This is true in physics where the system being modelled is governed by stable laws. You can confirm the model's predictive usefulness by experiment. If you test the model and find its limitations, you expect them to hold in 50 years' time.
Economic models, however, are themselves part of the economy. The ideas they are built on and their predictions become part of wider knowledge and influence the very thing the model is trying to predict or explain, possibly reinforcing or weakening certain behaviours. If a simplified model becomes widespread it can lead to blind spots in our understanding which cause systemic issues.
Of course that doesn't mean the model was bad or unsuitable for its original intent. But a simplified model can, in the wrong hands, be a net negative.
But what's the alternative besides starting with simplifications and iterating?
Which is the very problem "rational expectations" modeling [0] is trying to avoid. Rational expectations models don't 'know' anything (systematic) that the actors in it don't.
What do you value? What tradeoffs would you be willing to make for it? Now, let's assign those ratios numeric values...
The main problem with most models of market economics is that they only work when nothing interesting is happening.
Probably the best, as in most practically useful, idea from market economics has been that of arbitrage freedom. And even that falls apart in low liquidity scenarios which often characterise severe events.
Funny. I'm pretty tired of people saying that a terrible model that makes terrible predictions is better than no model.
The unifying feature of perfectly rational, perfect information and a perfectly competitive market is not that they are the best way to simplify economic models, it's that they're the best ways of creating models that conceal true sources of profit.
This is precisely what makes your line of argument tiresome: you fail to understand the very basics of what models are and how they are used.
What determines if a model is valid or not is its error margin for the intended use. Even if a model fails to draw accurate predictions, its ability to express cause-effect consequences is enough to demonstrate the model's usefulness. It makes absolutely no sense at all, and flies in the face of reason, to criticize a model because it might not be very accurate at representing a corner case. That's a very ignorant thing to claim.
To paraphrase George Box: "All models are wrong but some are useful". It seems you failed to understand the latter.
no, this is precisely what makes your line of argument argument tiresome - choosing one inherently biased and flawed model over another because you prefer the way that the biases look..
and actually I wasn't "arguing" for/against anything - but pointing out logical inconsistencies in an already occurring exchange..
I would wager just about any undergrad could come up with a superior measure to GDP.
in the case of rational free market theory, even OP pointed out the logical problems inherent in this theory, i shan't repeat here since it doesn't deviate from the thread
And as an aside, I am pretty tired of people saying things like this, without fail, in every thread about economics. A simplified model is better than no model at all. People have been trying to account for irrationality for ages. It's not particularly astute to recognize that individuals are not perfectly rational.