km/s.

A chemical hydrogen-oxygen rocket might have exhaust velocity of 4.5 km/s so mass ratio is exp(6/4.5) = 3.8.

A nuclear rocket with exhaust velocity 9 km/s gets a mass ratio 1.9.

Most likely the nuclear rocket uses hydrogen only, meaning the tank is likely bigger than the chemical rocket's! The thrust to weight ratio of a normalish solid nuclear engine is about ten times worse than a chemical one.

You do save on the oxygen mass, but that's it. It's probably bigger, heavier, more complex and definitely more expensive and dangerous than an ordinary chemical rocket.

For higher velocities, it starts making more sense...

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by ColanR on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:58PM (#15552400)
Any regulations that would prevent the development of nuclear rocketry on Mars, after a base was established?
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by philipkglass on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:14PM (#15552591)
None at present. The 1967 Outer Space Treaty prohibits nuclear weapons in space, but does not restrict peaceful uses of nuclear energy. A Mars base that is developed enough not only to support permanent human habitation but to conduct nuclear rocketry R&D is so far from where we are now that I couldn't speculate about what sort of laws might then apply on Mars, though.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by snerbles on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:50AM (#15551118)
At Earth orbit, yes. Recall that the inverse square law applies for light emitted by the sun.

On Mars, solar power per square meter is a bit over 550W.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by rbanffy on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:51PM (#15552326)
And you need about 200 sqm of solar panels to fully power each engine at Martian orbit, double that for the asteroid belt, double again for Jupiter.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Gravityloss on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:05PM (#15551284)
Yes, and that's still pretty high.

We use solar cells at Jupiter distances nowadays (various reasons for that though).

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by redcalx on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:56AM (#15551185)
That number sounds high. I make it about 300W for Earth.

http://heliosphan.org/solarenergy.html

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by dTal on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:09PM (#15551344)
1.4 KW is right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_irradiance#Earth

It's an unusual methodology to begin by looking up the power output of the sun, which is worked out using the reverse of your calculation. Might you have erroneously divided out the entire of Earth's surface area (which is 4 times the area of a circle the size of the Earth)?

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by redcalx on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:12PM (#15551382)
Yeh I forgot that's what I did, it was a while ago now, and I admit the average over entire surface area isn't a very useful number :)
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by comicjk on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:17PM (#15551440)
Don't sweat it, it's a common mistake. IIRC some French physicists used the same surface area calculation to try to disprove global warming, for which they got the nickname "knights of the flat earth".
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by snerbles on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:59AM (#15551212)
I should have clarified - this is raw irradiance, not the power you'd see from a photovoltaic cell.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by redcalx on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:10PM (#15551361)
Ahh, I forgot that my calc was based on an average for the Earth's surface - so including high latitudes and day/night. On that basis I figure our numbers broadly agree.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by jessriedel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:34PM (#15551588)
It's hard to miniaturize nuclear power. But if you're going to mars, you don't want miniature, you want economies of scale (both for descent/landing and for cruise). And this is what nuclear power provides in spades.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Gravityloss on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:44PM (#15551678)
It's hard to do any kind of nuclear reactor in space. You don't have bodies of water or even an atmosphere so radiative cooling it is, and that requires huge radiators. They alone weigh a lot. You must pipe coolant through them. What about micrometeoroids? You probably have to have valves to shut off leaking radiators.

You don't have gravity so you don't have convection or separation of gas and liquid. Hard to test such systems on Earth.

You can't make repairs easily.

Solar cells start to look really good really fast.

Maybe on Mars surface they could make some sense, or on the Moon where the night lasts for two weeks. Though on the Moon one would preferably settle near the poles without such problems.

But even on the surface, just regular batteries look really good on the simplicity front, and fuel cells beyond that.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by jessriedel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:55PM (#15551766)
Internal combustion engines once look really complicated compared to horses too -- so many new problems to solve! -- but it was a forgone conclusion that cars would replace horses once the fundamental energy source could be harnesses.

That nuclear powered space travel is more economical and efficient at large scales isn't disputed by experts. The barriers reaching that scale are funding and political, not the engineering ones you've highlighted.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Gravityloss on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:13PM (#15551943)
A more apt comparison might be coal fired steam. It was very unwieldy but replaced horses in some ways. Railroads and steam ships changed the world but still the technology was too heavy for personal mobility.

If you can invent any kind of technology at will, sure, it can be great. Then let's have light and reliable space nuclear power plants. At the moment we are very far from that.

It might have looked like a good choice forty years ago, but solar cells have improved a lot, as well as batteries.

We do have some newish things on the nuclear side that could help, like gas cooled reactors or supercritical power cycles. You need to get the temperature up (to make the radiators small) and the power density too.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by jessriedel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:26PM (#15552725)
Nuclear rockets don't look much like the reactors used for power generation.

We are much closer to the tech for efficient nuclear rockets than we are to the tech for an (even partially) self-sustaining colony on Mars.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by kbenson on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:51PM (#15551744)
> You don't have bodies of water or even an atmosphere so radiative cooling it is, and that requires huge radiators.

This is what I thought. To my (admittedly fairly uninformed) knowledge, nuclear power is really nuclear steam engines, at least the ones I know of. As awesome as a space steam engine sounds, it doesn't seem too feasible for the reasons you presented.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by jessriedel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:58PM (#15551797)
Your intuition doesn't even agree with 1970s technology. Radioisotope thermoelectric generators developed then are still more efficient than modern battery power sources. They don't use steam and they have no moving parts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_ge...

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by SigmundA on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:32PM (#15552790)
They are actually extremely inefficient since they use a thermocouple. They only convert about 5% of the thermal energy to electricity, the other 95% of the heat must be rejected somewhere.

A steam turbine nuclear reactor is a Rankine cycle heat engine, their efficiency is above 40%.

The reason RTG are used is simplicity and no moving parts, but efficiency greatly suffers. If we could figure out more efficient thermocouple all sorts of opportunities open up, haven't seen much work in this area.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by jessriedel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:22PM (#15555145)
The efficiency I'm talking about here is power and thrust per weight, not absolute (percentage) efficiency in the thermodynamic sense. (Yes, the latter is important for worrying about heat dissipation, but the former is the key physical limitation for interplanetary travel.)
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by kbenson on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:21PM (#15552020)
Does that scale to the level required here? Also, while it's not a steam engine, it is an engine based on heat transfer, so it's not entirely different, and a lot of the same problems apply. So, while my assumption doesn't hold, the requirements imposed by it may (and may be worse, RTGs can't vary their heat output in any way). Do we have numbers on how much heat a current fairly standard RTG generates (for what appears to be hundreds of Watts), and how hard that is to radiate in space?
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Gravityloss on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:12PM (#15551929)
Thermoelectric generators are at the moment not useful for primary propulsion use as the amount of energy generated is so small.

Though nowadays you could maybe improve them with advanced quantum technology, like long wavelength solar cells. The cell itself still has to be cooler than the source, so you still need radiators... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermophotovoltaic

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by nickik on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @06:23PM (#15554833)
It only needs to be lighter then the massive amounts of solar panels that would be needed on mars.

People have done the calculation and nuclear would be way, way better then solar for a mars colony.

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by emeraldd on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:07PM (#15551319)
So the next step is to figure out how to build the power plant in space instead of lugging all that material up out of the Earth's gravity well.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by camiller on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:43AM (#15551055)
"...1.3 kW per square meter sun power constantly..." at Earth's distance from the sun. At Mars it is .715 kW. Inverse square law and all that.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by sdenton4 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:05PM (#15551282)
New plan! Colonize Venus!

(What's all this about cloud cover?)

Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by snerbles on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:15PM (#15551415)
Airship colonies, take advantage of that dense atmosphere and float over the clouds.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by Symmetry on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:36PM (#15552831)
If you go high enough in Venus's atmosphere that the temperature and pressure are Earth-like you're getting 1.3 times the sunlight of Earth coming in from above and about 1.0 times reflected off the clouds below.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by chesimov on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:39AM (#15551020)
I think it's more like ~0.6kW/m^2 out at Mars
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records by kakali on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:42AM (#15551039)
I think your 1.3 kW number assumes being near Earth.