Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records
by Gravityloss on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:13PM
(#15551943)
A more apt comparison might be coal fired steam. It was very unwieldy but replaced horses in some ways. Railroads and steam ships changed the world but still the technology was too heavy for personal mobility.
If you can invent any kind of technology at will, sure, it can be great. Then let's have light and reliable space nuclear power plants. At the moment we are very far from that.
It might have looked like a good choice forty years ago, but solar cells have improved a lot, as well as batteries.
We do have some newish things on the nuclear side that could help, like gas cooled reactors or supercritical power cycles. You need to get the temperature up (to make the radiators small) and the power density too.
Re:Thruster for Mars mission breaks records
by jessriedel on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:26PM
(#15552725)
Nuclear rockets don't look much like the reactors used for power generation.
We are much closer to the tech for efficient nuclear rockets than we are to the tech for an (even partially) self-sustaining colony on Mars.
That nuclear powered space travel is more economical and efficient at large scales isn't disputed by experts. The barriers reaching that scale are funding and political, not the engineering ones you've highlighted.