News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:29PM (#15511290)
No, it doesn't. I've been doing it for something close to a decade now --- and, in fact, now have it pretty close to automated. I programmatically follow the people who write the worst racist and misogynistic and homophobic crap on this site. This is a problem I've studied, and one I think you know I've spent real, measurable, expensive time on here. I don't think you can dismiss what I'm saying so easily.

Individual flagging does not work to recover toxic threads. Flags are too slow and too invisible. By the time the worst stuff gets knocked down, its authors --- almost all of whom have no meaningful reputation on this site --- have reached the win condition of having guided the thread into hellish nerd litigation in which even the reasonable people grappling with the issues are made to write comments that serve trollish ends.

Flagging is what we have, and I'll continue to do it just like you will. But it does not work. It is inadequate to the task. This problem requires sitewide intervention, and until that happens, it is a rational, reasonable, moral choice to flag this stuff off the site as a harm mitigation mechanism.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by anigbrowl on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:47PM (#15511410)
Well, I was thinking of different moderation policies rather than user-driven flagging of the kind you describe, so in that sense we agree.

My basic disagreement is that 'just ignore it' and 'don't do things that attract their attention' are not viable strategies for target populations, and it's unjust to systematically shift the burden of responsibility from persistent antagonists to their victims.

I'm interested in your programmatic approach, but let's talk about that offsite.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by eropple on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:57PM (#15511492)
I would be interested in hearing about this, too, if you feel like cutting me in. I have a similar thing going as to 'tptacek, but I'm gonna bet that his is more refined.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by tptacek on Thursday October 19, 2017 @04:59PM (#15511512)
I'm happy to start a support group on the crypto slack, and also glad to hear I'm not the only person working seriously on the problem.
Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by specialist on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:06PM (#15511560)
I'd rather just follow other users. See HN as you see it. Piggyback off your good taste, curation.

A la the multireddit feature, if I could combine the page views & upvotes, and filter out the flags & downvotes, of you and everyone you recommend in your profile, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't see the trolls, flamewars.

I used to moderate forums. Major chore. The notion of just following people you like, trust would remove a lot of the moderator's make work.

Re:Analyzing HN moderation and censorship by iza on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:50PM (#15511831)
Have you heard of Hubski? It works exactly as you described.