This seems like an awfully good point. One of the incidents described was a bicycle rear-ending a car - reporting from that incident reveals a scraped knee, a scratched fender, and an intact bike. How many times a day do equally minor accidents between people get ignored?
Maybe self-driving cars really do get rear-ended more, but I haven't seen anyone try to account for reporting gaps like that.
http://www.thedrive.com/tech/11407/a-self-driving-chevy-bolt...
In contrast, I've found most speed limits in Germany to be reasonable absolute maximum limits - except on one or two places on streets I know very well. And I'm not talking about the Autobahn - if I see 70 km/h in Germany (45-ish mph), its probably dangerous to go faster. If I see 45 mph in the States, it seems to mean "everybody go 55 mph".
Counterpoint: creating traffic by going at the speed limit requires that other people on the road are going over. Both parties are to blame, but only one party isn't increasing their energy at a exponential rate (1/2mv^2).
Excessive speed is the primary cause of a third of all fatal accidents and a contributing factor in at least half. Instead of training the self-driving cars to be more human, we ought to train humans to act more like the computers! Speeding is one of the stupidest norms that exists in our society. We should definitely not try to encourage it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solomon_curve
> Speeding is one of the stupidest norms that exists in our society.
Politicians arbitrarily setting the speed limits is the root cause.
The EU has many countries which have higher freeway limits, yet lower accidents per mile driven. They also have more stringent licensing.
>Politicians arbitrarily setting the speed limits is the root cause.
Of speeding, or accidents?
The link sourced multiple studies. The originals were dubious, subsequent ones not so much.
But the issue the Solomon curve and other similar studies points out is that humans (and largely Americans) will ignore the rules if they feel they can safely go faster.
And sure, you can't ignore overall average speed. Crashes on roads where the average speed is 100 mph are going to be much more prone to fatalities than 55 mph roads. So, there are two rough equations: Lower average speeds mean less severe crashes; speed limits set to the 85th percentile mean fewer crashes. As the speed limit is raised (from 0), there will be at least one solution that satisfies both of those equations and results in the fewest fatal crashes (if that's your goal).
In certain situations the lower speed limits can make things less safe. For example, a straight, well maintained toll road with wide lanes, clear vision ahead, and say wildlife barriers that was designed for 75mph max speeds is constructed in a state with statewide 55mph speed limits. Construction uses the latest traffic easing and safety techniques, since you don't want to construct all roads to enforce speed limits that may change in the future.
So now most truckers and cautious drivers go 55mph, while people with less inhibitions are weaving in and out of them.
It doesn't mean increasing limits to something that is unsafe.
1. The traffic lights need to be coordinated and that means presuming a certain speed. Now the problem is a lot of traffic lights are close enough that changing the programming of just one should ripple through the entire system and this recently (especially on a regulation making time scale) was a problem consuming extraordinary amounts of computing power.
The other, more cynical reason for lowering speed limits is that in many countries now, speed traps are a significant source of income for the state. Making the speed limit significantly lower than what the standard 85% rule says is a good way to extract money from unsuspecting drivers.
On the flip side (almost literally), I once drove around Ireland for a week. Of course my instinct was to drive slightly over the speed limit, but I quickly found 100 kph on 1.5-lane roads winding around sheep pastures with no visibility nearly impossible to safely match let alone exceed…
This isn't obvious at all.
While crashing into an AI driver I may be able to blame the AI, it's still a huge pain and possible loss for me as a human.
If the reality is that AI is not leaving and they have peccadilloes, then the human drivers and legal structure will just need to adapt (something we aren't bad at).
If two actors, one of which is following the law, has a higher risk than two actors both breaking the law, the lawbreaker is still at fault for the increased risk.
Erratic behavior causes accidents, be it driving too slow, too fast, weaving, impaired, etc...
Now, if all the cars drove the same way, we'd be fine. We'd have very few accidents. However, we don't. So, we bump into stuff.
We don't actually tend to follow all the rules of the road. Like all changes in traffic, we will adapt. It takes time. Something like a rotary can take 18 months before traffic fully adapts. I can't speculate as to how long this will take.
I don't understand why we are not investing all of the efforts and resources that are now spent to develop full self-driving capibilities, into making existing viable safety technology cheaper, and eventually mandatory. I'm 100% convinced it would have a much bigger impact on traffic safety, in a much shorter timeframe, to the point we don't even need self-driving cars anymore. At least not for safety purposes.
Come to think of it, maybe the whole self-driving car hype is not actually because companies want to improve car safety, but because they see new business models based around them, and we, the public, need to be convinced self-driving cars will be safer than alternative technologies or modes of transportation.
And for some reason the minimal front distance for WV's ACC is almost an order of magnitude larger than safe braking distance, so other drivers see no issue with changing lanes into that large free space in front of you.
So in all, this technology obviously requires some work both in terms of reliability and in terms of UX.
1. Why don't people pay attention to break lights? It's hard for me to relate to people who are always stopping last minute.
2. When someone is driving aggressively or erratically behind me, I break-check them as often as a I feel I need. Won't solve all rear-end issues, but it improves your chances of avoiding accidents.
I'm sure self-driving behavior is a factor here, but I also suspect that breaking and passing at intersections is just a common cause of zero-damage accidents. After all, one of the collisions in the story was a bike rear-ending a car - how many drivers would report that if there was no damage?
Anecdotally, it depends on how far away you see it coming. I'm constantly scanning front, rear mirrors, and side mirrors and if someone is driving erratically I take steps to get out of their way (in a safe and predictable manner of course!) I have no evidence this keeps me safer, but this and other "traffic calming" behavior I engage in makes my commute less stressful. It has the nice side-effect of continuous practice that reinforces good driving techniques.
.. and by "brace yourself", you would touch your head to your headrest so that your neck has nowhere to move/flex with the impact. You want all of your body to be completely rearward in your seat.
Also, while this may be morally negative, if there is another car in front of you, you could creep forward and lightly touch their car with your own, making yourself the middle ball in the Newtons Cradle[1] that your three cars now describe.
If humans were required to report every bump and scrape, what would we find out? I suspect we would find that humans are just poor drivers overall, and "they don't drive like I do" is the number one cause of minor incidents worldwide.
My main submission to this argument is the ubiquitous rear-ending in the turning lane where the first car's driver starts to roll and then stops, while the second driver is turned to watch approaching traffic and thus oblivious to the behaviour of the car in front.