News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by cat199 on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @06:51PM (#15503970)
nor is it particularly astute to create an entire discipline used to justify our entire social order on a theory that is known at the onset to be incorrect, all the while claiming it is more 'rational' and less 'superstitious' than the ones that came before it..
Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by geezerjay on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @07:40PM (#15504265)
> nor is it particularly astute to create an entire discipline used to justify our entire social order on a theory that is known at the onset to be incorrect,

This is precisely what makes your line of argument tiresome: you fail to understand the very basics of what models are and how they are used.

What determines if a model is valid or not is its error margin for the intended use. Even if a model fails to draw accurate predictions, its ability to express cause-effect consequences is enough to demonstrate the model's usefulness. It makes absolutely no sense at all, and flies in the face of reason, to criticize a model because it might not be very accurate at representing a corner case. That's a very ignorant thing to claim.

To paraphrase George Box: "All models are wrong but some are useful". It seems you failed to understand the latter.

Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by cat199 on Friday October 20, 2017 @09:44AM (#15515674)
> This is precisely what makes your line of argument tiresome: you fail to understand the very basics of what models are and how they are used.

no, this is precisely what makes your line of argument argument tiresome - choosing one inherently biased and flawed model over another because you prefer the way that the biases look..

and actually I wasn't "arguing" for/against anything - but pointing out logical inconsistencies in an already occurring exchange..

Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by dsacco on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @07:00PM (#15504023)
Which theory specifically is used to "justify our entire social order"? How do we know it's incorrect, and what are the criteria for a successful theory?
Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by alexandercrohde on Wednesday October 18, 2017 @09:58PM (#15504921)
Well, I don't intend to defend the blanket phrasing of GP, let's take for example GDP and it being taken seriously as a measure of a country's progress.

I would wager just about any undergrad could come up with a superior measure to GDP.

Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by cat199 on Friday October 20, 2017 @09:44AM (#15515678)
the bold new idea of GDP/capita, perhaps.. hmm.
Re:MIT Economist Has a New Theory of Finance by cat199 on Friday October 20, 2017 @09:42AM (#15515665)
rational free market theory; humanistic positivism, etc.

in the case of rational free market theory, even OP pointed out the logical problems inherent in this theory, i shan't repeat here since it doesn't deviate from the thread