News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @10:54AM (#15508428)
Plenty of people who are deeply concerned about sexism in this industry also flag those stories, because it only takes 2-3 misogynist trolls to create a 300-comment shitshow out of them. There are still kinds of threads that this site simply can't do well, and it's better we not pretend we can until the guidelines and mod tools evolve to actually make them work here.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by anigbrowl on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:18PM (#15511221)
If we're killing off stories because of the behavior of trolls who don't like them, that seems like a victory for the trolls. Maybe it's the trolls who are the problem, rather than the targets of their misbehavior.

A basic problem in liberal (as in laissez-faire) politics is conflict aversion; victims of bullying are frequently treated worse than their antagonists, because it's less work. That creates perverse incentives, to put it mildly.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:25PM (#15511262)
It is in a sense a victory for the trolls (or, if you want to put it as charitably as you possibly can, a strategic retreat). With the moderation system we have now, it's the best outcome we're going to get.

What I won't sign onto is an endless series of septic threads maintained just to illustrate how inadequate the moderating response to this problem is.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by eropple on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:50AM (#15508932)
And, to underline, we have a lot more than 2-3 misogynist trolls in these parts. Reflexive rich-white-dude defensiveness is perhaps HN's greatest challenge.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by astura on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:12PM (#15509166)
Hopefully they are just trolls, trolls just post comments that are inflammatory to get people riled up, not because they actually mean what they post. If they actually are misogynistic and think they their contributions are reasonable and welcome, that's a different problem.
[dead]
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by KekDemaga on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:13PM (#15509668)
>And you long for the day when it's your particular brand of racism and sexism that wins?

Beautifully put, the solution to sexism isn't more sexism.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by dang on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:00PM (#15511076)
We've banned this account for violating the HN guidelines.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Also, trollish usernames are trolling:

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&prefix&page=0&dateRange=...

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday October 19, 2017 @09:37PM (#15512968)
Sorry, I don't see how this acocunt violated the guidelines, or how the username is trollish. Can you clarify?
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by timthelion on Friday October 20, 2017 @12:29AM (#15513553)
I think that dang was simply reacting to "Any user name with the word Kek in it is a troll." Kek is a word used almost solely by extreme right, sexist, racist trolls (in that order, more likely to be extremely sexist than racist).

http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/cult-of-kek

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by dang on Friday October 20, 2017 @02:10AM (#15513813)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15467478

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15044224

We eventually ban accounts that ignore our requests to follow the site guidelines. Inflammatory usernames catalyze that.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by Sir_Cmpwn on Friday October 20, 2017 @08:46AM (#15515299)
Gotcha. For the record, "kek" is a term that has been appropriated by trolls, but is not in and of itself a troll term. In the future, you should think twice about banning someone on that merit. The links you gave are better evidence, though, thanks!
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by pbhjpbhj on Friday October 20, 2017 @10:56AM (#15516261)
The links are a little snarky, not terribly helpful, but not especially out there. If you're banning that then banning those making racist remarks like up-thread seems right.

Personally I wouldn't ban either.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by timthelion on Friday October 20, 2017 @05:24PM (#15519204)
dang, there is no way to tell who the mods are. So those "requests" to change behavior aren't exactly clear that they are from the mods. And non-mods have certainly asked me to change my behavior in the past, and sometimes I have taken their advice and sometimes I have decided not to.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by dang on Sunday October 22, 2017 @12:02AM (#15525103)
It's true, yet I don't feel we should change that, e.g. by putting "mod" beside our names. There's a downside to that sort of thing too, and for HN, I think it's the greater downside.

I'd rather trust the community to figure things out, which it does extraordinarily well.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by eropple on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:05PM (#15510119)
> white men are all racist and sexist and are priveleged

We are; living in a racist and sexist society leaves its imprint and even the best-intentioned of us have racist and sexist baggage that we need to consciously and continually fight against. I'm sorry that that upsets you so. It exists, and it is real, and it is true, and that it upsets you does not change that it exists, and that it is real, and that it is true.

But for real: it's not that white men "can't comment." It's that white men have a listening problem in aggregate and that perhaps people who are not white men have perspectives that are deserving of being heard. Even if it means that you--and I--should give up our precious, precious megaphones for a sec.

Accepting and working on being mindful and decent does require effort. And it does mean that the "Kek de MAGA"s (how very subtle) of the world won't cheer you on. Somehow, though, those of us who give it an honest try seem to do alright without them.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:07PM (#15509619)
Flag the trolls, not the articles.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:11PM (#15509645)
No. That doesn't work.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by anigbrowl on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:20PM (#15511235)
Yes it does, it's just more labor-intensive.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:29PM (#15511290)
No, it doesn't. I've been doing it for something close to a decade now --- and, in fact, now have it pretty close to automated. I programmatically follow the people who write the worst racist and misogynistic and homophobic crap on this site. This is a problem I've studied, and one I think you know I've spent real, measurable, expensive time on here. I don't think you can dismiss what I'm saying so easily.

Individual flagging does not work to recover toxic threads. Flags are too slow and too invisible. By the time the worst stuff gets knocked down, its authors --- almost all of whom have no meaningful reputation on this site --- have reached the win condition of having guided the thread into hellish nerd litigation in which even the reasonable people grappling with the issues are made to write comments that serve trollish ends.

Flagging is what we have, and I'll continue to do it just like you will. But it does not work. It is inadequate to the task. This problem requires sitewide intervention, and until that happens, it is a rational, reasonable, moral choice to flag this stuff off the site as a harm mitigation mechanism.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by anigbrowl on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:47PM (#15511410)
Well, I was thinking of different moderation policies rather than user-driven flagging of the kind you describe, so in that sense we agree.

My basic disagreement is that 'just ignore it' and 'don't do things that attract their attention' are not viable strategies for target populations, and it's unjust to systematically shift the burden of responsibility from persistent antagonists to their victims.

I'm interested in your programmatic approach, but let's talk about that offsite.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by eropple on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:57PM (#15511492)
I would be interested in hearing about this, too, if you feel like cutting me in. I have a similar thing going as to 'tptacek, but I'm gonna bet that his is more refined.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:59PM (#15511512)
I'm happy to start a support group on the crypto slack, and also glad to hear I'm not the only person working seriously on the problem.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by specialist on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:06PM (#15511560)
I'd rather just follow other users. See HN as you see it. Piggyback off your good taste, curation.

A la the multireddit feature, if I could combine the page views & upvotes, and filter out the flags & downvotes, of you and everyone you recommend in your profile, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't see the trolls, flamewars.

I used to moderate forums. Major chore. The notion of just following people you like, trust would remove a lot of the moderator's make work.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by iza on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:50PM (#15511831)
Have you heard of Hubski? It works exactly as you described.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by ballenf on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:56AM (#15509001)
> ... until the guidelines and mod tools evolve to actually make them work here.

I think the "until" is "until all readers of this site share a single sociological view on controversial issues and/or lose all interest in having their view heard." Asking your moderation tools to solve societal problems or prevent a discussion forum from reflecting a raging societal debate is trying to hide from the problem.

> it only takes 2-3 misogynist trolls to create a 300-comment shitshow

I get what you mean, but would argue that, "it only takes 2-3 trolls plus 300 people who respond to them to create a 300-comment shitshow". An ignored troll is a powerless troll. They get their power to disrupt from the responses, not their words.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by clinth on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:57PM (#15510050)
> I get what you mean, but would argue that, "it only takes 2-3 trolls plus 300 people who respond to them to create a 300-comment shitshow". An ignored troll is a powerless troll. They get their power to disrupt from the responses, not their words.

I like this idea, but I don't think it's possible to get the shared agreement you discuss. I've never seen an online community where the hands-off, community-ignore method worked. Have you seen one?

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:11PM (#15509650)
Case in point.